Trond H. Larsen
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Trond H. Larsen has a total of 10 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Adrian Forsyth
Blue Moon Fund Charlottesville, VA 22902, USA
2 shared publications- Alejandro Lopera-Toro
Andes Amazon Fund Washington District of Columbia USA
2 shared publications Claire Kremen
Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ 08544, USA
1 shared publication- François Génier
Beaty Centre for Species Discovery; Canadian Museum of Nature; 1740 Chemin Pink; Gatineau; Quebec; J9J 3N7; Canada
1 shared publication Neal M. Williams
Department of Biology, Bryn Mawr College, 101 N. Merion Ave., Bryn Mawr, PA 19010, USA
1 shared publicationNj
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 20 January 2009
- Published by The Royal Society in Biology Letters
- Vol. 5 (2) , 152-155
From coprophagy to predation: a dung beetle that kills millipedes
The dung beetle subfamily Scarabaeinae is a cosmopolitan group of insects that feed primarily on dung. We describe the first case of an obligate predatory dung beetle and contrast its behaviour and morphology with those of its coprophagous sympatric congeners.Deltochilum valgumBurmeister killed and consumed millipedes in lowland rainforest in Peru. Ancestral ball-rolling behaviour shared by other canthonine species is abandoned, and the head, hind tibiae and pygidium ofD. valgumare modified for novel functions during millipede predation. Millipedes were killed by disarticulation, often through decapitation, using the clypeus as a lever. Beetles killed millipedes much larger than themselves. In pitfall traps,D. valgumwas attracted exclusively to millipedes, and preferred injured over uninjured millipedes. Morphological similarities placingD. valgumin the same subgenus with non-predatory dung-feeding species suggest a major and potentially rapid behavioural shift from coprophagy to predation. Ecological transitions enabling the exploitation of dramatically atypical niches, which may be more likely to occur when competition is intense, may help explain the evolution of novel ecological guilds and the diversification of exceptionally species-rich groups such as insects.
- 20 January 2009
- Published by The Royal Society in Biology Letters
- Vol. 5 (2) , 152-155
From coprophagy to predation: a dung beetle that kills millipedes
The dung beetle subfamily Scarabaeinae is a cosmopolitan group of insects that feed primarily on dung. We describe the first case of an obligate predatory dung beetle and contrast its behaviour and morphology with those of its coprophagous sympatric congeners.Deltochilum valgumBurmeister killed and consumed millipedes in lowland rainforest in Peru. Ancestral ball-rolling behaviour shared by other canthonine species is abandoned, and the head, hind tibiae and pygidium ofD. valgumare modified for novel functions during millipede predation. Millipedes were killed by disarticulation, often through decapitation, using the clypeus as a lever. Beetles killed millipedes much larger than themselves. In pitfall traps,D. valgumwas attracted exclusively to millipedes, and preferred injured over uninjured millipedes. Morphological similarities placingD. valgumin the same subgenus with non-predatory dung-feeding species suggest a major and potentially rapid behavioural shift from coprophagy to predation. Ecological transitions enabling the exploitation of dramatically atypical niches, which may be more likely to occur when competition is intense, may help explain the evolution of novel ecological guilds and the diversification of exceptionally species-rich groups such as insects.
- 24 September 2008
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- Vol. 22 (5) , 1288-1298
Understanding Trait‐Dependent Community Disassembly: Dung Beetles, Density Functions, and Forest Fragmentation
Abstract: Anthropogenic disturbances such as fragmentation are rapidly altering biodiversity, yet a lack of attention to species traits and abundance patterns has made the results of most studies difficult to generalize. We determined traits of extinction‐prone species and present a novel strategy for classifying species according to their population‐level response to a gradient of disturbance intensity. We examined the effects of forest fragmentation on dung beetle communities in an archipelago of 33 islands recently created by flooding in Venezuela. Species richness, density, and biomass all declined sharply with decreasing island area and increasing island isolation. Species richness was highly nested, indicating that local extinctions occurred nonrandomly. The most sensitive dung beetle species appeared to require at least 85 ha of forest, more than many large vertebrates. Extinction‐prone species were either large‐bodied, forest specialists, or uncommon. These explanatory variables were unrelated, suggesting at least 3 underlying causes of extirpation. Large species showed high wing loading (body mass/wing area) and a distinct flight strategy that may increase their area requirements. Although forest specificity made most species sensitive to fragmentation, a few persistent habitat generalists dispersed across the matrix. Density functions classified species into 4 response groups on the basis of their change in density with decreasing species richness. Sensitive and persistent species both declined with increasing fragmentation intensity, but persistent species occurred on more islands, which may be due to their higher baseline densities. Compensatory species increased in abundance following the initial loss of sensitive species, but rapidly declined with increasing fragmentation. Supertramp species (widespread habitat generalists) may be poor competitors but strong dispersers; their abundance peaked following the decline of the other 3 groups. Nevertheless, even the least sensitive species were extirpated or rare on the smallest and most isolated islands.
- 24 September 2008
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- Vol. 22 (5) , 1288-1298
Understanding Trait‐Dependent Community Disassembly: Dung Beetles, Density Functions, and Forest Fragmentation
Abstract: Anthropogenic disturbances such as fragmentation are rapidly altering biodiversity, yet a lack of attention to species traits and abundance patterns has made the results of most studies difficult to generalize. We determined traits of extinction‐prone species and present a novel strategy for classifying species according to their population‐level response to a gradient of disturbance intensity. We examined the effects of forest fragmentation on dung beetle communities in an archipelago of 33 islands recently created by flooding in Venezuela. Species richness, density, and biomass all declined sharply with decreasing island area and increasing island isolation. Species richness was highly nested, indicating that local extinctions occurred nonrandomly. The most sensitive dung beetle species appeared to require at least 85 ha of forest, more than many large vertebrates. Extinction‐prone species were either large‐bodied, forest specialists, or uncommon. These explanatory variables were unrelated, suggesting at least 3 underlying causes of extirpation. Large species showed high wing loading (body mass/wing area) and a distinct flight strategy that may increase their area requirements. Although forest specificity made most species sensitive to fragmentation, a few persistent habitat generalists dispersed across the matrix. Density functions classified species into 4 response groups on the basis of their change in density with decreasing species richness. Sensitive and persistent species both declined with increasing fragmentation intensity, but persistent species occurred on more islands, which may be due to their higher baseline densities. Compensatory species increased in abundance following the initial loss of sensitive species, but rapidly declined with increasing fragmentation. Supertramp species (widespread habitat generalists) may be poor competitors but strong dispersers; their abundance peaked following the decline of the other 3 groups. Nevertheless, even the least sensitive species were extirpated or rare on the smallest and most isolated islands.
- Open Access
- 1 April 2007
- Published by Conservation International
- Vol. rbba, 99
Dung Beetles of Lely and Nassau plateaus, Eastern Suriname
INTRODUCTION Dung beetles (Insecta: Coleoptera: Scarabaeidae: Scarabaeinae) are frequently used as a focal taxon in biodiversity studies for several reasons (Larsen and Forsyth 2005). Dung beetles are a diverse and abundant group of insects, especially in tropical forests, and their diversity patterns often mirror those of overall biodiversity. Most dung beetle species have small distributional ranges and high Beta-diversity, with relatively few species shared between habitat types (Spector 2002). Dung beetles are very sensitive to many kinds of disturbance. Since they depend primarily on mammal dung for food and reproduction, dung beetles may be a good indicator of mammal biomass and hunting intensity. By burying vertebrate dung, beetles perform several important ecosystem functions, including recycling nutrients for plants, dispersing seeds, and reducing infestation of mammals by parasites (Mittal 1993, Andresen 2002). Finally, dung beetles are a tractable group to study because they can be rapidly and cheaply sampled in a standardized and non-biased way using transects of baited pitfall traps (Larsen and Forsyth 2005). Within just a few days, this trapping method usually captures the majority of Alpha-diversity and also yields good abundance data. METHODS I sampled dung beetles at Lely and Nassau plateaus in eastern Suriname using pitfall trap transects. Ten traps baited with human dung were placed approximately 150 m apart at each site and collected every 24 hours for four days (see Larsen and Forsyth 2005 for methodology details). Each trap consisted of 16 oz plastic cups buried in the ground and filled with water and liquid detergent. Bait was suspended above the cups wrapped in nylon tulle and covered with large leaves. Human dung baits were replaced every two days. Since some dung beetle species feed on other resources, additional traps were baited with rotting fungus, rotting fruit, and dead insects. At Nassau, I placed two flight intercept traps consisting of mosquito netting with soapy water beneath. These types of traps often passively catch dung beetle species not attracted to baits. At Lely, 11 traps were placed from October 27–31, 2005 in primary forest that varied in canopy height and in plant species composition depending on the soil, with small, short trees dominating in more rocky areas. In addition, three traps were placed from October 27–29; one trap was placed in the grassy airstrip, one in secondary forest at the edge of the airstrip, and one in a weed-filled clear-cut area surrounding a radio tower. One trap baited with dead insects and one trap baited with rotting fungus were also placed in primary forest. At Nassau, 10 traps were placed from November 2–6, 2005 in the same general forest type as at Lely, although in many places the forest was taller and showed a wetter forest floor with greater leaf litter decomposition. Two flight intercept traps, one trap baited with dead insects and one trap baited with rotting fruit were also placed in primary forest. Beetles were sorted and identified as they were collected, and vouchers were placed in alcohol for further identification and museum collections. To determine the completeness of faunal sampling at each site, I compared the observed number of species to the expected number of species based on randomized species accumulation curves computed using EstimateS (Colwell 2003). I used the abundance-based coverage estimator (ACE) because it accounts for species abundance as well as incidence. Similarity indices were calculated using the same software. RESULTS I found a total of 42 species from both sites, represented by 1,110 individuals (Appendix 7). Lely had 37 species and 906 individuals, while at Nassau, I captured only 27 species and 204 individuals. Comparing only standardized dung pitfall transects from primary forest between the two sites, Lely had 33 species and 21.2 individuals/trap, while Nassau had 24 species and 4.3 individuals/trap. Species richness estimators (ACE) based on species accumulation curves from dung transects in primary forest predict true species richness of 39 species for Lely and 29 species for Nassau (sampling was about 85% complete for both sites). Both sites appeared to have hunting pressures that are likely to have negatively impacted dung beetle species richness and abundance, but Nassau appeared to have the strongest hunting pressure and the lowest beetle species richness and abundance. Dung beetle abundance at Nassau may also have been negatively affected by a large open cesspool near the basecamp. Even though Lely contained more dung beetle species, the dung beetle species composition of primary forest at the two sites was fairly similar. The sites shared 18 species and showed a high Morisita-Horn similarity index of 0.93. At Lely, only three individuals of one species, a grassland specialist, occurred on the airstrip. I only found four individuals of one species on the secondary forest edge, and no dung beetles at all in the weedy clearing. Dead insects attracted two species, while no species were attracted to fungus. One species (Anomiopus spp.) was only hand-collected on a leaf. A second species of Anomiopus was collected in a flight intercept trap at Nassau, as well as six other species. At Nassau, dead insects attracted seven species and fruit attracted none. One species was only hand-collected at felid scat. Both sites were characterized by hard, dry and rocky soils which may make it difficult for many dung beetle species to dig burrows for food and nesting, and may also increase larval mortality (Sowig 1995). This may be one reason why overall dung beetle abundance was much lower at both sites than for almost all other tropical forests where I have sampled dung beetles. Interesting Species While identification to the genus level is relatively simple, the taxonomic status and lack of identification keys for Neotropical dung beetles makes it difficult to place many species names, especially without comparing specimens against multiple museum collections. Nonetheless, I estimate that about 20–30% of the species collected are undescribed. The genera Anomiopus, Ateuchus, Canthidium and Uroxys are likely to contain the most undescribed species. A few species appear to have wide geographical ranges and are also found in the southern Amazon, although most species probably have relatively restricted ranges. A paucity of existing dung beetle data from nearby sites makes evaluation of range size difficult. At Lely, dead insects attracted one individual of Coprophanaeus lancifer, the largest species of neotropical dung beetle. This metallic blue species is highly valued for its impressive size and beauty, and the long horns possessed by both sexes. Both species of Anomiopus are likely to be undescribed. Species in this genus have never been attracted to baited traps, and their natural history is completely unknown, although their compact morphology suggests an association with ant nests observed for other genera. In most sites I have sampled in the neotropics, I have observed species of Canthidium which appear to be Batesian mimics of species in the ball-rolling tribe Canthonini, although to my knowledge nothing has been published about this. Almost all canthonines secrete a foul smelling chemical when handled, while Canthidium species, which are tunnellers rather than ball-rollers, do not. At Lely, Canthidium sp. 1 possesses the identical yellow and brown coloration pattern, including an unusual pronotal stripe, shown by Scybalocanthon cyanocephalus. THREATS AND RECOMMENDATIONS The greatest threats to dung beetle communities are logging and hunting, and dung beetles are known to be especially sensitive to fragmentation. Even slight perturbations of the forest are known to strongly affect dung beetles (Davis et al. 2001). At Lely, clear-cut areas and early secondary vegetation contained only two dung beetle species at extremely low abundance. Dung beetle communities at both sites are probably suffering from hunting, although the strongest hunting pressures are likely occurring from gold-miners at Nassau where dung beetle abundance was the lowest I have ever observed. A large open cesspool at Nassau may also be killing many thousands of dung beetles that are continuously attracted and drowned. An underground sewage system would not only spare many dung beetles, but would also make the area more pleasant for people. Although deforestation is still not widespread at either site, it is important to maintain large areas of intact primary forest in the future in order to maintain intact communities of mammals and dung beetles. I have found that some dung beetle species require more than 85 ha of continuous forest, and that many species will not cross even short distances of clear-cut forest such as to cross roads. I observed indications already at Nassau of a recently created dense network of roads that are fragmenting the forest so severely that the vegetation is being altered, and the dung beetles will also be strongly affected. I also observed no mammals in these strongly fragmented areas. Hunting is currently the greatest threat to dung beetles at both sites, but especially at Nassau. Stricter regulations and enforcement of hunting practices could make a big difference to dung beetles as well as mammals. Preventing what appears to be widespread hunting within the BHP concession at Nassau should be a first priority. Although fewer people live in the Lely area, hunting pressures are still strong, and incentives should be made for the workers to minimize hunting, especially of species which they are not killing for food. Maintaining healthy mammal and dung beetle communities will be especially important for maintaining primary and secondary seed dispersal which is essential for plant regeneration and forest dynamics (Larsen et al. 2005). REFERENCES 1 2 ColwellR. K. 2003EstimateS 7 version 7.5.1. Statistical estimation of species richness and shared species from samples.Web site: viceroy.eeb.uconn.edu/estimates Google Scholar 3 4 5 6 7 8 Appendices Appendix 7 Species list and abundance of dung beetles from the Nassau and Lely plateaus. Trond Larsen
- 1 April 2007
- Published by Conservation International
- Vol. rbba, 99
Open AccessDung Beetles of Lely and Nassau plateaus, Eastern Suriname
INTRODUCTION Dung beetles (Insecta: Coleoptera: Scarabaeidae: Scarabaeinae) are frequently used as a focal taxon in biodiversity studies for several reasons (Larsen and Forsyth 2005). Dung beetles are a diverse and abundant group of insects, especially in tropical forests, and their diversity patterns often mirror those of overall biodiversity. Most dung beetle species have small distributional ranges and high Beta-diversity, with relatively few species shared between habitat types (Spector 2002). Dung beetles are very sensitive to many kinds of disturbance. Since they depend primarily on mammal dung for food and reproduction, dung beetles may be a good indicator of mammal biomass and hunting intensity. By burying vertebrate dung, beetles perform several important ecosystem functions, including recycling nutrients for plants, dispersing seeds, and reducing infestation of mammals by parasites (Mittal 1993, Andresen 2002). Finally, dung beetles are a tractable group to study because they can be rapidly and cheaply sampled in a standardized and non-biased way using transects of baited pitfall traps (Larsen and Forsyth 2005). Within just a few days, this trapping method usually captures the majority of Alpha-diversity and also yields good abundance data. METHODS I sampled dung beetles at Lely and Nassau plateaus in eastern Suriname using pitfall trap transects. Ten traps baited with human dung were placed approximately 150 m apart at each site and collected every 24 hours for four days (see Larsen and Forsyth 2005 for methodology details). Each trap consisted of 16 oz plastic cups buried in the ground and filled with water and liquid detergent. Bait was suspended above the cups wrapped in nylon tulle and covered with large leaves. Human dung baits were replaced every two days. Since some dung beetle species feed on other resources, additional traps were baited with rotting fungus, rotting fruit, and dead insects. At Nassau, I placed two flight intercept traps consisting of mosquito netting with soapy water beneath. These types of traps often passively catch dung beetle species not attracted to baits. At Lely, 11 traps were placed from October 27–31, 2005 in primary forest that varied in canopy height and in plant species composition depending on the soil, with small, short trees dominating in more rocky areas. In addition, three traps were placed from October 27–29; one trap was placed in the grassy airstrip, one in secondary forest at the edge of the airstrip, and one in a weed-filled clear-cut area surrounding a radio tower. One trap baited with dead insects and one trap baited with rotting fungus were also placed in primary forest. At Nassau, 10 traps were placed from November 2–6, 2005 in the same general forest type as at Lely, although in many places the forest was taller and showed a wetter forest floor with greater leaf litter decomposition. Two flight intercept traps, one trap baited with dead insects and one trap baited with rotting fruit were also placed in primary forest. Beetles were sorted and identified as they were collected, and vouchers were placed in alcohol for further identification and museum collections. To determine the completeness of faunal sampling at each site, I compared the observed number of species to the expected number of species based on randomized species accumulation curves computed using EstimateS (Colwell 2003). I used the abundance-based coverage estimator (ACE) because it accounts for species abundance as well as incidence. Similarity indices were calculated using the same software. RESULTS I found a total of 42 species from both sites, represented by 1,110 individuals (Appendix 7). Lely had 37 species and 906 individuals, while at Nassau, I captured only 27 species and 204 individuals. Comparing only standardized dung pitfall transects from primary forest between the two sites, Lely had 33 species and 21.2 individuals/trap, while Nassau had 24 species and 4.3 individuals/trap. Species richness estimators (ACE) based on species accumulation curves from dung transects in primary forest predict true species richness of 39 species for Lely and 29 species for Nassau (sampling was about 85% complete for both sites). Both sites appeared to have hunting pressures that are likely to have negatively impacted dung beetle species richness and abundance, but Nassau appeared to have the strongest hunting pressure and the lowest beetle species richness and abundance. Dung beetle abundance at Nassau may also have been negatively affected by a large open cesspool near the basecamp. Even though Lely contained more dung beetle species, the dung beetle species composition of primary forest at the two sites was fairly similar. The sites shared 18 species and showed a high Morisita-Horn similarity index of 0.93. At Lely, only three individuals of one species, a grassland specialist, occurred on the airstrip. I only found four individuals of one species on the secondary forest edge, and no dung beetles at all in the weedy clearing. Dead insects attracted two species, while no species were attracted to fungus. One species (Anomiopus spp.) was only hand-collected on a leaf. A second species of Anomiopus was collected in a flight intercept trap at Nassau, as well as six other species. At Nassau, dead insects attracted seven species and fruit attracted none. One species was only hand-collected at felid scat. Both sites were characterized by hard, dry and rocky soils which may make it difficult for many dung beetle species to dig burrows for food and nesting, and may also increase larval mortality (Sowig 1995). This may be one reason why overall dung beetle abundance was much lower at both sites than for almost all other tropical forests where I have sampled dung beetles. Interesting Species While identification to the genus level is relatively simple, the taxonomic status and lack of identification keys for Neotropical dung beetles makes it difficult to place many species names, especially without comparing specimens against multiple museum collections. Nonetheless, I estimate that about 20–30% of the species collected are undescribed. The genera Anomiopus, Ateuchus, Canthidium and Uroxys are likely to contain the most undescribed species. A few species appear to have wide geographical ranges and are also found in the southern Amazon, although most species probably have relatively restricted ranges. A paucity of existing dung beetle data from nearby sites makes evaluation of range size difficult. At Lely, dead insects attracted one individual of Coprophanaeus lancifer, the largest species of neotropical dung beetle. This metallic blue species is highly valued for its impressive size and beauty, and the long horns possessed by both sexes. Both species of Anomiopus are likely to be undescribed. Species in this genus have never been attracted to baited traps, and their natural history is completely unknown, although their compact morphology suggests an association with ant nests observed for other genera. In most sites I have sampled in the neotropics, I have observed species of Canthidium which appear to be Batesian mimics of species in the ball-rolling tribe Canthonini, although to my knowledge nothing has been published about this. Almost all canthonines secrete a foul smelling chemical when handled, while Canthidium species, which are tunnellers rather than ball-rollers, do not. At Lely, Canthidium sp. 1 possesses the identical yellow and brown coloration pattern, including an unusual pronotal stripe, shown by Scybalocanthon cyanocephalus. THREATS AND RECOMMENDATIONS The greatest threats to dung beetle communities are logging and hunting, and dung beetles are known to be especially sensitive to fragmentation. Even slight perturbations of the forest are known to strongly affect dung beetles (Davis et al. 2001). At Lely, clear-cut areas and early secondary vegetation contained only two dung beetle species at extremely low abundance. Dung beetle communities at both sites are probably suffering from hunting, although the strongest hunting pressures are likely occurring from gold-miners at Nassau where dung beetle abundance was the lowest I have ever observed. A large open cesspool at Nassau may also be killing many thousands of dung beetles that are continuously attracted and drowned. An underground sewage system would not only spare many dung beetles, but would also make the area more pleasant for people. Although deforestation is still not widespread at either site, it is important to maintain large areas of intact primary forest in the future in order to maintain intact communities of mammals and dung beetles. I have found that some dung beetle species require more than 85 ha of continuous forest, and that many species will not cross even short distances of clear-cut forest such as to cross roads. I observed indications already at Nassau of a recently created dense network of roads that are fragmenting the forest so severely that the vegetation is being altered, and the dung beetles will also be strongly affected. I also observed no mammals in these strongly fragmented areas. Hunting is currently the greatest threat to dung beetles at both sites, but especially at Nassau. Stricter regulations and enforcement of hunting practices could make a big difference to dung beetles as well as mammals. Preventing what appears to be widespread hunting within the BHP concession at Nassau should be a first priority. Although fewer people live in the Lely area, hunting pressures are still strong, and incentives should be made for the workers to minimize hunting, especially of species which they are not killing for food. Maintaining healthy mammal and dung beetle communities will be especially important for maintaining primary and secondary seed dispersal which is essential for plant regeneration and forest dynamics (Larsen et al. 2005). REFERENCES 1 2 ColwellR. K. 2003EstimateS 7 version 7.5.1. Statistical estimation of species richness and shared species from samples.Web site: viceroy.eeb.uconn.edu/estimates Google Scholar 3 4 5 6 7 8 Appendices Appendix 7 Species list and abundance of dung beetles from the Nassau and Lely plateaus. Trond Larsen
- Top Cited Papers
- 12 April 2005
- Published by Wiley in Ecology Letters
- Vol. 8 (5) , 538-547
Extinction order and altered community structure rapidly disrupt ecosystem functioning
By causing extinctions and altering community structure, anthropogenic disturbances can disrupt processes that maintain ecosystem integrity. However, the relationship between community structure and ecosystem functioning in natural systems is poorly understood. Here we show that habitat loss appeared to disrupt ecosystem functioning by affecting extinction order, species richness and abundance. We studied pollination by bees in a mosaic of agricultural and natural habitats in California and dung burial by dung beetles on recently created islands in Venezuela. We found that large‐bodied bee and beetle species tended to be both most extinction‐prone and most functionally efficient, contributing to rapid functional loss. Simulations confirmed that extinction order led to greater disruption of function than predicted by random species loss. Total abundance declined with richness and also appeared to contribute to loss of function. We demonstrate conceptually and empirically how the non‐random response of communities to disturbance can have unexpectedly large functional consequences.
- 12 April 2005
- Published by Wiley in Ecology Letters
- Vol. 8 (5) , 538-547
Top Cited PapersExtinction order and altered community structure rapidly disrupt ecosystem functioning
By causing extinctions and altering community structure, anthropogenic disturbances can disrupt processes that maintain ecosystem integrity. However, the relationship between community structure and ecosystem functioning in natural systems is poorly understood. Here we show that habitat loss appeared to disrupt ecosystem functioning by affecting extinction order, species richness and abundance. We studied pollination by bees in a mosaic of agricultural and natural habitats in California and dung burial by dung beetles on recently created islands in Venezuela. We found that large‐bodied bee and beetle species tended to be both most extinction‐prone and most functionally efficient, contributing to rapid functional loss. Simulations confirmed that extinction order led to greater disruption of function than predicted by random species loss. Total abundance declined with richness and also appeared to contribute to loss of function. We demonstrate conceptually and empirically how the non‐random response of communities to disturbance can have unexpectedly large functional consequences.