M. Stella Atkins
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
M. Stella Atkins has a total of 24 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Bin Zheng
University of Alberta
4 shared publicationsArthur E. Kirkpatrick
School of Computing Science, Simon Fraser University, Burnaby, Canada
2 shared publications- Xianta Jiang
Department of Computer Science, Memorial University of Newfoundland, St. Johns, NL, Canada
2 shared publications Adam Meneghetti
University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
1 shared publicationAdelle Knight
Simon Fraser Univ. (Canada)
1 shared publicationAdrian Chung
Imperial College London
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 23 October 2016
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- p. 11-15
Gaze characteristics of video watching in a surgical setting
Observing surgical videos has been integrated intensively into surgical education. We test whether video watching can elicit the same eye motion pattern of an observer as the operator in performing the surgical procedure. While observing the task performed using tools, subjects started to move their eyes off the previous target 0.7 s after the tool but reached the next target 1.5 s before the tool. These two events in observing occurred approximately 0.5 s after times in operating. Fixations performed while observing the video were often shorter than while performing, especially before the tool touched the target. Participants in observing were primarily checking outcomes of tool movement; differing to actively collecting information on the target for guiding tool movement during task operating. This result has indication for developing new strategies of improving education outcomes from video watching.
- 23 October 2016
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- p. 11-15
Gaze characteristics of video watching in a surgical setting
Observing surgical videos has been integrated intensively into surgical education. We test whether video watching can elicit the same eye motion pattern of an observer as the operator in performing the surgical procedure. While observing the task performed using tools, subjects started to move their eyes off the previous target 0.7 s after the tool but reached the next target 1.5 s before the tool. These two events in observing occurred approximately 0.5 s after times in operating. Fixations performed while observing the video were often shorter than while performing, especially before the tool touched the target. Participants in observing were primarily checking outcomes of tool movement; differing to actively collecting information on the target for guiding tool movement during task operating. This result has indication for developing new strategies of improving education outcomes from video watching.
- 1 January 2013
- Vol. 184, 210-4
Pupil response to precision in surgical task execution.
Task-evoked pupil response (TEPR) has been extensively studied and well proven to be sensitive to mental workload changes. We aimed to explore how TEPR reflects mental workload changes in a surgical environment. We conducted a simulated surgical task that has 3 different subtasks with different levels of motor precision and different mental workload requirements. We found a significant effect among these different subtask groups by measuring pupil diameter change rate. This finding may improve patient safety in a real operating room by non-intrusively monitoring the surgeon's mental workload while performing a surgery using an eye-tracking system.
- 1 January 2013
- Vol. 184, 210-4
Pupil response to precision in surgical task execution.
Task-evoked pupil response (TEPR) has been extensively studied and well proven to be sensitive to mental workload changes. We aimed to explore how TEPR reflects mental workload changes in a surgical environment. We conducted a simulated surgical task that has 3 different subtasks with different levels of motor precision and different mental workload requirements. We found a significant effect among these different subtask groups by measuring pupil diameter change rate. This finding may improve patient safety in a real operating room by non-intrusively monitoring the surgeon's mental workload while performing a surgery using an eye-tracking system.
- 13 June 2012
- Published by SAGE Publications in Surgical Innovation
- Vol. 20 (3) , 241-248
What Do Surgeons See
Recording eye motions in surgical environments is challenging. This study describes the authors’ experiences with performing eye-tracking for improving surgery training, both in the laboratory and in the operating room (OR). Three different eye-trackers were used, each with different capabilities and requirements. For monitoring eye gaze shifts over the room scene in a simulated OR, a head-mounted system was used. The number of surgeons’ eye glances on the monitor displaying patient vital signs was successfully captured by this system. The resolution of the head-mounted eye-tracker was not sufficient to obtain the gaze coordinates in detail on the surgical display monitor. The authors then selected a high-resolution eye-tracker built in to a 17-inch computer monitor that is capable of recording gaze differences with resolution of 1° of visual angle. This system enables one to investigate surgeons’ eye–hand coordination on the surgical monitor in the laboratory environment. However, the limited effective tracking distance restricts the use of this system in the dynamic environment in the real OR. Another eye-tracker system was found with equally high level of resolution but with more flexibility on the tracking distance, as the eye-tracker camera was detached from the monitor. With this system, the surgeon’s gaze during 11 laparoscopic procedures in the OR was recorded successfully. There were many logistical challenges with unobtrusively integrating the eye-tracking equipment into the regular OR workflow and data processing issues in the form of image compatibility and data validation. The experiences and solutions to these challenges are discussed.
- 13 June 2012
- Published by SAGE Publications in Surgical Innovation
- Vol. 20 (3) , 241-248
What Do Surgeons See
Recording eye motions in surgical environments is challenging. This study describes the authors’ experiences with performing eye-tracking for improving surgery training, both in the laboratory and in the operating room (OR). Three different eye-trackers were used, each with different capabilities and requirements. For monitoring eye gaze shifts over the room scene in a simulated OR, a head-mounted system was used. The number of surgeons’ eye glances on the monitor displaying patient vital signs was successfully captured by this system. The resolution of the head-mounted eye-tracker was not sufficient to obtain the gaze coordinates in detail on the surgical display monitor. The authors then selected a high-resolution eye-tracker built in to a 17-inch computer monitor that is capable of recording gaze differences with resolution of 1° of visual angle. This system enables one to investigate surgeons’ eye–hand coordination on the surgical monitor in the laboratory environment. However, the limited effective tracking distance restricts the use of this system in the dynamic environment in the real OR. Another eye-tracker system was found with equally high level of resolution but with more flexibility on the tracking distance, as the eye-tracker camera was detached from the monitor. With this system, the surgeon’s gaze during 11 laparoscopic procedures in the OR was recorded successfully. There were many logistical challenges with unobtrusively integrating the eye-tracking equipment into the regular OR workflow and data processing issues in the form of image compatibility and data validation. The experiences and solutions to these challenges are discussed.
- 1 January 2011
- Vol. 163, 658-62
Quantifying surgeons' vigilance during laparoscopic operations using eyegaze tracking.
The vigilance of surgeons while operating is an important consideration for patient safety. Using a lightweight mobile eyegaze tracker, we can objectively observe and quantify a surgeon's vigilance measured as the frequency and duration of time spent gazing at an anaesthesia monitor displaying various patient vital signs. Expert surgeons and training surgical residents had their eyegaze recorded while performing a mock partial cholecystectomy on a computer simulator. Results show that experts glanced at the patient vital signs more than the residents, indicating a higher level of surgical vigilance.
- 1 January 2011
- Vol. 163, 658-62
Quantifying surgeons' vigilance during laparoscopic operations using eyegaze tracking.
The vigilance of surgeons while operating is an important consideration for patient safety. Using a lightweight mobile eyegaze tracker, we can objectively observe and quantify a surgeon's vigilance measured as the frequency and duration of time spent gazing at an anaesthesia monitor displaying various patient vital signs. Expert surgeons and training surgical residents had their eyegaze recorded while performing a mock partial cholecystectomy on a computer simulator. Results show that experts glanced at the patient vital signs more than the residents, indicating a higher level of surgical vigilance.
- 23 July 2008
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Digital Imaging
- Vol. 22 (4) , 369-382
Evaluating Interaction Techniques for Stack Mode Viewing
Three interaction techniques were evaluated for scrolling stack mode displays of volumetric data. Two used a scroll-wheel mouse: one used only the wheel, while another used a "click and drag" technique for fast scrolling, leaving the wheel for fine adjustments. The third technique used a Shuttle Xpress jog wheel. In a within-subjects design, nine radiologists searched stacked images for simulated hyper-intense regions on brain, knee, and thigh MR studies. Dependent measures were speed, accuracy, navigation path, and user preference. The radiologists considered the task realistic. They had high inter-subject variability in completion times, far larger than the differences between techniques. Most radiologists (eight out of nine) preferred familiar mouse-based techniques. Most participants scanned the data in two passes, first locating anomalies, then scanning for omissions. Participants spent a mean 10.4 s/trial exploring anomalies, with only mild variation between participants. Their rates of forward navigation searching for anomalies varied much more. Interaction technique significantly affected forward navigation rate (scroll wheel 5.4 slices/s, click and drag 9.4, and jog wheel 6.9). It is not clear what constrained the slowest navigators. The fastest navigator used a unique strategy of moving quickly just beyond an anomaly, then backing up. Eight naïve students performed a similar protocol. Their times and variability were similar to the radiologists, but more (three out of eight) students preferred the jog wheel. It may be worthwhile to introduce techniques such as the jog wheel to radiologists during training, and several techniques might be provided on workstations, allowing individuals to choose their preferred method.
- 23 July 2008
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Digital Imaging
- Vol. 22 (4) , 369-382
Evaluating Interaction Techniques for Stack Mode Viewing
Three interaction techniques were evaluated for scrolling stack mode displays of volumetric data. Two used a scroll-wheel mouse: one used only the wheel, while another used a "click and drag" technique for fast scrolling, leaving the wheel for fine adjustments. The third technique used a Shuttle Xpress jog wheel. In a within-subjects design, nine radiologists searched stacked images for simulated hyper-intense regions on brain, knee, and thigh MR studies. Dependent measures were speed, accuracy, navigation path, and user preference. The radiologists considered the task realistic. They had high inter-subject variability in completion times, far larger than the differences between techniques. Most radiologists (eight out of nine) preferred familiar mouse-based techniques. Most participants scanned the data in two passes, first locating anomalies, then scanning for omissions. Participants spent a mean 10.4 s/trial exploring anomalies, with only mild variation between participants. Their rates of forward navigation searching for anomalies varied much more. Interaction technique significantly affected forward navigation rate (scroll wheel 5.4 slices/s, click and drag 9.4, and jog wheel 6.9). It is not clear what constrained the slowest navigators. The fastest navigator used a unique strategy of moving quickly just beyond an anomaly, then backing up. Eight naïve students performed a similar protocol. Their times and variability were similar to the radiologists, but more (three out of eight) students preferred the jog wheel. It may be worthwhile to introduce techniques such as the jog wheel to radiologists during training, and several techniques might be provided on workstations, allowing individuals to choose their preferred method.
- 8 March 2007
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng
- Vol. 6515
Evaluating user interfaces for stack mode viewing
The goal of this research was to evaluate two different stack mode layouts for 3D medical images - a regular stack mode layout where just the topmost image was visible, and a new stack mode layout, which included the images just before and after the main image. We developed stripped down user interfaces to test the techniques, and designed a look-alike radiology task using 3D artificial target stimuli implanted in the slices of medical image volumes. The task required searching for targets and identifying the range of slices containing the targets. Eight naive students participated, using a within-subjects design. We measured the response time and accuracy of subjects using the two layouts and tracked the eyegaze of several subjects while they performed the task. Eyegaze data was divided into fixations and saccades Subjects were 19% slower with the new stack layout than the standard stack layout, but 5 of the 8 subjects preferred the new layout. Analysis of the eyegaze data showed that in the new technique, the context images on both sides were fixated once the target was found in the topmost image. We believe that the extra time was caused by the difficulty in controlling the rate of scrolling, causing overshooting. We surmise that providing some contextual detail such as adjacent slices in the new stack mode layout is helpful to reduce cognitive load for this radiology look-alike task.
- 8 March 2007
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng
- Vol. 6515
Evaluating user interfaces for stack mode viewing
The goal of this research was to evaluate two different stack mode layouts for 3D medical images - a regular stack mode layout where just the topmost image was visible, and a new stack mode layout, which included the images just before and after the main image. We developed stripped down user interfaces to test the techniques, and designed a look-alike radiology task using 3D artificial target stimuli implanted in the slices of medical image volumes. The task required searching for targets and identifying the range of slices containing the targets. Eight naive students participated, using a within-subjects design. We measured the response time and accuracy of subjects using the two layouts and tracked the eyegaze of several subjects while they performed the task. Eyegaze data was divided into fixations and saccades Subjects were 19% slower with the new stack layout than the standard stack layout, but 5 of the 8 subjects preferred the new layout. Analysis of the eyegaze data showed that in the new technique, the context images on both sides were fixated once the target was found in the topmost image. We believe that the extra time was caused by the difficulty in controlling the rate of scrolling, causing overshooting. We surmise that providing some contextual detail such as adjacent slices in the new stack mode layout is helpful to reduce cognitive load for this radiology look-alike task.
- 25 January 2005
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Digital Imaging
- Vol. 18 (2) , 109-115
Designing Better Radiology Workstations: Impact of Two User Interfaces on Interpretation Errors and User Satisfaction
This paper presents our solution for supporting radiologists’ interpretation of digital images by automating image presentation during sequential interpretation steps. We extended current hanging protocols with support for “stages” which reflect the presentation of digital information required to complete a single step within a complex task. We demonstrated the benefits of staging in a user experiment with 20 lay subjects involved in a comparative visual search for targets, similar to a radiology task of identifying anatomical abnormalities. We designed a task and a set of stimuli that allowed us to simulate the interpretation workflow from a typical radiology scenario—reading a chest radiography exam when a prior study is also available. The simulation was enabled by abstracting both the radiologist’s task and the basic workstation navigation functionality. The staged interface was significantly faster than the traditional user interface, provided a 37% reduction in the interpretation errors, and improved user satisfaction.
- 25 January 2005
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Digital Imaging
- Vol. 18 (2) , 109-115
Designing Better Radiology Workstations: Impact of Two User Interfaces on Interpretation Errors and User Satisfaction
This paper presents our solution for supporting radiologists’ interpretation of digital images by automating image presentation during sequential interpretation steps. We extended current hanging protocols with support for “stages” which reflect the presentation of digital information required to complete a single step within a complex task. We demonstrated the benefits of staging in a user experiment with 20 lay subjects involved in a comparative visual search for targets, similar to a radiology task of identifying anatomical abnormalities. We designed a task and a set of stimuli that allowed us to simulate the interpretation workflow from a typical radiology scenario—reading a chest radiography exam when a prior study is also available. The simulation was enabled by abstracting both the radiologist’s task and the basic workstation navigation functionality. The staged interface was significantly faster than the traditional user interface, provided a 37% reduction in the interpretation errors, and improved user satisfaction.
- 1 January 2005
- Published by Springer Nature in Lecture Notes in Computer Science
- Vol. 3749, 868-875
Photo-Realistic Tissue Reflectance Modelling for Minimally Invasive Surgical Simulation
Computer-based simulation is an important tool for surgical skills training and assessment. In general, the degree of realism experienced by the trainees is determined by the visual and biomechanical fidelity of the simulator. In minimally invasive surgery, specular reflections provide an important visual cue for tissue deformation, depth and orientation. This paper describes a novel image-based lighting technique that is particularly suitable for modeling mucous-covered tissue surfaces. We describe how noise functions can be used to control the shape of the specular highlights, and how texture noise is generated and encoded in image-based structure at a pre-processing stage. The proposed technique can be implemented at run-time by using the graphics processor to efficiently attain pixel-level control and photo-realism. The practical value of the technique is assessed with detailed visual scoring and cross comparison experiments by two groups of observers.
- 1 January 2005
- Published by Springer Nature in Lecture Notes in Computer Science
- Vol. 3749, 868-875
Photo-Realistic Tissue Reflectance Modelling for Minimally Invasive Surgical Simulation
Computer-based simulation is an important tool for surgical skills training and assessment. In general, the degree of realism experienced by the trainees is determined by the visual and biomechanical fidelity of the simulator. In minimally invasive surgery, specular reflections provide an important visual cue for tissue deformation, depth and orientation. This paper describes a novel image-based lighting technique that is particularly suitable for modeling mucous-covered tissue surfaces. We describe how noise functions can be used to control the shape of the specular highlights, and how texture noise is generated and encoded in image-based structure at a pre-processing stage. The proposed technique can be implemented at run-time by using the graphics processor to efficiently attain pixel-level control and photo-realism. The practical value of the technique is assessed with detailed visual scoring and cross comparison experiments by two groups of observers.
- 16 May 2002
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng
- Vol. 4685, 174-182
New trends in radiology workstation design
In the radiology workstation design, the race for adding more features is now morphing into an iterative user centric design with the focus on ergonomics and usability. The extent of the list of features for the radiology workstation used to be one of the most significant factors for a Picture Archiving and Communication System (PACS) vendor's ability to sell the radiology workstation. Not anymore is now very much the same between the major players in the PACS market. How these features work together distinguishes different radiology workstations. Integration (with the PACS/Radiology Information System (RIS) systems, with the 3D tool, Reporting Tool etc.), usability (user specific preferences, advanced display protocols, smart activation of tools etc.) and efficiency (what is the output a radiologist can generate with the workstation) are now core factors for selecting a workstation. This paper discusses these new trends in radiology workstation design. We demonstrate the importance of the interaction between the PACS vendor (software engineers) and the customer (radiologists) during the radiology workstation design. We focus on iterative aspects of the workstation development, such as the presentation of early prototypes to as many representative users as possible during the software development cycle and present the results of a survey of 8 radiologists on designing a radiology workstation.
- 16 May 2002
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng
- Vol. 4685, 174-182
New trends in radiology workstation design
In the radiology workstation design, the race for adding more features is now morphing into an iterative user centric design with the focus on ergonomics and usability. The extent of the list of features for the radiology workstation used to be one of the most significant factors for a Picture Archiving and Communication System (PACS) vendor's ability to sell the radiology workstation. Not anymore is now very much the same between the major players in the PACS market. How these features work together distinguishes different radiology workstations. Integration (with the PACS/Radiology Information System (RIS) systems, with the 3D tool, Reporting Tool etc.), usability (user specific preferences, advanced display protocols, smart activation of tools etc.) and efficiency (what is the output a radiologist can generate with the workstation) are now core factors for selecting a workstation. This paper discusses these new trends in radiology workstation design. We demonstrate the importance of the interaction between the PACS vendor (software engineers) and the customer (radiologists) during the radiology workstation design. We focus on iterative aspects of the workstation development, such as the presentation of early prototypes to as many representative users as possible during the software development cycle and present the results of a survey of 8 radiologists on designing a radiology workstation.