Lev Jardón-Barbolla
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Lev Jardón-Barbolla has a total of 39 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Kristin L. Mercer
Department of Horticulture and Crop Science, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, USA
4 shared publications - Natalia Elena Martínez Ainsworth
Centro de Investigaciones Interdisciplinarias en Ciencias y Humanidades, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Ciudad de México, México
4 shared publications - Daniel Piñero
Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México
3 shared publications - Alejandra Moreno-Letelier
Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México
2 shared publications - Leah K. McHale
Department of Horticulture and Crop Science, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH 43210, USA
2 shared publications - Patricia Delgado-Valerio
Universidad Michoacana de San Nicolás de Hidalgo
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 16 September 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Biology & Philosophy
- Vol. 40 (5) , 1-23
Biases and epistemic injustice in taxonomy: the case of arvense and semiwild plants flattened in domestication literature
Taxonomies about the natural world reflect or reinforce ways of thinking about the world structure. Almost a century ago, Nikolai Vavilov emphasized the importance of domestication gradients as a taxonomy to encompass agrobiodiversity within centers of origin of agriculture, such as the Mesoamerican one. To date, domestication gradients in Latin America prevail with different cultivated plant species that exist as semiwild or semidomesticated forms, subject to diverse management systems by peasant (campesino) communities. Agroecology and Ethnobotany have highlighted the socio-cultural relevance of arvense plants (plants associated to tillage). This category encompasses useful plants for peasant economies and indigenous cultures as well as weeds whose control involves other types of peasant management practices. Evolutionary biology recognizes the key role played by domestication and management gradients in crop plant evolution. Nevertheless, the term weed (“maleza” in Spanish) is widespread in the scientific literature published in English and it refers to all plants that have not been intentionally cultivated. In the present work we review the scientific literature and reflect on the concepts that underlie terms such as “semi-wild”, “weed” or “tolerated plant”. We propose that a conceptual flattening and concealment occurs when, through language, scientific literature in English reduces the current domestication stages and the plants under diverse management systems to mere “weeds”. We also explore how this categorization could be a case of epistemic injustice within agriculture, one that is aligned with agro-industrial production models. In this context, we posit the question, does the use of the term “weed” in scientific literature and the agro-industrial model of speech, as a broad category that homogenizes nuances of management and valuation, contribute to oppressing perspectives and perpetuates epistemic injustices.
- 16 September 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Biology & Philosophy
- Vol. 40 (5) , 1-23
Open AccessBiases and epistemic injustice in taxonomy: the case of arvense and semiwild plants flattened in domestication literature
Taxonomies about the natural world reflect or reinforce ways of thinking about the world structure. Almost a century ago, Nikolai Vavilov emphasized the importance of domestication gradients as a taxonomy to encompass agrobiodiversity within centers of origin of agriculture, such as the Mesoamerican one. To date, domestication gradients in Latin America prevail with different cultivated plant species that exist as semiwild or semidomesticated forms, subject to diverse management systems by peasant (campesino) communities. Agroecology and Ethnobotany have highlighted the socio-cultural relevance of arvense plants (plants associated to tillage). This category encompasses useful plants for peasant economies and indigenous cultures as well as weeds whose control involves other types of peasant management practices. Evolutionary biology recognizes the key role played by domestication and management gradients in crop plant evolution. Nevertheless, the term weed (“maleza” in Spanish) is widespread in the scientific literature published in English and it refers to all plants that have not been intentionally cultivated. In the present work we review the scientific literature and reflect on the concepts that underlie terms such as “semi-wild”, “weed” or “tolerated plant”. We propose that a conceptual flattening and concealment occurs when, through language, scientific literature in English reduces the current domestication stages and the plants under diverse management systems to mere “weeds”. We also explore how this categorization could be a case of epistemic injustice within agriculture, one that is aligned with agro-industrial production models. In this context, we posit the question, does the use of the term “weed” in scientific literature and the agro-industrial model of speech, as a broad category that homogenizes nuances of management and valuation, contribute to oppressing perspectives and perpetuates epistemic injustices.
- 10 May 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 1-34
Evolution Under Domestication: The Intersection of Genes, Organism and Management in Mexican Chili Pepper
- 10 May 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 1-34
Evolution Under Domestication: The Intersection of Genes, Organism and Management in Mexican Chili Pepper
- Open Access
- 28 November 2023
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 13 (11) , e10731
Fluctuation of ecological niches and geographic range shifts along chile pepper's domestication gradient
Domestication is an ongoing well‐described process. However, while many have studied the changes domestication causes in plant genetics, few have explored its impact on the portion of the geographic landscape in which the plants exist. Therefore, the goal of this study was to understand how the process of domestication changed the geographic space suitable for chile pepper (Capsicum annuum) in its center of origin (domestication). C. annuum is a major crop species globally whose center of domestication, Mexico, has been well‐studied. It provides a unique opportunity to explore the degree to which ranges of different domestication classes diverged and how these ranges might be altered by climate change. To this end, we created ecological niche models for four domestication classes (wild, semiwild, landrace, modern cultivar) based on present climate and future climate scenarios for 2050, 2070, and 2090. Considering present environment, we found substantial overlap in the geographic niches of all the domestication classes. Yet, environmental and geographic aspects of the current ranges did vary among classes. Wild and commercial varieties could grow in desert conditions, while landraces could not. With projections into the future, habitat was lost asymmetrically, with wild, semiwild, and landraces at greater risk of territorial declines than modern cultivars. Further, we identified areas where future suitability overlap between landraces and wilds is expected to be lost. While range expansion is widely associated with domestication, we found little support of a constant niche expansion (either in environmental or geographical space) throughout the domestication gradient in chile peppers in Mexico. Instead, particular domestication transitions resulted in loss, followed by capturing or recapturing environmental or geographic space. The differences in environmental characterization among domestication gradient classes and their future potential range shifts increase the need for conservation efforts to preserve landraces and semiwild genotypes.
- 28 November 2023
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 13 (11) , e10731
Open AccessFluctuation of ecological niches and geographic range shifts along chile pepper's domestication gradient
Domestication is an ongoing well‐described process. However, while many have studied the changes domestication causes in plant genetics, few have explored its impact on the portion of the geographic landscape in which the plants exist. Therefore, the goal of this study was to understand how the process of domestication changed the geographic space suitable for chile pepper (Capsicum annuum) in its center of origin (domestication). C. annuum is a major crop species globally whose center of domestication, Mexico, has been well‐studied. It provides a unique opportunity to explore the degree to which ranges of different domestication classes diverged and how these ranges might be altered by climate change. To this end, we created ecological niche models for four domestication classes (wild, semiwild, landrace, modern cultivar) based on present climate and future climate scenarios for 2050, 2070, and 2090. Considering present environment, we found substantial overlap in the geographic niches of all the domestication classes. Yet, environmental and geographic aspects of the current ranges did vary among classes. Wild and commercial varieties could grow in desert conditions, while landraces could not. With projections into the future, habitat was lost asymmetrically, with wild, semiwild, and landraces at greater risk of territorial declines than modern cultivars. Further, we identified areas where future suitability overlap between landraces and wilds is expected to be lost. While range expansion is widely associated with domestication, we found little support of a constant niche expansion (either in environmental or geographical space) throughout the domestication gradient in chile peppers in Mexico. Instead, particular domestication transitions resulted in loss, followed by capturing or recapturing environmental or geographic space. The differences in environmental characterization among domestication gradient classes and their future potential range shifts increase the need for conservation efforts to preserve landraces and semiwild genotypes.
- Open Access
Genomic signatures of adaptation to abiotic stress from a geographically diverse collection of chile peppers (Capsicum spp.) from Mexico
Extreme environmental variability requires the identification of genetic diversity that can help crops withstand difficult abiotic conditions. Understanding the genetic basis of adaptation to abiotic stress can provide tools for adapting agriculture to changing climates. Crop landraces and their wild ancestors from centers of domestication have often evolved across diverse environmental conditions and provide a unique opportunity to locate loci harboring alleles that could contribute to abiotic stress tolerance, among other traits. We collected chile peppers ( Capsicum spp.) from farmers in southern Mexico along environmental transects crossing temperature, precipitation, and elevational gradients. Using 32,623 filtered SNPs generated from genotyping-by-sequencing (GBS), we conducted an environmental association analysis (EAA) combined with two outlier analyses, F ST and spatial ancestry analyses to detect priority candidate loci associated with climate and soil phenotypes relevant to drought tolerance. Even though cultivated species may be shielded from some environmental selection by management practices (e.g., irrigation), we found fifteen priority loci whose genetic variation covaried with environmental variation in our EAA and were also allele frequency outliers (i.e., Fst and/or SPA). Thirty-three percent of the priority loci were validated with phenotype in response to water deficit. The haplotype blocks associated with these loci identify unique genetic variants worthy of conservation and harbor genes with abiotic stress-related functions. This work provides valuable information to explore quantitative trait loci (QTLs) underlying abiotic stress tolerance in chile pepper and is a new resource for improving plant breeding around the world. Article Summary: The extreme environmental variability faced by crops requires the identification of potentially adaptive loci for abiotic stressors. We conducted an environmental association analysis (EAA) environments using chile peppers collected in southern Mexico along environmental transects crossing temperature, precipitation, and elevational gradients. We combined EAA with outlier analyses F ST and spatial ancestry analysis to detect priority candidate loci associated with climate and soil phenotypes relevant to drought tolerance that may putatively contribute to abiotic stress adaptation.
Open AccessGenomic signatures of adaptation to abiotic stress from a geographically diverse collection of chile peppers (Capsicum spp.) from Mexico
Extreme environmental variability requires the identification of genetic diversity that can help crops withstand difficult abiotic conditions. Understanding the genetic basis of adaptation to abiotic stress can provide tools for adapting agriculture to changing climates. Crop landraces and their wild ancestors from centers of domestication have often evolved across diverse environmental conditions and provide a unique opportunity to locate loci harboring alleles that could contribute to abiotic stress tolerance, among other traits. We collected chile peppers ( Capsicum spp.) from farmers in southern Mexico along environmental transects crossing temperature, precipitation, and elevational gradients. Using 32,623 filtered SNPs generated from genotyping-by-sequencing (GBS), we conducted an environmental association analysis (EAA) combined with two outlier analyses, F ST and spatial ancestry analyses to detect priority candidate loci associated with climate and soil phenotypes relevant to drought tolerance. Even though cultivated species may be shielded from some environmental selection by management practices (e.g., irrigation), we found fifteen priority loci whose genetic variation covaried with environmental variation in our EAA and were also allele frequency outliers (i.e., Fst and/or SPA). Thirty-three percent of the priority loci were validated with phenotype in response to water deficit. The haplotype blocks associated with these loci identify unique genetic variants worthy of conservation and harbor genes with abiotic stress-related functions. This work provides valuable information to explore quantitative trait loci (QTLs) underlying abiotic stress tolerance in chile pepper and is a new resource for improving plant breeding around the world. Article Summary: The extreme environmental variability faced by crops requires the identification of potentially adaptive loci for abiotic stressors. We conducted an environmental association analysis (EAA) environments using chile peppers collected in southern Mexico along environmental transects crossing temperature, precipitation, and elevational gradients. We combined EAA with outlier analyses F ST and spatial ancestry analysis to detect priority candidate loci associated with climate and soil phenotypes relevant to drought tolerance that may putatively contribute to abiotic stress adaptation.
- Open Access
Capturing the distribution as it shifts: chile pepper ( Capsicum annuum L.) domestication gradient meets geography
Aim: Domestication is an ongoing well-described process. However, while many have studied the changes domestication causes in the genetic landscape, few have explored the way domestication changes the geographic landscape in which the plants exist. Therefore, the goal of this study was to understand how the domestication status changed the suitable geographic space of chile pepper in its center of origin. Methods: Capsicum annuum is a major crop species globally whose domestication center, Mexico, has been well studied. This provides a unique opportunity to explore the degree to which ranges of different domestication classes diverged and how these ranges might be altered by climate change. To this end, we created ecological niche models for four domestication classes (wild, semiwild, landrace, modern cultivar) based on present climate and future climate scenarios for 2050, 2070, and 2090. Results: Considering present environment, we found substantial overlap in the geographic niches of all the domestication gradient categories. Yet, there were also clear unique environmental and geographic aspects to the current ranges. Wild and commercial varieties were at ease in desert conditions as opposed to landraces. With projections into the future, habitat was lost asymmetrically, with wild, semiwild and landraces at far greater risk than modern cultivars. Further, we identified areas where future suitability overlap between landraces and wilds is expected to decouple. Main conclusions: While range expansion is widely associated with domestication, there is little support of a constant niche expansion (either in environmental or geographical space) throughout the domestication gradient. However, a shift to higher altitudes with cooler climate was identified for landraces. The clear differences in environmental adaptation, such as higher mean diurnal range and precipitation seasonality along the domestication gradient classes and their future potential range shifts show the need to increase conservation efforts, particularly to preserve landraces and semiwild genotypes.
Open AccessCapturing the distribution as it shifts: chile pepper ( Capsicum annuum L.) domestication gradient meets geography
Aim: Domestication is an ongoing well-described process. However, while many have studied the changes domestication causes in the genetic landscape, few have explored the way domestication changes the geographic landscape in which the plants exist. Therefore, the goal of this study was to understand how the domestication status changed the suitable geographic space of chile pepper in its center of origin. Methods: Capsicum annuum is a major crop species globally whose domestication center, Mexico, has been well studied. This provides a unique opportunity to explore the degree to which ranges of different domestication classes diverged and how these ranges might be altered by climate change. To this end, we created ecological niche models for four domestication classes (wild, semiwild, landrace, modern cultivar) based on present climate and future climate scenarios for 2050, 2070, and 2090. Results: Considering present environment, we found substantial overlap in the geographic niches of all the domestication gradient categories. Yet, there were also clear unique environmental and geographic aspects to the current ranges. Wild and commercial varieties were at ease in desert conditions as opposed to landraces. With projections into the future, habitat was lost asymmetrically, with wild, semiwild and landraces at far greater risk than modern cultivars. Further, we identified areas where future suitability overlap between landraces and wilds is expected to decouple. Main conclusions: While range expansion is widely associated with domestication, there is little support of a constant niche expansion (either in environmental or geographical space) throughout the domestication gradient. However, a shift to higher altitudes with cooler climate was identified for landraces. The clear differences in environmental adaptation, such as higher mean diurnal range and precipitation seasonality along the domestication gradient classes and their future potential range shifts show the need to increase conservation efforts, particularly to preserve landraces and semiwild genotypes.
- 4 July 2022
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Botany
- Vol. 109 (7) , 1157-1176
Genetic diversity, gene flow, and differentiation among wild, semiwild, and landrace chile pepper (Capsicum annuum) populations in Oaxaca, Mexico
Premise: Capsicum annuum (Solanaceae) was originally domesticated in Mexico, where wild (C. annuum var. glabriusculum) and cultivated (C. annuum var. annuum) chile pepper populations (>60 landraces) are common, and wild‐resembling individuals (hereafter semiwild) grow spontaneously in anthropogenic environments. Here we analyze the role of elevation and domestication gradients in shaping the genetic diversity in C. annuum from the state of Oaxaca, Mexico.Methods: We collected samples of 341 individuals from 28 populations, corresponding to wild, semiwild (C. annuum var. glabriusculum) and cultivated C. annuum, and closely related species Capsicum frutescens and C. chinense. From the genetic variation of 10 simple sequence repeat (SSR) loci, we assessed the population genetic structure, inbreeding, and gene flow through variance distribution analyses, genetic clustering, and connectivity estimations.Results: Genetic diversity (HE) did not differ across domestication levels. However, inbreeding coefficients were higher in semiwild and cultivated chiles than in wild populations. We found evidence for gene flow between wild populations and cultivated landraces along the coast. Genetic structure analysis revealed strong differentiation between most highland and lowland landraces.Conclusions: Gene flow between wild and domesticated populations may be mediated by backyards and smallholder farms, while mating systems may facilitate gene flow between landraces and semiwild populations. Domestication and elevation may overlap in their influence on genetic differentiation. Lowland Gui'ña dani clustered with highland landraces perhaps due to the social history of the Zapotec peoples. In situ conservation may play an important role in preserving semiwild populations and private alleles found in landraces.
- 4 July 2022
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Botany
- Vol. 109 (7) , 1157-1176
Genetic diversity, gene flow, and differentiation among wild, semiwild, and landrace chile pepper (Capsicum annuum) populations in Oaxaca, Mexico
Premise: Capsicum annuum (Solanaceae) was originally domesticated in Mexico, where wild (C. annuum var. glabriusculum) and cultivated (C. annuum var. annuum) chile pepper populations (>60 landraces) are common, and wild‐resembling individuals (hereafter semiwild) grow spontaneously in anthropogenic environments. Here we analyze the role of elevation and domestication gradients in shaping the genetic diversity in C. annuum from the state of Oaxaca, Mexico.Methods: We collected samples of 341 individuals from 28 populations, corresponding to wild, semiwild (C. annuum var. glabriusculum) and cultivated C. annuum, and closely related species Capsicum frutescens and C. chinense. From the genetic variation of 10 simple sequence repeat (SSR) loci, we assessed the population genetic structure, inbreeding, and gene flow through variance distribution analyses, genetic clustering, and connectivity estimations.Results: Genetic diversity (HE) did not differ across domestication levels. However, inbreeding coefficients were higher in semiwild and cultivated chiles than in wild populations. We found evidence for gene flow between wild populations and cultivated landraces along the coast. Genetic structure analysis revealed strong differentiation between most highland and lowland landraces.Conclusions: Gene flow between wild and domesticated populations may be mediated by backyards and smallholder farms, while mating systems may facilitate gene flow between landraces and semiwild populations. Domestication and elevation may overlap in their influence on genetic differentiation. Lowland Gui'ña dani clustered with highland landraces perhaps due to the social history of the Zapotec peoples. In situ conservation may play an important role in preserving semiwild populations and private alleles found in landraces.
- Open Access
- 7 January 2020
- Published by Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory in bioRxiv
Linking coleopteran diversity with agricultural management of maize agroecosystems in Oaxaca, Mexico
Biodiversity is known to be influenced by agricultural practices in many ways. However, it is necessary to understand how this relation takes place in particular agroecosystems, sociocultural contexts and for specific biological groups. Also, in order to systematically study and track how biodiversity responds or changes with agricultural practices, it is necessary to find groups that can be used as practical indicators. We conduct a study of beetle (Coleoptera) diversity in maize-based agricultural plots with heterogeneous management practices in the Central Valleys of Oaxaca, Mexico. First, we use a mixture of local knowledge and multivariate statistics to group the plots into two broad and contrasting management categories (traditional vs. industrialized). Then, we present an analysis of Coleopteran diversity for each category, showing higher levels across different diversity indexes for the traditional plots. Also, our results let us postulate the Curculionidae family as an indicator of both management type and overall Coleopteran diversity in the agricultural lands of the study site. We discuss our results in terms of the agricultural matrix quality and its role in joint productive and biodiversity conservation strategies.
- 7 January 2020
- Published by Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory in bioRxiv
Open AccessLinking coleopteran diversity with agricultural management of maize agroecosystems in Oaxaca, Mexico
Biodiversity is known to be influenced by agricultural practices in many ways. However, it is necessary to understand how this relation takes place in particular agroecosystems, sociocultural contexts and for specific biological groups. Also, in order to systematically study and track how biodiversity responds or changes with agricultural practices, it is necessary to find groups that can be used as practical indicators. We conduct a study of beetle (Coleoptera) diversity in maize-based agricultural plots with heterogeneous management practices in the Central Valleys of Oaxaca, Mexico. First, we use a mixture of local knowledge and multivariate statistics to group the plots into two broad and contrasting management categories (traditional vs. industrialized). Then, we present an analysis of Coleopteran diversity for each category, showing higher levels across different diversity indexes for the traditional plots. Also, our results let us postulate the Curculionidae family as an indicator of both management type and overall Coleopteran diversity in the agricultural lands of the study site. We discuss our results in terms of the agricultural matrix quality and its role in joint productive and biodiversity conservation strategies.
- Open Access
- 11 September 2017
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 17 (1) , 213
Appropriate homoplasy metrics in linked SSRs to predict an underestimation of demographic expansion times
Homoplasy affects demographic inference estimates. This effect has been recognized and corrective methods have been developed. However, no studies so far have defined what homoplasy metrics best describe the effects on demographic inference, or have attempted to estimate such metrics in real data. Here we study how homoplasy in chloroplast microsatellites (cpSSR) affects inference of population expansion time. cpSSRs are popular markers for inferring historical demography in plants due to their high mutation rate and limited recombination. In cpSSRs, homoplasy is usually quantified as the probability that two markers or haplotypes that are identical by state are not identical by descent (Homoplasy index, P). Here we propose a new measure of multi-locus homoplasy in linked SSR called Distance Homoplasy (DH), which measures the proportion of pairwise differences not observed due to homoplasy, and we compare it to P and its per cpSSR locus average, which we call Mean Size Homoplasy (MSH). We use simulations and analytical derivations to show that, out of the three homoplasy metrics analyzed, MSH and DH are more correlated to changes in the population expansion time and to the underestimation of that demographic parameter using cpSSR. We perform simulations to show that Approximate Bayesian Computation (ABC) can be used to obtain reasonable estimates of MSH and DH. Finally, we use ABC to estimate the expansion time, MSH and DH from a chloroplast SSR dataset in Pinus caribaea. To our knowledge, this is the first time that homoplasy has been estimated in population genetic data. We show that MSH and DH should be used to quantify how homoplasy affects estimates of population expansion time. We also demonstrate how ABC provides a methodology to estimate homoplasy in population genetic data.
- 11 September 2017
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 17 (1) , 213
Open AccessAppropriate homoplasy metrics in linked SSRs to predict an underestimation of demographic expansion times
Homoplasy affects demographic inference estimates. This effect has been recognized and corrective methods have been developed. However, no studies so far have defined what homoplasy metrics best describe the effects on demographic inference, or have attempted to estimate such metrics in real data. Here we study how homoplasy in chloroplast microsatellites (cpSSR) affects inference of population expansion time. cpSSRs are popular markers for inferring historical demography in plants due to their high mutation rate and limited recombination. In cpSSRs, homoplasy is usually quantified as the probability that two markers or haplotypes that are identical by state are not identical by descent (Homoplasy index, P). Here we propose a new measure of multi-locus homoplasy in linked SSR called Distance Homoplasy (DH), which measures the proportion of pairwise differences not observed due to homoplasy, and we compare it to P and its per cpSSR locus average, which we call Mean Size Homoplasy (MSH). We use simulations and analytical derivations to show that, out of the three homoplasy metrics analyzed, MSH and DH are more correlated to changes in the population expansion time and to the underestimation of that demographic parameter using cpSSR. We perform simulations to show that Approximate Bayesian Computation (ABC) can be used to obtain reasonable estimates of MSH and DH. Finally, we use ABC to estimate the expansion time, MSH and DH from a chloroplast SSR dataset in Pinus caribaea. To our knowledge, this is the first time that homoplasy has been estimated in population genetic data. We show that MSH and DH should be used to quantify how homoplasy affects estimates of population expansion time. We also demonstrate how ABC provides a methodology to estimate homoplasy in population genetic data.
- 31 January 2017
- Published by Springer Nature in Tree Genetics & Genomes
- Vol. 13 (1) , 1-14
Differential landscape effects on the fine-scale genetic structure of populations of a montane conifer from central Mexico
- 31 January 2017
- Published by Springer Nature in Tree Genetics & Genomes
- Vol. 13 (1) , 1-14
Differential landscape effects on the fine-scale genetic structure of populations of a montane conifer from central Mexico
- Open Access
- 30 July 2013
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 8 (7) , e70501
Phylogenetic Relationships and Species Delimitation in Pinus Section Trifoliae Inferrred from Plastid DNA
Recent diversification followed by secondary contact and hybridization may explain complex patterns of intra- and interspecific morphological and genetic variation in the North American hard pines (Pinus section Trifoliae), a group of approximately 49 tree species distributed in North and Central America and the Caribbean islands. We concatenated five plastid DNA markers for an average of 3.9 individuals per putative species and assessed the suitability of the five regions as DNA bar codes for species identification, species delimitation, and phylogenetic reconstruction. The ycf1 gene accounted for the greatest proportion of the alignment (46.9%), the greatest proportion of variable sites (74.9%), and the most unique sequences (75 haplotypes). Phylogenetic analysis recovered clades corresponding to subsections Australes, Contortae, and Ponderosae. Sequences for 23 of the 49 species were monophyletic and sequences for another 9 species were paraphyletic. Morphologically similar species within subsections usually grouped together, but there were exceptions consistent with incomplete lineage sorting or introgression. Bayesian relaxed molecular clock analyses indicated that all three subsections diversified relatively recently during the Miocene. The general mixed Yule-coalescent method gave a mixed model estimate of only 22 or 23 evolutionary entities for the plastid sequences, which corresponds to less than half the 49 species recognized based on morphological species assignments. Including more unique haplotypes per species may result in higher estimates, but low mutation rates, recent diversification, and large effective population sizes may limit the effectiveness of this method to detect evolutionary entities.
- 30 July 2013
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 8 (7) , e70501
Open AccessPhylogenetic Relationships and Species Delimitation in Pinus Section Trifoliae Inferrred from Plastid DNA
Recent diversification followed by secondary contact and hybridization may explain complex patterns of intra- and interspecific morphological and genetic variation in the North American hard pines (Pinus section Trifoliae), a group of approximately 49 tree species distributed in North and Central America and the Caribbean islands. We concatenated five plastid DNA markers for an average of 3.9 individuals per putative species and assessed the suitability of the five regions as DNA bar codes for species identification, species delimitation, and phylogenetic reconstruction. The ycf1 gene accounted for the greatest proportion of the alignment (46.9%), the greatest proportion of variable sites (74.9%), and the most unique sequences (75 haplotypes). Phylogenetic analysis recovered clades corresponding to subsections Australes, Contortae, and Ponderosae. Sequences for 23 of the 49 species were monophyletic and sequences for another 9 species were paraphyletic. Morphologically similar species within subsections usually grouped together, but there were exceptions consistent with incomplete lineage sorting or introgression. Bayesian relaxed molecular clock analyses indicated that all three subsections diversified relatively recently during the Miocene. The general mixed Yule-coalescent method gave a mixed model estimate of only 22 or 23 evolutionary entities for the plastid sequences, which corresponds to less than half the 49 species recognized based on morphological species assignments. Including more unique haplotypes per species may result in higher estimates, but low mutation rates, recent diversification, and large effective population sizes may limit the effectiveness of this method to detect evolutionary entities.