Requests for "inappropriate" treatment based on religious beliefs.
Authors:
- L B GenesenLGL B Genesen
Open Access
- 1 June 1997
- journal article
- case report
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 23 (3) , 142-147
Abstract
Requests by patients or their families for treatment which the patient's physician considers to be "inappropriate" are becoming more frequent than refusals of treatment which the physician considers appropriate. Such requests are often based on the patient's religious beliefs about the attributes of God (sovereignty, omnipotence), the attributes of persons (sanctity of life), or the individual's personal relationship with God (communication, commands, etc). We present four such cases and discuss some of the basic religious tenets of the three Abrahamic faith traditions as they relate to such requests. We suggest that religious reasons for requesting "inappropriate" treatment are "special" and deserve serious consideration. We offer guidance to assist clinicians and clinical ethicists as they attempt to resolve these conflicts, emphasising the importance of understanding the religious beliefs of the patient/surrogate and suggesting the assistance of a religious interpreter. We suggest open discussion with patients and families of both the clinical situation and the theological basis for these requests. We also suggest that clinicians use additional religious doctrines or principles from patients' own traditions to balance the reasons behind the requests. We conclude that most persistent requests for "inappropriate" treatment should be honoured.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Rationality and the refusal of medical treatment: a critique of the recent approach of the English courts.Journal of Medical Ethics, 1995
- Cross-cultural considerations in clinical ethics consultationsArchives of Family Medicine, 1995
- Asking the Courts to Set the Standard of Emergency Care -- The Case of Baby KNew England Journal of Medicine, 1994
- Beyond Autonomy -- Physicians' Refusal to Use Life-Prolonging Extracorporeal Membrane OxygenationNew England Journal of Medicine, 1993
- Brain Death, Religious Freedom, and Public Policy: New Jersey's Landmark Legislative InitiativeKennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 1991
- Autonomy, religious values, and refusal of lifesaving medical treatment.Journal of Medical Ethics, 1991
- Informed Demand for “Non-Beneficial” Medical TreatmentNew England Journal of Medicine, 1991
- Physicians' Refusal of Requested TreatmentNew England Journal of Medicine, 1990
- The desperate case: CARE (costs, applicability, research, ethics)1989
- Must We Always Use CPR?New England Journal of Medicine, 1987