SCSue Clegg

Sue Clegg

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Sue Clegg has a total of 4 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • The interview reconsidered: context, genre, reflexivity and interpretation in sociological approaches to interviews in higher education research

    by Sue Clegg, Jacqueline Stevenson

    The paper makes a number of arguments about the research interview and maintains that, despite the near ubiquity of the method in higher education research, the interview remains under-theorised and mis-described. We argue that by virtue of being ‘insider’, higher education research involves a form of tacit ethnography where multiple sources of data impact on the interpretation of events. The ‘interview’ therefore needs to be understood in its rich contextual setting. The paper critiques the genre of journal writing and the tendency to under-describe methodology, with a reliance on a description solely of method. Papers that challenge this practice are discussed as offering alternative ways of writing research. Finally the paper analyses the role of reflexivity in interviews, both the researcher's and the researched. It points to the contradictions involved when the forms of reflexivity evoked are tied to the very policies and practices (for example, ‘employability’) we are attempting to critique. The paper concludes that we need a much richer understanding of our methodologies and of knowledge making.


  • Conceptualising higher education research and/or academic development as ‘fields’: a critical analysis

    by Sue Clegg

    This paper calls into question the idea that we can simply think about higher education as a research field and explores different meanings of the term field. It asks whether there are related fields: research into higher education, academic development and disciplinary teaching research, rather than one. The approach of the paper is conceptual, rather than empirical. It draws on the work of Wenger, Becher and Trowler, Bernstein and Bourdieu, all of whom have a claim to help us think about the nature of fields and academics' relationship to them. Each of these theorists highlights different aspects of what we might mean by a field, and thus what it would mean to claim that research in higher education is a field. The paper suggests that there can be no innocent answers to the question of fields because of our implication within them. It argues that there are normative as well as substantive debates about the nature of fields and the questions that can be asked within them.


  • On the problem of theorising: an insider account of research practice

    by Sue Clegg

    This article addresses the problem of how we theorise in writing about higher education through a reconstruction and interrogation of my previous work. I argue that theorising is messy, incomplete and a non-reductive process. Using C. Wright-Mills' notion of craft and Val Hey's insights into theorists who come to haunt us, I retrace the steps involved in an investigation of personal development planning. This research led to a broader consideration of the nature of disciplines and the importance of temporality in higher education. These moves involved a re-conceptualisation of the problem under investigation, a new phase of empirical research and a change of subject. I suggest that more such accounts could yield insight into the nature of our craft and the process of theorising.


  • Academic identities re-formed? Contesting technological determinism in accounts of the digital age

    by Sue Clegg

    This paper will deconstruct ideas of the ‘digital age’ and ‘information society’ by exploring how digital technologies are invoked in accounts of changing academic identities. It argues that policy, and academic, narratives about the impact of digital technologies have been marred by a strand of technological determinism. Drawing on the work of Barbara Adam the paper will contest linear accounts of the experiences of time assumed in theories of space–time compression and suggest that attention needs to be given to the times of the body and the experiential which co-exist and interpolate the speeded up times of digital technologies. The paper explores the ways academic identities are being re-made, but also continuing commitments to the idea of an intellectual self. It argues that mundane technologies such as email are multiple in their effects, disrupting aspects of identity and exerting increased managerial surveillance, while simultaneously (in the same in-box) providing solace, research ideas, friendship and politics. The conclusions are more a sketch of a research agenda since there is remarkably little empirical research on academic identities and technology.


  • Cultural capital and agency: connecting critique and curriculum in higher education

    by Sue Clegg

    This paper explores some of the unresolved tensions in higher education systems and the contradiction between widening participation and the consolidation of social position. It shows how concepts of capital derived from Bourdieu, Coleman and Putnam provide a powerful basis for critique, but risk a deficit view of students from less privileged backgrounds. These students are more likely to attend lower‐status institutions and engage with an externally focused curriculum. The paper argues for greater attention to agency, and community and familial capital, in conceptualising the resilience of those from less privileged backgrounds. While the recognition of ‘voice’ is important, a curriculum that acknowledges the context independence of knowledge is essential if these students are not to be further disadvantaged.


  • Time future - the dominant discourse of higher education

    by Sue Clegg

    The paper presents a critique of the dominant temporality of higher education policy in the UK and globally. It argues that the temporality of ‘employability’ is what Barbara Adam and Chris Groves describe as the ‘present future’; a conception of the future as empty and open. Drawing on the work of Margaret Archer, the paper explores the differing existential temporalities associated with different forms of reflexivity and explores the complex temporalities of personal development planning. The increasing tempo of university life makes imagining otherwise, based on an ethical care for the future, increasingly difficult but nonetheless imperative.


  • Kindness in pedagogical practice and academic life

    by Sue Clegg, Stephen Rowland

    The paper presents the argument that kindness in teaching is both commonplace yet unremarked and that, moreover, it is subversive of neo‐liberal values. In arguing for the value of attending to kindness, we reject the dichotomy between emotion and reason and the associated gendered binaries. We distinguish kindness from ‘due care’ and acts that are required of professionals, and instead locate it philosophically in personal values and with a concern for lay normativity. We illustrate our claims for the pervasiveness of kindness through a re‐reading of student data from an earlier study. These data are used to elaborate the concept. We conclude by suggesting that what is subversive in thinking about higher education practice through the lens of kindness is that it cannot be regulated or prescribed.


  • Histories and institutional change: understanding academic development practices in the global ‘north’ and ‘south’

    by Sue Clegg

    Academic development has played a significant role in creating university ‘learning and teaching’ as an object of policy scrutiny and intervention. While academic development is a new field, its practices have been productive of new learning and teaching regimes in both the global ‘north’ and ‘south’. This paper explores the emergence of academic development as a practice and the agentic understandings of its actors in creating the academic development project in the face of global unevenness. The paper offers a critical account of the emergence of academic development practice in both the global ‘north’, drawing on the intertwined histories of the UK and Australia, and in the global ‘south’, drawing on the example of South Africa. In looking at the ongoing debates about academic development the paper argues that in constituting teaching and learning as its object, other more radical, feminist and critical pedagogies, which are capable of dealing with the power and curricula, were marginalised.


  • Student support through personal development planning: retrospection and time

    by Sue Clegg, Serena Bufton

    This article presents an analysis of higher education students’ retrospective meaning making of their experiences of personal development planning (PDP). An earlier study of first year students had indicated that students rarely reflected on their own meta‐cognitive processes and were preoccupied with practical study skill matters, particularly time management. The authors were interested, therefore, in looking at whether students in their final year had developed the ability to reflect on their learning, and which aspects of their learning experiences they felt supported them in these developments. They undertook 20 in‐depth interviews which explored how students approached learning and the supports they had found useful as well as probing specifically about the PDP elements of the course. Their analysis reveals the complexity of students’ understandings of their own first‐year experiences: their lack of engagement, and ‘faking’ reflection and planning by completing ‘plans’ only after the event. Retrospective realisation of relevance and an increased focus on results and the future shaped their understandings in the final year. The authors draw on theorists of time to explore how understanding the multiple temporalities involved in education might offer insight into the difficulties students experience and their lack of future orientation in the first year. Rather than being simply mundane concerns, time, time management, and perceptions of the present in terms of the past, present or the future illuminate some of the difficulties of reflection and of the projection of future selves implicit in the term ‘personal development planning’. Tempo and timing appear to be essential in terms of students’ shifting personal epistemologies, their experiences of self as both relatively unchanging and developing, and their capacities to judge relevance and access support.