The Conservatives returned to power in 1951, determined to create a property‐owning democracy by freeing the market in land and housing. But freeing the market proved to be no panacea and aroused much criticism. Most important, public housing continued to expand as the major alternative to private home ownership, in part because the supply of private rented housing declined precipitously. Dismayed at this situation, the Conservatives became increasingly concerned to find an affordable alternative to the continued expansion of public housing. To achieve this goal, they attempted to foster novel types of private ownership in the form of societies that could provide either some sort of co‐operative housing or rental housing at cost. Ultimately, these attempts to create a middle way in housing failed because they ignored the realities of the property market.