Using a GDSS to Facilitate Group Consensus: Some Intended and Unintended Consequences
Authors:
- 1 September 1988
- journal article
- Published by MIS Quarterly in MIS Quarterly
- Vol. 12 (3) , 463-478
Abstract
A cumulative body of experimental research is emerging that examines the ability of computer technology to support the processes and outcomes of small group meetings. For the most part the group decision support system effort has been concerned with demonstrating the usefulness of the technology in planning and decisionmaking situations where the quality of the meeting’s outcomes can be objectively assessed. In many decision situations, however, there is no objective measure of decision quality available. Rather, the group must reconcile differences in opinion, personal preference, or judgment and achieve consensus about a particularmode of action. As a contribution to the accumulating research on GDSS, the current study examines the effects of a GDSS in resolving conflicts of personal preference. In a task requiring resolution of competing personal preferences, 82 groups—the largest sample size in the GDSS literature to date—were randomly assigned to one of three experiment conditions: (1) a computer-based support system (GDSS); (2) a manual, paper and pencil, support system; or (3) no support whatsoever. Groups were either of size 3 or 4 persons. Use of the GDSS was expected to facilitate democratic participation in group discussion, move group members toward agreement with one another, and result in a high level of satisfaction with the group decision process. While several of the intended effects of the technology were observed, the groups experienced some unintended consequences as a result of using the GDSS. In general, the GDSS technology appeared to offer some advantage over no support, but little advantage over the pencil and paper method of supporting group discussion.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Group processes in computer-mediated communicationOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 1986
- A descriptive investigation of the possible communication‐based reasons for effective and ineffective group decision makingCommunication Monographs, 1983
- Computer Support for Group Versus Individual DecisionsIEEE Transactions on Communications, 1982
- A Computer-Based Interactive System for Group DecisionmakingIEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, 1981
- The effects of three social decision schemes on decision group processOrganizational Behavior and Human Performance, 1980
- A Fuzzy Analysis of Consensus in Small Groups1980
- Behavioral correlates of perceptions of quality in decision‐making discussionsCommunication Monographs, 1978
- Judgment Analysis in Policy Formation: A New Method for Improving Public ParticipationPublic Opinion Quarterly, 1978
- INTERVENTIONS INTO GROUP PROCESS: AN APPROACH TO IMPROVING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF GROUPS*Decision Sciences, 1974
- How we think.1910