MBMartin Butzlaff

Martin Butzlaff

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Martin Butzlaff has a total of 50 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Job requirements compared to medical school education: differences between graduates from problem-based learning and conventional curricula

    by Christopher L Schlett, Hinnerk Doll, Janosch Dahmen, Ole Polacsek, Gero Federkeil, Martin R Fischer, Fabian Bamberg, Martin Butzlaff

    Problem-based Learning (PBL) has been suggested as a key educational method of knowledge acquisition to improve medical education. We sought to evaluate the differences in medical school education between graduates from PBL-based and conventional curricula and to what extent these curricula fit job requirements.


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Knowledge transfer for the management of dementia: a cluster-randomised trial of blended learning in general practice

    by Horst C Vollmar, Herbert Mayer, Thomas Ostermann, Martin E Butzlaff, John E Sandars, Stefan Wilm, Monika A Rieger

    The implementation of new medical knowledge into general practice is a complex process. Blended learning may offer an effective and efficient educational intervention to reduce the knowledge-to-practice gap. The aim of this study was to compare knowledge acquisition about dementia management between a blended learning approach using online modules in addition to quality circles (QCs) and QCs alone.


  • Open Access

    Dementia care initiative in primary practice – study protocol of a cluster randomized trial on dementia management in a general practice setting

    by Rolf Holle, Elmar Gräßel, Stefan Ruckdäschel, Sonja Wunder, Hilmar Mehlig, Peter Marx, Olaf Pirk, Martin Butzlaff, Simone Kunz, Jörg Lauterberg

    Current guidelines for dementia care recommend the combination of drug therapy with non-pharmaceutical measures like counselling and social support. However, the scientific evidence concerning non-pharmaceutical interventions for dementia patients and their informal caregivers remains inconclusive. Targets of modern comprehensive dementia care are to enable patients to live at home as long and as independent as possible and to reduce the burden of caregivers. The objective of the study is to compare a complex intervention including caregiver support groups and counselling against usual care in terms of time to nursing home placement. In this paper the study protocol is described.


  • Open Access

    General Practitioners' preferences and use of educational media: a German perspective

    by Horst Christian Vollmar, Monika A Rieger, Martin E Butzlaff, Thomas Ostermann

    Several studies suggest that General Practitioners (GPs) prefer "traditional" media such as journals or quality circles when they are seeking out different options to meet their continuing medical education (CME) requirements. A survey was designed in order to gain a better understanding of German General Practitioners' preferences for different forms of educational media that will meet their CME needs.


  • Open Access

    Knowledge translation on dementia: a cluster randomized trial to compare a blended learning approach with a "classical" advanced training in GP quality circles

    by Horst C Vollmar, Martin E Butzlaff, Rolf Lefering, Monika A Rieger

    Background: Thus far important findings regarding the dementia syndrome have been implemented into patients' medical care only inadequately. A professional training accounting for both, general practitioners' (GP) needs and learning preferences as well as care-relevant aspects could be a major step towards improving medical care. In the WIDA-study, entitled "Knowledge translation on dementia in general practice" two different training concepts are developed, implemented and evaluated. Both concepts are building on an evidence-based, GP-related dementia guideline and communicate the guideline's essential insights. Methods/Design: Both development and implementation emphasize a procedure that is well-accepted in practice and, thus, can achieve a high degree of external validity. This is particularly guaranteed through the preparation of training material and the fact that general practitioners' quality circles (QC) are addressed. The evaluation of the two training concepts is carried out by comparing two groups of GPs to which several quality circles have been randomly assigned. The primary outcome is the GPs' knowledge gain. Secondary outcomes are designed to indicate the training's potential effects on the GPs' practical actions. In the first training concept (study arm A) GPs participate in a structured case discussion prepared for by internet-based learning material ("blended-learning" approach). The second training concept (study arm B) relies on frontal medical training in the form of a slide presentation and follow-up discussion ("classical" approach). Discussion: This paper presents the outline of a cluster-randomized trial which has been peer reviewed and support by a national funding organization – Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF) – and is approved by an ethics commission. The data collection has started in August 2006 and the results will be published independently of the study's outcome. Trial Registration: Current Controlled Trials [ISRCTN36550981]


  • Open Access

    German ambulatory care physicians' perspectives on clinical guidelines – a national survey

    by Martin Butzlaff, Daniela Kempkens, Melanie Schnee, Wilfried E Dieterle, Jan Böcken, Monika A Rieger

    There has been little systematic research about the extent to which German physicians accept or reject the concept and practice of a) clinical practice guidelines (CPG) and b) evidence based medicine (EBM) clinical practice guidelines (CPG) and evidence based medicine (EBM) The aim of this study was to investigate German office-based physicians' perspective on CPGs and EBM and their application in medical practice. Structured national telephone survey of ambulatory care physicians, four thematic blocks with 21 questions (5 point Likert scale). 511 office-based general practitioners and specialists. Main outcome measures were the application of Clinical Practice Guidelines in daily practice, preference for sources of guidelines and degree of knowledge and acceptance of EBM. In the data analysis Pearson's correlation coefficient was used for explorative analysis of correlations. The comparison of groups was performed by Student's t-test. Chi2 test was used to investigate distribution of two or more categorical variables. Of the total study population 55.3% of physicians reported already using guidelines in the treatment of patients. Physicians in group practices (GrP) as well as general practitioners (GP) agreed significantly more with the usefulness of guidelines as a basis for patient care than doctors in single practices (SP) or specialists (S) (Student's t-test mean GP 2.57, S 2.84, p < 0.01; mean GrP 2.55, SP 2.80, p < 0.05). 33.1% of the participants demonstrated a strong rejection to the application of guidelines in patient care. Acceptance of guidelines from a governmental institution was substantially lower than from physician networks or medical societies (36.2% vs. 53.4% vs. 62.0%). 73.8% of doctors interpret EBM as a combination of scientific research and individual medical knowledge; 80% regard EBM as the best basis for patient care. Despite a majority of physicians accepting and applying CPGs a large group remains that is critical and opposed to the utilization of CPGs in daily practice and to the concept of EBM in general. Doctors in single practice and specialists appear to be more critical than physicians in group practices and GPs. Future research is needed to evaluate the willingness to acquire necessary knowledge and skills for the promotion and routine application of CPGs.


    • 1 January 2006
      • Vol. 100  (6) , 453-60

    [EbM and patient perspective--a 5-step approach].

    by Jana Isfort, Nik Koneczny, Martin Butzlaff

    Shared decision making describes a way of involving patients in the planning and management of their individual healing process. Doing this effectively seems to be quite a challenge for both physicians and patients. The mutual transfer of information appears to be one of the main steps of this process. Clinical patient information or patient guidelines can help to explain complex medical processes in a non-specialist way and thus improve communication and self-management. In order to develop an "evidence-based asthma patient guideline" we tried to focus on both evidence-based recommendations and patients' perspectives. Patients were asked about their individual needs and knowledge and took part in the subsequent review. In order to explore patients' perspectives and needs we implemented two additional steps to our existing concept of guideline development: (1) a questionnaire for asthma patients with 10 items dealing with patients' knowledge about asthma and a personal grading of 16 "asthma-related questions", and (2) patients joining the actual guideline review panel. By evaluating the results of the questionnaire we discovered a gap between what patients consider to be interesting and/or important and what is necessary from the point of view of medicine and health policy. Although the patients showed a great interest in an autonomous approach to life with asthma [important items: "what can I do by myself" (68%); "how can I prevent an asthma attack" (86%); "how can I live a better life with asthma" (77%)], they were less interested in topics that would give them more autonomy ["structured educational programs" (41%); "how to use inhaling devices" (64%) or "peak flow measurement" (36%)]. Patients participating in the review panel emphasized the need for more or better information about pollution (i.e. ozone), complementary/alternative methods and the administration of cortisone during the asthma attack--topics that were not mentioned in the physicians' guideline. To acquire an "implementable" evidence-based patient guideline it is not sufficient to "translate" existing asthma guidelines into lay language. We should focus on the needs of individual asthma patients and the problems they encounter every day. Therefore patients should be asked what they want to know and what they do not know, and they should review the results and include their own views into the guideline. We applied this concept to the above mentioned evidence-based patient guideline and received a thematic ranking focused on patients' daily needs as well as a to-do list of topics that require increased attention (like peak flow measurement and structured education programs). The patients' perspectives changed our perspective on our patient guideline more than we expected.

    • 1 January 2006
      • Vol. 100  (8) , 587-92

    [How to change physicians' practice--health services research with the knowledge-performance gap on focus].

    by Nik Koneczny, Martin Butzlaff

    How can the knowledge-performance gap be bridged? The discrepancy between our scientific knowledge on the one hand and its inadequate application in everyday practice on the other remains a major challenge for implementation research. Looking back on ten years of Health Services Research and acknowledging the achievements of educational research we have gained access to a variety of research findings and tools describing how physicians'--and other health professionals'--behavior and performance in medical care may be influenced. The time has come for testing and evaluating them.

  • „Shared Decision Making“

    by Bettina Floer, Melanie Schnee, Jan Böcken, Waldemar Streich, Wilfried Kunstmann, Jana Isfort, Martin Butzlaff

    Patienten sollen und wollen in Therapieentscheidungen miteinbezogen werden. Sie erwarten eine patientenzentrierte Kommunikation mit ihrem Arzt und eine ausführliche Information. Bislang liegen kaum Daten zur ärztlichen Sichtweise dieser sog. gemeinsamen Entscheidungsfindung vor. Des Weiteren besteht Unklarheit darüber, in welchem Maße Ärzte über dafür notwendige kommunikative Basisfertigkeiten verfügen. Die vorliegende Untersuchung liefert aktuelle Daten zu diesen Bereichen aus ärztlicher Perspektive. Zum Vergleich wird der ärztlichen Perspektive punktuell die Patientenperspektive gegenübergestellt. Bei 502 niedergelassenen Ärzten wurde eine telefonische Befragung durchgeführt. Außerdem wurden 1 512 18– bis 79–jährige deutschsprachige Personen einer Bevölkerungsstichprobe aus einem Access Panel schriftlich befragt. Folgende Themenkomplexe wurden bei den Befragungen abgedeckt: Entscheidungsfindung in der Praxis aus Ärzte– und Patientensicht („Wer soll entscheiden?“), ärztliches kommunikatives Verhalten in der Praxis aus Ärzte– und Patientensicht. Die befragten Ärzte befürworten mehrheitlich das Konzept des Shared Decision Making. Besonders jüngere Ärzte sind der Meinung, dass Entscheidungen im Allgemeinen von Ärzten und Patienten gemeinschaftlich gefällt werden sollten. Aus der Gegenüberstellung der Patientenperspektive wird deutlich, dass Ärzte den Kommunikations– und Informationsbedarf ihrer Patienten unterschätzen. Sie nehmen ihre kommunikativen Fähigkeiten positiver wahr als die Patienten. Nicht nur in der öffentlichen und gesundheitspolitischen Diskussion wird das Modell des Shared Decision Making positiv bewertet, auch Ärzte zeigen eine grundlegende Bereitschaft, den Prozess einer gemeinsamen Entscheidungsfindung mit ihren Patienten einzugehen. Hierfür notwendige kommunikative Basisfertigkeiten sind vorhanden, aber noch weiterzuentwickeln. Eine medizinische Aus–, Weiter- und Fortbildung, die die Gesprächsführung weiter in den Mittelpunkt rückt, kann eine gute Grundlage bilden. Ebenso sollte eine Aufwertung des ärztlichen Gesprächs, z.B. in einem daran angepassten Einheitlichen Bewertungs– oder Honorarverteilungsmaßstab, angestrebt werden. More and more, patients want to participate in medical decision making. They expect a patient–centered communication as well as adequate information. However, little is known about the physicians’ perspective and skills regarding shared decision making (SDM). This paper presents data about the physicians’ perspective and allows focused comparison with the patients’ views. Standardized survey of 502 physicians from ambulatory care practices and of 1,512 German–speaking people, aged 18–79 years. Patient data were collected from a population–based random sample of an access panel. The following topics were included in this survey: medical decision making in daily practice, communication skills and behavior of physicians from the perspectives of physicians and patients. A majority of physicians approve the concept of SDM. Especially younger physicians favor the concept of SDM. Overall, physicians underestimate their patients’ preference to participate in medical decision making. Physicians also tend to overestimate their information and communication skills. Not only in the general public, but also among physicians, a model of SDM is widely accepted. The communication skills necessary for this process appear to exist. However, they need to be promoted and extended. Learning to communicate adequately should receive a greater focus in medical education and postgraduate training.


  • Open Access

    Learning with computerized guidelines in general practice?: A randomized controlled trial

    by M Butzlaff, Hc Vollmar, B Floer, N Koneczny, J Isfort, S Lange

    Background. Evidence-based guidelines are seen as an important instrument to transfer scientifically generated knowledge into daily clinical practice and to ensure high standards of clinical care. Despite wide promulgation, clinical guidelines so far have a limited impact on individual professional learning and on changing daily medical practice. Objectives. Our aims were (i) to study a potential knowledge increase among German GPs after implementation of web- and evidence-based guidelines and (ii) to identify and analyse potential barriers to individual professional learning with computerized guidelines. Methods. A prospective, randomized controlled trial was conducted including 72 GPs (21% female, 79% male). The intervention group (n = 38) had access to clinical guidelines via the Internet or CD-ROM, the control group had not (n = 34). Both groups received a standardized two-part questionnaire. An increase of knowledge was measured with 25 multiple choice questions related to four different medical topics. In addition, reasons for using or not using computerized guidelines were analysed after access to guidelines was open to all participating physicians. Results. There was no significant knowledge increase in the intervention group (P = 0.69). Twenty-two (58%) GPs of the intervention group had used the guidelines. Unspecified curiosity (76%) and a specific medical question (38%) were predominant motives for usage among physicians who had used the guidelines. Among ‘non-users’, 78% stated ‘lack of time’ as the main reason for not using guidelines. Conclusion. An efficient knowledge transfer through computerized guidelines was not achieved. Usage, individual learning and potential implementation depend on adequate incentives and pragmatic aspects of clinical practice: easy and quick access.