Julie M. Stevens

Holocytochrome c synthase (HCCS) attaches heme covalently to mitochondrial respiratory cytochromes c. Little is known about the reaction of heme attachment to apocytochromes c by HCCS, although recently it has been established that the CXXCH motif and the N‐terminus of the apocytochrome polypeptide are important protein–protein recognition motifs. Here, we explore further the important features of the N‐terminal sequence and investigate what variations in the CXXCH residues are productively recognised by HCCS in its substrate.

Cytochromes c comprise a diverse and widespread family of proteins containing covalently bound heme that are central to the life of most organisms. In many bacteria and in certain mitochondria, the synthesis of cytochromes c is performed by a complex post-translational modification apparatus called System I (or cytochrome c maturation, Ccm, system). In Escherichia coli, there are eight maturation proteins, several of which are involved in heme handling, but the mechanism of heme transfer from one protein to the next is not known. Attachment of the heme to the apocytochrome occurs via a novel covalent bond to a histidine residue of the heme chaperone CcmE. The discovery of a variant maturation system (System I*) has provided a new tool for studying cytochrome c assembly because the variant CcmE functions via a cysteine residue in the place of the histidine of System I. In this work, we use site-directed mutagenesis on both maturation systems to probe the function of the individual component proteins as well as their concerted action in transferring heme to the cytochrome c substrate. The roles of CcmA, CcmC, CcmE, and CcmF in the heme delivery process are compared between Systems I and I*. We show that a previously proposed quinone-binding site on CcmF is not essential for either system. Significant differences in the heme chemistry involved in the formation of cytochromes c in the variant system add new pieces to the cytochrome c biogenesis puzzle.

Cytochromes c are central proteins in energy transduction processes by virtue of their functions in electron transfer in respiration and photosynthesis. They have heme covalently attached to a characteristic CXXCH motif via protein‐catalyzed post‐translational modification reactions. Several systems with diverse constituent proteins have been identified in different organisms and are required to perform the heme attachment and associated functions. The necessary steps are translocation of the apocytochrome polypeptide to the site of heme attachment, transport and provision of heme to the appropriate compartment, reduction and chaperoning of the apocytochrome, and finally, formation of the thioether bonds between heme and two cysteines in the cytochrome. Here we summarize the established classical models for these processes and present recent progress in our understanding of the individual steps within the different cytochrome c biogenesis systems. © 2013 IUBMB Life, 65(3):209–216, 2013

Heme attachment to c‐type cytochromes in bacteria requires cysteine thiols in the CXXCH motif of the protein. The involvement of the periplasmic disulfide generation system in this process remains unclear. We undertake a systematic evaluation of the role of DsbA and DsbD in cytochrome c biogenesis in Escherichia coli and show unequivocally that DsbA is not essential for holocytochrome production under aerobic or anaerobic conditions. We also prove that DsbD is important but not essential for maturation of c‐type cytochromes. We discuss the findings in the context of a model in which heme attachment to, and oxidation of, the apocytochrome are competing processes.

The covalent attachment of heme to mitochondrial cytochrome c is catalysed by holocytochrome c synthase (HCCS, also called heme lyase). How HCCS functions and recognises the substrate apocytochrome is unknown. Here we have examined HCCS recognition of a chimeric substrate comprising a short mitochondrial cytochrome c N-terminal region with the C-terminal sequence, including the CXXCH heme-binding motif, of a bacterial cytochrome c that is not otherwise processed by HCCS. Heme attachment to the chimera demonstrates the importance of the N-terminal region of the cytochrome. A series of variants of a mitochondrial cytochrome c with amino acid replacements in the N-terminal region have narrowed down the specificity determinants, providing insight into HCCS substrate recognition.

The CXXCH motif is usually recognized in the bacterial periplasm as a haem attachment site in apocytochromes c. There is evidence that the Escherichia coli Ccm (cytochrome c maturation) system recognizes little more than the CXXCH sequence. A limited number of periplasmic proteins have this motif and yet are not c-type cytochromes. To explore how unwanted haem attachment to CXXCH might be avoided, and to determine whether haem attachment to the surface of a non-cytochrome protein would be possible, we converted the active-site CXXCK motif of a thioredoxin-like protein into CXXCH, the C-terminal domain of the transmembrane oxidoreductase DsbD (cDsbD). The E. coli Ccm system was found to catalyse haem attachment to a very small percentage of the resultant protein (∼0.2%). We argue that cDsbD folds sufficiently rapidly that only a small fraction fails to avoid the Ccm system, in contrast with bona fide c-type cytochromes that only adopt their tertiary structure following haem attachment. We also demonstrate covalent haem attachment at a low level in vivo to the periplasmic disulfide isomerase DsbC, which contains a native CXXCH motif. These observations provide insight into substrate recognition by the Ccm system and expand our understanding of the requirements for covalent haem attachment to proteins. The possible evolutionary relationship between thioredoxins and c-type cytochromes is discussed.

Escherichia coli employs several c -type cytochromes, which are found in the periplasm or on the periplasmic side of the cytoplasmic membrane; they are used for respiration under different growth conditions. All E. coli c -type cytochromes are multiheme cytochromes; E. coli does not have a monoheme cytochrome c of the kind found in mitochondria. The attachment of heme to cytochromes c occurs in the periplasm, and so the apoprotein must be transported across the cytoplasmic membrane; this step is mediated by the Sec system, which transports unfolded proteins across the membrane. The protein CcmE has been found to bind heme covalently via a single bond and then transfer the heme to apocytochromes. It should be mentioned that far less complex systems for cytochrome c biogenesis exist in other organisms and that enterobacteria do not function as a representative model system for the process in general, although plant mitochondria use the Ccm system found in E. coli . The variety and distribution of cytochromes and their biogenesis systems reflect their significance and centrality in cellular bioenergetics, though the necessity for and origin of the diverse biogenesis systems are enigmatic.

The proteins CcmA and CcmB have long been known to be essential for cytochrome c maturation in Escherichia coli. We have purified a complex of these proteins, and found it to have ATP hydrolysis activity. CcmA, which has the features of a soluble ATP hydrolysis subunit, is found in a membrane‐bound complex only when CcmB is present in the membrane. Mutation of the Walker A motif in CcmA(K40D) results in loss of the in vitro ATPase activity and in loss of cytochrome c biogenesis in vivo. The same mutation does not prevent covalent attachment of heme to the heme chaperone CcmE, but holo‐CcmE is, for some unidentified reason, incompetent for heme transfer to an apocytochrome c or for release into the periplasm as a soluble variant. Addition of exogenous heme to heme‐permeable E. coli with a ccmA deletion did not restore cytochrome c production. Our results suggest a role for CcmAB in the handling of heme by CcmE, which is chemically complex and involves an unusual histidine–heme covalent bond.

Haem (Fe-protoporphyrin IX) is a cofactor found in a wide variety of proteins. It confers diverse functions, including electron transfer, the binding and sensing of gases, and many types of catalysis. The majority of cofactors are non-covalently attached to proteins. There are, however, some proteins in which the cofactor binds covalently and one of the major protein classes characterized by covalent cofactor attachment is the c-type cytochromes. The characteristic haem-binding mode of c-type cytochromes requires the formation of two covalent bonds between two cysteine residues in the protein and the two vinyl groups of haem. Haem attachment is a complex post-translational process that, in bacteria such as Escherichia coli, occurs in the periplasmic space and involves the participation of many proteins. Unexpectedly, it has been found that the haem chaperone CcmE (cytochrome cmaturation), which is an essential intermediate in the process, also binds haem covalently before transferring the haem to apocytochromes. A single covalent bond is involved and occurs between a haem vinyl group and a histidine residue of CcmE. Several in vitro and in vivo studies have provided insight into the function of this protein and into the overall process of cytochrome c biogenesis.