Abstract
Anthropologists have often positioned their research as complex, not reductionist. In this article, I examine a flavorful herbal broth to show that reduction is not a simple thing. I develop the argument that reduction is multiple—and deserves to be analyzed as such—through an extended conversation with a nutrition scientist who studied linear growth restriction in Guatemala. Dr. Noel Solomons, with whom I collaborated for many years, sought to improve scientific knowledge about human growth and development, while also combating racism and stigma in public health. I consider places where our methods, languages, and commitments come together, as well as places where they diverge. I play a “language game” with different kinds of reduction (simplification, specification, and the concentration of flavor) to insist on the importance of grounding our terms in the practices in which they take place and with the people involved in these practices. That our terms take on different meanings in different practices is a call for situated theory, which can, in turn, feed new strategies for working together.

This publication has 49 references indexed in Scilit: