Critical and STEM higher education scholars document how the fallacy of White supremacy has produced racialized macro-level (e.g., state) and micro-level (e.g., individual) structures hindering the self-actualization and innovation of racially minoritized people and their communities. Although important, there has been an undertheorization of how meso-level structures like STEM academic departments contribute to the subordination of racially minoritized people and their knowledge systems. In this paper, we leverage Ray’s (2019) theory of racialized organizations to illustrate how STEM academic departments function as organizational sites of racial inequity. We use critical theory and empirical studies to explain how this racialization occurs at four levels: 1) graduate admissions and faculty hiring, 2) research, 3) instruction, and 4) service. We conclude by offering examples of how STEM academic departments can challenge and disrupt their racial exclusionary practices, so racially minoritized people and knowledge systems can receive support and thrive.