Inter- and Intraspecific Variation in Dorsal Pigmentation Patterns of Skates (Rajidae) from the Cantabrian Sea: Evidence of High Variability in Raja clavata and Implications for Species Identification
Authors:
- Clara Piedrafita-ZubillagaCPClara Piedrafita-Zubillaga
- Daniel A. Gómez-LoboDaniel A. Gómez-Lobo
- Isabel Gómez-ÁlvarezIGIsabel Gómez-Álvarez
- Johanne WautersJWJohanne Wauters
- Pablo de la Calva-CastiñeiraPCPablo de la Calva-Castiñeira
- Trinidad PérezTPTrinidad Pérez
- Ángel MuñozÁMÁngel Muñoz
- Yaisel J. BorrellYaisel J. Borrell
- Laura MirallesLaura Miralles
Open Access
Abstract
Accurate species identification is essential to assess population trends and implement effective conservation measures. Many rajid species have life-history characteristics that increase their vulnerability to fishing mortality, while their conservation status differs among species. However, species identification within the family Rajidae is hampered by morphological conservatism and intraspecific phenotypic variation, which frequently lead to misidentification in fisheries surveys and seafood markets. Here, we combine COI DNA barcoding with a detailed photographic assessment of dorsal pigmentation patterns in 484 skate specimens collected from a fish wholesaler market in the Cantabrian Sea. Seven species were genetically identified as Raja clavata, Raja montagui, Raja microocellata, Raja undulata, Raja brachyura, Leucoraja naevus, and Leucoraja circularis. Substantial overlap in pigmentation patterns was detected among genetically distinct species, while R. clavata exhibited nine distinct morphotypes, five of which have not been previously described. We further investigated whether R. maderensis individuals display dorsal patterns distinct from those of R. clavata. Notably, a dark-crossbar pattern, previously unreported in R. montagui, was recorded in this species. Moreover, an unusually extreme case of hypomelanosis in R. microocellata is also discussed. Together, these findings demonstrate that dorsal pigmentation alone in processed individuals is insufficient for reliable species discrimination in skates and highlights the need to integrate molecular tools into fisheries monitoring and biodiversity assessments.Keywords
Funding Information
- Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación (MCINN-24-PID2023-150709OB-I00/MCIU/AEI/FEDER, UE)
- Gobierno del Principado de Asturias (SEK-25-GRU-GIC-24-051)
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Addressing skate and ray mislabelling from the Cantabrian Sea (southern Bay of Biscay) through collaboration between scientists and market managersScientific Reports, 2026
- The evolution of eyespots in skates and raysNature Ecology & Evolution, 2026
- An interesting case of a single ocellus in a brown ray from the Adriatic SeaMarine Biodiversity, 2023
- Blondes do it better? A comparative study on the morphometry and life-history traits of commercially important skates blonde ray Raja brachyura, thornback ray Raja clavata, and spotted ray Raja montagui, with management implicationsFisheries Research, 2023
- Overfishing drives over one-third of all sharks and rays toward a global extinction crisisCurrent Biology, 2021
- Morphological abnormality in thornback ray Raja clavata in the Irish SeaEnvironmental Biology of Fishes, 2021
- Population Genomics: Marine Organisms2020
- Rays of the World2016
- Resolving taxonomic uncertainty in vulnerable elasmobranchs: are the Madeira skate (Raja maderensis) and the thornback ray (Raja clavata) distinct species?Conservation Genetics, 2016
- Genetics in fisheries managementHydrobiologia, 2000