Of Black Boxes, Instruments, and Experts: Testing the Validity of Forensic Science
Author:
- Jennifer L. MnookinJMJennifer L. Mnookin
- 1 October 2008
- journal article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Episteme
- Vol. 5 (3) , 343-358
Abstract
This paper argues that judges assessing the scientific validity and the legal admissibility of forensic science techniques ought to privilege testing over explanation. Their evaluation of reliability should be more concerned with whether the technique has been adequately validated by appropriate empirical testing than with whether the expert can offer an adequate description of the methods she uses, or satisfactorily explain her methodology or the theory from which her claims derive. This paper explores these issues within two specific contexts: latent fingerprint examination and the use of breath tests for the detection of alcohol. Especially in the forensic science arena, I suggest courts have often been seduced by superficially plausible explanations and descriptions of a technique or method, and permitted these to serve as a substitute for empirical testing. Thinking through these two examples illustrates both why evaluating the extent of testing should be the most important method by which courts assess reliability, and why, when other forms of explanatory evidence are readily available, we may nonetheless elect to make use of them. This paper suggests that these descriptions and explanations may at times usefully supplement evidence of testing, but should not generally be substituted for it. Finally, this paper embraces a kind of evidentiary pragmatism, in which the quantum of evidence required to establish legal reliability is determined not in the abstract, but in relation to the evidence that is, or ought to be, available as a result of reasonable research and investigation.Keywords
This publication has 6 references indexed in Scilit:
- Scientific validation of fingerprint evidence under DaubertLaw, Probability and Risk, 2007
- The validity of latent fingerprint identification: confessions of a fingerprinting moderateLaw, Probability and Risk, 2007
- Contextual information renders experts vulnerable to making erroneous identificationsForensic Science International, 2006
- Reliability and the Admissibility of ExpertsSSRN Electronic Journal, 2003
- The Daubert/Kumho Implications of Observer Effects in Forensic Science: Hidden Problems of Expectation and SuggestionCalifornia Law Review, 2002
- Scripting Expertise: The History of Handwriting Identification Evidence and the Judicial Construction of ReliabilityVirginia Law Review, 2001