Quantitative evaluation of beta-amyloid brain PET imaging in dementia: a comparison between two commercial software packages and the clinical report
- 8 May 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in British Journal of Radiology
- Vol. 92 (1101) , 20181025
Abstract
Objective: To compare commercially available image analysis tools Hermes BRASS and Siemens Syngo.VIA with clinical assessment in 18F-Florbetapir PET scans Methods: 225 scans were reported by clinicians and quantified using two software packages. Scans were classified into Type A (typical features) or non-Type A (atypical features) for both positive and negative scans. For BRASS, scans with z-score ≥ 2 in 2 ≥ region of interest were classed positive. For Syngo.VIA a positive scan was indicated when mean cortical standardized uptake value ratio (mcSUVR) ≥ 1.17. Results: 81% scans were Type A, and 19% scans were non-Type A. The sensitivity of BRASS and Syngo.VIA for Type A scans was 98.8 and 96.3%, specificity was 73 and 92%, respectively. Sensitivity for non-Type A scans was 95.8 and 79.2%, specificity was 36.8 and 57.9%, respectively. A third threshold of identifiable levels of plaque (1.08 ≤ mcSUVR ≤ 1.17) was recommended for Syngo.VIA to increase detection of false negative scans. The false positive rate of BRASS significantly decreased when an alternative positive threshold value of mcSUVR ≥ 1.18. Introduction of alternative criteria did not improve prediction outcome for non-Type A scans. More complex solutions are recommended. Conclusion: Hermes criteria for a positive scan leads to a high sensitivity but a low specificity. Siemens Syngo.VIA criteria gives a high sensitivity and specificity and agrees better with the clinical report. Alternative thresholds and classifications may help to improve agreement with the clinical report. Advances in knowledge: Software packages may assist with clinical reporting of more difficult to interpret cases that require a more experienced read.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- Amyloid Load: A More Sensitive Biomarker for Amyloid ImagingJournal of Nuclear Medicine, 2018
- Clinical utility of amyloid PET imaging with (18)F-florbetapir: a retrospective study of 100 patientsJournal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry, 2017
- Automated quantification of amyloid positron emission tomography: a comparison of PMOD and MIMneuroAnnals of Nuclear Medicine, 2016
- Evaluation of software tools for automated identification of neuroanatomical structures in quantitative β-amyloid PET imaging to diagnose Alzheimer’s diseaseEuropean Journal of Nuclear Medicine and Molecular Imaging, 2016
- Improved longitudinal [18F]-AV45 amyloid PET by white matter reference and VOI-based partial volume effect correctionNeuroImage, 2015
- Quantitative Analysis of PiB-PET with FreeSurfer ROIsPLOS ONE, 2013
- Glutamate system, amyloid β peptides and tau protein: functional interrelationships and relevance to Alzheimer disease pathologyJournal of Psychiatry and Neuroscience, 2013
- Using Positron Emission Tomography and Florbetapir F 18 to Image Cortical Amyloid in Patients With Mild Cognitive Impairment or Dementia Due to Alzheimer DiseaseArchives of Neurology, 2011