ABAnn B. Butler

Ann B. Butler

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Ann B. Butler has a total of 6 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Hallmarks of Consciousness

    by Ann B. Butler

    Consciousness, ranging from the primary, or perceptual, level to high levels that include a sense of self, can be identified in various organisms by a set of hallmarks that include behavioral, neural and phenomenal and/or informational. Behavioral hallmarks include those that indicate high cognitive abilities, such behavioral flexibility, verbal abilities, episodic memories, theory of mind, object constancy, transitive inference and multistability, all of which have been demonstrated in birds as well as in primates. Neural hallmarks include the thalamocortical model for mammals and similar circuitry in some nonmammalian taxa. Informational hallmarks include sensorimotor awareness, as provided by somatosensory and/or lateral line systems, which may form the basis for the sense of self and distinguishing self from nonself, as well as other sensory information, such as the richness and quantity of color and form information obtained by the visual system. The comparative method reveals a correlation of these different types of hallmarks with each other in their degree of development, which thus may be indicative of the level of consciousness present in a particular species.


  • Evolution of the amniote pallium and the origins of mammalian neocortex

    by Ann B. Butler, Anton Reiner, Harvey J. Karten

    Karten's neocortex hypothesis holds that many component cell populations of the sauropsid dorsal ventricular ridge (DVR) are homologous to particular cell populations in layers of auditory and visual tectofugal‐recipient neocortex of mammals (i.e., temporal neocortex), as well as to some amygdaloid populations. The claustroamygdalar hypothesis, based on gene expression domains, proposes that mammalian homologues of DVR are found in the claustrum, endopiriform nuclei, and/or pallial amygdala. Because hypotheses of homology need to account for the totality of the evidence, the available data on multiple forebrain features of sauropsids and mammals are reviewed here. While some genetic data are compatible with the claustroamygdalar hypothesis, and developmental (epigenetic) data are indecisive, hodological, morphological, and topographical data favor the neocortex hypothesis and are inconsistent with the claustroamygdalar hypothesis. Detailed studies of gene signaling cascades that establish neuronal cell‐type identity in DVR, tectofugal‐recipient neocortex, and claustroamygdala will be needed to resolve this debate about the evolution of neocortex.


  • Evolution of the thalamus: a morphological and functional review

    by Ann B. Butler

    Enlargement of the forebrain, including elaboration of the thalamus, has occurred independently within different groups of vertebrates. Dorsal and ventral thalamic territories can be identified in most vertebrates, with variations in the presence of GABAergic neuronal components. An inhibitory thalamic reticular nucleus-like input to the dorsal thalamus might be a common feature, as might the organizational plan of two divisions of the dorsal thalamus, the lemnothalamus and collothalamus. Differential, independent elaboration of these divisions occurred in mammals and sauropsids (reptiles and birds), making their evolutionary relationships challenging to discern. Not all of the crucial features identified for mammalian thalamocortical circuitry are present in other vertebrates, but birds share the most features identified to date. These include specific and nonspecific thalamic relay neurons, reciprocal pallial projections, and a GABAergic thalamic reticular nucleus with some but not all hodological features. Because birds share many higher-level cognitive abilities and, thus, possibly higher-level consciousness, with mammals, comparison of the thalamocortical (thalamopallial) circuitry might prove a fruitful resource for testing functional hypotheses. Comparisons with selected other vertebrates that likewise have relatively large brain:body ratios and also exhibit some cognitively sophisticated behaviors, such as cichlid fish, might also prove valuable.


  • Mammalian and Avian Neuroanatomy and the Question of Consciousness in Birds

    by Ann B. Butler, Rodney M. J. Cotterill

    Some birds display behavior reminiscent of the sophisticated cognition and higher levels of consciousness usually associated with mammals, including the ability to fashion tools and to learn vocal sequences. It is thus important to ask what neuroanatomical attributes these taxonomic classes have in common and whether there are nevertheless significant differences. While the underlying brain structures of birds and mammals are remarkably similar in many respects, including high brain-body ratios and many aspects of brain circuitry, the architectural arrangements of neurons, particularly in the pallium, show marked dissimilarity. The neural substrate for complex cognitive functions that are associated with higher-level consciousness in mammals and birds alike may thus be based on patterns of circuitry rather than on local architectural constraints. In contrast, the corresponding circuits in reptiles are substantially less elaborated, with some components actually lacking, and in amphibian brains, the major ...


  • The serial transformation hypothesis of vertebrate origins: comment on “the new head hypothesis revisited”

    by Ann B. Butler

    In “The New Head Hypothesis Revisited,” R.G. Northcutt (2005. J Exp Zool (Mol Dev Evol) 304B:274–297) evaluates the original postulates of this hypothesis (Northcutt and Gans, 1983. Quart Rev Biol 58:1–28). One of these postulates is that the brain—particularly the forebrain—evolved at essentially the same time as many neural crest and neurogenic placode derivatives—including sensory ganglia, dermal skeleton and sensory capsules of the head, and branchial arches. Northcutt's subsequent paper in 1996 concluded with the idea that transitional forms might not have occurred at the origin of vertebrates. Butler proposed a “Serial Transformation” hypothesis in 2000, which disputed the latter idea in that paired eyes and an enlarged brain (but lacking telencephalon) were envisioned to have been gained before elaboration of most neural crest and neurogenic placodal derivatives. In 2003, J. Mallatt and J.‐Y. Chen analyzed fossils of the Cambrian animal Haikouella, which strongly support its affinity to craniates and aspects of several hypotheses, including Butler's transformational model, because although branchial bars are present, most other neural crest and placodal derivatives are absent, while paired eyes and an enlarged brain (but probably without telencephalon) are present. A more complete picture of vertebrate origins can be realized when the various hypotheses are constructively reconciled. J. Exp. Zool. (Mol. Dev. Evol.) 306B, 2006.


  • Clustered Phylogenetic Distribution of Nucleus rostrolateralis among Ray-Finned Fishes

    by Ann B. Butler, William M. Saidel

    Nucleus rostrolateralis, which was named for its location in the rostrolateral part of the diencephalon of neopterygian fishes, has been identified in a variety of species based on position, cytoarchitecture, hodology, and/or histochemistry. The phylogenetic distribution of the nucleus is highly sporadic, however. Due to this distribution, nucleus rostrolateralis cannot be regarded as phylogenetically homologous, but it might be an example of syngeny, or generative homology, which applies to characters that have the same genetic and/or developmental basis inherited from a common ancestor, whether or not the character itself has a phylogenetic distribution congruent with a monophyletic taxon – i.e., in general terms, an example of either phylogenetic homology or parallelism. To test whether the nucleus occurs in closely related taxonomic clusters, as might be expected for a character with a shared generative basis, a number of species of cyprinids and atherinomorphs (both teleost taxa) were examined for its presence. Many of the species examined appear to lack the nucleus, but a clustered occurrence of it was found within both taxa. Within cyprinids, nucleus rostrolateralis occurs in all three members examined of the Subfamily Rasborinae. Within atherinomorphs, it occurs in both members examined of the Tribe Poeciliini (of the Subfamily Poeciliinae, Family Poeciliidae) and in the one member examined of the Family Anablepidae. The clustered occurrence of nucleus rostrolateralis supports the hypothesis that it is an example of syngeny. Its postulated shared generative basis appears to derive from the common ancestor of the entire neopterygian radiation despite the rare occurrence of the character itself.


  • The third alternative: Duplication of collopallium in isocortical evolution

    by Ann B. Butler

    One hypothesis of isocortical evolution requires tangential migration of glutaminergic neurons. A second requires invasion of collothalamic afferents into the dorsal pallium, a territory that in sauropsids is solely lemnopallial. A third alternative is noted here – duplication of the original collopallial territory. The duplicated region would be formed by radial migration of excitatory neurons and would maintain its collothalamic innervation.

  • Apparent Absence of Claustrum in Monotremes: Implications for Forebrain Evolution in Amniotes

    by Ann B. Butler, Zoltán Molnár, Paul R. Manger

    The claustrum, which comprises the claustrum proper and the endopiriform nucleus, is generally thought to be present in all mammals. Some previous reports of its possible absence in monotremes have appeared in the literature, but the question of its presence or absence in this clade has not been formally addressed. Whether monotremes have a claustrum is of some importance for formulating and evaluating hypotheses relating to the evolution of the structures in the lateral sector of the pallium across amniotes. Archival sets of sections through the brains of the platypus and the short-beaked echidna were examined and included material stained for seven different histochemical and immunohistochemical protocols. No cytoarchitectonically distinct claustrum could be identified in this material for either monotreme. We thus conclude that if monotremes have any cell population that is homolgous to the claustrum of therian mammals, it is entirely cryptic. A claustrum might have been present in ancestral mammals and lost in the monotreme clade, or it might have been gained at the origin of therian mammals. Nonetheless, its absence as a cytoarchitectonically discrete and identifiable structure in monotremes fails to support homology of the claustrum of therian mammals with any single part of the sauropsid pallium.