Contextual Strength and the Subordinate Bias Effect: Comment on Martin, Vu, Kellas, and Metcalf
Authors:
Open Access
- 1 November 1999
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology Section A
- Vol. 52 (4) , 841-852
Abstract
Martin, Vu, Kellas, and Metcalf (this issue) claim to have demonstrated that the subordinate bias effect (when preceding context instantiates the subordinate meaning of an ambiguous word that has a highly dominant meaning, reading time on that word is lengthened) can be eliminated by strong context. They argue that this provides evidence critical to discriminating between competing models of lexical ambiguity resolution: the reordered access model (in which access of meanings for an ambiguous word is exhaustive but in which the order of access is influenced by prior disambiguating context) and the context-sensitive model (in which access is selective in the presence of prior disambiguating information). We argue that there are methodological problems with their demonstration, but even if there were not, it is unclear that the subordinate bias effect is appropriate for discriminating between competing models of lexical ambiguity resolution (the reordered access model and the context-sensitive model). The effect is an empirical finding and not a fundamental tenet of the reordered access model.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Contextual strength does not modulate the subordinate bias effect: Evidence from eye fixations and self-paced readingPsychonomic Bulletin & Review, 1998
- Eye movements and lexical ambiguity resolution: Effects of prior encounter and discourse topic.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 1995
- Effects of Prior Encounter and Global Discourse Bias on the Processing of Lexically Ambiguous Words: Evidence From Eye FixationsJournal of Memory and Language, 1994
- University of Alberta norms of relative meaning frequency for 566 homographsMemory & Cognition, 1994
- The Effect of Meaning Frequency on Processing Lexically Ambiguous Words: Evidence from Eye FixationsPsychological Science, 1992
- Influence of contextual features on the activation of ambiguous word meanings.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 1992
- Selection mechanisms in reading lexically ambiguous words.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 1989
- Lexical ambiguity and fixation times in readingJournal of Memory and Language, 1988
- Time course of priming for associate and inference words in a discourse contextMemory & Cognition, 1988
- The University of South Florida homograph normsBehavior Research Methods, 1980