Lessons from pendulums: A design comparison of three lab activities
Authors:
- Ian DescampsIDIan Descamps
- N. G. HolmesNHN. G. Holmes
Preprint
Abstract
We present three versions of a pendulum lab activity and explore how shared theoretical commitments, motivations, and aspirations can lead to divergences in curriculum design. Building on Boudreaux & Elby (2020) we provide another demonstration of how theoretical commitments and perspectives influence curriculum development. In this paper, the variations across these lab activities despite our shared theoretical bases constitutes the phenomena of interest. We argue that three main factors lead to the variations in our design decisions: different expectations and understandings of our student populations, variations in our ancillary pedagogical goals, and fine grained differences in our theoretical perspectives. By focusing on the differences between our labs, we highlight the limitations of theory alone to determine curriculum development and demonstrate the process of theory, in conversation with local particularities, guiding design.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 69 references indexed in Scilit:
- Characterizing Lab Environments Using Activity Theory2023
- Best practice for instructional labsNature Physics, 2021
- Making Space to Sensemake: Epistemic Distancing in Small Group Physics DiscussionsCognition and Instruction, 2018
- Positioning as not‐understanding: The value of showing uncertainty for engaging in scienceJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 2017
- The past and future of physics education reformPhysics Today, 2017
- Making the failure more productive: scaffolding the invention process to improve inquiry behaviors and outcomes in invention activitiesInstructional Science, 2013
- Student Behavior and Epistemological Framing: Examples from Collaborative Active-Learning Activities in PhysicsCognition and Instruction, 2009
- ?Doing the lesson? or ?doing science?: Argument in high school geneticsScience Education, 2000
- Enhancing teaching through constructive alignmentHigher Education, 1996
- Toward an Epistemology of PhysicsCognition and Instruction, 1993