Service Isolation vs. Consolidation: Implications for IaaS Cloud Application Deployment
Authors:
- Wes LloydWLWes Lloyd
- Shrideep PallickaraSPShrideep Pallickara
- Olaf DavidODOlaf David
- Jim LyonJLJim Lyon
- Mazdak ArabiMAMazdak Arabi
- Ken RojasKRKen Rojas
- 1 March 2013
- conference paper
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- p. 21-30
Abstract
Service isolation, achieved by deploying components of multi-tier applications using separate virtual machines (VMs), is a common "best" practice. Various advantages cited include simpler deployment architectures, easier resource scalability for supporting dynamic application throughput requirements, and support for component-level fault tolerance. This paper presents results from an empirical study which investigates the performance implications of component placement for deployments of multi-tier applications to Infrastructure-as-a-Service (IaaS) clouds. Relationships between performance and resource utilization (CPU, disk, network) are investigated to better understand the implications which result from how applications are deployed. All possible deployments for two variants of a multi-tier application were tested, one computationally bound by the model, the other bound by a geospatial database. The best performing deployments required as few as 2 VMs, half the number required for service isolation, demonstrating potential cost savings with service consolidation. Resource use (CPU time, disk I/O, and network I/O) varied based on component placement and VM memory allocation. Using separate VMs to host each application component resulted in performance overhead of ~1-2%. Relationships between resource utilization and performance were harnessed to build a multiple linear regression model to predict performance of component deployments. CPU time, disk sector reads, and disk sector writes are identified as the most powerful performance predictors for component deployments.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Performance Modeling to Support Multi-tier Application Deployment to Infrastructure-as-a-Service Clouds2012
- Quality of service provisioning for distributed data center inter-connectivity enabled by network virtualizationFuture Generation Computer Systems, 2012
- Pesto2011
- Cuanta2011
- Migration of Multi-tier Applications to Infrastructure-as-a-Service Clouds: An Investigation Using Kernel-Based Virtual Machines2011
- Autonomic Resource Management with Support Vector Machines2011
- Enhancement of Xen's scheduler for MapReduce workloads2011
- The Eucalyptus Open-Source Cloud-Computing System2009
- Developing natural resource models using the object modeling system: feasibility and challengesAdvances in Geosciences, 2005
- Xen and the art of virtualization2003