Robert D. Holt
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Robert D. Holt has a total of 588 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Michael Barfield
Department of Zoology, University of FloridaGainesville, FL 32611-8525, USA
7 shared publicationsHolt
4 shared publicationsTimothy H. Keitt
3 shared publicationsAlison M. Dunn
2 shared publications- Andrew Gonzalez
Department of Biology, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada
2 shared publications Andrew P. Dobson
Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ 08540, USA
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Top Cited Papers
- 17 November 2009
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 106 (supplement) , 19659-19665
Bringing the Hutchinsonian niche into the 21st century: Ecological and evolutionary perspectives
G. Evelyn Hutchinson more than a half century ago proposed that one could characterize the ecological niche of a species as an abstract mapping of population dynamics onto an environmental space, the axes of which are abiotic and biotic factors that influence birth and death rates. If a habitat has conditions within a species' niche, a population should persist without immigration from external sources, whereas if conditions are outside the niche, it faces extinction. Analyses of species' niches are essential to understanding controls on species' geographical range limits and how these limits might shift in our rapidly changing world. Recent developments in ecology and evolutionary biology suggest it is time to revisit and refine Hutchinson's niche concept. After reviewing techniques for quantifying niches, I examine subtleties that arise because of impacts species have on their own environments, the density-dependent modulation of how individuals experience environments, and the interplay of dispersal and temporal heterogeneity in determining population persistence. Moreover, the evolutionary record over all time scales reveals a spectrum of rates of change in species' niches, from rapid niche evolution to profound niche conservatism. Substantial challenges revolving around the evolutionary dimension of the Hutchinsonian niche include quantifying the magnitude of evolved intraspecific and clade-level variation in niches and understanding the factors that govern where along the spectrum of potential evolutionary rates any given lineage lies. A growing body of theory provides elements of a conceptual framework for understanding niche conservatism and evolution, paving the way for an evolutionary theory of the niche.
- 17 November 2009
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 106 (supplement) , 19659-19665
Top Cited PapersBringing the Hutchinsonian niche into the 21st century: Ecological and evolutionary perspectives
G. Evelyn Hutchinson more than a half century ago proposed that one could characterize the ecological niche of a species as an abstract mapping of population dynamics onto an environmental space, the axes of which are abiotic and biotic factors that influence birth and death rates. If a habitat has conditions within a species' niche, a population should persist without immigration from external sources, whereas if conditions are outside the niche, it faces extinction. Analyses of species' niches are essential to understanding controls on species' geographical range limits and how these limits might shift in our rapidly changing world. Recent developments in ecology and evolutionary biology suggest it is time to revisit and refine Hutchinson's niche concept. After reviewing techniques for quantifying niches, I examine subtleties that arise because of impacts species have on their own environments, the density-dependent modulation of how individuals experience environments, and the interplay of dispersal and temporal heterogeneity in determining population persistence. Moreover, the evolutionary record over all time scales reveals a spectrum of rates of change in species' niches, from rapid niche evolution to profound niche conservatism. Substantial challenges revolving around the evolutionary dimension of the Hutchinsonian niche include quantifying the magnitude of evolved intraspecific and clade-level variation in niches and understanding the factors that govern where along the spectrum of potential evolutionary rates any given lineage lies. A growing body of theory provides elements of a conceptual framework for understanding niche conservatism and evolution, paving the way for an evolutionary theory of the niche.
- 14 October 2009
- Published by Wiley in Molecular Ecology
- Vol. 18 (21) , 4347-4348
Up against the edge: invasive species as testbeds for basic questions about evolution in heterogeneous environments
Yogi Berra is often credited with having opined that 'prediction is very difficult, especially about the future'. There is no discipline for which this statement holds with more force than invasion biology, where it has been historically very challenging to predict the fate of introduced species (Williamson 2006). Some species after introduction quickly go extinct. Other relatively similar species may persist, but with little spread from their initial beachheads. Yet others can become aggressive invaders, with devastating consequences for native communities and ecosystems. This lack of predictability may of course sometimes reflect a simple lack of knowledge, both about key features of a species' basic biology, and about the environmental and community milieu in which invasion occurs (Williamson 2006). However, unpredictability may also arise from a fundamental fact about populations of living organisms - they almost always contain genetic variation, and so are not fixed entities responding to an environmental template, but instead labile in how they cope with the environment, over many spatial and temporal scales. Chance vicissitudes in the origination, maintenance and spatial organization of genetic variation could play a large role in generating the observed unpredictability in the fates of introduced species. The degree to which a particular introduced species becomes 'invasive'- to the extent of coming to the attention of worried land managers, governmental officials and the public - may reflect in part its capacity for adaptive evolution across a wide range of environmental conditions.
- 14 October 2009
- Published by Wiley in Molecular Ecology
- Vol. 18 (21) , 4347-4348
Up against the edge: invasive species as testbeds for basic questions about evolution in heterogeneous environments
Yogi Berra is often credited with having opined that 'prediction is very difficult, especially about the future'. There is no discipline for which this statement holds with more force than invasion biology, where it has been historically very challenging to predict the fate of introduced species (Williamson 2006). Some species after introduction quickly go extinct. Other relatively similar species may persist, but with little spread from their initial beachheads. Yet others can become aggressive invaders, with devastating consequences for native communities and ecosystems. This lack of predictability may of course sometimes reflect a simple lack of knowledge, both about key features of a species' basic biology, and about the environmental and community milieu in which invasion occurs (Williamson 2006). However, unpredictability may also arise from a fundamental fact about populations of living organisms - they almost always contain genetic variation, and so are not fixed entities responding to an environmental template, but instead labile in how they cope with the environment, over many spatial and temporal scales. Chance vicissitudes in the origination, maintenance and spatial organization of genetic variation could play a large role in generating the observed unpredictability in the fates of introduced species. The degree to which a particular introduced species becomes 'invasive'- to the extent of coming to the attention of worried land managers, governmental officials and the public - may reflect in part its capacity for adaptive evolution across a wide range of environmental conditions.
- 25 February 2009
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
- Vol. 276 (1661) , 1435-1442
Trophic interactions and range limits: the diverse roles of predation
Interactions between natural enemies and their victims are a pervasive feature of the natural world. In this paper, we discuss trophic interactions as determinants of geographic range limits. Predators can directly limit ranges, or do so in conjunction with competition. Dispersal can at times permit a specialist predator to constrain the distribution of its prey—and thus itself—along a gradient. Conversely, we suggest that predators can also at times permit prey to have larger ranges than would be seen without predation. We discuss several ecological and evolutionary mechanisms that can lead to this counter-intuitive outcome.
- 25 February 2009
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
- Vol. 276 (1661) , 1435-1442
Trophic interactions and range limits: the diverse roles of predation
Interactions between natural enemies and their victims are a pervasive feature of the natural world. In this paper, we discuss trophic interactions as determinants of geographic range limits. Predators can directly limit ranges, or do so in conjunction with competition. Dispersal can at times permit a specialist predator to constrain the distribution of its prey—and thus itself—along a gradient. Conversely, we suggest that predators can also at times permit prey to have larger ranges than would be seen without predation. We discuss several ecological and evolutionary mechanisms that can lead to this counter-intuitive outcome.
- 7 November 2008
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Theoretical Biology
- Vol. 255 (1) , 152-161
Generalizing Levins metapopulation model in explicit space: Models of intermediate complexity
- 7 November 2008
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Theoretical Biology
- Vol. 255 (1) , 152-161
Generalizing Levins metapopulation model in explicit space: Models of intermediate complexity
- Open Access
THEORETICAL PERSPECTIVES ON RESOURCE PULSES
Over the last several decades, there has been a growing appreciation of the importance of nonequilibrial phenomena and transient dynamics in explaining the structure of ecological communities. This paper provides an overview of theoretical themes related to resource pulses. Theoretical models suggest short‐term responses to a single pulse can qualitatively differ from longer‐term responses. Recurrent resource pulses can alter community structure, permitting coexistence that otherwise would not occur, or hamper coexistence mechanisms effective in stable environments. For a given resource input, system responses can be more dramatic with short pulses. Resource pulses can cause transitions between alternative states. Dispersal permits species to exploit locally sporadic resource pulses and persist in environments that on average are unsuitable. All these issues are ripe for further theoretical explorations.
Open AccessTHEORETICAL PERSPECTIVES ON RESOURCE PULSES
Over the last several decades, there has been a growing appreciation of the importance of nonequilibrial phenomena and transient dynamics in explaining the structure of ecological communities. This paper provides an overview of theoretical themes related to resource pulses. Theoretical models suggest short‐term responses to a single pulse can qualitatively differ from longer‐term responses. Recurrent resource pulses can alter community structure, permitting coexistence that otherwise would not occur, or hamper coexistence mechanisms effective in stable environments. For a given resource input, system responses can be more dramatic with short pulses. Resource pulses can cause transitions between alternative states. Dispersal permits species to exploit locally sporadic resource pulses and persist in environments that on average are unsuitable. All these issues are ripe for further theoretical explorations.
- 1 January 2008
- Published by University of Chicago Press
- p. 277-300
Spatial Dynamics and Coexistence of the Serengeti Grazer Community
Two characteristics define the Serengeti grazer community in the minds of many observers: exceptional species diversity and exceptional mobility. Twenty-eight species of large ungulates are found in the greater Serengeti ecosystem. Many of these species have similar resource needs and occupy similar habitats. Under these circumstances, one would normally expect to witness competitive exclusion by the dominant competitor and hence reduced diversity; yet there is unparalleled diversity in the Serengeti. This chapter uses simulation models to explore three possible explanations for this seeming paradox, all of which point to size variation among herbivores, spatial variation in resources, and behavioral responses to this variation. The first hypothesis is that no grazer is consistently at a competitive advantage. A second plausible hypothesis is that Serengeti grazers facilitate each other, rather than compete for food resources. A third hypothesis is that seasonal migration by the predominant species—the wildebeest—prevents competitive exclusion of other grazers.
- 1 January 2008
- Published by University of Chicago Press
- p. 277-300
Spatial Dynamics and Coexistence of the Serengeti Grazer Community
Two characteristics define the Serengeti grazer community in the minds of many observers: exceptional species diversity and exceptional mobility. Twenty-eight species of large ungulates are found in the greater Serengeti ecosystem. Many of these species have similar resource needs and occupy similar habitats. Under these circumstances, one would normally expect to witness competitive exclusion by the dominant competitor and hence reduced diversity; yet there is unparalleled diversity in the Serengeti. This chapter uses simulation models to explore three possible explanations for this seeming paradox, all of which point to size variation among herbivores, spatial variation in resources, and behavioral responses to this variation. The first hypothesis is that no grazer is consistently at a competitive advantage. A second plausible hypothesis is that Serengeti grazers facilitate each other, rather than compete for food resources. A third hypothesis is that seasonal migration by the predominant species—the wildebeest—prevents competitive exclusion of other grazers.
- 1 January 2008
- Published by University of Chicago Press
- p. 241-276
Reticulate Food Webs in Space and Time
This chapter uses some simple models to determine what kinds of predictions can be made about ecosystem responses to some plausible perturbations, and what additional information is needed to either enable or improve these predictions. It begins by proposing three potential perturbations: (1) increased mortality of lions, which could arise due to upsurges in disease such as canine distemper, or direct attacks from humans; (2) increased mortality of wildebeest, which, for instance, could reflect an outbreak of rinderpest; and (3) an increase in the growth rate of the major grass species (a potential, although far from certain, outcome of global climate change). It then evaluates current knowledge of the Serengeti food web and applies it to the task of determining the consequences of these perturbations. In addition to assessing how well the fate of major players within the ecosystem can be predicted, this exercise can shed light on the potential ability to make similar types of predictions in other ecosystems.
- 1 January 2008
- Published by University of Chicago Press
- p. 241-276
Reticulate Food Webs in Space and Time
This chapter uses some simple models to determine what kinds of predictions can be made about ecosystem responses to some plausible perturbations, and what additional information is needed to either enable or improve these predictions. It begins by proposing three potential perturbations: (1) increased mortality of lions, which could arise due to upsurges in disease such as canine distemper, or direct attacks from humans; (2) increased mortality of wildebeest, which, for instance, could reflect an outbreak of rinderpest; and (3) an increase in the growth rate of the major grass species (a potential, although far from certain, outcome of global climate change). It then evaluates current knowledge of the Serengeti food web and applies it to the task of determining the consequences of these perturbations. In addition to assessing how well the fate of major players within the ecosystem can be predicted, this exercise can shed light on the potential ability to make similar types of predictions in other ecosystems.
ALTERNATIVE PREY AND THE DYNAMICS OF INTRAGUILD PREDATION: THEORETICAL PERSPECTIVES
A rich body of theoretical literature now exists focused on the three-species module of intraguild predation (IGP), in which a top predator both attacks and competes with an intermediate predator. Simple models of intraguild predation are often unstable, either because one consumer is excluded, or because sustained oscillations emerge from long feedback loops. Yet, many natural IGP systems robustly persist. Standard models of intraguild predation simplify natural systems in crucial ways that could influence persistence; in particular, many empirical IGP systems are embedded in communities with alternative prey species. We briefly review the key conclusions of standard three-species IGP theory, and then present results of theoretical explorations of how alternative prey can influence the persistence and stability of a focal intraguild predation interaction.
ALTERNATIVE PREY AND THE DYNAMICS OF INTRAGUILD PREDATION: THEORETICAL PERSPECTIVES
A rich body of theoretical literature now exists focused on the three-species module of intraguild predation (IGP), in which a top predator both attacks and competes with an intermediate predator. Simple models of intraguild predation are often unstable, either because one consumer is excluded, or because sustained oscillations emerge from long feedback loops. Yet, many natural IGP systems robustly persist. Standard models of intraguild predation simplify natural systems in crucial ways that could influence persistence; in particular, many empirical IGP systems are embedded in communities with alternative prey species. We briefly review the key conclusions of standard three-species IGP theory, and then present results of theoretical explorations of how alternative prey can influence the persistence and stability of a focal intraguild predation interaction.
- 1 January 2007
- Published by JSTOR in The American Naturalist
- Vol. 169 (5) , 690
Predation Can Increase the Prevalence of Infectious Disease
Many host‐pathogen interactions are embedded in a web of other interspecific interactions. Recent theoretical studies have suggested that reductions in predator abundance can indirectly lead to upsurges in infectious diseases harbored by prey populations. In this note, we use simple models to show that in some circumstances, predation can actually increase the equilibrial prevalence of infection in a host, where prevalence is defined as the fraction of host population that is infected. Our results show that there is no complete generalization possible about how shifts in predation pressure translate into shifts in infection levels, without some understanding of host population regulation and the role of acquired immunity. Our results further highlight the importance of understanding the dynamics of nonregulatory pathogens in reservoir host populations and the understudied effects of demographic costs incurred by individuals that survive infection and develop acquired immunity.
- 1 January 2007
- Published by JSTOR in The American Naturalist
- Vol. 169 (5) , 690
Predation Can Increase the Prevalence of Infectious Disease
Many host‐pathogen interactions are embedded in a web of other interspecific interactions. Recent theoretical studies have suggested that reductions in predator abundance can indirectly lead to upsurges in infectious diseases harbored by prey populations. In this note, we use simple models to show that in some circumstances, predation can actually increase the equilibrial prevalence of infection in a host, where prevalence is defined as the fraction of host population that is infected. Our results show that there is no complete generalization possible about how shifts in predation pressure translate into shifts in infection levels, without some understanding of host population regulation and the role of acquired immunity. Our results further highlight the importance of understanding the dynamics of nonregulatory pathogens in reservoir host populations and the understudied effects of demographic costs incurred by individuals that survive infection and develop acquired immunity.
- 1 January 2007
- Published by JSTOR in The American Naturalist
- Vol. 169 (3)
Canalization Breakdown and Evolution in a Source-Sink System
Understanding the process of adaptation to novel environments may help to elucidate several ecological phenomena, from the stability of species range margins to host‐pathogen specificity and persistence in degraded habitats. We study evolution in one type of novel environment: a sink habitat where populations cannot persist without recurrent immigration from a source population. Previous studies on source‐sink evolution have focused on how extrinsic environmental factors influence adaptation to a sink, but few studies have examined how intrinsic genetic factors influence adaptation. We use an individual‐based model to explore how genetic canalization that evolves in gene regulation networks influences the adaptation of a population to a sink. We find that as canalization in the regulation network increases, the probability of adaptation to the novel habitat decreases. When adaptation to the habitat does occur, it is usually preceded by a breakdown of canalization. As evolution continues in the novel habitat, canalization reemerges, but a legacy of the breakdown may remain, even after several generations. We also find that environmental noise tends to increase the probability of adaptation to the novel habitat. Our results suggest that the details of genetic architecture can significantly influence the likelihood of niche evolution in novel environments.
- 1 January 2007
- Published by JSTOR in The American Naturalist
- Vol. 169 (3)
Canalization Breakdown and Evolution in a Source-Sink System
Understanding the process of adaptation to novel environments may help to elucidate several ecological phenomena, from the stability of species range margins to host‐pathogen specificity and persistence in degraded habitats. We study evolution in one type of novel environment: a sink habitat where populations cannot persist without recurrent immigration from a source population. Previous studies on source‐sink evolution have focused on how extrinsic environmental factors influence adaptation to a sink, but few studies have examined how intrinsic genetic factors influence adaptation. We use an individual‐based model to explore how genetic canalization that evolves in gene regulation networks influences the adaptation of a population to a sink. We find that as canalization in the regulation network increases, the probability of adaptation to the novel habitat decreases. When adaptation to the habitat does occur, it is usually preceded by a breakdown of canalization. As evolution continues in the novel habitat, canalization reemerges, but a legacy of the breakdown may remain, even after several generations. We also find that environmental noise tends to increase the probability of adaptation to the novel habitat. Our results suggest that the details of genetic architecture can significantly influence the likelihood of niche evolution in novel environments.