TMTamaryn Menneer

Tamaryn Menneer

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Tamaryn Menneer has a total of 26 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    The Influence of Training with One or Two Faces on Dual-Target Face Search

    by Natalie Mestry, Silke Vos, Tamaryn Menneer, Nick Donnelly

    Mestry et al. (2017) reported a dual-target cost when searching for two unfamiliar faces relative to search for one. In dual-target search, participants prioritized one target such that search was better with one face than the other. In the current study, we test if prior training with single face targets or dual-target faces influences the efficiency of dual-target face search in a test phase. Participants completed a training phase with sequential blocks of single-target face search for each face or two blocks of dual-target search for both faces. Following training, participants performed dual-target search in a test phase, followed by two short blocks of single-target search (one for each target). The final two blocks allow insight into the short-term influence of dual-target search on subsequent single-target face search. Response times reduced over phases in all conditions. More importantly, with respect to the effect of training condition on dual-target search, while participants in the single-target training condition were faster overall during training than those receiving dual-target training, those trained with dual-target search responded faster in the test phase. With respect to the short-term influence of dual-target search on subsequent single-target search, the mean response times to faces in the test phase were used to determine preferred and non-preferred faces. By definition the preferred faces were responded to faster than the non-preferred faces in the dual-target test phase. However, and importantly, the same effect of face preference was also found in the two short blocks of single-target face search that followed the test phase. We conclude that (1) if dual-target face search is the task you will ultimately be required to perform, then it is better to be trained in dual-target than single-target search, and (2) the prioritization strategy adopted in dual-target face search has implications for subsequent single-target face search. Meeting abstract presented at VSS 2018

  • Open Access

    Modeling search guidance: Three parameters for characterizing performance in different types of visual search.

    by Tamaryn Menneer, Kyle Cave, Michael Stroud, Elina Kaplan, Nick Donnelly

    The accuracy of search guidance is reflected in the probability of fixating distractors within a search display as a function of their similarity to the target (e.g., Stroud et al., JEP:HPP, 2012). Strong search guidance produces high fixation rates to distractors that match the target on a given dimension (e.g., color), and low fixation rates to distractors that do not match the target. When guidance is absent, fixation rates are equal across all distractors, regardless of similarity to target. We modeled fixation rates across different levels of target similarity using a sigmoid function. Three parameters are necessary and sufficient to fit the function across a range of color-search tasks: single-target search, dual-target search, search plus a working-memory task, and search plus shape discrimination (modeled data: Stroud et al., ACP, 2011; Stroud et al., VSS, 2011; Stroud et al., JEP:HPP, 2012; Menneer et al., BPS, 2014). These parameters are as follows. (1) Unguided fixation rate (u): Even in guided search, participants exhibit a baseline fixation rate to distractors that are maximally different to the target. u defines the ratio of unguided fixations to guided fixations. (2) Selectivity (s): Participants with high selectivity (e.g., for target-similar colors) exhibit a guidance curve that drops off steeply for distractors less similar to the target, while low selectivity produces a shallow drop-off. (3) Target region (t): Some tasks produce high fixation rates to the target color only, but others produce high fixations rates to a range of colors similar to the target color. t allows adjustment of the region in color space that receives high fixation rates, and determines the level of dissimilarity at which the fixation rate begins to drop off steeply. The estimates for these three parameters demonstrate how guidance changes across different types of search. Meeting abstract presented at VSS 2015

  • Open Access

    Visual Search for Transparent Overlapping Objects in Depth: Overlap Impairs Performance, but Depth does not benefit Performance

    by Hayward Godwin, Tamaryn Menneer, Simon Liversedge, Kyle Cave, Nick Holliman, Nick Donnelly

    During everyday visual search tasks, such as searching for keys in a cluttered room, it is commonplace for objects to overlap one another and occur at different levels of depth. This situation stands in contrast to standard search tasks in which objects are presented on a single depth plane and do not overlap with one another. We previously examined how overlap and depth influence search performance by asking participants to search displays containing overlapping opaque polygons presented on different depth planes to one another. We found that overlap impaired search performance (increased RTs, decreased accuracy), and the presence of depth in the highly-overlapping displays decreased RTs. Here, we extend this previous work to examine search in displays containing transparent overlapping coloured polygons, again assessing whether the presence of depth aids performance, and whether overlap impairs performance. In such displays, overlap results in combinations of colours that alter the colour (but not the shape) of objects. We found that, with transparent displays, response accuracy was high – higher than our previous study where participants searched overlapping opaque objects. However, this increase in accuracy came at the cost of increased RTs. Finally, the presence of depth information in the displays had no effect on accuracy or speed. Overall, in displays containing opaque objects, response accuracy is negatively affected by overlap because the opaque nature of the objects removes information regarding object identities. However, in displays containing transparent objects, accuracy is negatively affected by overlap to a lesser extent, while response times are negatively affected to a greater extent. This is because information regarding object identity is available in transparent displays, but it requires more time to disambiguate each object’s identity from that of other objects. The delay occurs because the transparency of overlapping objects changes and obfuscates the colour of the objects. Meeting presented at VSS 2015

  • Open Access

    Dual-Target Cost in Visual Search for Multiple Unfamiliar Faces

    by Natalie Mestry, Tamaryn Menneer, Hayward Godwin, Kyle Cave, Nick Donnelly

    Visual search is slower and less accurate when trying to find more than one target object, referred to as the dual-target cost, and reduced attentional guidance has been shown to be the cause (e.g. Menneer et al., 2012). Studies in the eye-witness domain have shown the presence of two target faces reduces accuracy of identifying a single target face in both memory and matching paradigms (Megreya & Burton, 2006; Bindemann et al., 2012; Megreya & Bindemann, 2012). Here we examine behavioural performance and eye movements when searching for one versus two unfamiliar faces. Specifically, we were interested to see whether there was a dual-target cost and, if observed, whether the cause is the same for faces as for objects. Across two experiments, we varied the visual similarity of distractors to target faces using morphing. In both experiments, the similarity of distractors to targets was graded. In Experiment 1 distractors were morphed with only one of the targets and in Experiment 2 some distractors were morphs of both targets. In both experiments there was evidence of a dual-target cost: dual-target search took longer and was less accurate than single-target search. On target-absent trials, the participants searched exhaustively in both single and dual-target conditions, highlighting the difficulty of the task. Searching for two targets resulted in ‘shedding’, wherein participants gave up searching for one of the targets. There was evidence of guidance to faces in relation to the participant’s preferred target in both single and dual-target search in Experiment 2, but only single-target search in Experiment 1. Probability of fixation to distractors was proportional to the similarity of the distractor to the preferred target. Overall, results suggest effective visual search for unfamiliar faces is limited to a single face, which has profound implications for applied search tasks. Meeting presented at VSS 2015

  • Semantic and Visual Similarity Guide Visual Search for Words and Numbers

    by Michael Hout, Hayward J. Godwin, Gemma Fitzsimmons, Arryn Robbins, Tamaryn Menneer

  • Dual Target Search Is Neither Purely Simultaneous nor Purely Successive

    by Kyle Cave, Tamaryn Menneer, Mohammad S. Nomani, Michael J. Stroud, Nick Donnelly

  • Open Access

    Discriminating Thatcherised from typical faces in a case of prosopagnosia

    by Natalie Mestry, Nick Donnelly, Tamaryn Menneer, Rosaleen A. McCarthy


  • Search for two categories of target produces fewer fixations to target-color items.

    by Tamaryn Menneer, Michael J. Stroud, Kyle R. Cave, Xingshan Li, Hayward J. Godwin, Simon P. Liversedge, Nick Donnelly

    Searching simultaneously for metal threats (guns and knives) and improvised explosive devices (IEDs) in X-ray images is less effective than 2 independent single-target searches, 1 for metal threats and 1 for IEDs. The goals of this study were to (a) replicate this dual-target cost for categorical targets and to determine whether the cost remains when X-ray images overlap, (b) determine the role of attentional guidance in this dual-target cost by measuring eye movements, and (c) determine the effect of practice on guidance. Untrained participants conducted 5,376 trials of visual search of X-ray images, each specializing in single-target search for metal threats, single-target search for IEDs, or dual-target search for both. In dual-target search, only 1 target (metal threat or IED) at most appeared on any 1 trial. Eye movements, response time, and accuracy were compared across single-target and dual-target searches. Results showed a dual-target cost in response time, accuracy, and guidance, with fewer fixations to target-color objects and disproportionately more to non-target-color objects, compared with single-target search. Such reduction in guidance explains why targets are missed in dual-target search, which was particularly noticeable when objects overlapped. After extensive practice, accuracy, response time, and guidance remained better in single-target search than in dual-target search. The results indicate that, when 2 different target representations are required for search, both representations cannot be maintained as accurately as in separate single-target searches. They suggest that baggage X-ray security screeners should specialize in one type of threat, or be trained to conduct 2 independent searches, 1 for each threat item.