Quantifying the Relative Contributions of Divisive and Subtractive Feedback to Rhythm Generation
Authors:
Open Access
- 21 April 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Computational Biology
- Vol. 7 (4) , e1001124
Abstract
Biological systems are characterized by a high number of interacting components. Determining the role of each component is difficult, addressed here in the context of biological oscillations. Rhythmic behavior can result from the interplay of positive feedback that promotes bistability between high and low activity, and slow negative feedback that switches the system between the high and low activity states. Many biological oscillators include two types of negative feedback processes: divisive (decreases the gain of the positive feedback loop) and subtractive (increases the input threshold) that both contribute to slowly move the system between the high- and low-activity states. Can we determine the relative contribution of each type of negative feedback process to the rhythmic activity? Does one dominate? Do they control the active and silent phase equally? To answer these questions we use a neural network model with excitatory coupling, regulated by synaptic depression (divisive) and cellular adaptation (subtractive feedback). We first attempt to apply standard experimental methodologies: either passive observation to correlate the variations of a variable of interest to system behavior, or deletion of a component to establish whether a component is critical for the system. We find that these two strategies can lead to contradictory conclusions, and at best their interpretive power is limited. We instead develop a computational measure of the contribution of a process, by evaluating the sensitivity of the active (high activity) and silent (low activity) phase durations to the time constant of the process. The measure shows that both processes control the active phase, in proportion to their speed and relative weight. However, only the subtractive process plays a major role in setting the duration of the silent phase. This computational method can be used to analyze the role of negative feedback processes in a wide range of biological rhythms. As modern experimental techniques uncover new components in biological systems and describe their mutual interactions, the problem of determining the contribution of each component becomes critical. The many feedback loops created by these interactions can lead to oscillatory behavior. Examples of oscillations in biology include the cell cycle, circadian rhythms, the electrical activity of excitable cells, and predator-prey systems. While we understand how negative feedback loops can cause oscillations, when multiple feedback loops are present it becomes difficult to identify the dominant mechanism(s), if any. We address the problem of establishing the relative contribution of a feedback process using a biological oscillator model for which oscillations are controlled by two types of slow negative feedback. To determine which is the dominant process, we first use standard experimental methodologies: either passive observation to correlate a variable's behavior to system activity, or deletion of a component to establish whether that component is critical for the system. We find that these methods have limited applicability to the determination of the dominant process. We then develop a new quantitative measure of the contribution of each process to the oscillations. This computational method can be extended to a wide variety of oscillatory systems.Keywords
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- Slow variable dominance and phase resetting in phantom burstingJournal of Theoretical Biology, 2011
- Inhibitory Modulation of Cortical Up StatesJournal of Neurophysiology, 2010
- How Multiple Conductances Determine Electrophysiological Properties in a Multicompartment ModelThe Journal of Neuroscience, 2009
- Robust, Tunable Biological Oscillations from Interlinked Positive and Negative Feedback LoopsScience, 2008
- Dominant ionic mechanisms explored in spiking and bursting using local low-dimensional reductions of a biophysically realistic model neuronJournal of Computational Neuroscience, 2008
- Dynamical Characteristics Common to Neuronal Competition ModelsJournal of Neurophysiology, 2007
- Hybrid Systems Analysis of the Control of Burst Duration by Low-Voltage-Activated Calcium Current in Leech Heart InterneuronsJournal of Neurophysiology, 2006
- A Model for the Circadian Rhythm of Cyanobacteria that Maintains Oscillation without Gene ExpressionBiophysical Journal, 2006
- The dynamic clamp comes of ageTrends in Neurosciences, 2004
- Presynaptic modulation of CA3 network activityNature Neuroscience, 1998