TDTimothy DelSole

Timothy DelSole

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Timothy DelSole has a total of 23 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Inferring Aerosol Cooling from Hydrological Sensitivity

    by Timothy DelSole, Xiaoqin Yan, Michael K. Tippett

    Hydrological sensitivity is the change in global-mean precipitation per degree of global mean temperature change. This paper shows that the hydrological sensitivity of the response to anthropogenic aerosol forcing is distinct from that of the combined response to all other forcings, and that this difference is sufficient to infer the associated cooling in global mean temperature. This result is demonstrated using temperature and precipitation data generated by climate models and is robust across different climate models. Remarkably, greenhouse gas warming and aerosol cooling can be estimated in a model without using any spatial or temporal gradient information in the response, provided temperature data is augmented by precipitation data. Over the late twentieth century, the hydrological sensitivities of climate models differ significantly from that of observations. Whether this discrepancy can be attributed to observational error, which is substantial as different estimates of global mean precipitation are not even significantly correlated with each other, or to model error is unclear. The results highlight the urgency to construct accurate estimates of global precipitation from past observations and for reducing model uncertainty in hydrological sensitivity. This paper also clarifies that previous estimates of hydrological sensitivity are limited in that standard regression methods neglect temperature-precipitation relations that occur through internal variability. An alternative method for estimating hydrological sensitivity that overcomes this limitation is presented.


  • Open Access

    Forecast Comparison Based on Random Walks

    by Timothy DelSole, Michael K. Tippett

    This paper proposes a procedure based on random walks for testing and visualizing differences in forecast skill. The test is formally equivalent to the sign test and has numerous attractive statistical properties, including being independent of distributional assumptions about the forecast errors and being applicable to a wide class of measures of forecast quality. While the test is best suited for independent outcomes, it provides useful information even when serial correlation exists. The procedure is applied to deterministic ENSO forecasts from the North American Multimodel Ensemble and yields several revealing results, including 1) the Canadian models are the most skillful dynamical models, even when compared to the multimodel mean; 2) a regression model is significantly more skillful than all but one dynamical model (to which it is equally skillful); and 3) in some cases, there are significant differences in skill between ensemble members from the same model, potentially reflecting differences in initialization. The method requires only a few years of data to detect significant differences in the skill of models with known errors/biases, suggesting that the procedure may be useful for model development and monitoring of real-time forecasts.


  • Laplacian Eigenfunctions for Climate Analysis

    by Timothy DelSole, Michael K. Tippett

    This paper proposes a new method for representing data in a general domain on a sphere. The method is based on the eigenfunctions of the Laplace operator, which form an orthogonal basis set that can be ordered by a measure of length scale. Representing data with Laplacian eigenfunctions is attractive if one wants to reduce the dimension of a dataset by filtering out small-scale variability. Although Laplacian eigenfunctions are ubiquitous in climate modeling, their use in arbitrary domains, such as over continents, is not common because of the numerical difficulties associated with irregular boundaries. Recent advances in machine learning and computational sciences are exploited to derive eigenfunctions of the Laplace operator over an arbitrary domain on a sphere. The eigenfunctions depend only on the geometry of the domain and hence require no training data from models or observations, a feature that is especially useful in small sample sizes. Another novel feature is that the method produces reasonable eigenfunctions even if the domain is disconnected, such as a land domain comprising isolated continents and islands. The eigenfunctions are illustrated by quantifying variability of monthly mean temperature and precipitation in climate models and observations. This analysis extends previous studies by showing that climate models have significant biases not only in global-scale spatial averages but also in global-scale dipoles and other physically important structures. MATLAB and R codes for deriving Laplacian eigenfunctions are available upon request.


  • Open Access

    Comparing Forecast Skill

    by Timothy DelSole, Michael K. Tippett


  • Open Access

    Skill improvement from increased ensemble size and model diversity

    by Timothy DelSole, Jyothi Nattala, Michael K. Tippett

    This paper proposes an objective procedure for deciding if the skill of a combination of forecasts is significantly larger than that of a single forecast, and for deciding if the observed improvement is dominated by reduction of noise associated with ensemble averaging, or by addition of new predictable signals. Information theory provides an attractive framework for addressing these questions. The procedure is applied to El Niño–Southern Oscillation hindcasts from the North American Multimodel Ensemble (NMME) and reveals that the observed skill advantage of the NMME compared to individual models is substantially greater than that expected from increased ensemble size alone and is more consistent with the addition of new signals.


  • Open Access

    Scale-Selective Ridge Regression for Multimodel Forecasting

    by Timothy DelSole, Liwei Jia, Michael K. Tippett

    This paper proposes a new approach to linearly combining multimodel forecasts, called scale-selective ridge regression, which ensures that the weighting coefficients satisfy certain smoothness constraints. The smoothness constraint reflects the “prior assumption” that seasonally predictable patterns tend to be large scale. In the absence of a smoothness constraint, regression methods typically produce noisy weights and hence noisy predictions. Constraining the weights to be smooth ensures that the multimodel combination is no less smooth than the individual model forecasts. The proposed method is equivalent to minimizing a cost function comprising the familiar mean square error plus a “penalty function” that penalizes weights with large spatial gradients. The method reduces to pointwise ridge regression for a suitable choice of constraint. The method is tested using the Ensemble-Based Predictions of Climate Changes and Their Impacts (ENSEMBLES) hindcast dataset during 1960–2005. The cross-validated skill of the proposed forecast method is shown to be larger than the skill of either ordinary least squares or pointwise ridge regression, although the significance of this difference is difficult to test owing to the small sample size. The model weights derived from the method are much smoother than those obtained from ordinary least squares or pointwise ridge regression. Interestingly, regressions in which the weights are completely independent of space give comparable overall skill. The scale-selective ridge is numerically more intensive than pointwise methods since the solution requires solving equations that couple all grid points together.


  • Open Access

    Potential seasonal predictability: Comparison between empirical and dynamical model estimates

    by Timothy DelSole, Arun Kumar, Bhaskar Jha

    Methods for estimating potential seasonal predictability from a single realization of daily data are validated against an ensemble of simulations from an atmospheric model driven by observed sea surface temperature, sea ice extent, and greenhouse gas concentration. The methods give surprisingly good estimates of potential predictability of seasonal precipitation despite the fact that the methods assume Gaussian distributions. For temperature, the methods systematically underestimate weather noise variance over land, often by a factor of 2 or more. This bias can be reduced by taking account of precipitation‐induced variability. These conclusions may be model dependent, and hence, confirmation in other models would be of interest. Nevertheless, for the state‐of‐the‐art atmospheric model used in this study, the results strongly support the validity of the single time series approach to estimating potential predictability and enhances our confidence in previous estimates of potential predictability based on observations alone.


  • Open Access

    The “Shukla–Gutzler” Method for Estimating Potential Seasonal Predictability

    by Timothy DelSole, Xia Feng

    This paper reexamines a procedure proposed by Shukla and Gutzler for estimating potential seasonal predictability. Certain subtle and unverified assumptions required for the method to work are clarified, and Monte Carlo experiments are used to demonstrate that these assumptions are adequate even for autocorrelated processes in typical applications, provided the effective time scale T0 of the stochastic process is known. This paper highlights the fact that the time scale T0 is difficult to estimate reliably (as noted in other papers) and can be biased by an order of magnitude. This bias can seriously compromise the reliability of the Shukla–Gutzler method.


  • Open Access

    Decadal prediction of observed and simulated sea surface temperatures

    by Timothy DelSole, Liwei Jia, Michael K. Tippett

    A multivariate regression model derived from climate model simulations is shown to produce skillful predictions of unforced, annual mean sea surface temperature variations on multiyear time scales in observations and climate model simulations. Patterns that can be predicted with skill are identified explicitly and shown to arise from a combination of persistence and coupled interactions in the Pacific Ocean. Adding the regression model predictions to an estimate of the response to anthropogenic and natural forcing yields a prediction with higher skill than either alone, demonstrating the contribution of initial condition information to skill on multiyear time scales.


  • Rebound in Atmospheric Predictability and the Role of the Land Surface

    by Zhichang Guo, Paul A. Dirmeyer, Timothy DelSole, Randal D. Koster

    Total predictability within a chaotic system like the earth’s climate cannot increase over time. However, it can be transferred between subsystems. Predictability of air temperature and precipitation in numerical model forecasts over North America rebounds during late spring to summer because of information stored in the land surface. Specifically, soil moisture anomalies can persist over several months, but this memory cannot affect the atmosphere during early spring because of a lack of coupling between land and atmosphere. Coupling becomes established in late spring, enabling the effects of soil moisture anomalies to increase atmospheric predictability in 2-month forecasts begun as early as 1 May. This predictability is maintained through summer and then drops as coupling fades again in fall. This finding suggests summer forecasts of rainfall and air temperature over parts of North America could be significantly improved with soil moisture observations during spring.