Governing Public-Sector AI Through Judicially Informed Decision-Making
- 4 December 2026
- book chapter
- Published by IGI Global Scientific Publishing
- p. 95-122
Abstract
Artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly used in public administration, yet its evaluation often remains centered on performance, efficiency, transparency, or explainability. This chapter argues that such approaches are insufficient for legally consequential administrative action because they do not adequately address whether AI-assisted decisions remain lawfully justified, intelligible, and open to review. To address this gap, the chapter develops the Judicially Informed Decision Framework, a five-step framework for evaluating AI-assisted public decision-making through the lens of administrative justification. The framework asks whether an administrative process can adequately define the case, identify the correct legal basis, reason through the case, write reasons that faithfully reflect the grounds of decision, and preserve meaningful opportunities for review and challenge. The chapter argues that AI in public administration should be treated as a bounded support technology rather than as a substitute for administrative reasoning.This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Challenges for generative AI in legal reasoningDiscover Artificial Intelligence, 2026
- Automation Bias in the AI Act: On the Legal Implications of Attempting to De-Bias Human Oversight of AIEuropean Journal of Risk Regulation, 2025
- Automated decision-making in public administration: Changing the decision space between public officials and citizensGovernment Information Quarterly, 2025
- Potentials and Challenges of Large Language Models (LLMs) in the Context of Administrative Decision-MakingEuropean Journal of Risk Regulation, 2025
- Artificial Intelligence and Administrative Discretion: Exploring Adaptations and BoundariesEuropean Journal of Risk Regulation, 2024
- Refining public policies with machine learning: The case of tax auditingJournal of Econometrics, 2024
- Decision-making power and responsibility in an automated administrationDiscover Artificial Intelligence, 2024
- Code is law: how COMPAS affects the way the judiciary handles the risk of recidivismArtificial Intelligence and Law, 2024
- Explanation and the Right to ExplanationJournal of the American Philosophical Association, 2023
- Artificial intelligence and democratic legitimacy. The problem of publicity in public authorityAI & SOCIETY, 2022