Laurent Lehmann
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Laurent Lehmann has a total of 40 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Charles Mullon
Department of Ecology and Evolution, University of Lausanne, 1015 Lausanne, Switzerland
11 shared publications - Jorge Peña
Institute for Advanced Study in Toulouse, University of Toulouse Capitole, Toulouse, France
6 shared publications - Georg Nöldeke
Faculty of Business and Economics, University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland
5 shared publications - Laurent Keller
Department of Ecology and Evolution, Biophore Building, University of Lausanne
5 shared publications - François Rousset
ISEM, Univ Montpellier, CNRS, IRD, Montpellier, France
4 shared publications - Carel P. van Schaik
Department of Evolutionary Anthropology, University of Zurich
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 3 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Theoretical Biology
- Vol. 633, 112545
Evolution of quantitative traits: exploring the ecological, social and genetic bases of adaptive polymorphism
- 3 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Theoretical Biology
- Vol. 633, 112545
Open AccessEvolution of quantitative traits: exploring the ecological, social and genetic bases of adaptive polymorphism
- Open Access
Darwinian fitness, its directional derivative, and Hamilton’s rule for limited dispersal with class structure under within- and between-generation environmental stochasticity
Darwinian fitness is equated here with invasion fitness and defined as that quantity determining the fate—certain extinction or possible spread—of a single mutant type. We derive it, together with its phenotypic derivative, for evolution occurring in group-structured populations under limited genetic mixing, where the demography of the focal species and its environment is modeled as a discrete-time stochastic process. Reproduction, physiological development, dispersal, and survival are influenced by interactions within and between groups and by environmental fluctuations within and across generations. Using multitype branching processes in random environments, we show that invasion fitness is predicted by a stochastic growth rate that can be represented biologically in two meaningful genealogical ways. First, as the long-term geometric mean of the expected per-capita number of mutant copies produced per time step by a representative member of the mutant lineage. Second, as the long-term geometric mean of the expected reproductive-value-weighted per-capita number of mutant copies produced by such an individual. This latter representation is useful for computing the phenotypic directional derivative of invasion fitness. Moreover, this derivative can be written as an actor-centered inclusive-fitness effect derived from properties of the resident population process alone. This effect depends on class-specific fitness differentials, relatedness, reproductive values, and class frequencies. However, unless generation- and class-specific fitness defines a stochastic matrix, the derivative does not separate stochastic reproductive values from relatedness and class frequencies, and must be evaluated by simulations. In summary, we formalize invasion fitness biologically quite generally and show how Hamilton’s marginal rule can be deduced from it.
Open AccessDarwinian fitness, its directional derivative, and Hamilton’s rule for limited dispersal with class structure under within- and between-generation environmental stochasticity
Darwinian fitness is equated here with invasion fitness and defined as that quantity determining the fate—certain extinction or possible spread—of a single mutant type. We derive it, together with its phenotypic derivative, for evolution occurring in group-structured populations under limited genetic mixing, where the demography of the focal species and its environment is modeled as a discrete-time stochastic process. Reproduction, physiological development, dispersal, and survival are influenced by interactions within and between groups and by environmental fluctuations within and across generations. Using multitype branching processes in random environments, we show that invasion fitness is predicted by a stochastic growth rate that can be represented biologically in two meaningful genealogical ways. First, as the long-term geometric mean of the expected per-capita number of mutant copies produced per time step by a representative member of the mutant lineage. Second, as the long-term geometric mean of the expected reproductive-value-weighted per-capita number of mutant copies produced by such an individual. This latter representation is useful for computing the phenotypic directional derivative of invasion fitness. Moreover, this derivative can be written as an actor-centered inclusive-fitness effect derived from properties of the resident population process alone. This effect depends on class-specific fitness differentials, relatedness, reproductive values, and class frequencies. However, unless generation- and class-specific fitness defines a stochastic matrix, the derivative does not separate stochastic reproductive values from relatedness and class frequencies, and must be evaluated by simulations. In summary, we formalize invasion fitness biologically quite generally and show how Hamilton’s marginal rule can be deduced from it.
- Open Access
- 6 April 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Evolutionary Human Sciences
- Vol. 8, 1-36
How does stochasticity in learning impact the accumulation of knowledge and the evolution of learning?
Learning is crucial for humans and other animals to acquire knowledge, enhancing survival and reproduction. In particular, individual and social learning allow populations to accumulate knowledge across generations. Here, we examine how stochasticity in the production and social acquisition of knowledge influences the evolution of learning strategies and cumulative knowledge. Using a mathematical model where learning is stochastic, we show that learning stochasticity enhances cumulative knowledge by generating variability in knowledge levels. This allows selection to enhance population knowledge: individuals who acquire more knowledge by chance are more likely to survive and reproduce, and therefore to transmit their knowledge to the next generation. As knowledge accumulates, social learning exemplars tend to possess more of it, favoring greater time investment in social learning. Because social learning provides access to substantially more knowledge when learning is stochastic, selection also favors the evolution of greater investment into learning, at the expense of a fecundity cost. Moreover, when knowledge enhances fecundity but not survival, learning stochasticity favors learning from parents rather than other adults, because learning stochasticity increases uncertainty about exemplar knowledge, making parenthood a cue for possessing fecundity-enhancing knowledge. Finally, when learning occurs predominantly from parents, learning stochasticity itself is favored by selection.
- 6 April 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Evolutionary Human Sciences
- Vol. 8, 1-36
Open AccessHow does stochasticity in learning impact the accumulation of knowledge and the evolution of learning?
Learning is crucial for humans and other animals to acquire knowledge, enhancing survival and reproduction. In particular, individual and social learning allow populations to accumulate knowledge across generations. Here, we examine how stochasticity in the production and social acquisition of knowledge influences the evolution of learning strategies and cumulative knowledge. Using a mathematical model where learning is stochastic, we show that learning stochasticity enhances cumulative knowledge by generating variability in knowledge levels. This allows selection to enhance population knowledge: individuals who acquire more knowledge by chance are more likely to survive and reproduce, and therefore to transmit their knowledge to the next generation. As knowledge accumulates, social learning exemplars tend to possess more of it, favoring greater time investment in social learning. Because social learning provides access to substantially more knowledge when learning is stochastic, selection also favors the evolution of greater investment into learning, at the expense of a fecundity cost. Moreover, when knowledge enhances fecundity but not survival, learning stochasticity favors learning from parents rather than other adults, because learning stochasticity increases uncertainty about exemplar knowledge, making parenthood a cue for possessing fecundity-enhancing knowledge. Finally, when learning occurs predominantly from parents, learning stochasticity itself is favored by selection.
- 26 November 2025
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
- Vol. 292 (2059) , 20251711
How economic exchange can favour human genetic diversity
By allowing individuals to use goods they do not produce, economic exchange is recognized as driving the wide diversity of economic activities seen in human societies. Since productivity also depends on innate abilities, we ask whether economic exchange could have influenced human evolution and promoted adaptive genetic diversity. We model a system where individuals produce and exchange goods under a Walrasian equilibrium, with abilities determined by an evolving quantitative genetic trait. We then analyse how exchange shapes the evolutionary pressures on this trait. Our analysis demonstrates that exchange consistently promotes negative frequency-dependent selection, which favours the maintenance of genetic diversity. Exchange also generates stable long-term adaptive polymorphism when the production of goods requires different abilities. Importantly, we establish that the mode of exchange matters: markets, where individuals can switch trading partners, promote genetic diversity under broader conditions than when exchange occurs in isolated pairs. Finally, we show that genetic diversity and economic specialization can facilitate the emergence of the other under a wider range of conditions. Our findings suggest that economic exchanges play a crucial role in fostering biological diversity and offer insights into how a culturally determined mode of organization may have shaped human evolution.
- 26 November 2025
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
- Vol. 292 (2059) , 20251711
How economic exchange can favour human genetic diversity
By allowing individuals to use goods they do not produce, economic exchange is recognized as driving the wide diversity of economic activities seen in human societies. Since productivity also depends on innate abilities, we ask whether economic exchange could have influenced human evolution and promoted adaptive genetic diversity. We model a system where individuals produce and exchange goods under a Walrasian equilibrium, with abilities determined by an evolving quantitative genetic trait. We then analyse how exchange shapes the evolutionary pressures on this trait. Our analysis demonstrates that exchange consistently promotes negative frequency-dependent selection, which favours the maintenance of genetic diversity. Exchange also generates stable long-term adaptive polymorphism when the production of goods requires different abilities. Importantly, we establish that the mode of exchange matters: markets, where individuals can switch trading partners, promote genetic diversity under broader conditions than when exchange occurs in isolated pairs. Finally, we show that genetic diversity and economic specialization can facilitate the emergence of the other under a wider range of conditions. Our findings suggest that economic exchanges play a crucial role in fostering biological diversity and offer insights into how a culturally determined mode of organization may have shaped human evolution.
- 16 October 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Evolutionary Biology
- Vol. 38 (12) , 1690-1698
The genetical evolution of social preferences: where the categorical imperatives of Hamilton, Kant, and Nash meet
This paper models the genetical evolution of individual behaviour rules that guide the choice of strategies in pairwise assortative interactions under incomplete information. Building on results at the cross-roads of evolutionary theory and game theory, it is first shown that in an uninvadable population state of behaviour rule evolution, individuals are compelled to use strategies that are Nash equilibria of a lineage fitness game. Thus, choice behaviour evolves to be representable as the maximization of a utility function, as if each individual holds a personal rational preference. Second, the paper contrasts two representations of personal utility that are found to be uninvadable. The first is semi-Kantian in form. This preference averages a fitness self-interest with a Kantian interest, where the average involves the genetic relatedness between interacting individuals. The Kantian interest evaluates the consequence of own behaviour for own fitness, assuming the interaction partner adopts the same behaviour as self. The second preference is a personal inclusive fitness. This preference combines a self-regarding interest with a relatedness weighted other-regarding interest. Each of these interests takes the form of an average effect, which evaluates the consequence of expressing own behaviour, instead of average population behaviour, on a statistical average fitness to self and the interaction partner, respectively.
- 16 October 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Evolutionary Biology
- Vol. 38 (12) , 1690-1698
The genetical evolution of social preferences: where the categorical imperatives of Hamilton, Kant, and Nash meet
This paper models the genetical evolution of individual behaviour rules that guide the choice of strategies in pairwise assortative interactions under incomplete information. Building on results at the cross-roads of evolutionary theory and game theory, it is first shown that in an uninvadable population state of behaviour rule evolution, individuals are compelled to use strategies that are Nash equilibria of a lineage fitness game. Thus, choice behaviour evolves to be representable as the maximization of a utility function, as if each individual holds a personal rational preference. Second, the paper contrasts two representations of personal utility that are found to be uninvadable. The first is semi-Kantian in form. This preference averages a fitness self-interest with a Kantian interest, where the average involves the genetic relatedness between interacting individuals. The Kantian interest evaluates the consequence of own behaviour for own fitness, assuming the interaction partner adopts the same behaviour as self. The second preference is a personal inclusive fitness. This preference combines a self-regarding interest with a relatedness weighted other-regarding interest. Each of these interests takes the form of an average effect, which evaluates the consequence of expressing own behaviour, instead of average population behaviour, on a statistical average fitness to self and the interaction partner, respectively.
- Open Access
Evolution of quantitative traits: exploring the ecological, social and genetic bases of adaptive polymorphism
Adaptive polymorphisms in quantitative traits are characterised by the coexistence of distinct genetically encoded phenotypes maintained by selection. Such intraspecific genetic and phenotypic variation make a substantial contribution to biological diversity. Building on established results from invasion analysis, we analyse conditions under which adaptive polymorphism can emerge under long-term gradual evolution. We first note that, in general, fully characterising an adaptive polymorphism, including its number of morphs, trait values and frequencies, is a computationally hard problem. Nevertheless, standard invasion results reveal a unifying necessary condition for the gradual emergence of polymorphism: negative trait-dependent selection (NTDS), whereby the marginal fitness effect of increasing trait expression in a mutant depends negatively on the population-level trait expression, reflecting a negative interaction between mutant and population trait changes. We use NTDS as an organising principle to structure the pathways through which polymorphism can evolve. This is based on a decomposition of fitness that distinguishes production factors, the inputs to survival and reproduction that are endogenous to individuals, from regulating factors, the ecological, social or genetic inputs to fitness that are influenced in part by conspecifics. This decomposition allows us to clarify how NTDS arises across three broad classes of interactions: ecological, social and genetic; and to identify previously unrecognised adaptive polymorphisms in well-studied scenarios, including life-history, social preferences, and class-structured populations. More broadly, by integrating perspectives from population genetics, evolutionary ecology, adaptive dynamics, game theory and inclusive fitness theory, we aim to provide a common thread among the pathways through which selection favours intraspecific variation.
Open AccessEvolution of quantitative traits: exploring the ecological, social and genetic bases of adaptive polymorphism
Adaptive polymorphisms in quantitative traits are characterised by the coexistence of distinct genetically encoded phenotypes maintained by selection. Such intraspecific genetic and phenotypic variation make a substantial contribution to biological diversity. Building on established results from invasion analysis, we analyse conditions under which adaptive polymorphism can emerge under long-term gradual evolution. We first note that, in general, fully characterising an adaptive polymorphism, including its number of morphs, trait values and frequencies, is a computationally hard problem. Nevertheless, standard invasion results reveal a unifying necessary condition for the gradual emergence of polymorphism: negative trait-dependent selection (NTDS), whereby the marginal fitness effect of increasing trait expression in a mutant depends negatively on the population-level trait expression, reflecting a negative interaction between mutant and population trait changes. We use NTDS as an organising principle to structure the pathways through which polymorphism can evolve. This is based on a decomposition of fitness that distinguishes production factors, the inputs to survival and reproduction that are endogenous to individuals, from regulating factors, the ecological, social or genetic inputs to fitness that are influenced in part by conspecifics. This decomposition allows us to clarify how NTDS arises across three broad classes of interactions: ecological, social and genetic; and to identify previously unrecognised adaptive polymorphisms in well-studied scenarios, including life-history, social preferences, and class-structured populations. More broadly, by integrating perspectives from population genetics, evolutionary ecology, adaptive dynamics, game theory and inclusive fitness theory, we aim to provide a common thread among the pathways through which selection favours intraspecific variation.
- 12 February 2025
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
- Vol. 292 (2040) , 20242470
The coevolution of learning schedules and teaching enhances cumulative knowledge and drives a teacher–innovator syndrome
Natural selection shapes how individuals learn and acquire knowledge from their environment. Under the right conditions, this can lead to the evolution of learning schedules—how individuals allocate resources to acquire knowledge throughout their lifespan—that promote the accumulation of knowledge across generations (‘cumulative knowledge’ or ‘cumulative culture’). In spite of having been observed across multiple taxa, the role of parental teaching in this evolutionary process remains understudied. Using mathematical modelling, we show that learning schedules and parental teaching coevolve, resulting in greater time spent learning individually and innovating, as well as greater intergenerational transfer of knowledge from parent to offspring. These outcomes together enhance cumulative knowledge. Our analyses further reveal that within populations, selection typically favours an association between teaching and individual learning whereby some individuals innovate and teach within the family (‘knowledge producers’ with extensive knowledge), while others teach less and learn socially outside of the family (‘knowledge scroungers’ with less knowledge). Overall, our findings indicate that the coevolution of learning schedules and teaching promotes knowledge accumulation within and between generations and favours diversity within and between populations in knowledge acquisition, possession and transmission.
- 12 February 2025
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
- Vol. 292 (2040) , 20242470
The coevolution of learning schedules and teaching enhances cumulative knowledge and drives a teacher–innovator syndrome
Natural selection shapes how individuals learn and acquire knowledge from their environment. Under the right conditions, this can lead to the evolution of learning schedules—how individuals allocate resources to acquire knowledge throughout their lifespan—that promote the accumulation of knowledge across generations (‘cumulative knowledge’ or ‘cumulative culture’). In spite of having been observed across multiple taxa, the role of parental teaching in this evolutionary process remains understudied. Using mathematical modelling, we show that learning schedules and parental teaching coevolve, resulting in greater time spent learning individually and innovating, as well as greater intergenerational transfer of knowledge from parent to offspring. These outcomes together enhance cumulative knowledge. Our analyses further reveal that within populations, selection typically favours an association between teaching and individual learning whereby some individuals innovate and teach within the family (‘knowledge producers’ with extensive knowledge), while others teach less and learn socially outside of the family (‘knowledge scroungers’ with less knowledge). Overall, our findings indicate that the coevolution of learning schedules and teaching promotes knowledge accumulation within and between generations and favours diversity within and between populations in knowledge acquisition, possession and transmission.
- Open Access
- 8 November 2024
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 121 (46)
Central place foragers, prey depletion halos, and how behavioral niche partitioning promotes consumer coexistence
Many seabirds congregate in large colonies for breeding, a time when they are central place foragers. An influential idea in seabird ecology posits that competition during breeding results in an area of reduced prey availability around colonies, a phenomenon known as Ashmole’s halo, and that this limits colony size. This idea has gained empirical support, including the finding that species coexisting within a colony might be able to do so by foraging on a single prey species but at different distances. Here, we provide a comprehensive mathematical model for central place foragers exploiting a single prey in a two-dimensional environment, where the prey distribution is the result of intrinsic birth and death, movement in space, and mortality due to foraging birds (we also consider a variant tailored toward colonial social insects). Bird predation at different distances occurs according to an ideal free foraging distribution that maximizes prey delivery under flight and search costs. We fully characterize the birds’ ideal free distribution and the prey distribution it generates. Our results show that prey depletion halos around breeding colonies are a robust phenomenon and that the birds’ ideal free distribution is sensitive to prey movement. Furthermore, coexistence of several seabird species on a single prey easily emerges through behavioral niche partitioning whenever trait differences between species entail trade-offs between efficiently exploiting a scarce prey close to the colony and a more abundant prey far away. Such behavioral-based coexistence-inducing mechanism should generalize to other habitat and diet choice scenarios.
- 8 November 2024
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 121 (46)
Open AccessCentral place foragers, prey depletion halos, and how behavioral niche partitioning promotes consumer coexistence
Many seabirds congregate in large colonies for breeding, a time when they are central place foragers. An influential idea in seabird ecology posits that competition during breeding results in an area of reduced prey availability around colonies, a phenomenon known as Ashmole’s halo, and that this limits colony size. This idea has gained empirical support, including the finding that species coexisting within a colony might be able to do so by foraging on a single prey species but at different distances. Here, we provide a comprehensive mathematical model for central place foragers exploiting a single prey in a two-dimensional environment, where the prey distribution is the result of intrinsic birth and death, movement in space, and mortality due to foraging birds (we also consider a variant tailored toward colonial social insects). Bird predation at different distances occurs according to an ideal free foraging distribution that maximizes prey delivery under flight and search costs. We fully characterize the birds’ ideal free distribution and the prey distribution it generates. Our results show that prey depletion halos around breeding colonies are a robust phenomenon and that the birds’ ideal free distribution is sensitive to prey movement. Furthermore, coexistence of several seabird species on a single prey easily emerges through behavioral niche partitioning whenever trait differences between species entail trade-offs between efficiently exploiting a scarce prey close to the colony and a more abundant prey far away. Such behavioral-based coexistence-inducing mechanism should generalize to other habitat and diet choice scenarios.
- Open Access
Central place foragers, prey depletion halos, and how behavioral niche partitioning promotes consumer coexistence
Many seabirds congregate in large colonies for breeding, a time when they are central place foragers. An influential idea in seabird ecology posits that competition during breeding results in an area of reduced prey availability around colonies, a phenomenon known as Ashmole’s halo, and that this limits colony size. This idea has gained empirical support, including the finding that species coexisting within a colony might be able to do so by foraging on a single prey species but at different distances. Here, we provide a comprehensive mathematical model for central place foragers exploiting a single prey in a two-dimensional environment, where the prey distribution is the result of intrinsic birth and death, movement in space and mortality due to foraging birds (we also consider a variant tailored toward colonial social insects). Prey mortality is the result of bird predation at different distances according to an ideal free distribution that maximizes prey delivery under flight and search costs. We fully characterize the birds’ ideal free distribution and the concomitant prey distribution. Our results show that prey depletion halos around breeding colonies are a robust phenomenon and that the birds’ ideal free distribution is sensitive to prey movement. Furthermore, coexistence of several seabird species on a single prey easily emerges through behavioral niche partitioning whenever trait differences between species entail trade-offs between efficiently exploiting a scarce prey close to the colony and a more abundant prey far away. Such behavioral-based coexistence-inducing mechanisms should generalize to other habitat and diet choice scenarios. Significance statement Large numbers of seabirds, often belonging to different species, breed on small islands and forage in the surrounding sea to provision their offspring. Due to travel costs, these birds are restricted to a limited area around their colony. Using mathematical modelling, we show that such central place foragers produce a zone of prey depletion around islands. In agreement with empirical observations, our model furthermore shows that different bird species can coexist, despite feeding on the same prey species, due to behavioral segregation into different circular zones around the island. Behavioral segregation emerges when individuals chose foraging distances so as to maximize their prey delivery rate and when different species experience different costs while flying to and foraging at different distances.
Open AccessCentral place foragers, prey depletion halos, and how behavioral niche partitioning promotes consumer coexistence
Many seabirds congregate in large colonies for breeding, a time when they are central place foragers. An influential idea in seabird ecology posits that competition during breeding results in an area of reduced prey availability around colonies, a phenomenon known as Ashmole’s halo, and that this limits colony size. This idea has gained empirical support, including the finding that species coexisting within a colony might be able to do so by foraging on a single prey species but at different distances. Here, we provide a comprehensive mathematical model for central place foragers exploiting a single prey in a two-dimensional environment, where the prey distribution is the result of intrinsic birth and death, movement in space and mortality due to foraging birds (we also consider a variant tailored toward colonial social insects). Prey mortality is the result of bird predation at different distances according to an ideal free distribution that maximizes prey delivery under flight and search costs. We fully characterize the birds’ ideal free distribution and the concomitant prey distribution. Our results show that prey depletion halos around breeding colonies are a robust phenomenon and that the birds’ ideal free distribution is sensitive to prey movement. Furthermore, coexistence of several seabird species on a single prey easily emerges through behavioral niche partitioning whenever trait differences between species entail trade-offs between efficiently exploiting a scarce prey close to the colony and a more abundant prey far away. Such behavioral-based coexistence-inducing mechanisms should generalize to other habitat and diet choice scenarios. Significance statement Large numbers of seabirds, often belonging to different species, breed on small islands and forage in the surrounding sea to provision their offspring. Due to travel costs, these birds are restricted to a limited area around their colony. Using mathematical modelling, we show that such central place foragers produce a zone of prey depletion around islands. In agreement with empirical observations, our model furthermore shows that different bird species can coexist, despite feeding on the same prey species, due to behavioral segregation into different circular zones around the island. Behavioral segregation emerges when individuals chose foraging distances so as to maximize their prey delivery rate and when different species experience different costs while flying to and foraging at different distances.
- Open Access
Evolution of semi-Kantian preferences in two-player assortative interactions with complete and incomplete information and plasticity
We model the evolution of preferences guiding behavior in pairwise interactions in group-structured populations. The model uses long-term evolution theory to examine different interaction scenarios, including conditional preference expression upon recognition of the partner's type. We apply the model to the evolution of semi-Kantian preferences at the fitness level, which combine self-interest and a Kantian interest evaluating own behavior in terms of consequences for own fitness if the partner also adopted this behavior. We seek the convergence stable and uninvadable value of the Kantian coefficient, i.e., the weight attached to the Kantian interest, a quantitative trait varying between zero and one. We consider three scenarios: (a) incomplete information; (b) complete information and incomplete plasticity; and (c) complete information and complete plasticity, where individuals not only recognize the type of their interaction partner (complete information), but also conditionally express the Kantian coefficient upon it (complete plasticity). For (a), the Kantian coefficient generally evolves to equal the coefficient of neutral relatedness between interacting individuals; for (b), it evolves to a value that depends on demographic and interaction assumptions, while for (c) there are generally multiple uninvadable types, including the type whereby an individual is a pure Kantian when interacting with individuals of the same type and applies the Kantian coefficient that is uninvadable under complete information with zero relatedness when interacting with a different typed individual. Overall, our model connects several concepts for analysing the evolution of behavior rules for strategic interactions that have been emphasized in different and sometimes isolated literatures.
Open AccessEvolution of semi-Kantian preferences in two-player assortative interactions with complete and incomplete information and plasticity
We model the evolution of preferences guiding behavior in pairwise interactions in group-structured populations. The model uses long-term evolution theory to examine different interaction scenarios, including conditional preference expression upon recognition of the partner's type. We apply the model to the evolution of semi-Kantian preferences at the fitness level, which combine self-interest and a Kantian interest evaluating own behavior in terms of consequences for own fitness if the partner also adopted this behavior. We seek the convergence stable and uninvadable value of the Kantian coefficient, i.e., the weight attached to the Kantian interest, a quantitative trait varying between zero and one. We consider three scenarios: (a) incomplete information; (b) complete information and incomplete plasticity; and (c) complete information and complete plasticity, where individuals not only recognize the type of their interaction partner (complete information), but also conditionally express the Kantian coefficient upon it (complete plasticity). For (a), the Kantian coefficient generally evolves to equal the coefficient of neutral relatedness between interacting individuals; for (b), it evolves to a value that depends on demographic and interaction assumptions, while for (c) there are generally multiple uninvadable types, including the type whereby an individual is a pure Kantian when interacting with individuals of the same type and applies the Kantian coefficient that is uninvadable under complete information with zero relatedness when interacting with a different typed individual. Overall, our model connects several concepts for analysing the evolution of behavior rules for strategic interactions that have been emphasized in different and sometimes isolated literatures.