Sabine Maguire
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Sabine Maguire has a total of 63 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
A. Kemp
School of Medicine, Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK
4 shared publicationsAlison Mary Kemp
School of Medicine Cardiff University UK
3 shared publicationsAm Kemp
Cochrane Institute of Primary Care and Public Health, Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK
3 shared publicationsA Emond
Prevention Theme, Healing Foundation Children’s Burns Research Centre, Bristol, UK
2 shared publicationsB. Ellaway
Cardiff University, Wales College of Medicine, Department of Child Health Cardiff, Wales, United Kingdom
2 shared publicationsD Rea
Prevention Theme, Healing Foundation Children’s Burns Research Centre, Bristol, UK
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 24 May 2017
- Published by BMJ
- Vol. 102, A56-A57
G138(P) Estimated annual incidence of childhood burns within the UK (2013–2015)
Aims Current burns research focuses on Burns Units admissions, thus underestimating a more widespread problem. This study aims to estimate the annual incidence of burns among children and young people (CYP) in the UK (2013–15) encompassing: mortality, Hospital Admissions (HA), Emergency Attendances (EA), and General Practice (GP). Methods Sources used are shown in Table 1. Office for National Statistics mid-year population data were used to estimate annual incidence. Table 1 Sources used to estimate childhood burn incidence Results The majority of cases are aged Conclusion Conservative estimates using mixed sources suggest burns result in 1–6 UK child deaths, 6800 hospitalisations, 40 700 EAs, and 28 900 GP contacts annually. Childhood burns are preventable, yet create significant burden on health services. These findings provide a baseline to inform prevention and service provision. Sources used to estimate childhood burn incidence Sources used to estimate childhood burn incidence
- 24 May 2017
- Published by BMJ
- Vol. 102, A56-A57
G138(P) Estimated annual incidence of childhood burns within the UK (2013–2015)
Aims Current burns research focuses on Burns Units admissions, thus underestimating a more widespread problem. This study aims to estimate the annual incidence of burns among children and young people (CYP) in the UK (2013–15) encompassing: mortality, Hospital Admissions (HA), Emergency Attendances (EA), and General Practice (GP). Methods Sources used are shown in Table 1. Office for National Statistics mid-year population data were used to estimate annual incidence. Table 1 Sources used to estimate childhood burn incidence Results The majority of cases are aged Conclusion Conservative estimates using mixed sources suggest burns result in 1–6 UK child deaths, 6800 hospitalisations, 40 700 EAs, and 28 900 GP contacts annually. Childhood burns are preventable, yet create significant burden on health services. These findings provide a baseline to inform prevention and service provision. Sources used to estimate childhood burn incidence Sources used to estimate childhood burn incidence
- 27 April 2016
- Published by BMJ in Archives of Disease in Childhood
- Vol. 101 (Suppl 1) , A127.1-A127
G231(P) Hairstyling hazards and other non-scald burns in children-results from a prospective UK study
Aims To identify the causes and mechanisms of unintentional non-scald burns among children presenting to hospital, and their associated clinical and social characteristics. Methods A prospective cross-sectional study was conducted across two UK centres (four Emergency Departments (ED), two Minor Injury Units and one burns unit) between 15/01/2013–31/12/2014. Standardised data collection was performed for all children aged 0–16 completed years with a burn (contact, flame, caustic, electric, radiation, friction). Data recorded included: demographics, burn agent, mechanism and environment, location of the burn on the body, severity, total body surface area (TBSA) and first aid applied. House fires, fatalities and burns due to maltreatment were excluded. Results Data was ascertained on 85% of children presenting with burns. Of 424 children identified, 34 were excluded due to safeguarding concerns, and one had multiple missing data. The 389 cases (59% boys) included: 86.6% (337/389) contact burns, 3.6% (14/389) sunburns, 3.3% (13/389) caustic burns, 3.1% (12/389) flame burns, with remaining 3.3% (13/389) other causes. The mean age of children sustaining non-scalds burn was 4 years (SD 4.3), the median age was 2 years (CI 2–3). Peak prevalence was at one year (27%, 105/390), while 74.3% (289/389) were aged 5 years or younger. The most common agents causing contact burns are hairstyling devices (67/337, 19.9%) including hair straighteners (15.4%, 52/337), curling tongs (4.2%, 14/337) and hair dryers (0.3%, 1/337). While 85.1% (57/67) of burns from hairstyling devices were to children aged ≤ 5 years old, in contrast, 75% (9/12) of flame burns and 46.1% (6/13) of caustic burns occurred in children >5 years old. TBSA was 5%, both being flame burns (0.6%, 2/317) (72 cases had TBSA missing). First aid was given to 90.5% (352/389) of children, but only 23.6% (61/258) used cool running water for ≥20 min as recommended by national guidelines. Conclusions Hairstyling devices pose a major threat to children aged less than five years, warranting a targeted prevention campaign. While first aid was frequently attempted, appropriate first aid was uncommon.
- 27 April 2016
- Published by BMJ in Archives of Disease in Childhood
- Vol. 101 (Suppl 1) , A127.1-A127
G231(P) Hairstyling hazards and other non-scald burns in children-results from a prospective UK study
Aims To identify the causes and mechanisms of unintentional non-scald burns among children presenting to hospital, and their associated clinical and social characteristics. Methods A prospective cross-sectional study was conducted across two UK centres (four Emergency Departments (ED), two Minor Injury Units and one burns unit) between 15/01/2013–31/12/2014. Standardised data collection was performed for all children aged 0–16 completed years with a burn (contact, flame, caustic, electric, radiation, friction). Data recorded included: demographics, burn agent, mechanism and environment, location of the burn on the body, severity, total body surface area (TBSA) and first aid applied. House fires, fatalities and burns due to maltreatment were excluded. Results Data was ascertained on 85% of children presenting with burns. Of 424 children identified, 34 were excluded due to safeguarding concerns, and one had multiple missing data. The 389 cases (59% boys) included: 86.6% (337/389) contact burns, 3.6% (14/389) sunburns, 3.3% (13/389) caustic burns, 3.1% (12/389) flame burns, with remaining 3.3% (13/389) other causes. The mean age of children sustaining non-scalds burn was 4 years (SD 4.3), the median age was 2 years (CI 2–3). Peak prevalence was at one year (27%, 105/390), while 74.3% (289/389) were aged 5 years or younger. The most common agents causing contact burns are hairstyling devices (67/337, 19.9%) including hair straighteners (15.4%, 52/337), curling tongs (4.2%, 14/337) and hair dryers (0.3%, 1/337). While 85.1% (57/67) of burns from hairstyling devices were to children aged ≤ 5 years old, in contrast, 75% (9/12) of flame burns and 46.1% (6/13) of caustic burns occurred in children >5 years old. TBSA was 5%, both being flame burns (0.6%, 2/317) (72 cases had TBSA missing). First aid was given to 90.5% (352/389) of children, but only 23.6% (61/258) used cool running water for ≥20 min as recommended by national guidelines. Conclusions Hairstyling devices pose a major threat to children aged less than five years, warranting a targeted prevention campaign. While first aid was frequently attempted, appropriate first aid was uncommon.
- Open Access
- 27 April 2015
- Published by BMJ in Archives of Disease in Childhood
- Vol. 100 (Suppl 3) , A19.2-A19
G46 A clinical prediction tool (cpt) to identify maltreatment in children with burns and scalds
Aims An estimated 10% of childhood burns arise from neglect or physical abuse. The challenge for emergency department (ED) staff with limited child protection training and a high staff turn over is to recognise these children. The aim of this study is to design an evidence-based CPT to assess the risk of maltreatment in a child who presents to ED with a burn or scald. Methods Derivation: An evidence-based proforma Burns and Scalds Assessment Tool (BaSAT) was developed from a systematic review of the characteristics of burns or scalds due to maltreatment. Standardised data were collected on 1327 children Results The validation: Of 789 children (median age 30 months) with burns, 7% (54) were referred to social services. The CPT classified 19% (74/389) scalds, and 26% (104/400) burns as ‘concern’. For scalds the sensitivity for identification of children referred to social care was 83% (95% CI 59–96%) and specificity was 84% (95% CI 80–88%) for scalds; positive likelihood ratio (LR+) 5.2 for non scalds the sensitivity was 81% (95% CI 64–92%) and specificity of 79% (95% CI 74–83%) for non-scalds; LR+ 3.9. Conclusions The CPT shows promise as an aid to clinical decision making in the ED setting. In conjunction with the BaSAT it provides standardised clinical assessment and documentation of children with burns/scalds and a prediction of the likelihood of maltreatment. Its applicability and accuracy will now be tested in an implementation evaluation.
- 27 April 2015
- Published by BMJ in Archives of Disease in Childhood
- Vol. 100 (Suppl 3) , A19.2-A19
Open AccessG46 A clinical prediction tool (cpt) to identify maltreatment in children with burns and scalds
Aims An estimated 10% of childhood burns arise from neglect or physical abuse. The challenge for emergency department (ED) staff with limited child protection training and a high staff turn over is to recognise these children. The aim of this study is to design an evidence-based CPT to assess the risk of maltreatment in a child who presents to ED with a burn or scald. Methods Derivation: An evidence-based proforma Burns and Scalds Assessment Tool (BaSAT) was developed from a systematic review of the characteristics of burns or scalds due to maltreatment. Standardised data were collected on 1327 children Results The validation: Of 789 children (median age 30 months) with burns, 7% (54) were referred to social services. The CPT classified 19% (74/389) scalds, and 26% (104/400) burns as ‘concern’. For scalds the sensitivity for identification of children referred to social care was 83% (95% CI 59–96%) and specificity was 84% (95% CI 80–88%) for scalds; positive likelihood ratio (LR+) 5.2 for non scalds the sensitivity was 81% (95% CI 64–92%) and specificity of 79% (95% CI 74–83%) for non-scalds; LR+ 3.9. Conclusions The CPT shows promise as an aid to clinical decision making in the ED setting. In conjunction with the BaSAT it provides standardised clinical assessment and documentation of children with burns/scalds and a prediction of the likelihood of maltreatment. Its applicability and accuracy will now be tested in an implementation evaluation.
- 1 April 2014
- Published by BMJ in Archives of Disease in Childhood
- Vol. 99 (Suppl 1) , A72
G162 'Mind the Gap' - Observable features of parent-child interactions amongst neglected children aged 0 to 13 years
Aim Neglect has far reaching consequences on a child’s emotional, psychological and social development. Our systematic review aims to identify the evidence base for observable features of the parent child interaction amongst neglected or emotionally abused children. Methods Using 80 key words & phrases we searched 18 databases and seven websites for the period 1950–2012, supplemented by handsearching journals and references. Of 10,206 abstracts identified, 922 full texts were scanned, and 188 articles reviewed by two independent reviewers (from a panel of paediatricians, child & educational psychologists, psychiatrists, teachers and social workers), using standardised critical appraisal methods. Included: age < 13 years, observed features in the parent-child interaction (both in the parent and/or the child during the interaction), neglect or emotional abuse confirmed by explicit criteria. Excluded: longterm outcome data, mixed forms of maltreatment where neglect could not be separated. Results 18 studies met the inclusion criteria and reported direct observation of the parent child interaction, 16 case control, 2 longitudinal cohort studies. Distinguishing features observed in the parent-child interaction included: hostility from parent (8 studies), showing less verbal interactions, more punishment, criticism & verbal aggression, less positive verbalisation. Unavailability and lack of attunement (12 studies): parents less responsive, less support to children completing tasks, interaction developmentally inappropriate, more likely to end/less likely to initiate interaction, less eye contact, less emotional discussion. Neglected children display more negativity in the parent-child interaction (2 studies) showing less verbal and non verbal affection and more physical aggression towards parents. Parental risk factors such as poor social competence, substance abuse, mental health problems of mothers and domestic violence in families were also confirmed. Conclusions Most paediatric consults offer the opportunity to observe the parent-child interaction, thus all practitioners could identify worrying features which merit further evaluation. The parent who is developmentally inappropriate with their child; a child displaying physical aggression towards their parent or concerning parent–child interaction requires recording and consideration of safeguarding implications.
- 1 April 2014
- Published by BMJ in Archives of Disease in Childhood
- Vol. 99 (Suppl 1) , A72
G162 'Mind the Gap' - Observable features of parent-child interactions amongst neglected children aged 0 to 13 years
Aim Neglect has far reaching consequences on a child’s emotional, psychological and social development. Our systematic review aims to identify the evidence base for observable features of the parent child interaction amongst neglected or emotionally abused children. Methods Using 80 key words & phrases we searched 18 databases and seven websites for the period 1950–2012, supplemented by handsearching journals and references. Of 10,206 abstracts identified, 922 full texts were scanned, and 188 articles reviewed by two independent reviewers (from a panel of paediatricians, child & educational psychologists, psychiatrists, teachers and social workers), using standardised critical appraisal methods. Included: age < 13 years, observed features in the parent-child interaction (both in the parent and/or the child during the interaction), neglect or emotional abuse confirmed by explicit criteria. Excluded: longterm outcome data, mixed forms of maltreatment where neglect could not be separated. Results 18 studies met the inclusion criteria and reported direct observation of the parent child interaction, 16 case control, 2 longitudinal cohort studies. Distinguishing features observed in the parent-child interaction included: hostility from parent (8 studies), showing less verbal interactions, more punishment, criticism & verbal aggression, less positive verbalisation. Unavailability and lack of attunement (12 studies): parents less responsive, less support to children completing tasks, interaction developmentally inappropriate, more likely to end/less likely to initiate interaction, less eye contact, less emotional discussion. Neglected children display more negativity in the parent-child interaction (2 studies) showing less verbal and non verbal affection and more physical aggression towards parents. Parental risk factors such as poor social competence, substance abuse, mental health problems of mothers and domestic violence in families were also confirmed. Conclusions Most paediatric consults offer the opportunity to observe the parent-child interaction, thus all practitioners could identify worrying features which merit further evaluation. The parent who is developmentally inappropriate with their child; a child displaying physical aggression towards their parent or concerning parent–child interaction requires recording and consideration of safeguarding implications.
- Open Access
- 1 June 2013
- Published by BMJ in Archives of Disease in Childhood
- Vol. 98 (Suppl 1) , A5-A6
P11 Can Real-Time Performance Feedback Improve Chest Compression Quality During Simulated Infant CPR? A Randomised Controlled Trial
Aims Current International Liaison Committee on Resuscitation (ILCOR) guidelines emphasise the provision of high quality chest compressions during infant cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR). Recent research, however, reports that Methods Sixty-nine certified European and Advanced Paediatric Life Support (EPLS and APLS) training course instructors were recruited from seven EPLS/APLS training courses. Instructors were randomly allocated to either a ‘no-feedback’ or ‘feedback’ group, and performed 60 seconds of two-thumb (TT) and two-finger (TF) chest compressions on a “physiological” CPR manikin instrumented to measure chest deflections. Baseline data were recorded for both groups without feedback, before chest compressions were repeated in the experimental phase with the ‘feedback’ group receiving real-time performance feedback. Chest compression depths, chest release forces, chest compression rates and compression duty cycles were recorded for all participants. Quality indices were calculated to report the proportion of chest compressions that achieved internationally recommended quality targets for each measure, with an overall quality index calculated to report the proportion of chest compressions that simultaneously achieved all four quality targets. Results were compared between the ‘no-feedback’ and ‘feedback’ groups. Results Baseline data were consistent with other studies, with < % of chest compressions simultaneously achieving all four internationally recommended quality targets. During the experimental stage (Table 1), the provision of real-time performance feedback improved the quality of the chest compression depths, chest compression rates and compression duty cycles provided by both techniques (all measures: p < 0.001). This enabled the ‘feedback’ group to simultaneously achieve all four quality targets in 75% of TF and 80% of TT technique chest compressions, whilst Conclusions Real-time performance feedback considerably increased the quality of chest compressions provided during simulated infant CPR. If these results transfer into clinical practise this technology could, for the first time, support resuscitators in performing high quality chest compressions during infant CPR and thus potentially improve future outcomes.
- 1 June 2013
- Published by BMJ in Archives of Disease in Childhood
- Vol. 98 (Suppl 1) , A5-A6
Open AccessP11 Can Real-Time Performance Feedback Improve Chest Compression Quality During Simulated Infant CPR? A Randomised Controlled Trial
Aims Current International Liaison Committee on Resuscitation (ILCOR) guidelines emphasise the provision of high quality chest compressions during infant cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR). Recent research, however, reports that Methods Sixty-nine certified European and Advanced Paediatric Life Support (EPLS and APLS) training course instructors were recruited from seven EPLS/APLS training courses. Instructors were randomly allocated to either a ‘no-feedback’ or ‘feedback’ group, and performed 60 seconds of two-thumb (TT) and two-finger (TF) chest compressions on a “physiological” CPR manikin instrumented to measure chest deflections. Baseline data were recorded for both groups without feedback, before chest compressions were repeated in the experimental phase with the ‘feedback’ group receiving real-time performance feedback. Chest compression depths, chest release forces, chest compression rates and compression duty cycles were recorded for all participants. Quality indices were calculated to report the proportion of chest compressions that achieved internationally recommended quality targets for each measure, with an overall quality index calculated to report the proportion of chest compressions that simultaneously achieved all four quality targets. Results were compared between the ‘no-feedback’ and ‘feedback’ groups. Results Baseline data were consistent with other studies, with < % of chest compressions simultaneously achieving all four internationally recommended quality targets. During the experimental stage (Table 1), the provision of real-time performance feedback improved the quality of the chest compression depths, chest compression rates and compression duty cycles provided by both techniques (all measures: p < 0.001). This enabled the ‘feedback’ group to simultaneously achieve all four quality targets in 75% of TF and 80% of TT technique chest compressions, whilst Conclusions Real-time performance feedback considerably increased the quality of chest compressions provided during simulated infant CPR. If these results transfer into clinical practise this technology could, for the first time, support resuscitators in performing high quality chest compressions during infant CPR and thus potentially improve future outcomes.
- Open Access
- 1 June 2013
- Published by BMJ in Archives of Disease in Childhood
- Vol. 98 (Suppl 1) , A97
G217(P) Validation of a Proposed Clinical Tool to Estimate the Probability of Abusive Head Trauma in Children Aged Less Than Three Years
Background Abusive head trauma (AHT) is the most common cause of death and disability in abused children, and presents significant diagnostic challenges. Previous research identified six individual features (retinal haemorrhage, rib and long bone fractures, facial bruising, apnoea and seizures) associated with AHT to create a statistical model to determine the probability of AHT based upon different combinations of these features in a child with intracranial injury. Aims The primary aim was to independently validate the statistical model on a novel dataset. The secondary aim was to look for association between AHT and the original six features, and further features not included in the original model, to suggest areas for refinement. Methods Retrospective, notes-based review of 44 cases of children aged less than 36 months admitted with intracranial head injury (20 AHT), identified at neuroimaging (01/01/2007–31/02/2012). Sensitivity, Specificity, Positive Predictive Value (PPV) and Negative Predictive Value (NPV) were calculated to determine the model’s accuracy. Fisher’s Exact Test and logistic regression were used to test for association between individual features and AHT. Significant association was found between AHT and retinal haemorrhage (p < 0.001), seizures (p < 0.02). Strong but not significant association was found between AHT and apnoea (p < 0.08), and between non-AHT and skull fracture (p < 0.25). Subdural haemorrhage, not included in the original model, was significantly associated with AHT (p < 0.04) On sub-analysis of retinal features, too numerous to count retinal haemorrhage was significantly associated with AHT (p < 0.04). Retinal haemorrhages were more likely to be multi-layered and bilateral in AHT cases. Conclusions When tested on this dataset the model had similar sensitivity and specificity to the original study, although imputing data caused variation. Type of intracranial injury and specific retinal features were identified as areas for refinement. The high sensitivity suggests that the tool has the potential to identify cases of suspected AHT that Warrant further detailed assessment, and could be useful for clinical practise.
- 1 June 2013
- Published by BMJ in Archives of Disease in Childhood
- Vol. 98 (Suppl 1) , A97
Open AccessG217(P) Validation of a Proposed Clinical Tool to Estimate the Probability of Abusive Head Trauma in Children Aged Less Than Three Years
Background Abusive head trauma (AHT) is the most common cause of death and disability in abused children, and presents significant diagnostic challenges. Previous research identified six individual features (retinal haemorrhage, rib and long bone fractures, facial bruising, apnoea and seizures) associated with AHT to create a statistical model to determine the probability of AHT based upon different combinations of these features in a child with intracranial injury. Aims The primary aim was to independently validate the statistical model on a novel dataset. The secondary aim was to look for association between AHT and the original six features, and further features not included in the original model, to suggest areas for refinement. Methods Retrospective, notes-based review of 44 cases of children aged less than 36 months admitted with intracranial head injury (20 AHT), identified at neuroimaging (01/01/2007–31/02/2012). Sensitivity, Specificity, Positive Predictive Value (PPV) and Negative Predictive Value (NPV) were calculated to determine the model’s accuracy. Fisher’s Exact Test and logistic regression were used to test for association between individual features and AHT. Significant association was found between AHT and retinal haemorrhage (p < 0.001), seizures (p < 0.02). Strong but not significant association was found between AHT and apnoea (p < 0.08), and between non-AHT and skull fracture (p < 0.25). Subdural haemorrhage, not included in the original model, was significantly associated with AHT (p < 0.04) On sub-analysis of retinal features, too numerous to count retinal haemorrhage was significantly associated with AHT (p < 0.04). Retinal haemorrhages were more likely to be multi-layered and bilateral in AHT cases. Conclusions When tested on this dataset the model had similar sensitivity and specificity to the original study, although imputing data caused variation. Type of intracranial injury and specific retinal features were identified as areas for refinement. The high sensitivity suggests that the tool has the potential to identify cases of suspected AHT that Warrant further detailed assessment, and could be useful for clinical practise.
- Open Access
- 1 June 2013
- Published by BMJ in Archives of Disease in Childhood
- Vol. 98 (Suppl 1) , A95-A96
G213 How Does the Pattern of Bruising Relate to the Mechanism of Injury in Children?
Objective It is essential that paediatricians assessing a child with bruising in suspected physical abuse can identify when the explanation for the bruise is implausible. Several published studies describe bruising patterns in populations of abused and non-abused children but we are not aware of any that describe the relationship between mechanism of injury and bruise pattern. Methods Details of the mechanism of unintentional injury, the number of bruises, location and size were recorded for: children aged 0–11 years attending a Children’s Emergency Department (ED) at a tertiary centre and children in the community (4–11 years at school, 0–4 year olds at two nurseries) with bruises of known cause. Students T-test, Chi-squared and Fisher’s exact test were used to analyse associations between mechanisms and bruise patterns. Results 351 children were recruited. Nine mechanisms of injury were recorded (Table 1). 81% (p < 0.001) of non-ambulant children (mean age = 9.9 months, SD = 6.3) sustained impact injuries whilst 60% of ambulant children (mean age = 41.7 months, SD = 30.4) fell from Conclusion The data demonstrate predominant injury mechanisms for unintentional injury in children that relate to child’s level of development. Multiple bruises from a single incident were rare, bruises were small and predominantly to the forehead, knees and shins and head. This predictable pattern of unintentional bruising can aid clinicians to judge the likelihood that a pattern of bruising is consistent with the mechanism of injury, and improve the detection of physical abuse where bruising pattern does NOT fit with a proposed mechanism. Bruise location according to mechanism
- 1 June 2013
- Published by BMJ in Archives of Disease in Childhood
- Vol. 98 (Suppl 1) , A95-A96
Open AccessG213 How Does the Pattern of Bruising Relate to the Mechanism of Injury in Children?
Objective It is essential that paediatricians assessing a child with bruising in suspected physical abuse can identify when the explanation for the bruise is implausible. Several published studies describe bruising patterns in populations of abused and non-abused children but we are not aware of any that describe the relationship between mechanism of injury and bruise pattern. Methods Details of the mechanism of unintentional injury, the number of bruises, location and size were recorded for: children aged 0–11 years attending a Children’s Emergency Department (ED) at a tertiary centre and children in the community (4–11 years at school, 0–4 year olds at two nurseries) with bruises of known cause. Students T-test, Chi-squared and Fisher’s exact test were used to analyse associations between mechanisms and bruise patterns. Results 351 children were recruited. Nine mechanisms of injury were recorded (Table 1). 81% (p < 0.001) of non-ambulant children (mean age = 9.9 months, SD = 6.3) sustained impact injuries whilst 60% of ambulant children (mean age = 41.7 months, SD = 30.4) fell from Conclusion The data demonstrate predominant injury mechanisms for unintentional injury in children that relate to child’s level of development. Multiple bruises from a single incident were rare, bruises were small and predominantly to the forehead, knees and shins and head. This predictable pattern of unintentional bruising can aid clinicians to judge the likelihood that a pattern of bruising is consistent with the mechanism of injury, and improve the detection of physical abuse where bruising pattern does NOT fit with a proposed mechanism. Bruise location according to mechanism
- 13 November 2012
- Published by Wiley in Child Abuse Review
- Vol. 22 (1) , 29-43
A Systematic Review of the Differential Diagnosis of Retinal Haemorrhages in Children with Clinical Features associated with Child Abuse
Retinal haemorrhages (RH) in a young child suggest child abuse, yet other causes merit consideration. This systematic review addresses non‐traumatic causes of RH in children with one or more overlapping clinical features of abuse (bruising, fractures, intracranial haemorrhage). Searching 12 databases (1950–2009) identified 338 studies for review by two reviewers. Inclusion criteria included: children < 15 years examined by an ophthalmologist detailing retinal findings, confirmed organic cause and exclusion of abuse. Exclusion criteria included: diagnosed coagulopathy, ocular mass lesion and post‐mortem cases. Twenty included studies identified nine relevant conditions (metabolic diseases, bony dysplasias, bleeding disorders and vascular malformations). Where detailed, the RH were bilateral and involved only one area of the retina (the posterior pole). Among proposed confounders of RH, no child with a cough (100 children) or acute life‐threatening event (184 cases) had RH. Just two of 217 children with seizures had posterior pole RH, one unilateral and one bilateral. One cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) study (43 cases) was included where a child with co‐existent clotting abnormalities had tiny (bilateral dot) RH after 60 minutes’ resuscitation. Child abuse remains the commonest cause of RH in young children, although rarer disorders merit consideration. There are insufficient data to conclude that CPR is a confounder in children with RH. Copyright © 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.‘Searching 12 databases (1950–2009) identified 338 studies for review’ ‘There are insufficient data to conclude that CPR is a confounder in children with RH’Key Practitioner Message: Retinal Haemorrhages are strongly associated with Abusive Head Trauma, but have been described in certain medical conditions. Neither cough nor ALTE are associated with RH, which have been found in < 3% of children with seizures. There are inadequate data to conclude that CPR is associated with RH. Case series have reported RH in children who also have clinical features that may overlap with physical abuse, namely certain metabolic, vascular, haematologic disorders and bony dysplasias (specifically osteogenesis imperfecta).
- 13 November 2012
- Published by Wiley in Child Abuse Review
- Vol. 22 (1) , 29-43
A Systematic Review of the Differential Diagnosis of Retinal Haemorrhages in Children with Clinical Features associated with Child Abuse
Retinal haemorrhages (RH) in a young child suggest child abuse, yet other causes merit consideration. This systematic review addresses non‐traumatic causes of RH in children with one or more overlapping clinical features of abuse (bruising, fractures, intracranial haemorrhage). Searching 12 databases (1950–2009) identified 338 studies for review by two reviewers. Inclusion criteria included: children < 15 years examined by an ophthalmologist detailing retinal findings, confirmed organic cause and exclusion of abuse. Exclusion criteria included: diagnosed coagulopathy, ocular mass lesion and post‐mortem cases. Twenty included studies identified nine relevant conditions (metabolic diseases, bony dysplasias, bleeding disorders and vascular malformations). Where detailed, the RH were bilateral and involved only one area of the retina (the posterior pole). Among proposed confounders of RH, no child with a cough (100 children) or acute life‐threatening event (184 cases) had RH. Just two of 217 children with seizures had posterior pole RH, one unilateral and one bilateral. One cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) study (43 cases) was included where a child with co‐existent clotting abnormalities had tiny (bilateral dot) RH after 60 minutes’ resuscitation. Child abuse remains the commonest cause of RH in young children, although rarer disorders merit consideration. There are insufficient data to conclude that CPR is a confounder in children with RH. Copyright © 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.‘Searching 12 databases (1950–2009) identified 338 studies for review’ ‘There are insufficient data to conclude that CPR is a confounder in children with RH’Key Practitioner Message: Retinal Haemorrhages are strongly associated with Abusive Head Trauma, but have been described in certain medical conditions. Neither cough nor ALTE are associated with RH, which have been found in < 3% of children with seizures. There are inadequate data to conclude that CPR is associated with RH. Case series have reported RH in children who also have clinical features that may overlap with physical abuse, namely certain metabolic, vascular, haematologic disorders and bony dysplasias (specifically osteogenesis imperfecta).
- 1 September 2011
- Published by American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) in Pediatrics
- Vol. 128 (3) , e550-e564
Estimating the Probability of Abusive Head Trauma: A Pooled Analysis
CONTEXT AND OBJECTIVE: To determine which combinations of clinical features assist in distinguishing abusive head trauma (AHT) from nonabusive head trauma. METHODS: Individual patient data from 6 comparative studies of children younger than 3 years with intracranial injury were analyzed to determine the association between AHT and combinations of apnea; retinal hemorrhage; rib, skull, and long-bone fractures; seizures; and head and/or neck bruising. An aggregate analysis of data from these studies used multiple imputation of combined clinical features using a bespoke hotdeck imputation strategy, which accounted for uncertainty arising from missing information. RESULTS: Analyzing 1053 children (348 had AHT), excluding nonsignificant variables (gender, age, skull fractures), for a child with an intracranial injury and 1 or 2 of the 6 features, the positive predictive value (PPV) of AHT varies from 4% to 97% according to the different combinations. Although rarely recorded, apnea is significantly associated with AHT (odds ratio [OR]: 6.89 [confidence interval: 2.08–22.86]). When rib fracture or retinal hemorrhage was present with any 1 of the other features, the OR for AHT is >100 (PPV > 85%). Any combination of 3 or more of the 6 significant features yielded an OR of >100 (PPV for AHT > 85%). CONCLUSIONS: Probabilities of AHT can be estimated on the basis of different combinations of clinical features. The model could be further developed in a prospective large-scale study, with an expanded clinical data set, to contribute to a more refined tool to inform clinical decisions about the likelihood of AHT.
- 1 September 2011
- Published by American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) in Pediatrics
- Vol. 128 (3) , e550-e564
Estimating the Probability of Abusive Head Trauma: A Pooled Analysis
CONTEXT AND OBJECTIVE: To determine which combinations of clinical features assist in distinguishing abusive head trauma (AHT) from nonabusive head trauma. METHODS: Individual patient data from 6 comparative studies of children younger than 3 years with intracranial injury were analyzed to determine the association between AHT and combinations of apnea; retinal hemorrhage; rib, skull, and long-bone fractures; seizures; and head and/or neck bruising. An aggregate analysis of data from these studies used multiple imputation of combined clinical features using a bespoke hotdeck imputation strategy, which accounted for uncertainty arising from missing information. RESULTS: Analyzing 1053 children (348 had AHT), excluding nonsignificant variables (gender, age, skull fractures), for a child with an intracranial injury and 1 or 2 of the 6 features, the positive predictive value (PPV) of AHT varies from 4% to 97% according to the different combinations. Although rarely recorded, apnea is significantly associated with AHT (odds ratio [OR]: 6.89 [confidence interval: 2.08–22.86]). When rib fracture or retinal hemorrhage was present with any 1 of the other features, the OR for AHT is >100 (PPV > 85%). Any combination of 3 or more of the 6 significant features yielded an OR of >100 (PPV for AHT > 85%). CONCLUSIONS: Probabilities of AHT can be estimated on the basis of different combinations of clinical features. The model could be further developed in a prospective large-scale study, with an expanded clinical data set, to contribute to a more refined tool to inform clinical decisions about the likelihood of AHT.
- 3 June 2011
- Published by BMJ in Archives of Disease in Childhood
- Vol. 96 (9) , 810-816
Which urgent care services do febrile children use and why?
Objectives To explore how parents navigate urgent and emergency care (U&EC) services when their child Design Parents of a febrile child Results Of 556 parents expressing an interest, 220 enrolled, making 570 contacts (median 3, range 1–13) with services during the child's illness which lasted 3 days on average. Parents' first preference for advice in hours was to see a general practitioner (GP) (67%; 93/138) and when unavailable, National Health Service Direct (46%; 38/82). 155 made more than one contact and 63% of the repeat contacts were initiated by a service provider. A range of factors influenced parents' use of services. Parents who reported receiving ‘safety netting’ advice (81%) were less likely to re-present to U&EC services than those who did not recall receiving such advice (35% vs 52%, p=0.01). Parents identified a need for accurate, consistent, written advice regarding fever and antipyretics. Conclusion Parents know the U&EC service options available, and their first choice is the GP. Multiple contacts are being made for relatively well children, often due to repeated referrals within the system. Safety netting advice reduces re-attendances but parents want explicit and consistent advice for appropriate home management.
- 3 June 2011
- Published by BMJ in Archives of Disease in Childhood
- Vol. 96 (9) , 810-816
Which urgent care services do febrile children use and why?
Objectives To explore how parents navigate urgent and emergency care (U&EC) services when their child Design Parents of a febrile child Results Of 556 parents expressing an interest, 220 enrolled, making 570 contacts (median 3, range 1–13) with services during the child's illness which lasted 3 days on average. Parents' first preference for advice in hours was to see a general practitioner (GP) (67%; 93/138) and when unavailable, National Health Service Direct (46%; 38/82). 155 made more than one contact and 63% of the repeat contacts were initiated by a service provider. A range of factors influenced parents' use of services. Parents who reported receiving ‘safety netting’ advice (81%) were less likely to re-present to U&EC services than those who did not recall receiving such advice (35% vs 52%, p=0.01). Parents identified a need for accurate, consistent, written advice regarding fever and antipyretics. Conclusion Parents know the U&EC service options available, and their first choice is the GP. Multiple contacts are being made for relatively well children, often due to repeated referrals within the system. Safety netting advice reduces re-attendances but parents want explicit and consistent advice for appropriate home management.