Evidence and Implications of Multiple Paradigms in Accounting Knowledge Production
Authors:
- 16 April 2008
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in European Accounting Review
- Vol. 17 (1) , 161-191
Abstract
This paper uses evidence gathered in two perception studies of Australasian and British accounting academics to reflect on aspects of the knowledge production system within accounting academe. We provide evidence of the representation of multiple paradigms in many journals that are scored by participants as being of high quality. Indeed most of the journals we surveyed are perceived by accounting academics as incorporating research from more than one paradigm. It is argued that this ‘catholic’ approach by journal editors and the willingness of many respondents in our surveys to score journals highly on material they publish from both paradigm categories reflects a balanced acceptance of the multi-paradigmatic state of accounting research. Our analysis is set within an understanding of systems of accounting knowledge production as socially constructed and as playing an important role in the distribution of power and reward in the academy. We explore the impact of our results on concerns emerging from the work of a number of authors who carefully expose localised ‘elites’. The possibilities for a closer relationship between research emerging from a multi-paradigm discipline and policy setting and practice are also discussed. The analysis provides a sense of optimism that the broad constituency of accounting academics operates within an environment conducive for the exchange of ideas. That optimism is dampened by concerns about the impact of local ‘elites’ and the need for more research on their impact on accounting academe.Keywords
This publication has 64 references indexed in Scilit:
- The most influential journals in academic accountingAccounting, Organizations and Society, 2006
- Journal Rankings in Business and Management and the 2001 Research Assessment Exercise in the UKBritish Journal of Management, 2004
- Exploring Diversity in Accounting through Faculty Journal Perceptions*Contemporary Accounting Research, 2003
- Commentary: Research Productivity Measurement and the Field of Academic Accounting*Canadian Accounting Perspectives, 2003
- Building the Tower of Babel: Communities of Practice and Paradigmatic Pluralism in Organization StudiesOrganization, 1998
- Is accounting a global or a local discipline? evidence from major research journalsAccounting, Organizations and Society, 1996
- Influential accounting articles, individuals, Ph.D. granting institutions and faculties: A citational analysisAccounting, Organizations and Society, 1996
- Managing the Academics: Commodification and Control in the Development of University Education in the U.K.Human Relations, 1995
- The rhetoric and rationality of accounting researchAccounting, Organizations and Society, 1992
- Positive Accounting: An AssessmentAbacus, 1990