GGGene Gindi

Gene Gindi

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Gene Gindi has a total of 21 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Rapid performance evaluation for ideal FROC and AFROC observers

    by Bin Liu, Parmeshwar Khurd, Gene Gindi

    FROC and AFROC analyses are useful in medical imaging to characterize detection performance for the case of multiple lesions. We had previously developed1 ideal FROC and AFROC observers. Their performance is ideal in that they maximize the area or any partial area under the FROC or AFROC curve. Such observers could be useful in imaging system optimization or in assessing human observer efficiency. However, the performance evaluation of these ideal observers is impractically computationally complex. We propose 3 reasonable assumptions under which the ideal observers reduce approximately to a particular form of a scan-statistic observer. Performance for the "scan-statistic-reduced ideal observer" can be evaluated far more rapidly albeit with slight error than that of the originally proposed ideal observer. Through simulations, we confirm the accuracy of our approximate ideal observers. We also compare the performance of our approximate ideal observer with that of a conventional scan-statistic observer and show that the performance of our approximate ideal observer is significantly greater.

  • Open Access

    Collimator optimization in SPECT based on a joint detection and localization task

    by Lili Zhou, Gene Gindi

    In SPECT the collimator is a crucial element of the imaging chain and controls the noise-resolution tradeoff of the collected data. Optimizing collimator design has been a long studied topic, with many different criteria used to evaluate the design. One class of criteria is task based, in which the collimator is designed to optimize detection of a signal (lesion). Here we consider a new, more realistic task, the joint detection and localization of a signal. Furthermore, we use an ideal observer-one that attains a theoretically maximum task performance-to optimize collimator design. The ideal observer operates on the sinogram data. We consider a family of parallel-hole low-energy collimators of varying resolution and efficiency and optimize over this set. We observe that for a 2D object characterized by noise due to background variability and a sinogram with photon noise, the optimal collimator tends to be of lower resolution and higher efficiency than equivalent commercial collimators. Furthermore, this optimal design is insensitive to the tolerance radius within which the signal must be localized. So for this scenario, the addition of a localization task does not change the optimal collimator. Optimal collimator resolution gets worse as signal size grows, and improves as the level of background variability noise increases. These latter two trends are also observed when the detection task is signal-known-exactly and background variable.


  • The efficiency of the human observer for lesion detection and localization in emission tomography

    by Bin Liu, Lili Zhou, Santosh Kulkarni, Gene Gindi

    For the medically relevant task of joint detection and localization of a signal (lesion) in an emission computed tomographic (ECT) image, it is of interest to measure the efficiency, defined as the relative task performance of a human observer versus that of an ideal observer. Efficiency studies can be used in system optimization, improving postprocessing (e.g., reconstruction) algorithms, deriving human-emulating model observers and computer-aided detection methods. Calculation of ideal observer performance for ECT is highly computationally complex. We can, however, compute ideal observer performance exactly using a simplified 'filtered-noise' model of ECT. This model results in images whose correlation structure, due to quantum noise, background variability and regularization, is similar to that of real ECT reconstructed images. A two-alternative forced choice test is used to obtain the performance of the human observers. We compare the efficiency of our joint detection-localization task with that of a corresponding signal-known-exactly (SKE) detection task. For the joint task, efficiency is low when the search tolerance is stringent. Efficiency for the joint task rises with signal intensity but is flat for the SKE task. For both tasks, efficiency peaks at a mid-range level of regularization corresponding to a particular noise-resolution tradeoff.


  • Impact on Reader Performance for Lesion-Detection/ Localization Tasks of Anatomical Priors in SPECT Reconstruction

    by Andre Lehovich, Philippe P. Bruyant, Howard S. Gifford, Peter B. Schneider, Shayne Squires, Robert Licho, Gene Gindi, Michael A. King

    With increasing availability of multimodality imaging systems, high-resolution anatomical images can be used to guide the reconstruction of emission tomography studies. By measuring reader performance on a lesion detection task, this study investigates the improvement in image-quality due to use of prior anatomical knowledge, for example organ or lesion boundaries, during SPECT reconstruction. Simulated 67Ga -citrate source and attenuation distributions were created from the mathematical cardiac-torso (MCAT) anthropomorphic digital phantom. The SIMIND Monte Carlo software was then used to generate SPECT projection data. The data were reconstructed using the De Pierro maximum a posteriori (MAP) algorithm and the rescaled-block-iterative (RBI) algorithm for comparison. We compared several degrees of prior knowledge about the anatomy: no knowledge about the anatomy; knowledge of organ boundaries; knowledge of organ and lesion boundaries; and knowledge of organ, lesion, and pseudo-lesion (non-emission uptake altering) boundaries. The MAP reconstructions used quadratic smoothing within anatomical regions, but not across any provided region boundaries. The reconstructed images were read by human observers searching for lesions in a localization receiver operating characteristic (LROC) study of the relative detection/localization accuracies of the reconstruction algorithms. Area under the LROC curve was computed for each algorithm as the comparison metric. We also had humans read images reconstructed using different prior strengths to determine the optimal trade-off between data consistency and the anatomical prior. Finally by mixing together images reconstructed with and without the prior, we tested to see if having an anatomical prior only some of the time changes the observer's detection/localization accuracy on lesions where no boundary prior is available. We found that anatomical priors including organ and lesion boundaries improve observer performance on the lesion detection/localization task. Use of just organ boundaries did not provide a statistically significant improvement in performance however. We also found that optimal prior strength depends on the level of anatomical knowledge, with a broad plateau in which observer performance is near optimal. We found no evidence that having anatomical priors use lesion boundaries only when available changes the observer's performance when they are not available. We conclude that use of anatomical priors with organ and lesion boundaries improves reader performance on a lesion-detection/localization task, and that pseudo-lesion boundaries do not hurt reader performance. However, we did not find evidence that a prior using only organ boundaries helps observer performance. Therefore we suggest prior strength should be tuned to the organ-only case, since a prior will likely not be available for all lesions.


  • Statistical Properties of SPECT MAP Reconstruction Incorporating Window Based Scatter Correction

    by Santosh Kulkarni, Parmeshwar Khurd, Lili Zhou, Gene Gindi

    In SPECT, the sinogram contains scatter counts that degrade the reconstructed image quality. We develop theoretical expressions to predict the reconstructed mean, covariance, and local point-spread function for SPECT MAP (maximum a posteriori) reconstructions. These expressions apply to window-based scatter correction methods, such as the triple-energy-window method, where the scatter correction is incorporated directly into the forward imaging model as an affine term. In addition this forward imaging model is incorporated directly in the MAP objective. We model a scatter estimate as a noisy quantity so that the reconstruction is driven by both photon noise in the photopeak and the noise in the scatter estimate. We use sample reconstruction methods to validate our theoretical expressions. We compare the speed of our theoretical methods to that of methods based on sample reconstructions. Such theoretical formulae could be used to rapidly assess the impact of different scatter correction strategies on image quality.


  • Open Access

    Aperture optimization in emission imaging using ideal observers for joint detection and localization

    by Lili Zhou, Parmeshwar Khurd, Santosh Kulkarni, Anand Rangarajan, Gene Gindi

    For the familiar 2-class detection problem (signal present/absent), ideal observers have been applied to optimization of pinhole and collimator parameters in planar emission imaging. Given photon noise and background and signal variabilities, such experiments show how to optimize an aperture to maximize detectability of the signal. Here, we consider a fundamentally different, more realistic task in which the observer is required to both detect and localize a signal. The signal is embedded in a variable background and is known except for location. We inquire whether the addition of a localization requirement changes conclusions on aperture optimization. We have previously formulated an ideal observer for this joint detection/localization task, and here apply it to the classic problem of determining an optimal pinhole diameter in a planar emission imaging system. We conclude that as search tolerance on localization decreases, the optimal pinhole diameter shrinks from that required by detection alone, and, in addition, task performance becomes more sensitive to fluctuations about the optimal pinhole diameter. As in the case for detection only, the optimal pinhole diameter shrinks as the amount of background variability grows and, in addition, conspicuity limits can be observed. Unlike the case for detection only, our task leads to a finite aperture size in the absence of background variability. For both tasks, the inclusion of background variability yields a finite aperture size.


  • A channelized Hotelling observer study of lesion detection in SPECT MAP reconstruction using anatomical priors

    by S Kulkarni, P Khurd, I Hsiao, L Zhou, G Gindi

    In emission tomography, anatomical side information, in the form of organ and lesion boundaries, derived from intra-patient coregistered CT or MR scans can be incorporated into the reconstruction. Our interest is in exploring the efficacy of such side information for lesion detectability. To assess detectability we used the SNR of a channelized Hotelling observer and a signal-known exactly/background-known exactly detection task. In simulation studies, we incorporated anatomical side information into a SPECT MAP (maximum a posteriori) reconstruction by smoothing within but not across organ or lesion boundaries. A non-anatomical prior was applied by uniform smoothing across the entire image. We investigated whether the use of anatomical priors with organ boundaries alone or with perfect lesion boundaries alone would change lesion detectability relative to the case of a prior with no anatomical information. Furthermore, we investigated whether any such detectability changes for the organ-boundary case would be a function of the distance of the lesion to the organ boundary. We also investigated whether any detectability changes for the lesion-boundary case would be a function of the degree of proximity, i.e. a difference in the radius of the true functional lesion and the radius of the anatomical lesion boundary. Our results showed almost no detectability difference with versus without organ boundaries at any lesion-to-organ boundary distance. Our results also showed no difference in lesion detectability with and without lesion boundaries, and no variation of lesion detectability with degree of proximity.


  • Rapid optimization of SPECT scatter correction using model LROC observers

    by S. Kulkarni, P. Khurd, L. Zhou, G. Gindi

    The problem we address is the optimization and comparison of window-based scatter correction (SC) methods in SPECT for maximum a posteriori reconstructions. While sophisticated reconstruction-based SC methods are available, the commonly used window-based SC methods are fast, easy to use, and perform reasonably well. Rather than subtracting a scatter estimate from the measured sinogram and then reconstructing, we use an ensemble approach and model the mean scatter sinogram in the likelihood function. This mean scatter sinogram estimate, computed from satellite window data, is itself inexact (noisy). Therefore two sources of noise, that due to Poisson noise of unscattered photons and that due to the model error in the scatter estimate, are propagated into the reconstruction. The optimization and comparison is driven by a figure of merit, the area under the LROC curve (ALROC) that gauges performance in a signal detection plus localization task. We use model observers to perform the task. This usually entails laborious generation of many sample reconstructions, but in this work, we instead develop a theoretical approach that allows one to rapidly compute ALROC given known information about the imaging system and the scatter correction scheme. A critical step in the theory approach is to predict additional (above that due to to the propagated Poisson noise of the primary photons) contributions to the reconstructed image covariance due to scatter (model error) noise. Simulations show that our theory method yields, for a range of search tolerances, LROC curves and ALROC values in close agreement to that obtained using model observer responses obtained from sample reconstruction methods. This opens the door to rapid comparison of different window-based SC methods and to optimizing the parameters (including window placement and size, scatter sinogram smoothing kernel) of the SC method.


  • Decision strategies maximizing the area under the LROC curve

    by Parmeshwar Khurd, Gene Gindi

    For the 2-class detection problem (signal absent/present), the likelihood ratio is an ideal observer in that it minimizes Bayes risk for arbitrary costs and it maximizes AUC, the area under the ROC curve. The AUC-optimizing property makes it a valuable tool in imaging system optimization. If one considered a different task, namely, joint detection and localization of the signal, then it would be similarly valuable to have a decision strategy that optimized a relevant scalar figure of merit. We are interested in quantifying performance on decision tasks involving location uncertainty using the LROC methodology. We derive decision strategies that maximize the area under the LROC curve, ALROC. We show that these decision strategies minimize Bayes risk under certain reasonable cost constraints. We model the detection-localization task as a decision problem in three increasingly realistic ways. In the first two models, we treat location as a discrete parameter having finitely many values resulting in an (L+1) class classification problem. In our first simple model, we do not include search tolerance effects and in the second, more general, model, we do. In the third and most general model, we treat location as a continuous parameter and also include search tolerance effects. In all cases, the essential proof that the observer maximizes ALROC is obtained with a modified version of the Neyman-Pearson lemma using Lagrange multiplier methods. A separate form of proof is used to show that in all three cases, the decision strategy minimizes the Bayes risk under certain reasonable cost constraints.


  • Provably convergent OSEM-like reconstruction algorithm for emission tomography

    by Ing-Tsung Hsiao, Anand Rangarajan, Gene R. Gindi

    We investigate a new, provably convergent OSEM-like (ordered-subsets expectation-maximization) reconstruction algorithm for emission tomography. The new algorithm, which we term C-OSEM (complete-data OSEM), can be shown to monotonically increase the log-likelihood at each iteration. The familiar ML-EM reconstruction algorithm for emission tomography can be derived in a novel way. One may write a single objective function with complete, incomplete data and the reconstruction variables as in the EM approach. But in the objective function approach, there is no E-step. Instead, a suitable alternating descent on the complete data and then the reconstruction variables results in two update equations that can be shown to be equivalent to the familiar EM algorithm. Hence, minimizing this objective becomes equivalent to maximizing the likelihood. We derive our C-OSEM algorithm by modifying the above approach to update the complete data only along ordered subsets. The resulting update equation is quite different from OSEM, but still retains the speed-enhancing feature of the updates due to the limited backprojection facilitated by the ordered subsets. Despite this modification, we are able to show that the objective function decreases at each iteration, and (given a few more mild assumptions regarding the number of fixed points) conclude that the C-OSEM algorithm provides a monotonic convergence toward the maximum likelihood solution. We simulated noisy and noiseless emission projection data, and reconstructed them using the ML-EM, and the proposed C-OSEM with 4 subsets. We also reconstruct the data using the OSEM method. Anecdotal results show that the C-OSEM algorithm is much faster than ML-EM though slower than OSEM.