Why clinicians should provide lifesaving treatment after attempted suicide despite patient refusal
- 21 November 2025
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Clinical Ethics
- Vol. 21 (1) , 1-10
Abstract
Historically, EMTs and clinicians intervened to resuscitate patients and provide lifesaving treatment following a suicide attempt. Despite this, the literature describes a range of cases following an attempted suicide where some physicians and ethicists assert that clinicians should not resuscitate the patient or provide lifesaving interventions, and instead allow the patient to die. Building upon a recent clinical ethics consultation case, this article provides a taxonomy of cases in the literature of patients who refuse lifesaving treatment following a suicide attempt. Often, these cases occur rapidly in emergency settings, offering little time for deliberation or discussion. While adults with decision-making capacity do have a right to refuse lifesaving treatment, this right does not extend to patients whose capacity is compromised or absent. This article outlines key legal points to guide clinician actions, including considerations for capacity assessments, duties under the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act, the doctrine of presumed consent, and emergency psychiatric hold laws. Integrating legal duties along with ethical principles of autonomy, nonmaleficence, and beneficence, this article provides a model recommendation to guide future cases.Keywords
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- Do Suicide Attempters Have a Right Not to Be Stabilized in an Emergency?Hastings Center Report, 2024
- Risk‐Sensitive Assessment of Decision‐Making Capacity: A Comprehensive DefenseHastings Center Report, 2023
- Assessing psychiatric safety in suicidal emergency department patientsJACEP Open, 2020
- Value-Based Choice, Contingency Learning, and Suicidal Behavior in Mid- and Late-Life DepressionBiological Psychiatry, 2019
- Decision-making performance of depressed patients within 72 h following a suicide attemptJournal of Affective Disorders, 2018
- Assessing Decision Making Capacity for Do Not Resuscitate Requests in Depressed Patients: How to Apply the “Communication” and “Appreciation” CriteriaHEC Forum, 2017
- Should Health Care Providers Uphold the DNR of a Terminally Ill Patient Who Attempts Suicide?HEC Forum, 2015
- Code2013
- Informed Consent and Refusal of Treatment: Challenges for Emergency PhysiciansEmergency Medicine Clinics of North America, 2006
- Operating Experiences at Desalting Plants; Key West, Fla., Desalting PlantJournal AWWA, 1972