Plagiarism or appropriation? A study on international influences in the contents on the teaching of sciences of the Dicccionario de Pedagogía published by Editorial Labor (1936)
The Dictionary of Pedagogy edited in 1936 by the publishing house Labor constitutes a little-explored work despite its dimensions and scope. In the same year of its publication, the pedagogue Lorenzo Luzuriaga stated that it was a translation of Josef Spieler’s Lexikon der Pädagogik der Gegenwart (1930-1932), published by the Catholic publishing house Herder, and that Labor’s work was therefore of a confessional character. In 1960, Luzuriaga took up the subject again, this time stating that the translation was from another of Herder’s works, that of E. M. Roloff ’s Lexikon der Pädagogik. In order to assess the international influences on the content relating to science teaching in the Dictionary of Pedagogy, we set ourselves two objectives. In the first instance, to determine whether its eight entries on the teaching of scientific subjects are taken from the German dictionaries of Spieler and Roloff, as indicated by Luzuriaga. In relation to the possible German origin of that content, we evaluate its confessional nature based on the study of sex education and the contributions on this issue of the teacher trainer Margarita Comas Camps (Alaior, 1892- Exeter, 1972), one of the collaborators of the Dictionary… Secondly, we analyze the nature of the bibliographic recommendations offered by the entries in the Dictionary…. We conclude that the contents on the teaching of science subjects in the Dictionary of Pedagogy were adapted in large measure from a translation of Spieler’s Lexikon…, a detail that Labor withheld from its readers. In the field of science education, the Dictionary… exemplifies a process of appropriation of knowledge through an adapted translation that could today be interpreted as plagiarism. Nevertheless, the work facilitated the dissemination in Spain of the methodologies and resources proposed by authors close to the German New School for learning science through contact with nature, which Spanish readers would otherwise have had difficulty accessing. Our study of the bibliography of the entries also reveals the effort that Labor undertook to assemble international references from other European countries, as well as from Latin America and the USA.