Evaluation of the NAL-NL1 and the DSL v.4.1 prescriptions for children: Paired-comparison intelligibility judgments and functional performance ratings
- 29 January 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Audiology
- Vol. 49 (sup1) , S35-s48
Abstract
This paper reports intelligibility judgments and real-life functional performance of 48 children in a double-blind, cross-over trial comparing the NAL-NL1 and the DSL v.4.1 prescriptions. Intelligibility judgments were obtained by using a paired-comparisons procedure with audiovisual stimuli. Functional performance of children during two eight-week periods, each with hearing aids adjusted to one prescription, was assessed by parents and teachers (PEACH and TEACH) and by children's self reports (SELF). Consistently across reports, performance was significantly better in quiet than in noise. On average, better performance in noise (a higher Noise subscale score) was associated with NAL-NL1 than with DSL v.4.1, both for the PEACH and the SELF. This difference was significant for the SELF in Australia. Intelligibility judgments revealed preferences that were equally split between prescriptions in both countries, on average. In the Australian sample, intelligibility judgments agreed with the questionnaire ratings and with parents’ ratings. An increase in preference for NAL was significantly associated with lesser hearing loss. The effect was not significant in the Canadian sample. Sumario Este trabajo reporta juicios de inteligibilidad y rendimiento funcional en la vida real de 48 niños, en un estudio doble ciego cruzado para comparar las prescripciones NAL-NL1 y DSL v.4.1. Los juicios de inteligibilidad se obtuvieron usando comparaciones por pares con estímulos audio-visu-ales. El rendimiento funcional de los niños durante dos perío-dos de ocho semanas, con auxiliares auditivos ajustados a una de las prescripciones, fue evaluado por padres (PEACH) y maestros (TEACH) y por auto-reportes de los niños (SELF). Consistentemente en los reportes, el rendimiento fue signifi-cativamente mejor en silencio que en ruido. En promedio, el mejor rendimiento en ruido (puntuación de una mayor subes-cala de ruido) se asoció con NAL-NL 1 en comparación con DSL v.4.1, ambos con PEACH y SELF. Esta diferencia fue significativa para SELF en Australia. Los juicios de inteligi-bilidad revelaron preferencias que se dividieron igualmente en promedio, entre las prescripciones en ambos países. En la muestra de Australia, los juicios de inteligibilidad estuvieron de acuerdo con las puntuaciones de cuestionarios y con las de los padres. Un aumento en la preferencia por el NAL se aso-ció significativamente con menor pérdida auditiva. El efecto no fue significativo en la muestra de Canadá.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Evaluation of the NAL-NL1 and DSL v4.1 prescriptions for children: Preference in real world useInternational Journal of Audiology, 2010
- A cross-over, double-blind comparison of the NAL-NL1 and the DSL v4.1 prescriptions for children with mild to moderately severe hearing lossInternational Journal of Audiology, 2010
- Prescribed real-ear and achieved real-life differences in children's hearing aids adjusted according to the NAL-NL1 and the DSL v.4.1 prescriptionsInternational Journal of Audiology, 2010
- Effect of variations in hearing-aid frequency response on real-life functional performance of children with severe or profound hearing lossInternational Journal of Audiology, 2008
- Clinical Protocols for Hearing Instrument Fitting in the Desired Sensation Level MethodTrends in Amplification, 2005
- How to assess outcome of hearing aid fitting in childrenScandinavian Audiology, 2001
- An international comparison of long-term average speech spectraThe Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 1994
- Hearing Aid Gain and Frequency Response Requirements for the Severely/Profoundly Hearing ImpairedEar & Hearing, 1990
- Effect of Low-Frequency Hearing Aid Response on Four Measures of Speech PerceptionEar & Hearing, 1984
- Paired comparison judgments of relative intelligibility in noiseThe Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 1982