TSTimothy A. Shahan

Timothy A. Shahan

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Timothy A. Shahan has a total of 47 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Contingency discrimination training and resurgence: Effects of nonzero alternative reinforcement rates during “off” sessions

    by Timothy A. Shahan, Joshua B. Hiltz, Matias Avellaneda, Brian D. Greer

    Resurgence is an increase in a previously reduced target behavior with worsening conditions for a more recently reinforced alternative behavior. Alternating sessions in which alternative reinforcement is available (i.e., “on” sessions) versus extinction (i.e., “off” sessions) during treatment (i.e., contingency discrimination training [CDT]) reduces resurgence. This experiment examined whether CDT could mitigate resurgence without complete extinction during “off” sessions. Target lever pressing of rats was reinforced in baseline and then extinguished during treatment. In treatment, all groups experienced “on” sessions with high‐rate alternative reinforcement delivered on a variable‐interval (VI) 10‐s schedule. “Off” sessions arranged either extinction, the same (VI 10 s), or lower rates of alternative reinforcement (VI 12.5 s, VI 16.6 s, VI 25 s, or VI 50 s). CDT eliminated resurgence only when extinction was arranged during “off” sessions, but resurgence was reduced when the VI 50 s was arranged. Resurgence as choice in context theory described the data well, assuming that the biasing effects of discriminating the relevant contingencies are a function of the ratio of alternative reinforcement rates for “off” versus “on” sessions. These findings suggest CDT can reduce resurgence without requiring extinction of the alternative response if alternating reinforcement rates differ enough across sessions.

  • The extinction burst: Effects of alternative reinforcement rate

    by Timothy A. Shahan, Matias Avellaneda, Joshua B. Hiltz, Brian D. Greer, Wayne W. Fisher

  • Open Access

    Contingency discrimination training and resurgence: Effects of reduced extinction session durations

    by Timothy A. Shahan, Joshua B. Hiltz, Matias Avellaneda, Brian D. Greer

    Resurgence is an increase in a suppressed target behavior following a worsening of conditions for a more recently reinforced alternative behavior. Prior research shows that exposure to equal‐duration sessions of alternative reinforcement availability versus unavailability during treatment (i.e., contingency discrimination training; CDT) reduces resurgence. Clinically, minimizing exposure to extinction while maintaining the resurgence‐mitigating effects of CDT would be desirable. This experiment examined the effects of reduced off‐session durations by exposing groups of rats to different ratios of off:on session durations: All On (0 min: 30 min), CDT 1:1 (30 min: 30 min), CDT 1:2 (15 min: 30 min), CDT 1:6 (5 min: 30 min), and CDT escalate (i.e., [Esc] off‐session duration increased across sessions). Resurgence decreased exponentially with “off” session duration, with CDT 1:2 reducing resurgence and both CDT 1:1 and CDT Esc eliminating resurgence while generating control of alternative behavior by the prevailing reinforcement contingencies, without increasing the total number of target responses during treatment. Resurgence as choice in context theory described the data well with the assumption that the effect of the signaling properties of the reinforcement contingencies themselves increases linearly with the off:on duration ratio, as is true with the S−/S+ ratio in other discriminations.


  • Further assessment of a model of changeover behavior: Implications for the matching law

    by Matias A. Avellaneda, Timothy A. Shahan

    Choice in concurrent schedules is organized in visits to each alternative, and the duration of these visits is exponentially distributed. A model of changeover behavior based on this fact successfully described changeover behavior in two large data sets from published experiments, but some limitations were apparent in this analysis, seemingly reflecting an effect of the passage of time on the data across the lengthy experiments. This article describes an experiment that exposed rats to a dynamic concurrent variable‐interval procedure designed to address these limitations. One of 35 possible combinations of overall and relative reinforcement rates was chosen pseudorandomly at the beginning of each session without signaling the specific combination in effect. By allowing the sensitivity parameter in the generalized matching law to be a function of the overall reinforcement rate, the model provided a satisfactory description of the results. This modification includes free parameters that presumably reflect the effects of how discriminable the alternatives are and how costly it is to switch between them, increasing the scope of the matching law. The updated model holds promise as the foundation for a general theory of performance in concurrent schedules of reinforcement.

  • The extinction burst: Effects of alternative reinforcement magnitude

    by Timothy A. Shahan, Matias Avellaneda

    Discontinuing reinforcement for an operant behavior sometimes produces a transient increase in responding (i.e., an extinction burst). A matching‐law‐based quantitative model posits that the extinction burst results from the elimination of competition from reinforcement‐related behavior with the onset of extinction. Consistent with this suggestion, retrospective case reviews in applied settings suggest reduced prevalence of the extinction burst when alternative reinforcement is available, but there has been no relevant prospective research. The present experiment used rats and methods approximating conditions in applied settings to examine the effects of alternative reinforcement magnitude on the extinction burst. Lever pressing in baseline produced a one‐pellet reinforcer on a variable‐interval 1.5‐s schedule before a within‐session transition to extinction that included no alternative reinforcement, one pellet, or six pellets of alternative reinforcement. A robust extinction burst was obtained when no alternative reinforcement was available, but the prevalence and magnitude of the extinction burst was reduced with an alternative reinforcer available, more so with the larger alternative reinforcer. The data were well described by the model. Similar prospective studies directly examining related effects in basic and applied settings could strengthen the empirical basis of current practice and further evaluate the utility of the present theoretical approach.


  • Open Access

    Further examining how animals weigh conflicting information about reward sources over time

    by Jack Van Allsburg, Timothy A. Shahan

    Spontaneous recovery of choice is a behavioral phenomenon where a delay period (without new experience) elicits the recovery of a preference consistent with a previous distribution of rewards, rather than the most recently experienced distribution of rewards. On short timescales (< 48 h), the occurrence of spontaneous recovery of choice has been effectively predicted by the Temporal Weighting Rule. However, previous study of this phenomenon over longer timescales (> 48 h) has found results inconsistent with model predictions. The present experiments investigated three potential explanations for these results: (1.) whether time’s passage alone causes animals to revert to random exploratory behavior; (2.) whether time’s effect on behavior is moderated by experience of volatility in rewards during training; and (3.) whether a drift toward random exploratory behavior produced by time’s passage can be distinguished from the effect of spontaneous recovery of choice. Subjects experienced varied reward conditions in a concurrent choice procedure before preference between options was evaluated at various test delays. Obtained results ruled out these first two explanations, but were inconclusive in distinguishing the effects of a drift toward random exploratory behavior from the effect of spontaneous recovery of choice. Limitations and directions for further investigation are discussed.

  • Open Access

    Effects of reinforcer probability on attending to element and compound sample stimuli

    by Eric A. Thrailkill, Christopher A. Podlesnik, Stacey L. Quick, Timothy A. Shahan

    Previous research has shown that divided‐attention performance is sensitive to variations in relative reinforcement in a manner consistent with the generalized matching law. Two experiments with pigeons were designed to better understand the effects of different reinforcement conditions on divided‐attention performance. Experiment 1 asked whether separate experience with different relative reinforcement probabilities for elements alone would produce changes in performance during nondifferentially reinforced divided‐attention trials with compound samples consisting of those elements. The results suggest that accuracy following compound sample trials varied as a function of relative reinforcement experienced in element trials in a manner consistent with the matching law. Experiment 2 used an adjusting‐sample‐duration procedure to maintain constant accuracy on element and divided‐attention trials and varied the probability of reinforcement across conditions. The sample durations that were required to maintain constant accuracy increased as reinforcement probability decreased even though that longer sample durations were required to maintain accuracy for compound‐sample trials than for element‐sample trials (the element‐superiority effect). Overall, the present results are consistent with the notion that increased attention is allocated to stimuli that are associated with more reinforcement.


  • Punishment and dynamic choice: Assessment of the direct‐suppression model

    by Rafaela M. Fontes, Timothy A. Shahan

    The effects of punishment rate on response allocation were investigated using a choice procedure where relative reinforcement rates changed rapidly within session. Predictions from a modified version of the direct‐suppression model were tested in two separate experiments. In both experiments, sessions were composed of seven unsignaled components, each programming a different reinforcement ratio. In Experiment 1, equal punishment rates were superimposed on the schedule of reinforcement for both responses and absolute punishment rates increased across blocks of sessions. Punishment increased preference for the richer schedule of reinforcement, but the degree of the preference shift was not a function of absolute punishment rates. In Experiment 2, unequal punishment rates were superimposed on the schedules of reinforcement for both responses and relative punishment rates changed across blocks of sessions. Response allocation shifted away from the richer punishment schedule creating a bias toward the option associated with less frequent punishment. The results from both experiments challenged the predictions of the direct‐suppression model. Furthermore, fits of the generalized matching law to the data indicated that superimposition of equal or unequal punishment schedules on responses maintained by unequal reinforcement schedules differentially affect the values of sensitivity and bias.


  • The extinction burst: Effects of reinforcement magnitude

    by Timothy A. Shahan, Matias Avellaneda

    The extinction burst is an increase in an operant behavior early in the transition to extinction. A matching‐law‐based quantitative theory suggests that it results from the elimination of competition from reinforcement‐related behavior that accompanies the transition to extinction. This experiment examined the effects of reinforcement magnitude on the extinction burst with rats. Responding produced either 1 pellet or 6 pellets prior to a within‐session transition to extinction. Baseline response rates were lower with 6 pellets than with 1 pellet but increased more in the first minute of extinction following 6 pellets. Furthermore, an order effect was observed where rats having first experienced extinction following 1 pellet showed a smaller extinction burst when subsequently trained with 6 pellets—an outcome resulting from a faster deceleration of responding during extinction. The model described the data well, including the order effect, when augmented to include the potential asymmetrical influence of learning to discriminate the continued absence of different magnitudes of reinforcement. We conclude that the approach holds promise by formally incorporating the extinction burst into the corpus of matching theory and serving as an example of the utility of better aligning basic research methods and theorizing with areas of applied concern.