CSCharles Tristan Stayton

Charles Tristan Stayton

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Charles Tristan Stayton has a total of 14 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Does Phenotypic Integration Promote Convergent Evolution?

    by C Tristan Stayton

    Synopsis: Phenotypic integration is often perceived as being able to produce convergent evolution in the absence of selection, but specific mechanisms for this process are lacking and a connection has never been empirically demonstrated. A new model of the effect of integration on convergence provides such a mechanism, along with other predictions about the influence of integration on evolutionary patterns. I use simulations and data from three empirical systems—turtle shells, characiform fish, and squirrel mandibles—to investigate the degree to which evolutionary integration is associated with high levels of convergent evolution. Levels of integration were varied in Brownian motion simulations and the resulting amounts of stochastic convergent evolution were quantified. Each empirical system was divided into modules, and the strength of integration, average amount of convergence, phenotypic disparity, and rate of evolution in each module were measured. Results from the simulations and from all three empirical systems converge on a common result: higher levels of phenotypic integration are indeed associated with higher levels of convergence. This is despite a lack of consistent association between the strength of phenotypic integration and evolutionary rate or disparity. The results here are only correlational. Further studies that more closely examine the influence of within-population drivers of evolutionary integration—for example, genetic or developmental integration—on convergence are required before it is possible to definitively establish when phenotypic integration can cause evolutionary convergence. Until then, however, the results of this study strongly suggest that phenotypic integration will often promote convergent evolution.


  • How many trees to see the forest? Assessing the effects of morphospace coverage and sample size in performance surface analysis

    by Stephanie M. Smith, C. Tristan Stayton, Kenneth D. Angielczyk

    Linking morphology and function is critical to understanding the evolution of organismal shape. Performance landscapes, or performance surfaces, associate empirical functional performance data with a morphospace to assess how shape variation relates to functional variation. Performance surfaces for multiple functions also can be combined to understand the functional trade‐offs that affect the morphology of a particular structure across species. However, morphological performance surfaces usually require empirical determination of performance for a number of theoretical shapes that are evenly distributed throughout the morphospace. This process is time‐consuming, and is problematic for structures that are difficult to precisely manipulate. We sought to (a) understand the degree and pattern of sampling required to produce a reliable and nuanced performance surface and (b) investigate the possibility of building a surface using only naturally occurring morphologies. To do this, we subsampled a pre‐existing set of turtle shell performance surfaces in four different ways: first, uniform subsampling of theoretical morphologies across the surface; second, random subsampling of theoretical morphologies across the surface; third, a combination uniform/random subsampling method called close‐pairs sampling and fourth, subsampling only points on the surface known to correspond to a naturally occurring turtle shell morphology. Each subset was interpolated with ordinary Kriging to produce a new performance surface for comparison to the original. We found that using a fraction of the theoretical morphologies examined in the original study (half as many or fewer) was sufficient to produce a performance surface bearing close resemblance to the original (Pearson correlation ≥0.90); close‐pairs sampling dramatically increased the power of small sample sizes. We also discovered that only sampling points on the surface corresponding to naturally occurring morphologies produced an accurate surface, but results were better when individual specimens, rather than species averages, were used. Our findings demonstrate the viability of using performance surfaces to understand the evolution of complex morphologies for which theoretical shape modelling is difficult or computationally burdensome. Both lower levels of carefully configured sampling throughout the theoretical morphospace, and development of performance surfaces using only data from naturally occurring morphologies, are acceptable alternatives to the dense theoretical shape sampling employed in previous studies. ​


  • Open Access

    Are our phylomorphospace plots so terribly tangled? An investigation of disorder in data simulated under adaptive and nonadaptive models

    by C Tristan Stayton

    Contemporary methods for visualizing phenotypic evolution, such as phylomorphospaces, often reveal patterns which depart strongly from a naïve expectation of consistently divergent branching and expansion. Instead, branches regularly crisscross as convergence, reversals, or other forms of homoplasy occur, forming patterns described as “birds’ nests”, “flies in vials”, or less elegantly, “a mess”. In other words, the phenotypic tree of life often appears highly tangled. Various explanations are given for this, such as differential degrees of developmental constraint, adaptation, or lack of adaptation. However, null expectations for the magnitude of disorder or “tangling” have never been established, so it is unclear which or even whether various evolutionary factors are required to explain messy patterns of evolution. I simulated evolution along phylogenies under a number of varying parameters (number of taxa and number of traits) and models (Brownian motion, Ornstein–Uhlenbeck (OU)-based, early burst, and character displacement (CD)] and quantified disorder using 2 measures. All models produce substantial amounts of disorder. Disorder increases with tree size and the number of phenotypic traits. OU models produced the largest amounts of disorder—adaptive peaks influence lineages to evolve within restricted areas, with concomitant increases in crossing of branches and density of evolution. Large early changes in trait values can be important in minimizing disorder. CD consistently produced trees with low (but not absent) disorder. Overall, neither constraints nor a lack of adaptation is required to explain messy phylomorphospaces—both stochastic and deterministic processes can act to produce the tantalizingly tangled phenotypic tree of life.


  • Performance Surface Analysis Identifies Consistent Functional Patterns across 10 Morphologically Divergent Terrestrial Turtle Lineages

    by C Tristan Stayton

    Newly-developed methods for utilizing performance surfaces — multivariate representations of the relationship between phenotype and functional performance — allow researchers to test hypotheses about adaptive landscapes and evolutionary diversification with explicit attention to functional factors. Here, information from performance surfaces of 3 turtle shell functions — shell strength, hydrodynamics, and self-righting — is used to test the hypothesis that turtle lineages transitioning from aquatic to terrestrial habitats show patterns of shell shape evolution consistent with decreased importance of hydrodynamic performance. Turtle shells are excellent model systems for evolutionary functional analysis. The evolution of terrestriality is an interesting test case for the efficacy of these methods, because terrestrial turtles do not show a straightforward pattern of morphological convergence in shell shape: Many terrestrial lineages show increased shell height, typically assumed to decrease hydrodynamic performance, but there are also several lineages where the evolution of terrestriality was accompanied by shell flattening. Performance surface analyses allow exploration of these complex patterns and explicit quantitative analysis of the functional implications of changes in shell shape. Ten lineages were examined. Nearly all terrestrial lineages, including those which experienced decreased shell height, are associated with morphological changes consistent with a decrease in the importance of shell hydrodynamics. This implies a common selective pattern across lineages showing divergent morphological patterns. Performance studies such as these hold great potential for integrating adaptive and performance data in macroevolutionary studies.


  • Effects of Sutured Pelvic Elements on Turtle Shell Strength: A Comparison of Pleurodire and Cryptodire Shell Mechanics

    by Cameron Williams, C. Tristan Stayton

    The two extant clades of turtles, Pleurodira and Cryptodira, can be distinguished by the fact that the pelvic elements of pleurodire turtles are extensively sutured to both the carapace and plastron whereas the pelvic elements of cryptodire turtles are not. Pleurodire shells are also generally flatter than those of cryptodires. These distinctive features could potentially contribute to differences in the strength of the shell in these two clades, but quantitative assessments are lacking. We asked the following questions: How do the sutured pelvic elements of Pelomedusa subrufa (Pleurodira) affect the strength of the turtle's shell? Does the height of the turtle shell affect shell strength? Are there differences in the strength of the shells of pleurodires and cryptodires living in the same geographic regions? We developed finite element models of pleurodire and cryptodire shells and used them to assess the effects of various morphologies and loading regimes on shell stress. The pleurodire model without pelvic elements had higher maximum and average stresses for all load cases, and thus lower strength, than the model with pelvic elements, showing that sutured pelvic elements increase the strength of the shell. Increases in shell height increased shell strength. No differences in strength were found between pleurodire and cryptodire species living in the same geographic regions, indicating that the two clades might be evolving in response to the same selective pressures or requirements, but doing so in different ways. Overall, pleurodires and cryptodires are both able to increase the strength of their shells, but the morphological characteristics that they use to do so differ between the clades.


  • Performance in three shell functions predicts the phenotypic distribution of hard‐shelled turtles

    by C. Tristan Stayton

    Adaptive landscapes have served as fruitful guides to evolutionary research for nearly a century. Current methods guided by landscape frameworks mostly utilize evolutionary modeling (e.g., fitting data to Ornstein–Uhlenbeck models) to make inferences about adaptive peaks. Recent alternative methods utilize known relationships between phenotypes and functional performance to derive information about adaptive landscapes; this information can then help explain the distribution of species in phenotypic space and help infer the relative importance of various functions for guiding diversification. Here, data on performance for three turtle shell functions–strength, hydrodynamic efficiency, and self‐righting ability–are used to develop a set of predicted performance optima in shell shape space. The distribution of performance optima shows significant similarity to the distribution of existing turtle species and helps explain the absence of shells in otherwise anomalously empty regions of morphospace. The method outperforms a modeling‐based approach in inferring the location of reasonable adaptive peaks and in explaining the shape of the phenotypic distributions of turtle shells. Performance surface‐based methods allow researchers to more directly connect functional performance with macroevolutionary diversification, and to explain the distribution of species (including presences and absences) across phenotypic space.


  • Warped finite element models predict whole shell failure in turtle shells

    by C. Tristan Stayton

    Finite element (FE) models have become increasingly popular in comparative biomechanical studies, with researchers continually developing methods such as ‘warping’ preexisting models to facilitate analyses. However, few studies have investigated how well FE models can predict biologically crucial whole‐structure performance or whether ‘warped’ models can provide useful information about the mechanical behavior of actual specimens. This study addresses both of these issues through a validation of warped FE models of turtle shells. FE models for 40 turtle specimens were built using 3D landmark coordinates and thin‐plate spline interpolations to warp preexisting turtle shell models. Each actual turtle specimen was loaded to failure, and the load at failure and mode of fracture were then compared with the behavior predicted by the models. Overall, the models performed very well, despite the fact that many simplifying assumptions were made for analysis. Regressions of observed on predicted loads were significant for the dataset as a whole, as well as in separate analyses within two turtle species, and the direction of fracture was generally consistent with the patterns of stresses observed in the models. This was true even when size (an important factor in determining strength) was removed from analyses – the models were also able to predict which shells would be relatively stronger or weaker. Although some residual variation remains unexplained, this study supports the idea that warped FE models run with simplifying assumptions at least can provide useful information for comparative biomechanical studies.


  • The influence of multiple functional demands on morphological diversification: A test on turtle shells

    by C. Tristan Stayton, Lauren F. O'COnnor, Nicole M. Nisivoccia

    Organismal parts are often involved in the performance of more than one function. The role of trade‐offs in influencing phenotypic evolution of such parts is well‐studied; less well‐understood is their role in influencing phenotypic diversity. Increases in the number of functions a part is involved in may inhibit subsequent diversification, as the number of trade‐offs increases. Alternately, such an increase might promote phenotypic diversification, by increasing adaptive landscape complexity and promoting specialization for different roles. We compare these predictions by testing whether aquatic turtle shells, which resist loads, act as hydrodynamic elements, facilitate self‐righting, and exchange heat with the environment, differ in phenotypic diversity from those of terrestrial species, which perform all the same functions except for hydrodynamics. We used 53 3D landmarks digitized on 2722 specimens of 274 hard‐shelled turtle species to quantify shell shape variation, and a set of phylogenetic hypotheses to examine evolutionary patterns. Terrestrial turtles consistently had higher phenotypic diversity than aquatic species. Differences are not due to differences in the rates of evolution between the two groups, but rather differences in evolutionary mode. Thus this study supports the traditional view of the role of multiple functions in determining phenotypic diversity. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved


  • Side-necked Versus Hidden-necked: A Comparison of Shell Morphology Between Pleurodiran and Cryptodiran Turtles

    by Taylor B. Wise, C. Tristan Stayton

    This study explores the potential morphological differences between pleurodiran and cryptodiran turtle shells. Pleurodires (Suborder Pleurodira), as suggested by their name, retract their heads into the shell by bending the neck to the side; this is different from cryptodires (Suborder Cryptodira), which withdraw their necks along a sagittal plane. Pleurodires also have evolved a unique pelvic morphology typified by two columnar pelvic elements sutured to both the carapace and plastron; in contrast, the pelvic girdle in cryptodires is loosely connected to the shell. These differences might put very different selective pressures on shell shape in these animals: The different head retraction strategies in the two groups could lead pleurodires to evolve wider and flatter anterior apertures while the differences in pelvic structure might permit the evolution of flatter carapaces (particularly in the posterior carapace) and narrower bridges as compared to cryptodires. We used 3D landmark data to char...


  • Size, Shape, and Stress in Tortoise Shell Evolution

    by Michael Dosik, Tristan Stayton

    Testudinid turtles, comprising a single family with a fairly uniform shell morphology but a wide range of body sizes, present a unique opportunity for testing hypotheses regarding the evolution of shell size, shape, and functional performance. Here, we apply geometric morphometric methods and finite element models to test two hypotheses regarding the coevolution of size, shape, and mechanical performance (shell strength). First, we predicted that larger turtles will tend to have shell shapes distinct from those of smaller turtles. Second, we predicted that the shell shapes (independent of size) of smaller turtles will be stronger than those of larger turtles to compensate for the reduction in strength that accompanies a decrease in size. We used multivariate phylogenetic comparative methods to assess the significance of the relationship between shell size and shell shape, and used finite element analysis to assess the mechanical behavior of tortoise shells. We detected a relationship between shell shape and size—the shells of larger tortoise species had larger carapaces relative to plastrons, larger vertebral and pleural scutes relative to marginal scutes, and more vertically oriented marginal scutes. We did not detect a relationship between size-independent shell strength and size, however, and the direction of the trend was the opposite of what we predicted (larger tortoises tended to possess stronger shells than smaller tortoises). This is consistent with larger tortoise species having more highly domed carapaces than smaller species. Future studies should focus on the effect that additional functional factors (such as righting ability or heat exchange), and their interactions, might have on the selective pressures that affect the evolutionary path of tortoises.