RSRobert Stevenson

Robert Stevenson

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Robert Stevenson has a total of 75 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Enabling ecological survey data integration with the Humboldt Extension to Darwin Core

    by Yanina V. Sica, Wesley M. Hochachka, Robert D. Stevenson, Kate Ingenloff, Paula F. Zermoglio, John Wieczorek, Yi Ming Gan, Dmitry Schigel, Zachary R. Kachian, Steve Baskauf, et al.

    In the face of the global biodiversity crisis, accessibility to biodiversity data that are maximally effective for downstream use in science, conservation, and policy is paramount. The Darwin Core standard has played a central role in providing a standardised structure and vocabulary for biodiversity data. However, early iterations of the standard were not optimised to capture the sampling context of biodiversity surveys – survey methods, scope, and sampling effort – which is essential for the correct interpretation and potential reuse of such data. To address this limitation, we present the Humboldt Extension to Darwin Core, a ratified standard designed to accommodate datasets that contain such contextual information. Building upon an initial, previously developed framework, we significantly improved, fully tested, and ratified a final standard, following a community process defined by biodiversity information standards (TDWG), an international standards organisation. The resulting Humboldt Extension adds 55 terms that enrich the Darwin Core, providing the terms needed to capture and share multiple types of biodiversity survey data. We illustrate the benefits of implementing the Humboldt Extension with three case studies and demonstrate how richer data can be used in research, modelling, and to inform decision‐making. We urge the uptake and use of this Extension to facilitate the reuse and synthesis of monitoring data, particularly structured surveys and inventories, for science, conservation, and policy.


  • Open Access

    Want to Describe and Share Biodiversity Inventory and Monitoring Data? The Humboldt Extension for Ecological Inventories Can Help!

    by Yanina Sica, Wesley Hochachka, Yi-Ming Gan, Kate Ingenloff, Dmitry Schigel, Robert Stevenson, Steven Baskauf, Peter Brenton, Anahita Kazem, John Wieczorek

    Access to high-quality ecological data is critical to assessing and modeling biodiversity and its changes through space and time. The Darwin Core standard has proven to be immensely helpful in sharing species occurrence data (see Wieczorek et al. 2012, Global Biodiversity Information Facility, GBIF) and promoting biodiversity research following the FAIR principles of findability, accessibility, interoperability and reusability (Wilkinson et al. 2016). However, it is limited in its ability to fully accommodate inventory data (i.e., linked records of multiple taxa at a specific place and time). Information about the inventory processes is often either unreported or described in an unstructured manner, limiting its potential re-use for larger-scale analyses. Two key aspects that are not captured in a structured manner yet are: i) information about the species that were not detected during an inventory, and ii) ancillary information about sampling effort and completeness. Non-detections (i.e., reported counts of zero) potentially enable more accurate and precise estimates of distribution, abundance, and changes in abundance. This becomes possible when variation in effort is used to estimate the likelihood that a non-detection represents a true absence of that taxon during the inventory. Currently, ecological inventory data, when shared at all, are typically discoverable through dataset catalogs (e.g., governmental data repositories) and supplementary materials to publications. With few exceptions, indexing of such data with the detail and structure needed has not been attempted at broad temporal and spatial scales, despite the potentially high value resulting from making inventory data more readily accessible. To address these limitations in documenting inventory data using the Darwin Core, Guralnick et al. (2018) proposed the Humboldt Core. Subsequent discussions within the biodiversity standards community made it clear that greater integration could be achieved by creating an extension of the Darwin Core, rather than developing a new standard in isolation. Extension design work began in 2021 and progress has been reported by Brenton (2021) and Sica et al. (2022). Over the last year the Humboldt Extension Task Group has sought advice from data providers and aggregators and updated its vocabulary terms. A challenging aspect has been creating terminology for the parent-child relationships (see Properties of Hierarchical Events) needed to describe surveys that may be as simple as a collection of checklists (one level of hierarchy) or as complex as species records from traps within plots along transects across habitats over multiple years (at least four levels of hierarchy). The Task Group has committed to completing a User Guide for the Humboldt Extension. Group members who contributed to the Darwin Core (Darwin Core Task Group 2009) and the Vocabulary Maintenance Specification (Vocabulary Maintenance Specification Task Group 2017) have provided valuable expertise on term refinement and process. Through ratification of the Humboldt Extension as a Darwin Core Event extension, we expect to provide the community with a usable solution, tied to well-established data publication mechanisms, for sharing and using inventory data. This effort promises to overcome a key bottleneck in the sharing of critically important ecological data, enhancing data discoverability, interoperability and re-use while lowering reporting burden and data and metadata heterogeneity. Global data aggregation initiatives, such as GBIF, will benefit from this development as they develop their data models and the range of standards and extensions they support. We anticipate that the Humboldt Extension will be attractive both to data publishers and data users, by facilitating the representation and indexing of data in richer, more meaningful ways. Despite the data-intensive nature of fundamental ecological research and applied monitoring for management and policy, ecological data have remained as one of the FAIR data frontiers. We anticipate that the Humboldt Extension will address most data exchange needs of all professional communities involved.

  • Open Access

    Can Biodiversity Data Scientists Document Volunteer and Professional Collaborations and Contributions in the Biodiversity Data Enterprise?

    by Robert Stevenson, Elizabeth R. Ellwood, Peter Brenton, Paul Flemons, Jeff Gerbracht, Wesley Hochachka, Scott Loarie, Carrie Seltzer

    The collection, archiving and use of biodiversity data depend on a network of pipelines herein called the Biodiversity Data Enterprise (BDE) and best understood globally through the work of the Global Biodiversity Information Facility (GBIF). Efforts to sustain and grow the BDE require information about the data pipeline and the infrastructure that supports it. A host of metrics from GBIF, including institutional participation (member countries, institutional contributors, data publishers), biodiversity coverage (occurrence records, species, geographic extent, data sets) and data usage (records downloaded, published papers using the data) (Miller 2021), document the rapid growth and successes of the BDE (GBIF Secretariat 2022). Heberling et al. (2021) make a convincing case that the data integration process is working. The Biodiversity Information Standards' (TDWG) Basis of Record term provides information about the underlying infrastructure. It categorizes the kinds of processes*1 that teams undertake to capture biodiversity information and GBIF quantifies their contributions*2 (Table 1). Currently 83.4% of observations come from human observations, of which 63% are of birds. Museum preserved specimens account for 9.5% of records. In both cases, a combination of volunteers (who make observations, collect specimens, digitize specimens, transcribe specimen labels) and professionals work together to make records available. To better understand how the BDE is working, we suggest that it would be of value to know the number of contributions and contributors and their hours of engagement for each data set. This can help the community address questions such as, "How many volunteers do we need to document birds in a given area?" or "How much professional support is required to run a camera trap network?" For example, millions of observations were made by tens of thousands of observers in two recent BioBlitz events, one called Big Day, focusing on birds, sponsored by the Cornell Laboratory of Ornithology and the other called the City Nature Challenge, addressing all taxa, sponsored jointly by the California Academy of Sciences and the Natural History Musuems of Los Angeles County (Table 2). In our presentation we will suggest approaches to deriving metrics that could be used to document the collaborations and contribution of volunteers and staff using examples from both Human Observation (eBird, iNaturalist) and Preserved Specimen (DigiVol, Notes from Nature) record types. The goal of the exercise is to start a conversation about how such metrics can further the development of the BDE.


  • Open Access

    Measuring Habitat Restoration using the Darwin and "Event" Cores: Australian examples powered by BioCollect

    by Peter Brenton, Peggy Eby, Robert Stevenson, Elizabeth Ellwood

    Habitat decline and fragmentation are major factors in biodiversity loss across the globe and can be difficult to measure, particularly at landscape scale (Brooks et al. 2002, Fahrig 2003, Ritchie and Roser 2019). In Australia, rural, coastal and urban communities have been undertaking habitat restoration activities since the mid-1980s to protect and restore ecological balance on private land and in local shared and natural spaces. Much of the restoration effort has centered around hands-on activities as a mechanism for building community with environmental benefits. Over such a time span, thousands of locations throughout the country have been transformed from degraded and highly disturbed landscapes into resemblances of more-or-less natural areas. However, collecting and analysing data for these activities was given little attention until quite recently, as governments, philanthropists and other investors have become increasingly interested in measuring the value and outcomes from investment. To measure the effectiveness of the restoration effort, it is essential to to benchmark the environmental state and species composition before the restoration begins, but surprisingly or unsurprisingly, this is rarely done (Hale et al. 2019). Responding to this call for better documentation of restoration outcomes, over 30 groups have been using the Atlas of Living Australia’s BioCollect platform to capture complex information about current and past restoration work. The BioCollect platform enables each type of monitoring, establishment, and follow-up activity to have its own data collection schema and associated metadata structured around using a hierarchy of sampling events based on the Event class in the Darwin Core standard, which allows relationships between types of event records to be specified. When event records are created through use of an activity-based template, each occurrence of a species is also parsed and configured as a Darwin Core occurrence record. Standard templates have been created for a range of activities, such as benchmarking assessments, site establishment, follow-up interventions and monitoring over time, which are being used by many different groups over large areas of the landscape. This allows each group to operate independently, yet collect standardised data that can be easily aggregated at larger temporal and spatial scales, quantifying change over time. The relationships between occurrences and the event context in which they were collected is also preserved and navigable. Here we present how Darwin Core and Event Core have been implemented in the BioCollect platform to enable this important data to be collected and stored in its full richness and resolution.

  • Open Access

    Application of Humboldt Extension to Real-world Cases

    by Yanina Sica, Kate Ingenloff, Yi-Ming Gan, Zachary Kachian, Steven J Baskauf, John Wieczorek, Paula Zermoglio, Robert Stevenson

    Access to high-quality ecological data is pivotal to assessing and modeling biodiversity and its change through space and time. Inventory data (i.e., recording multiple species at specific places and times) are particularly relevant to monitoring species distributions and abundance, but their reliability for use in downstream models depends on reporting the methodology implemented and associated sampling effort and completeness. This information about the inventory processes is often either not reported or described in an unstructured manner, greatly limiting potential re-use for larger-scale analyses. In order to support the reuse of inventories and to assure better standardization of newly collected data, we developed a framework to standardize inventory data reporting that is general enough for broad use. Guralnick et al. (2018) introduced the Humboldt Core as a proof of concept. In 2021, the TDWG Humboldt Core Task Group was established to review how to best integrate the terms proposed in the original publication with existing standards and implementation schemas. In the context of sharing data using the Darwin Core standard (DwC), different types of inventories can be represented as Events with different nesting levels. Therefore, it was deemed appropriate to develop an extension to DwC that allows capturing the details of the inventory process. The Task Group members revised all original terms, reformulated definitions, and discarded or added new terms where needed. We are developing a user guide and reaching out to the larger biodiversity community to test the Humboldt Extension with real-world case study datasets using a test instance of the GBIF Integrated Publishing Toolkit (IPT). In this presentation, we will review the development process, give an overview of how the Humboldt Extension can be used to report key information on the inventory process, and provide example cases. After testing with real world cases, our next step will be to seek ratification of Humboldt as a Darwin Core Event extension following the Vocabulary Maintenance Standard. We expect that this will help to overcome a key bottleneck in the sharing of critically important ecological data, enhancing data discoverability, interoperability and re-use while lowering reporting burden.


  • Open Access

    Looking More Carefully: A Successful Bioblitz Orientation Activity at an Urban Public University

    by Megan Rokop, Rajini Srikanth, Marc Albert, Catherine Radonic, Rachel Vincent, Robert Stevenson


  • Open Access

    Crowdsourcing Fungal Biodiversity: Approaches and standards used by an all-volunteer community science project

    by Bill Sheehan, Rob Stevenson, Joanne Schwartz

    Fungal Diversity Survey (FunDiS) is an all-volunteer community science organization that documents the diversity and distribution of macrofungi (visible with the naked eye) across North America. FunDiS addresses a key gap in biodiversity conservation: fungi, one of life’s major kingdoms, have been largely neglected in conservation efforts. Fungi are hyperdiverse: it is estimated that only 5% of fungal species have been described (Willis 2018), while support for professional taxonomists has been declining for decades. Therefore, FunDiS engages legions of amateur mycologists to document fungal diversity. Our participation model has four levels for crowdsourcing fungal biodiversity. It consists of a pyramid of participants and skills, continually drawing more people in at the base (simplest tasks), and encouraging them to move up to the next level. Level 1. Field observations: Community scientists document fungi in the field with georeferenced color photos and post observations on public, databased platforms; FunDiS uses iNaturalist and Mushroom Observer. FunDiS established a curated iNaturalist project called the FunDiS Diversity Database, inspired by FungiMap in Australia. Mushroom enthusiasts add observations, with the incentive that they will be reviewed by a team of expert identifiers. Another team of triagers goes through new observations, rejects those that do not follow FunDiS quality standards, and writes encouraging notes to posters on how to make observations more scientifically valuable. As of August 2021, there were almost 50,000 verifiable observations, of which 30,465 (including 3,204 species) were research grade and uploaded by iNaturalist onto the website of the Global Biodiversity Information Facility (GBIF). Another FunDiS initiative, Rare Fungi Challenges, enlists amateurs to search for rare or threatened fungi. Level 2. Sequence: FunDiS built a program for amateurs to submit tissue for DNA sequencing and provided help interpreting results. Barcoding is especially needed to identify fungi because mopho-characteristics and images are often insufficient. Participants register projects, post observations to iNaturalist or Mushroom Observer, and apply to FunDiS for sequencing grants or pay out-of-pocket for sequencing. More than 200 local projects have been registered from Alaska to Puerto Rico, and Iceland to Hawaii. Some 7,000 specimens were sequenced by June 2021. Data are deposited in GenBank. Level 3. Voucher: FunDiS supports preserving well-documented, dried specimens in curated fungaria. To date, this participation level has developed slowly because of limitations of personnel and capacity of those institutions. Level 4. Super User: These are advanced observers with extensive field knowledge who have learned DNA technology; can teach others how to analyze DNA results and create phylogenies; and even describe new species. There are perhaps several dozen super users in the North American fungal science community. Challenges and lessons Feedback - Feedback to and from participants is critical to the success of community science projects. We have learned that it takes time and personnel to inspire rich interaction with participants in real time and that relying on volunteers with insufficient capacity for coordination, consistency and continuity often disappoints participants. Similarly DNA sequencing is intimidating to most amateurs. We found that guidance was needed for many participants just to correctly document, dry and submit tissue samples for sequencing. An even bigger challenge is making sense of the data that is generated, e.g., knowing if the sequence is of a described species or should be identified as a new species. Deep knowledge is needed for this kind of decision-making. In the past year we were fortunate to have the volunteer services of two professional mycologists and a doctoral student to analyze sequence data. Linking data - Linking data between field observations, genetic sequences and specimens is a major challenge. Our initial goal was to automate both external and internal data flows, but success has been limited with volunteer programmers. They managed to automate uploading iNaturalist and Mushroom Observer observations to our sequencing facility (Barcode of Life), but most other linkages have been tracked by volunteers on static spreadsheets. Paid staff - In retrospect, it was optimistic to attempt a project of such ambitious scope using only volunteer management and labor. The vast majority of community science projects are institution-based, with paid staff to manage and funds for outreach (Pocock et al. 2017). To continue at the present scale, we believe a core of paid staff is essential to leverage the large community we have been building.


  • Open Access

    Seven Primary Data Types in Citizen Science Determine Data Quality Requirements and Methods

    by Robert D. Stevenson, Todd Suomela, Heejun Kim, Yurong He

    Data quality (DQ) is a major concern in citizen science (CS) programs and is often raised as an issue among critics of the CS approach. We examined CS programs and reviewed the kinds of data they produce to inform CS communities of strategies of DQ control. From our review of the literature and our experiences with CS, we identified seven primary types of data contributions. Citizens can carry instrument packages, invent or modify algorithms, sort and classify physical objects, sort and classify digital objects, collect physical objects, collect digital objects, and report observations. We found that data types were not constrained by subject domains, a CS program may use multiple types, and DQ requirements and evaluation strategies vary according to the data types. These types are useful for identifying structural similarities among programs across subject domains. We conclude that blanket criticism of the CS data quality is no longer appropriate. In addition to the details of specific programs and variability among individuals, discussions can fruitfully focus on the data types in a program and the specific methods being used for DQ control as dictated or appropriate for the type. Programs can reduce doubts about their DQ by becoming more explicit in communicating their data management practices.


  • Open Access

    Tracking Science: An Alternative for Those Excluded by Citizen Science

    by Louis Liebenberg, /Am //Ao, Marlize Lombard, Michael Shermer, /Uase Xhukwe, Megan Biesele, Di //Xao, Peter Carruthers, ≠Oma Kxao, Sven Ove Hansson, et al.