Harrington Wells
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Harrington Wells has a total of 61 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Charles Ira Abramson
Laboratory of Comparative Psychology and Behavioral Biology, Department of Psychology, Oklahoma State University, Stillwater, OK 74078, USA
9 shared publications - Marisol Amaya-Márquez
Universidad Nacional de Colombia–Sede Bogotá, Facultad de Ciencias, Instituto de Ciencias Naturales, Bogotá, Colombia
4 shared publications - Tugrul Giray
Department of Biology, University of Puerto Rico, Rio Piedras, Puerto Rico
3 shared publications - Ibrahim Çakmak
Beekeeping Development, Application and Research Center, Bursa, Turkiye; Department of Animal Science, Faculty of Agriculture, Bursa Uludağ University, Bursa, Turkiye
2 shared publications John F. Barthell
University of Central Oklahoma
2 shared publications- Juan Carlos Hernández
Instituto de Ciencias Naturales, Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Bogotá 111321, Colombia
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 25 August 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Conservation
- Vol. 6 (3) , 104
Southern Great Plains River Ecology: A Story of Anthropogenic Ecological Change
The unique climate and rivers of the Southern Great Plains of the United States have shaped both ecological and human communities. Historically, the rivers of this region supported a wide variety of endemic species evolutionarily adapted to the particularly harsh environment, characterized by flow variability, periodic flooding and drying, and overall complexity. In this review, we provide an extensive overview of the many perils that the rivers of the Southern Great Plains are now facing due to the anthropogenic changes centered on river dam construction, high agricultural water demand, and groundwater depletion. These factors have fundamentally reshaped the flow regime of the Southern Great Plains rivers, resulting in a decline of native fish assemblages and increases in invasive species as a consequence of modified sediment transport, decrease in microhabitat diversity, changes in channel morphology, and an increase in habitat fragmentation. The case that we describe in the present article represents a prototypical example of the ecological consequences of human-induced alterations of river ecosystems. Here, we present this case as an example of damming-induced alteration of the riverine ecosystem, and we propose possible conservation measures to restore the original riverine environment and protect the currently threatened native fish diversity.
- 25 August 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Conservation
- Vol. 6 (3) , 104
Open AccessSouthern Great Plains River Ecology: A Story of Anthropogenic Ecological Change
The unique climate and rivers of the Southern Great Plains of the United States have shaped both ecological and human communities. Historically, the rivers of this region supported a wide variety of endemic species evolutionarily adapted to the particularly harsh environment, characterized by flow variability, periodic flooding and drying, and overall complexity. In this review, we provide an extensive overview of the many perils that the rivers of the Southern Great Plains are now facing due to the anthropogenic changes centered on river dam construction, high agricultural water demand, and groundwater depletion. These factors have fundamentally reshaped the flow regime of the Southern Great Plains rivers, resulting in a decline of native fish assemblages and increases in invasive species as a consequence of modified sediment transport, decrease in microhabitat diversity, changes in channel morphology, and an increase in habitat fragmentation. The case that we describe in the present article represents a prototypical example of the ecological consequences of human-induced alterations of river ecosystems. Here, we present this case as an example of damming-induced alteration of the riverine ecosystem, and we propose possible conservation measures to restore the original riverine environment and protect the currently threatened native fish diversity.
- Open Access
The Effects of Silver and Potassium Iodide on Honey Bee (Apis mellifera) Learning
Silver iodide (AgI) and potassium iodide (KI), which are used in cloud seeding, were administered to bees in a variety of pretreatments (low or high dosing) and analyzed through a series of experiments to determine the effect on bees’ ability to learn. Cloud seeding is the process of dispersing chemicals into an already-formed cloud to attract water molecules that fall to Earth as rain or snow. These chemicals then enter the ecosystem through water and soil. Honey bees were used because they represent a robust and ecologically appropriate model organism to study the behavioral impacts of cloud seeding. The first experiment utilized a shuttle box to test whether honey bees could avoid shock in a punishment experiment. Results revealed that the majority of the pretreatments did inhibit bees’ ability to learn to avoid shock. Experiment 2 consists of two proboscis extension reflex experiments (PER) where bees are trained to associate an odor with a sucrose feeding. Using the PER paradigm, we investigated simple conditioning and odor discrimination. Results revealed that in both the simple conditioning and discrimination experiments, learning was inhibited by the pretreatment of chemicals regardless of dosing amount. The final experiment explored reward discrimination in a free-flying flower patch paradigm. Results revealed that learning ability was not affected; however, return times were greatly impacted. Overall, results showed that AgI and KI throughout each experiment (i.e., shuttle box, PER, and free-flying discrimination) had some degree of negative effect on honey bee behavior.
Open AccessThe Effects of Silver and Potassium Iodide on Honey Bee (Apis mellifera) Learning
Silver iodide (AgI) and potassium iodide (KI), which are used in cloud seeding, were administered to bees in a variety of pretreatments (low or high dosing) and analyzed through a series of experiments to determine the effect on bees’ ability to learn. Cloud seeding is the process of dispersing chemicals into an already-formed cloud to attract water molecules that fall to Earth as rain or snow. These chemicals then enter the ecosystem through water and soil. Honey bees were used because they represent a robust and ecologically appropriate model organism to study the behavioral impacts of cloud seeding. The first experiment utilized a shuttle box to test whether honey bees could avoid shock in a punishment experiment. Results revealed that the majority of the pretreatments did inhibit bees’ ability to learn to avoid shock. Experiment 2 consists of two proboscis extension reflex experiments (PER) where bees are trained to associate an odor with a sucrose feeding. Using the PER paradigm, we investigated simple conditioning and odor discrimination. Results revealed that in both the simple conditioning and discrimination experiments, learning was inhibited by the pretreatment of chemicals regardless of dosing amount. The final experiment explored reward discrimination in a free-flying flower patch paradigm. Results revealed that learning ability was not affected; however, return times were greatly impacted. Overall, results showed that AgI and KI throughout each experiment (i.e., shuttle box, PER, and free-flying discrimination) had some degree of negative effect on honey bee behavior.
- Open Access
Honey Bee Foraging Decisions Are Shaped by Floral Trait Distinctiveness and Perception of Gains or Losses
The floral choices of honey bees (Apis mellifera) were studied using artificial flower patches to understand how foragers manage changing floral landscapes. Bees were observed under conditions where reward quality changed over time in blue and white flowers. We evaluated initial learning and reversal learning, varying the magnitude of reward quality-difference and color distinctness in the honey bee’s color vision space (being either similar or more distinct). Flower color fidelity was higher when flower colors were more distinct, but it also made it more difficult for bees to abandon the flower color in the reversal learning phase. Smaller differences in reward quality reduced flower color fidelity and promoted reversal learning. When reward difference between flower colors was created (initial learning), a decrease in one of the flower color rewards elicited a stronger behavioral response from foragers than an increase in reward. Our work highlights that bees used and integrated information from different axes of information: distinctiveness of color cues, magnitude of reward difference, and directionality (being stronger for losses than gains). Thus, flower distinctiveness, opportunity cost, and loss aversion drive honey bee foraging decisions. Higher accuracy at initial learning has stronger costs in behavioral adaptations at changing floral landscapes.
Open AccessHoney Bee Foraging Decisions Are Shaped by Floral Trait Distinctiveness and Perception of Gains or Losses
The floral choices of honey bees (Apis mellifera) were studied using artificial flower patches to understand how foragers manage changing floral landscapes. Bees were observed under conditions where reward quality changed over time in blue and white flowers. We evaluated initial learning and reversal learning, varying the magnitude of reward quality-difference and color distinctness in the honey bee’s color vision space (being either similar or more distinct). Flower color fidelity was higher when flower colors were more distinct, but it also made it more difficult for bees to abandon the flower color in the reversal learning phase. Smaller differences in reward quality reduced flower color fidelity and promoted reversal learning. When reward difference between flower colors was created (initial learning), a decrease in one of the flower color rewards elicited a stronger behavioral response from foragers than an increase in reward. Our work highlights that bees used and integrated information from different axes of information: distinctiveness of color cues, magnitude of reward difference, and directionality (being stronger for losses than gains). Thus, flower distinctiveness, opportunity cost, and loss aversion drive honey bee foraging decisions. Higher accuracy at initial learning has stronger costs in behavioral adaptations at changing floral landscapes.
- Open Access
The Essential Oil Component Terpinyl Acetate Alters Honey Bee Energy Levels and Foraging Behavior
Essential oils have been utilized in the health, learning/memory, and agricultural fields, but not much is known about the biological activity of their individual components. Terpinyl acetate is a p-menthane monoterpenoid commonly found in cardamom, pine, cajeput, pine needle, and other essential oils. Using a cell culture model system, we found that terpinyl acetate is a potent and specific inhibitor of mitochondrial ATP production, suggesting it might function as a plant toxin. Remarkably, however, terpinyl acetate was not cytotoxic because cells switched to glycolysis to maintain ATP levels. Based on these findings, we hypothesized that terpinyl acetate might be employed to benefit plant survival by modulating metabolism/behavior of plant pollinators such as the honey bee. This hypothesis was tested by investigating terpinyl acetate’s effect on honey bee foraging. Free-flying honey bee flower color choice was recorded when visiting a blue-white dimorphic artificial flower patch of 36 flowers. The nectar–reward difference between flower colors was varied in a manner in which both learning and reversal learning could be measured. Terpinyl acetate ingestion disrupted reversal learning but not initial learning: this change caused bees to remain faithful to a flower color longer than was energetically optimal.
Open AccessThe Essential Oil Component Terpinyl Acetate Alters Honey Bee Energy Levels and Foraging Behavior
Essential oils have been utilized in the health, learning/memory, and agricultural fields, but not much is known about the biological activity of their individual components. Terpinyl acetate is a p-menthane monoterpenoid commonly found in cardamom, pine, cajeput, pine needle, and other essential oils. Using a cell culture model system, we found that terpinyl acetate is a potent and specific inhibitor of mitochondrial ATP production, suggesting it might function as a plant toxin. Remarkably, however, terpinyl acetate was not cytotoxic because cells switched to glycolysis to maintain ATP levels. Based on these findings, we hypothesized that terpinyl acetate might be employed to benefit plant survival by modulating metabolism/behavior of plant pollinators such as the honey bee. This hypothesis was tested by investigating terpinyl acetate’s effect on honey bee foraging. Free-flying honey bee flower color choice was recorded when visiting a blue-white dimorphic artificial flower patch of 36 flowers. The nectar–reward difference between flower colors was varied in a manner in which both learning and reversal learning could be measured. Terpinyl acetate ingestion disrupted reversal learning but not initial learning: this change caused bees to remain faithful to a flower color longer than was energetically optimal.
- 21 May 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Comparative Physiology A
- Vol. 211 (4) , 483-504
Physiological and behavioral pharmacology of ethanol in honey bees
Ethanol has been consumed by humans since the dawn of civilization and, over the course of millennia, a wide variety of ethanol-rich drinks have been produced across cultures. Traditionally, it was believed that only humans voluntarily consume ethanol and become inebriated by it. However, a growing amount of evidence is showing that several non-human animal species spontaneously consume ethanol in nature. Among these, there is the honey bee (Apis mellifera), which can find ethanol in decaying fruits and in the fermented nectar of flowers. Importantly, honey bees represent a useful animal model of ethanol consumption as, like humans, they voluntarily consume ethanol, they show acute dose-dependent motor and postural signs of inebriation, they display ethanol-induced disruption of cognitive functions and social behavior, and they develop ethanol dependence. Moreover, they are small, easy to acquire and easy to maintain in the laboratory. Finally, we possess a vast database of information on their natural history, physiology, genetics and behavior, with their ethogram comprising a wide variety of basic to complex behaviors, including the capacity to self-administer large quantities of ethanol. The present article reviews what is currently known about the physiological and behavioral pharmacology of ethanol in honey bees. The topics covered include the effect of ethanol on gene expression, epigenetic changes of DNA, neuronal stress, posture, locomotion, learning (comprising classical and operant conditioning), communication, social feeding (trophallaxis), aggression and foraging-related decision-making in honey bees.
- 21 May 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Comparative Physiology A
- Vol. 211 (4) , 483-504
Physiological and behavioral pharmacology of ethanol in honey bees
Ethanol has been consumed by humans since the dawn of civilization and, over the course of millennia, a wide variety of ethanol-rich drinks have been produced across cultures. Traditionally, it was believed that only humans voluntarily consume ethanol and become inebriated by it. However, a growing amount of evidence is showing that several non-human animal species spontaneously consume ethanol in nature. Among these, there is the honey bee (Apis mellifera), which can find ethanol in decaying fruits and in the fermented nectar of flowers. Importantly, honey bees represent a useful animal model of ethanol consumption as, like humans, they voluntarily consume ethanol, they show acute dose-dependent motor and postural signs of inebriation, they display ethanol-induced disruption of cognitive functions and social behavior, and they develop ethanol dependence. Moreover, they are small, easy to acquire and easy to maintain in the laboratory. Finally, we possess a vast database of information on their natural history, physiology, genetics and behavior, with their ethogram comprising a wide variety of basic to complex behaviors, including the capacity to self-administer large quantities of ethanol. The present article reviews what is currently known about the physiological and behavioral pharmacology of ethanol in honey bees. The topics covered include the effect of ethanol on gene expression, epigenetic changes of DNA, neuronal stress, posture, locomotion, learning (comprising classical and operant conditioning), communication, social feeding (trophallaxis), aggression and foraging-related decision-making in honey bees.
- Open Access
- 22 March 2021
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in International Journal of Comparative Psychology
- Vol. 34
Inducing Ethanol Tolerance in Free-Flying Honey Bees (Apis mellifera L.)
Ethanol dependency affects the health of more than 15 million adults in the United States of America. Honey bees have been used as a model for ethanol studies because of similarities in neural structure to vertebrates and their complex social behaviors. This study compares honey bee free-flight visitation to a food source after exposure to ethanol in aqueous sucrose. Individual bees were followed making 6 attachment visits to a test-station containing 1M sucrose. After attachment, honey bees were randomly assigned to one of five groups: 0%, 2.5%, 5%, 10% EtOH, or a staged increase in ethanol concentrations (2.5%, 5%, 10%). The results indicate that honey bees tolerate up to 2.5% EtOH without avoidance or altered behavior, and up to 5% EtOH without avoidance but with slower trips. At 10% ethanol, attrition was 75% by the 18th return trip. In the staged increase in concentration, bees were more likely to return than bees that were offered 10% ethanol in sucrose solution after attachment. The results of this study imply that ethanol induced tolerance to the effects of ethanol can be achieved in honey bees through incremental increase in EtOH but only in terms of attrition. Other measures of foraging efficiency did not show ethanol induced tolerance. Understanding how ethanol tolerance develops in bees may provide insight into these processes in humans with minimized ethical considerations.
- 22 March 2021
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in International Journal of Comparative Psychology
- Vol. 34
Open AccessInducing Ethanol Tolerance in Free-Flying Honey Bees (Apis mellifera L.)
Ethanol dependency affects the health of more than 15 million adults in the United States of America. Honey bees have been used as a model for ethanol studies because of similarities in neural structure to vertebrates and their complex social behaviors. This study compares honey bee free-flight visitation to a food source after exposure to ethanol in aqueous sucrose. Individual bees were followed making 6 attachment visits to a test-station containing 1M sucrose. After attachment, honey bees were randomly assigned to one of five groups: 0%, 2.5%, 5%, 10% EtOH, or a staged increase in ethanol concentrations (2.5%, 5%, 10%). The results indicate that honey bees tolerate up to 2.5% EtOH without avoidance or altered behavior, and up to 5% EtOH without avoidance but with slower trips. At 10% ethanol, attrition was 75% by the 18th return trip. In the staged increase in concentration, bees were more likely to return than bees that were offered 10% ethanol in sucrose solution after attachment. The results of this study imply that ethanol induced tolerance to the effects of ethanol can be achieved in honey bees through incremental increase in EtOH but only in terms of attrition. Other measures of foraging efficiency did not show ethanol induced tolerance. Understanding how ethanol tolerance develops in bees may provide insight into these processes in humans with minimized ethical considerations.
- Open Access
High Prevalence of Three Potyviruses Infecting Cucurbits in Oklahoma and Phylogenetic Analysis of Cucurbit Aphid-Borne Yellows Virus Isolated from Pumpkins
Field information about viruses infecting crops is fundamental for understanding the severity of the effects they cause in plants. To determine the status of cucurbit viruses, surveys were conducted for three consecutive years (2016–2018) in different agricultural districts of Oklahoma. A total of 1331 leaf samples from >90 fields were randomly collected from both symptomatic and asymptomatic cucurbit plants across 11 counties. All samples were tested with the dot-immunobinding assay (DIBA) against the antisera of 10 known viruses. Samples infected with papaya ringspot virus (PRSV-W), watermelon mosaic virus (WMV), zucchini yellow mosaic virus (ZYMV), and cucurbit aphid-borne-yellows virus (CABYV) were also tested by RT-PCR. Of the 10 viruses, PRSV-W was the most widespread, with an overall prevalence of 59.1%, present in all 11 counties, followed by ZYMV (27.6%), in 10 counties, and WMV (20.7%), in seven counties, while the remaining viruses were present sporadically with low incidence. Approximately 42% of the infected samples were positive, with more than one virus indicating a high proportion of mixed infections. CABYV was detected for the first time in Oklahoma, and the phylogenetic analysis of the first complete genome sequence of a CABYV isolate (BL-4) from the US showed a close relationship with Asian isolates.
Open AccessHigh Prevalence of Three Potyviruses Infecting Cucurbits in Oklahoma and Phylogenetic Analysis of Cucurbit Aphid-Borne Yellows Virus Isolated from Pumpkins
Field information about viruses infecting crops is fundamental for understanding the severity of the effects they cause in plants. To determine the status of cucurbit viruses, surveys were conducted for three consecutive years (2016–2018) in different agricultural districts of Oklahoma. A total of 1331 leaf samples from >90 fields were randomly collected from both symptomatic and asymptomatic cucurbit plants across 11 counties. All samples were tested with the dot-immunobinding assay (DIBA) against the antisera of 10 known viruses. Samples infected with papaya ringspot virus (PRSV-W), watermelon mosaic virus (WMV), zucchini yellow mosaic virus (ZYMV), and cucurbit aphid-borne-yellows virus (CABYV) were also tested by RT-PCR. Of the 10 viruses, PRSV-W was the most widespread, with an overall prevalence of 59.1%, present in all 11 counties, followed by ZYMV (27.6%), in 10 counties, and WMV (20.7%), in seven counties, while the remaining viruses were present sporadically with low incidence. Approximately 42% of the infected samples were positive, with more than one virus indicating a high proportion of mixed infections. CABYV was detected for the first time in Oklahoma, and the phylogenetic analysis of the first complete genome sequence of a CABYV isolate (BL-4) from the US showed a close relationship with Asian isolates.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2020
- Published by International Society of Comparative Psychology in International Journal of Comparative Psychology
- Vol. 33
Do Honey Bees (Apis mellifera) Form Cognitive Representations of Unconditioned Stimuli?
Previous research looking at expectancy in animals has used various experimental designs focusing on appetitive and avoidance behaviors. In this study, honey bees (Apis mellifera) were tested ina series of three proboscis extension response (PER) experiments to determine to what degree honey bees’ form a cognitive-representation of an unconditioned stimulus (US). Tthe first experiment, bees were presented with either a 2 sec. sucrose US or 2 sec. honey US appetitive reward and the proboscis-extension duration was measured under each scenario. The PER duration was longer for the honey US even though each US was presented for just 2 sec. Honey bees in the second experiment were tested during extinction trials on a conditioned stimulus (CS) of cinnamon or lavender that was paired with either the sucrose US or honey US in the acquisition trials. The proportion of bees showing the PER response to the CS was recorded for each extinction trial for each US scenario, as was the duration of the proboscis extension for each bee. Neither measure differed between the honey US and sucrose US scenarios, In experiment three, bees were presented with a cinnamon or lavender CS paired with either honey US or sucrose US in a set of acquisition trials, but here the US was not given until after the proboscis was retracted. The PER duration after the CS, and again subsequent after the US, were recorded. While the PER duration after the US was longer for honey, the PER duration after the CS did not differ between honey US and sucrose US.
- 1 January 2020
- Published by International Society of Comparative Psychology in International Journal of Comparative Psychology
- Vol. 33
Open AccessDo Honey Bees (Apis mellifera) Form Cognitive Representations of Unconditioned Stimuli?
Previous research looking at expectancy in animals has used various experimental designs focusing on appetitive and avoidance behaviors. In this study, honey bees (Apis mellifera) were tested ina series of three proboscis extension response (PER) experiments to determine to what degree honey bees’ form a cognitive-representation of an unconditioned stimulus (US). Tthe first experiment, bees were presented with either a 2 sec. sucrose US or 2 sec. honey US appetitive reward and the proboscis-extension duration was measured under each scenario. The PER duration was longer for the honey US even though each US was presented for just 2 sec. Honey bees in the second experiment were tested during extinction trials on a conditioned stimulus (CS) of cinnamon or lavender that was paired with either the sucrose US or honey US in the acquisition trials. The proportion of bees showing the PER response to the CS was recorded for each extinction trial for each US scenario, as was the duration of the proboscis extension for each bee. Neither measure differed between the honey US and sucrose US scenarios, In experiment three, bees were presented with a cinnamon or lavender CS paired with either honey US or sucrose US in a set of acquisition trials, but here the US was not given until after the proboscis was retracted. The PER duration after the CS, and again subsequent after the US, were recorded. While the PER duration after the US was longer for honey, the PER duration after the CS did not differ between honey US and sucrose US.
- Open Access
Olfactory Learning in the Stingless Bee Melipona eburnea Friese (Apidae: Meliponini)
Olfactory learning and floral scents are co-adaptive traits in the plant–pollinator relationship. However, how scent relates to cognition and learning in the diverse group of Neotropical stingless bees is largely unknown. Here we evaluated the ability of Melipona eburnea to be conditioned to scent using the proboscis extension reflex (PER) protocol. Stingless bees did not show PER while harnessed but were able to be PER conditioned to scent when free-to-move in a mini-cage (fmPER). We evaluated the effect of: 1) unconditioned stimulus (US) reward, and 2) previous scent–reward associations on olfactory learning performance. When using unscented-US, PER-responses were low on day 1, but using scented-US reward the olfactory PER-response increased on day 1. On day 2 PER performance greatly increased in bees that previously had experienced the same odor and reward combination, while bees that experienced a different odor on day 2 showed poor olfactory learning. Bees showed higher olfactory PER conditioning to guava than to mango odor. The effect of the unconditioned stimulus reward was not a significant factor in the model on day 2. This indicates that olfactory learning performance can increase via either taste receptors or accumulated experience with the same odor. Our results have application in agriculture and pollination ecology.
Open AccessOlfactory Learning in the Stingless Bee Melipona eburnea Friese (Apidae: Meliponini)
Olfactory learning and floral scents are co-adaptive traits in the plant–pollinator relationship. However, how scent relates to cognition and learning in the diverse group of Neotropical stingless bees is largely unknown. Here we evaluated the ability of Melipona eburnea to be conditioned to scent using the proboscis extension reflex (PER) protocol. Stingless bees did not show PER while harnessed but were able to be PER conditioned to scent when free-to-move in a mini-cage (fmPER). We evaluated the effect of: 1) unconditioned stimulus (US) reward, and 2) previous scent–reward associations on olfactory learning performance. When using unscented-US, PER-responses were low on day 1, but using scented-US reward the olfactory PER-response increased on day 1. On day 2 PER performance greatly increased in bees that previously had experienced the same odor and reward combination, while bees that experienced a different odor on day 2 showed poor olfactory learning. Bees showed higher olfactory PER conditioning to guava than to mango odor. The effect of the unconditioned stimulus reward was not a significant factor in the model on day 2. This indicates that olfactory learning performance can increase via either taste receptors or accumulated experience with the same odor. Our results have application in agriculture and pollination ecology.
- Open Access
- 11 October 2018
- Published by PeerJ in PeerJ Preprints
Appetitive reversal learning differences of two honey bee subspecies with different foraging behaviors
We aimed to examine mechanistically the observed foraging differences across two honey bee, Apis mellifera, subspecies using the Proboscis Extension Response (PER) assay. Specifically, we compared differences in appetitive reversal learning ability between honey bee subspecies:Apis mellifera caucasica(Pollman), andApis mellifera syriaca(Skorikov) in a “common garden” apiary. It was hypothesized that specific learning differences could explain previously observed foraging behavior differences of these subspecies: A.m. caucasica switches between different flower color morphs in response to reward variability, and A.m. syriaca does not switch. We suggest that flower constancy allows reduced exposure by minimizing search and handling time, whereas plasticity is important when maximizing harvest in preparation for long winter is at a premium. In the initial or Acquisition phase of the test we examined specifically discrimination learning, where bees were trained to respond to a paired conditioned stimulus with an unconditioned stimulus and not to respond to a second conditioned stimulus that is not followed by an unconditioned stimulus. We found no significant differences among the subspecies in the Acquisition phase in appetitive learning. During the second, Reversal phase of the experiment, where flexibility in association was tested, the paired and unpaired conditioned stimuli were reversed. During the Reversal phaseA. mellifera syriacashowed a reduced ability to learn the reverse association in the appetitive learning task. This observation is consistent with the hypothesis that A.m. syriaca foragers cannot change the foraging choice because of lack of flexibility in appetitive associations under changing contingencies. Interestingly, both subspecies continued responding to the previously rewarded conditioned stimulus in the reversal phase. We discuss potential ecological correlates and molecular underpinnings of these differences in learning across the two subspecies. In addition, in a supplemental experiment we demonstrated that these differences in appetitive reversal learning do not occur in other learning contexts.
- 11 October 2018
- Published by PeerJ in PeerJ Preprints
Open AccessAppetitive reversal learning differences of two honey bee subspecies with different foraging behaviors
We aimed to examine mechanistically the observed foraging differences across two honey bee, Apis mellifera, subspecies using the Proboscis Extension Response (PER) assay. Specifically, we compared differences in appetitive reversal learning ability between honey bee subspecies:Apis mellifera caucasica(Pollman), andApis mellifera syriaca(Skorikov) in a “common garden” apiary. It was hypothesized that specific learning differences could explain previously observed foraging behavior differences of these subspecies: A.m. caucasica switches between different flower color morphs in response to reward variability, and A.m. syriaca does not switch. We suggest that flower constancy allows reduced exposure by minimizing search and handling time, whereas plasticity is important when maximizing harvest in preparation for long winter is at a premium. In the initial or Acquisition phase of the test we examined specifically discrimination learning, where bees were trained to respond to a paired conditioned stimulus with an unconditioned stimulus and not to respond to a second conditioned stimulus that is not followed by an unconditioned stimulus. We found no significant differences among the subspecies in the Acquisition phase in appetitive learning. During the second, Reversal phase of the experiment, where flexibility in association was tested, the paired and unpaired conditioned stimuli were reversed. During the Reversal phaseA. mellifera syriacashowed a reduced ability to learn the reverse association in the appetitive learning task. This observation is consistent with the hypothesis that A.m. syriaca foragers cannot change the foraging choice because of lack of flexibility in appetitive associations under changing contingencies. Interestingly, both subspecies continued responding to the previously rewarded conditioned stimulus in the reversal phase. We discuss potential ecological correlates and molecular underpinnings of these differences in learning across the two subspecies. In addition, in a supplemental experiment we demonstrated that these differences in appetitive reversal learning do not occur in other learning contexts.