More on Pseudoscience in Science and the Case for Psychiatric Diagnosis
Author:
- Robert L. SpitzerRSRobert L. Spitzer
- 1 April 1976
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Medical Association (AMA) in Archives of General Psychiatry
- Vol. 33 (4) , 459-470
Abstract
• Rosenhan's 1973 article,1"On Being Sane in Insane Places," was pseudoscience presented as science. Just as his pseudopatients were diagnosed at discharge as having "schizophrenia in remission," so a careful examination of this study's methods, results, and conclusions leads to a diagnosis of "logic in remission." Rosenhan's study proves that pseudopatients are not detected by psychiatrists as having simulated signs of mental illness and that the implementation of certain invalid research designs can make psychiatrists appear foolish. These rather unremarkable findings are irrelevant to the real problems of the reliability and validity of psychiatric diagnosis and only serve to obscure them. A correct interpretation of his own data contradicts his conclusions. There are purposes to psychiatric diagnosis that Rosenhan's article ignores. His more recent suggestion that certain requirements be met prior to the adoption of a new psychiatric classification system is unrealistic.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Concerning science and societyClinical Social Work Journal, 1974
- Rosenhan was wrong: The staff was lousyClinical Social Work Journal, 1974
- Popular opinion is not empirical dataClinical Social Work Journal, 1974
- From Rationalization to ReasonAmerican Journal of Psychiatry, 1974
- Look to the recordSocial Work, 1974
- PROCEDURE RE-EXAMINEDThe Lancet, 1974
- Medical Ethnocentrism and the Treatment of AddictionInternational Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 1974
- Sane: Insane1973
- The Relationship of Marihuana Usage to Personality and Motivational FactorsThe Journal of Psychology, 1973
- Social Psychiatry: An OverviewAmerican Journal of Psychiatry, 1973