The Determination of Relevant Contextual Factors for the Interpretation of Intervention Studies: a Stepwise Approach with Online Information (Preprint)
Authors:
- Michael Van der ElstMEMichael Van der Elst
- Birgitte SchoenmakersBSBirgitte Schoenmakers
- Eva DierckxEDEva Dierckx
- Liesbeth De DonderLDLiesbeth De Donder
- Ellen De RoeckEREllen De Roeck
- Daan DuppenDDDaan Duppen
- Bram FretBFBram Fret
- Jos M.G.A. ScholsJSJos M.G.A. Schols
- Gertrudis I.J.M KempenGKGertrudis I.J.M Kempen
- Jan De LepeleireJLJan De Lepeleire
- D-SCOPE ConsortiumDCD-SCOPE Consortium
Preprint
- 22 March 2020
- preprint
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Abstract
BACKGROUND The role of the context within intervention studies is often ignored. To consider the context in future research, one needs to know whether enough information is available, and a uniform methodology to study the local context in a standardized way is desirable. Through the World Wide Web, a lot of information is nowadays available. OBJECTIVE The present study aims to test the feasibility of studying the local context with online information and to provide a stepwise approach how to detect these relevant contextual factors which might moderate the effect of an intervention. METHODS The present study is framed within the D-SCOPE project, where a complex intervention by means of home visits was set up to improve the access to tailored care in 3 municipalities (Ghent, Knokke-Heist and Tienen). A case study of these three municipalities was performed to determine which contextual factors could influence the D-SCOPE intervention, a five-step approach was designed and tested: (1) a theoretical/conceptual discussion of relevant contextual factor domains was held; (2) a search was done to find appropriate web-based public datasets which covered these topics with standardized information (e.g., official statistics); (3) a list of all identified contextual factors was made (inventory); (4) a concise list with the assumedly most relevant contextual factors was made by two independent reviewers to reduce the long list of contextual factors+; and (5) a Nominal Grouping Technique was applied. RESULTS Based on the aims of the D-SCOPE intervention, the research team decided that the datasets should cover sociodemographic contextual factors, socioeconomic contextual factors, contextual factors related to care supply/availability or care use and contextual factors related to the local government. The team also decided to use only standardized data. Three public web-based datasets were found resulting in an inventory of 157 contextual factors. After the selection by two independent reviewers, 41 contextual factors were left over and presented in the Nominal Grouping Technique. According to the Nominal Grouping Technique, contextual factors such as: dependency ratio (65+/20-64y), availability of a community center, percentage of people aged 65 or more living alone, and the total resources of the community social security system were considered as most decisive. CONCLUSIONS The present study shows that the five-step approach is feasible to determine relevant contextual factors that might affect the results of an intervention study. Such information may be used to correct for in the statistical analyses and for interpretation of the outcomes of intervention studies. CLINICALTRIAL noneKeywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Interventions for frail community-dwelling older adults have no significant effect on adverse outcomes: a systematic review and meta-analysisBMC Geriatrics, 2018
- Randomized controlled trial to evaluate a prevention program for frail community-dwelling older adults: a D-SCOPE protocolBMC Geriatrics, 2018
- Unravelling complex primary-care programs to maintain independent living in older people: a systematic overviewJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2018
- Process evaluation of complex interventions: Medical Research Council guidanceBMJ, 2015
- Developing and evaluating complex interventions: the new Medical Research Council guidanceBMJ, 2008
- Realistic EvaluationThe Social Science Journal, 2004
- Coordination Networks Within and Across Organizations: A Multi‐level Framework*Journal of Management Studies, 2003
- Medical Research Council (MRC)2001
- Advantages and disadvantages of group decision‐ making approachesTeam Performance Management: An International Journal, 1996
- A Group Process Model for Problem Identification and Program PlanningThe Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 1971