Charlotte Lemanski
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Charlotte Lemanski has a total of 9 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Camila Bassi
Sheffield Hallam University
1 shared publication - David Lambert
Department of Geography, Royal Holloway, University of London ,© 2008, David Lambert
1 shared publication Grant Saff
Hofstra University, Hempstead, NY
1 shared publication- Jason Dittmer
University College London
1 shared publication Karina Landman
The Council for Scientific and Industrial Research
1 shared publication- Lucy Budd
Transport Studies Group, School of Civil and Building Engineering, Loughborough University, Loughborough, Leicestershire LE113TU, United Kingdom
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 8 January 2014
- Published by SAGE Publications in Urban Studies
- Vol. 51 (14) , 2943-2960
Hybrid gentrification in South Africa: Theorising across southern and northern cities
This paper reveals how urban theories traditionally rooted in northern cities and academies are challenged and redeveloped by southern perspectives. Critiques of urban theory as narrowly northern (or Anglo-American) have recently emerged, spawning the comparative urbanism movement that calls for urban theories to be open to the experiences of all cities. Using the example of the sale of state-subsidised houses in South Africa, this research uses two parallel concepts, gentrification and downward raiding, to challenge the northern empirical focus of urban theory. Despite describing similar processes of urban class-based change, the concepts are rarely considered analogous, entrenched in divergent empirical contexts and academic literatures. While gentrification debates largely reference the northern central city, downward raiding is reserved for the southern ‘slum’. In contrast, this research develops ‘hybrid gentrification’ as a concept and methodological approach that demonstrates how non-northern urban experiences can and should create and refine urban theory.
- 8 January 2014
- Published by SAGE Publications in Urban Studies
- Vol. 51 (14) , 2943-2960
Open AccessHybrid gentrification in South Africa: Theorising across southern and northern cities
This paper reveals how urban theories traditionally rooted in northern cities and academies are challenged and redeveloped by southern perspectives. Critiques of urban theory as narrowly northern (or Anglo-American) have recently emerged, spawning the comparative urbanism movement that calls for urban theories to be open to the experiences of all cities. Using the example of the sale of state-subsidised houses in South Africa, this research uses two parallel concepts, gentrification and downward raiding, to challenge the northern empirical focus of urban theory. Despite describing similar processes of urban class-based change, the concepts are rarely considered analogous, entrenched in divergent empirical contexts and academic literatures. While gentrification debates largely reference the northern central city, downward raiding is reserved for the southern ‘slum’. In contrast, this research develops ‘hybrid gentrification’ as a concept and methodological approach that demonstrates how non-northern urban experiences can and should create and refine urban theory.
- Open Access
- 20 April 2012
- Published by Wiley in Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers
- Vol. 38 (1) , 91-105
The ‘missing middle’: class and urban governance in Delhi’s unauthorised colonies
This research critically engages with existing theories of class and urban governance, and is empirically located in Delhi, India. The paper argues that existing theories of urban participatory governance in the global South, which polarise urban citizens and their mobilisation strategies into the elite, typically understood as guilty of ‘capturing’ participatory structures; and the poor, conceptualised as excluded from formal governance mechanisms but active in more politicised forms of mobilisation, are incomplete. This research identifies urban citizens who fit neither the ‘elite’ nor ‘poor’ conceptual binary, and explores how such ‘ordinary’ citizens engage in participatory urban governance. Empirically, research addresses Delhi’s unauthorised colonies (UCs), residential areas that have evolved mostly on private land that is not classified ‘residential’ in the Delhi Master Plan. Housing roughly a quarter to one‐third of Delhi’s population and comprising a mix of classes, UCs are technically illegal locations for residential development, are consequently excluded from Delhi’s network of basic urban services (water, roads, electricity) and face potential demolition. UCs are conceptualised as representing India’s ‘missing middle’ both empirically, highlighting the multiplicity of the middle class, and conceptually, revealing the failure of binary concepts to accurately describe participatory urban governance for those in ‘the middle’. In addition, analysis highlights how UCs’ invisibility (linked to their heterogeneity – i.e. their empirical and conceptual ‘middle‐ness’) functions as both an asset and a limitation in terms of participation in urban governance. The paper calls for greater recognition in academic and policy debates regarding the nuances in everyday life that are overlooked by neat binaries. As the Delhi case shows, a large proportion of urban populations are neither ‘poor’ nor ‘elite’, and arguably a similar trend is likely to exist in cities throughout the world where segments of populations demographically in ‘the middle’ are ‘missing’ from academic and policy debates.
- 20 April 2012
- Published by Wiley in Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers
- Vol. 38 (1) , 91-105
Open AccessThe ‘missing middle’: class and urban governance in Delhi’s unauthorised colonies
This research critically engages with existing theories of class and urban governance, and is empirically located in Delhi, India. The paper argues that existing theories of urban participatory governance in the global South, which polarise urban citizens and their mobilisation strategies into the elite, typically understood as guilty of ‘capturing’ participatory structures; and the poor, conceptualised as excluded from formal governance mechanisms but active in more politicised forms of mobilisation, are incomplete. This research identifies urban citizens who fit neither the ‘elite’ nor ‘poor’ conceptual binary, and explores how such ‘ordinary’ citizens engage in participatory urban governance. Empirically, research addresses Delhi’s unauthorised colonies (UCs), residential areas that have evolved mostly on private land that is not classified ‘residential’ in the Delhi Master Plan. Housing roughly a quarter to one‐third of Delhi’s population and comprising a mix of classes, UCs are technically illegal locations for residential development, are consequently excluded from Delhi’s network of basic urban services (water, roads, electricity) and face potential demolition. UCs are conceptualised as representing India’s ‘missing middle’ both empirically, highlighting the multiplicity of the middle class, and conceptually, revealing the failure of binary concepts to accurately describe participatory urban governance for those in ‘the middle’. In addition, analysis highlights how UCs’ invisibility (linked to their heterogeneity – i.e. their empirical and conceptual ‘middle‐ness’) functions as both an asset and a limitation in terms of participation in urban governance. The paper calls for greater recognition in academic and policy debates regarding the nuances in everyday life that are overlooked by neat binaries. As the Delhi case shows, a large proportion of urban populations are neither ‘poor’ nor ‘elite’, and arguably a similar trend is likely to exist in cities throughout the world where segments of populations demographically in ‘the middle’ are ‘missing’ from academic and policy debates.
- 22 November 2011
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in African Affairs
- Vol. 111 (442) , 163-165
New South Africa Review 1: 2010: Development or decline?
The New South Africa Review 2010 is the first edition of a new series emerging as a semi-renewal of the 1980–90s South African Review texts which addressed the changing nature of state–society relations during the demise of apartheid and early democracy. This new series aims to assess how South Africa is coping, 15 years since the advent of democracy, with the combined pressures of economic development and social transformation – a broad and ambitious task. Consequently, the book is a large edited collection, covering a wide range of issues relevant to contemporary South Africa, from health and education to crime and sex, authored by leading experts. The volume is spearheaded by the Wits University Department of Sociology, but is accessible as a reader across the humanities and social sciences, and has a...
- 22 November 2011
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in African Affairs
- Vol. 111 (442) , 163-165
New South Africa Review 1: 2010: Development or decline?
The New South Africa Review 2010 is the first edition of a new series emerging as a semi-renewal of the 1980–90s South African Review texts which addressed the changing nature of state–society relations during the demise of apartheid and early democracy. This new series aims to assess how South Africa is coping, 15 years since the advent of democracy, with the combined pressures of economic development and social transformation – a broad and ambitious task. Consequently, the book is a large edited collection, covering a wide range of issues relevant to contemporary South Africa, from health and education to crime and sex, authored by leading experts. The volume is spearheaded by the Wits University Department of Sociology, but is accessible as a reader across the humanities and social sciences, and has a...
- 1 August 2011
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
- Vol. 36 (5) , 565-581
Accessandassessment? Incentives for independent study
This paper explores incentives for students to engage with continuous learning outside the classroom, i.e. independent study. Two questionnaires were completed with undergraduate students, asking them quantitative and qualitative questions regarding their engagement (or lack thereof) with weekly readings which are non‐assessed and non‐monitored. The questionnaires identified that the majority of students do not complete the readings despite a consensus that they are crucial for understanding the course material. The two primary reasons expressed for not undertaking independent study are lack of assessment or time‐bound deadlines and poor access to reading material. Students were also asked to imagine potential incentives to encourage the completion of weekly readings, and then ranked these ideas in the second questionnaire. The two proposals with a majority of student support are the introduction of assessment measures to incentivise weekly readings (albeit with some student opposition to such an interventionalist approach) and the introduction of mechanisms that provide greater access to learning materials. These findings introduce the role of ‘access’ as a key mechanism to stimulate independent study, thus challenging the literature’s emphasis on assessment as the primary means to facilitate learning.
- 1 August 2011
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education
- Vol. 36 (5) , 565-581
Accessandassessment? Incentives for independent study
This paper explores incentives for students to engage with continuous learning outside the classroom, i.e. independent study. Two questionnaires were completed with undergraduate students, asking them quantitative and qualitative questions regarding their engagement (or lack thereof) with weekly readings which are non‐assessed and non‐monitored. The questionnaires identified that the majority of students do not complete the readings despite a consensus that they are crucial for understanding the course material. The two primary reasons expressed for not undertaking independent study are lack of assessment or time‐bound deadlines and poor access to reading material. Students were also asked to imagine potential incentives to encourage the completion of weekly readings, and then ranked these ideas in the second questionnaire. The two proposals with a majority of student support are the introduction of assessment measures to incentivise weekly readings (albeit with some student opposition to such an interventionalist approach) and the introduction of mechanisms that provide greater access to learning materials. These findings introduce the role of ‘access’ as a key mechanism to stimulate independent study, thus challenging the literature’s emphasis on assessment as the primary means to facilitate learning.
- 23 August 2010
- Published by Wiley in International Journal of Urban and Regional Research
- Vol. 35 (1) , 57-77
Moving up the Ladder or Stuck on the Bottom Rung? Homeownership as a Solution to Poverty in Urban South Africa
In the global South, policies providing property titles to low‐income households are increasingly implemented as a solution to poverty. Integrating poor households into the capitalist economy using state‐subsidized homeownership is intended to provide poor people with an asset that can be used in a productive manner. In this article the South African ‘housing subsidy system’ is assessed using quantitative and qualitative data from in‐depth research in a state‐subsidized housing settlement in the city of Cape Town. The findings show that while state‐subsidized property ownership provides long‐term shelter and tenure security to low‐income households, houses have mixed value as a financial asset. Although state‐subsidized houses in South Africa are a financially tradable asset, transaction values are too low for low‐income vendors to reach the next rung on the housing ladder, the township market. Furthermore, low‐income homeowners are reticent to use their (typically primary) asset as collateral security for credit, and thus property ownership is not providing the financial returns that titling theories assume. Résumé Les pays du Sud instaurent de plus en plus souvent des politiques publiques qui octroient des titres de propriété aux ménages à faible revenu afin de lutter contre la pauvreté. Intégrer les ménages défavorisés à l'économie capitaliste en leur permettant une accession à la propriété financée par l'État a pour but de leur procurer un bien utilisable de manière productive. Le système sud‐africain de logements subventionnés est évaluéà partir de données quantitatives et qualitatives issues d'une étude détaillée sur une implantation de logements subventionnés par l'État dans la ville du Cap. Les résultats montrent que, dans ce cadre, l'accession à la propriété offre aux ménages défavorisés un abri à long terme et une sécurité de maintien dans les lieux, mais que les maisons ont une valeur inégale sur le plan financier. Même si celles‐ci constituent un bien négociable financièrement, les valeurs de transaction sont trop faibles pour que les vendeurs à bas revenu puissent atteindre l'échelon suivant sur l'échelle des logements: le marché des townships. En outre, comme les nouveaux propriétaires rechignent à recourir à leur bien (généralement principal) pour garantir un crédit, l'accession à la propriété ne procure pas les bénéfices financiers théoriquement associés à la délivrance de titres de propriété.
- 23 August 2010
- Published by Wiley in International Journal of Urban and Regional Research
- Vol. 35 (1) , 57-77
Moving up the Ladder or Stuck on the Bottom Rung? Homeownership as a Solution to Poverty in Urban South Africa
In the global South, policies providing property titles to low‐income households are increasingly implemented as a solution to poverty. Integrating poor households into the capitalist economy using state‐subsidized homeownership is intended to provide poor people with an asset that can be used in a productive manner. In this article the South African ‘housing subsidy system’ is assessed using quantitative and qualitative data from in‐depth research in a state‐subsidized housing settlement in the city of Cape Town. The findings show that while state‐subsidized property ownership provides long‐term shelter and tenure security to low‐income households, houses have mixed value as a financial asset. Although state‐subsidized houses in South Africa are a financially tradable asset, transaction values are too low for low‐income vendors to reach the next rung on the housing ladder, the township market. Furthermore, low‐income homeowners are reticent to use their (typically primary) asset as collateral security for credit, and thus property ownership is not providing the financial returns that titling theories assume. Résumé Les pays du Sud instaurent de plus en plus souvent des politiques publiques qui octroient des titres de propriété aux ménages à faible revenu afin de lutter contre la pauvreté. Intégrer les ménages défavorisés à l'économie capitaliste en leur permettant une accession à la propriété financée par l'État a pour but de leur procurer un bien utilisable de manière productive. Le système sud‐africain de logements subventionnés est évaluéà partir de données quantitatives et qualitatives issues d'une étude détaillée sur une implantation de logements subventionnés par l'État dans la ville du Cap. Les résultats montrent que, dans ce cadre, l'accession à la propriété offre aux ménages défavorisés un abri à long terme et une sécurité de maintien dans les lieux, mais que les maisons ont une valeur inégale sur le plan financier. Même si celles‐ci constituent un bien négociable financièrement, les valeurs de transaction sont trop faibles pour que les vendeurs à bas revenu puissent atteindre l'échelon suivant sur l'échelle des logements: le marché des townships. En outre, comme les nouveaux propriétaires rechignent à recourir à leur bien (généralement principal) pour garantir un crédit, l'accession à la propriété ne procure pas les bénéfices financiers théoriquement associés à la délivrance de titres de propriété.
- 29 January 2010
- Published by SAGE Publications in Urban Affairs Review
- Vol. 45 (4) , 507-543
The Value(s) of Space: The Discourses and Strategies of Residential Exclusion in Cape Town and Long Island
This article analyzes the discourses and strategies of residential exclusion in Cape Town and New York. Although representing vastly different regions, both case studies are historically middle-class residential areas that have recently undergone significant immigrant influx. The responses of long-term residents and local governments are explored, in particular, the role of “values” (sociocultural, physical, and economic) ascribed to space by residents in shaping and legitimizing exclusive discourses and practices. The authors conclude that while long-term homeowners express some very “real” and “valid” reasons for exclusionary attitudes, the consequent exclusion of already underprivileged demographic groups is problematic.
- 29 January 2010
- Published by SAGE Publications in Urban Affairs Review
- Vol. 45 (4) , 507-543
The Value(s) of Space: The Discourses and Strategies of Residential Exclusion in Cape Town and Long Island
This article analyzes the discourses and strategies of residential exclusion in Cape Town and New York. Although representing vastly different regions, both case studies are historically middle-class residential areas that have recently undergone significant immigrant influx. The responses of long-term residents and local governments are explored, in particular, the role of “values” (sociocultural, physical, and economic) ascribed to space by residents in shaping and legitimizing exclusive discourses and practices. The authors conclude that while long-term homeowners express some very “real” and “valid” reasons for exclusionary attitudes, the consequent exclusion of already underprivileged demographic groups is problematic.
- Open Access
- 1 October 2008
- Published by SAGE Publications in Environment & Urbanization
- Vol. 20 (2) , 393-410
Houses without community: problems of community (in)capacity in Cape Town, South Africa
Literature from the global South has highlighted the role of self-organized “grassroots” groups in championing the rights of the poor, securing specific objectives (e.g. service provision) and strengthening individual and collective capacity. Less attention has been paid to what happens when a poor community is provided with services in the context of weak collective capacity and in the absence of grassroots organization. This case study describes a former informal settlement in Cape Town, where residents were awarded formal housing by the state without a “struggle” and thus without developing the collective drive, capacity or leadership necessary to be full participants in the ensuing process. The paper assesses the community's struggle to assert itself collectively over time, linking their pre-development community diversity to subsequent exclusion from the development process and continuing problems of post-development community consolidation. The implications of becoming beneficiaries without community agreement, involvement, organization or capacity are considered.
- 1 October 2008
- Published by SAGE Publications in Environment & Urbanization
- Vol. 20 (2) , 393-410
Open AccessHouses without community: problems of community (in)capacity in Cape Town, South Africa
Literature from the global South has highlighted the role of self-organized “grassroots” groups in championing the rights of the poor, securing specific objectives (e.g. service provision) and strengthening individual and collective capacity. Less attention has been paid to what happens when a poor community is provided with services in the context of weak collective capacity and in the absence of grassroots organization. This case study describes a former informal settlement in Cape Town, where residents were awarded formal housing by the state without a “struggle” and thus without developing the collective drive, capacity or leadership necessary to be full participants in the ensuing process. The paper assesses the community's struggle to assert itself collectively over time, linking their pre-development community diversity to subsequent exclusion from the development process and continuing problems of post-development community consolidation. The implications of becoming beneficiaries without community agreement, involvement, organization or capacity are considered.
- 21 July 2008
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Gender, Place & Culture
- Vol. 15 (4) , 445-455
Book reviews
- 21 July 2008
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Gender, Place & Culture
- Vol. 15 (4) , 445-455
Book reviews
- 3 April 2008
- Published by Springer Nature in Urban Forum
- Vol. 19 (2) , 133-158
Divergent and Similar Experiences of ‘Gating’ in South Africa: Johannesburg, Durban and Cape Town
- 3 April 2008
- Published by Springer Nature in Urban Forum
- Vol. 19 (2) , 133-158
Divergent and Similar Experiences of ‘Gating’ in South Africa: Johannesburg, Durban and Cape Town