Edgar Berdahl
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Edgar Berdahl has a total of 13 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Julius O. Smith
Stanford University Center for Computer Research in Music and Acoustics 660 Lomita Drive, Stanford, California 94305
5 shared publications- Günter Niemeyer
Stanford Univ., Mech. Eng., Bldg. 530, Stanford, CA 94305, USA
3 shared publications Gunter Niemeyer
Dept. of Music, CCRMA, Stanford Univ., Stanford, CA 94305
2 shared publicationsStephen D. Beck
Music, Louisiana State Univ., 102 New Music Bldg., Baton Rouge, LA 70803
2 shared publicationsAndrew Pfalz
Music, Louisiana State Univ., 102 New Music Bldg., Baton Rouge, LA 70803
1 shared publication- Dan Overholt
Aalborg University Copenhagen, København, Denmark
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 1 May 2017
- Published by Acoustical Society of America (ASA) in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Vol. 141 (5_Suppleme) , 3620
Audio-haptic interaction with modal synthesis models
Using a musical instrument that is augmented with haptic feedback, a performer can be enabled to haptically interact with a modal synthesis-based sound synthesizer. This subject is explored using the resonators object in Synth-A-Modeler. For synthesizing a single mode of vibration, the resonators object should be configured with a single frequency in Hertz, a single T60 exponential decay time in seconds, and a single equivalent mass in kg. Changing the mass not only changes the level of the output sound, it also changes how the mode feels when touched using haptic feedback. The resonators object can further be configured to represent a driving-point admittance corresponding to arbitrarily many modes of vibration. In this case, each mode of vibration is specified by its own frequency, decay time, and equivalent mass. Since the modal parameters can be determined using an automated procedure, it is possible to (within limits) approximately calibrate modal models using recordings of sounds that decay approximately exponentially. Various model structures incorporating the resonators object are presented in a variety of contexts. The musical application of these models is demonstrated alongside presentation of compositions that use them.
- 1 May 2017
- Published by Acoustical Society of America (ASA) in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Vol. 141 (5_Suppleme) , 3620
Audio-haptic interaction with modal synthesis models
Using a musical instrument that is augmented with haptic feedback, a performer can be enabled to haptically interact with a modal synthesis-based sound synthesizer. This subject is explored using the resonators object in Synth-A-Modeler. For synthesizing a single mode of vibration, the resonators object should be configured with a single frequency in Hertz, a single T60 exponential decay time in seconds, and a single equivalent mass in kg. Changing the mass not only changes the level of the output sound, it also changes how the mode feels when touched using haptic feedback. The resonators object can further be configured to represent a driving-point admittance corresponding to arbitrarily many modes of vibration. In this case, each mode of vibration is specified by its own frequency, decay time, and equivalent mass. Since the modal parameters can be determined using an automated procedure, it is possible to (within limits) approximately calibrate modal models using recordings of sounds that decay approximately exponentially. Various model structures incorporating the resonators object are presented in a variety of contexts. The musical application of these models is demonstrated alongside presentation of compositions that use them.
- 1 May 2017
- Published by Acoustical Society of America (ASA) in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Vol. 141 (5_Suppleme) , 3875-3876
Applying information theory to investigate music performance with continuous electronic sensors
A wide variety of electronic sensors can be used for designing new digital musical instruments and other human-computer interfaces. However, presently human abilities for continuously controlling such sensors are not well quantified. The field of information theory suggests that a human together with a user interface can be modeled as a communication channel. Previously, Fitts' Law used a discrete communications channel to model information conveyed by a human pointing at discrete targets. In contrast, the present work employs a continuous communications channel to model a human continuously controlling an analog-valued sensor. The Shannon-Hartley theorem implies that the channel capacity (e.g., HCI throughput) can be estimated by asking human subjects to perform gestures that match idealized, bandlimited Gaussian “target gestures” across a range of bandwidths. Then, the signal-to-noise ratio of the recorded gestures determines the channel capacity (e.g., HCI throughput). This approach is tested on human users alternately operating simple analog sensors. Suggestions are made for creating knowledge about user interfaces that could potentially transmit an enhanced amount of information to a computer.
- 1 May 2017
- Published by Acoustical Society of America (ASA) in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Vol. 141 (5_Suppleme) , 3875-3876
Applying information theory to investigate music performance with continuous electronic sensors
A wide variety of electronic sensors can be used for designing new digital musical instruments and other human-computer interfaces. However, presently human abilities for continuously controlling such sensors are not well quantified. The field of information theory suggests that a human together with a user interface can be modeled as a communication channel. Previously, Fitts' Law used a discrete communications channel to model information conveyed by a human pointing at discrete targets. In contrast, the present work employs a continuous communications channel to model a human continuously controlling an analog-valued sensor. The Shannon-Hartley theorem implies that the channel capacity (e.g., HCI throughput) can be estimated by asking human subjects to perform gestures that match idealized, bandlimited Gaussian “target gestures” across a range of bandwidths. Then, the signal-to-noise ratio of the recorded gestures determines the channel capacity (e.g., HCI throughput). This approach is tested on human users alternately operating simple analog sensors. Suggestions are made for creating knowledge about user interfaces that could potentially transmit an enhanced amount of information to a computer.
- 1 April 2016
- Published by Acoustical Society of America (ASA) in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Vol. 139 (4_Suppleme) , 2204
A physical model of a highly nonlinear string and its use in the music composition Quartet for Strings
A real-time virtual string model is created that supports two modes of haptic force-feedback interaction. Using one haptic controller, the string can be plucked, and using a second haptic controller, the virtual string's pitch can be continuously varied by applying pressure to the string. Via both controllers, the vibrations of the virtual string can be felt while it is played. These functionalities are achieved by modeling the string as a finite sequence of interleaved masses and stiffening springs. For artistic purposes, a nonlinear spring force characteristic function is selected that limits the effective stiffness of each spring to a range between k and (k + ks). This function is F(x) = kx + (ksx3)/(β2+x> + x2), where x is the displacement of the nonlinear spring and β approximately adjusts the displacement at which the stiffness becomes significantly nonlinear. For small displacements, the string's undamped fundamental frequency is tuned by k, and for sufficiently large displacements, the string's undamped fundamental frequency is approximately tuned by (k + ks). The composition Quartet for Strings features the model tuned to four different scales (treble 1, treble 2, alto, and bass), each of which is played by a human performer according to the score of Quartet for Strings. For this composition, (k + ks) is set so that when the string is vibrated at sufficiently large displacements, the pitch increases by approximately an octave but not precisely an octave, in order to provide for a more complex pitch space.
- 1 April 2016
- Published by Acoustical Society of America (ASA) in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Vol. 139 (4_Suppleme) , 2204
A physical model of a highly nonlinear string and its use in the music composition Quartet for Strings
A real-time virtual string model is created that supports two modes of haptic force-feedback interaction. Using one haptic controller, the string can be plucked, and using a second haptic controller, the virtual string's pitch can be continuously varied by applying pressure to the string. Via both controllers, the vibrations of the virtual string can be felt while it is played. These functionalities are achieved by modeling the string as a finite sequence of interleaved masses and stiffening springs. For artistic purposes, a nonlinear spring force characteristic function is selected that limits the effective stiffness of each spring to a range between k and (k + ks). This function is F(x) = kx + (ksx3)/(β2+x> + x2), where x is the displacement of the nonlinear spring and β approximately adjusts the displacement at which the stiffness becomes significantly nonlinear. For small displacements, the string's undamped fundamental frequency is tuned by k, and for sufficiently large displacements, the string's undamped fundamental frequency is approximately tuned by (k + ks). The composition Quartet for Strings features the model tuned to four different scales (treble 1, treble 2, alto, and bass), each of which is played by a human performer according to the score of Quartet for Strings. For this composition, (k + ks) is set so that when the string is vibrated at sufficiently large displacements, the pitch increases by approximately an octave but not precisely an octave, in order to provide for a more complex pitch space.
- 1 April 2016
- Published by Acoustical Society of America (ASA) in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Vol. 139 (4_Suppleme) , 2097
Electroacoustics laboratory assignments for computer music students
A series of pedagogical exercises are described that integrate concepts from traditional musical acoustics laboratory assignments with the fundamentals of computer music. Students are asked to rapidly prototype hybrid devices that contain both musical acoustic components as well as sensors, embedded audio signal processing, and loudspeaker drivers. To help students rapidly complete working prototypes, students are provided with working audio effects and sound synthesizer programs. Students learn the programming language (Pure Data) only by example for making small changes to the previously designed programs, as they are integrated with custom-made, physical acoustics components (e.g., D-I-Y vibrating strings, drums, columns of air, rattles, etc.). Music students first learned that building quality acoustic instrument components is harder than they originally thought. Although out-of-the-box thinking is regarded as an important factor in devising novel electroacoustic prototypes, students starting from previously existing designs and making small changes tended to be more successful (at least initially) than students striking out on completely new paths. Several pictures of completed instruments will be shown, and one or two example prototypes of electroacoustic instruments and electroacoustic audio effects will be presented live. The example “starter“ programs in Pure Data will be made available for community members wishing to run them on the Raspberry Pi 2, as supported by the author's Satellite CCRMA platform.
- 1 April 2016
- Published by Acoustical Society of America (ASA) in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Vol. 139 (4_Suppleme) , 2097
Electroacoustics laboratory assignments for computer music students
A series of pedagogical exercises are described that integrate concepts from traditional musical acoustics laboratory assignments with the fundamentals of computer music. Students are asked to rapidly prototype hybrid devices that contain both musical acoustic components as well as sensors, embedded audio signal processing, and loudspeaker drivers. To help students rapidly complete working prototypes, students are provided with working audio effects and sound synthesizer programs. Students learn the programming language (Pure Data) only by example for making small changes to the previously designed programs, as they are integrated with custom-made, physical acoustics components (e.g., D-I-Y vibrating strings, drums, columns of air, rattles, etc.). Music students first learned that building quality acoustic instrument components is harder than they originally thought. Although out-of-the-box thinking is regarded as an important factor in devising novel electroacoustic prototypes, students starting from previously existing designs and making small changes tended to be more successful (at least initially) than students striking out on completely new paths. Several pictures of completed instruments will be shown, and one or two example prototypes of electroacoustic instruments and electroacoustic audio effects will be presented live. The example “starter“ programs in Pure Data will be made available for community members wishing to run them on the Raspberry Pi 2, as supported by the author's Satellite CCRMA platform.
- 1 January 2012
- Published by Acoustical Society of America (ASA) in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Vol. 131 (1) , 963-973
Feedback control of acoustic musical instruments: Collocated control using physical analogs
Traditionally, the average professional musician has owned numerous acoustic musical instruments, many of them having distinctive acoustic qualities. However, a modern musician could prefer to have a single musical instrument whose acoustics are programmable by feedback control, where acoustic variables are estimated from sensor measurements in real time and then fed back in order to influence the controlled variables. In this paper, theory is presented that describes stable feedback control of an acoustic musical instrument. The presentation should be accessible to members of the musical acoustics community who may have limited or no experience with feedback control. First, the only control strategy guaranteed to be stable subject to any musical instrument mobility is described: the sensors and actuators must be collocated, and the controller must emulate a physical analog system. Next, the most fundamental feedback controllers and the corresponding physical analog systems are presented. The effects that these controllers have on acoustic musical instruments are described. Finally, practical design challenges are discussed. A proof explains why changing the resonance frequency of a musical resonance requires much more control power than changing the decay time of the resonance.
- 1 January 2012
- Published by Acoustical Society of America (ASA) in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Vol. 131 (1) , 963-973
Feedback control of acoustic musical instruments: Collocated control using physical analogs
Traditionally, the average professional musician has owned numerous acoustic musical instruments, many of them having distinctive acoustic qualities. However, a modern musician could prefer to have a single musical instrument whose acoustics are programmable by feedback control, where acoustic variables are estimated from sensor measurements in real time and then fed back in order to influence the controlled variables. In this paper, theory is presented that describes stable feedback control of an acoustic musical instrument. The presentation should be accessible to members of the musical acoustics community who may have limited or no experience with feedback control. First, the only control strategy guaranteed to be stable subject to any musical instrument mobility is described: the sensors and actuators must be collocated, and the controller must emulate a physical analog system. Next, the most fundamental feedback controllers and the corresponding physical analog systems are presented. The effects that these controllers have on acoustic musical instruments are described. Finally, practical design challenges are discussed. A proof explains why changing the resonance frequency of a musical resonance requires much more control power than changing the decay time of the resonance.
- 1 April 2011
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Organised Sound
- Vol. 16 (2) , 154-165
Advancements in Actuated Musical Instruments
This article presents recent developments in actuated musical instruments created by the authors, who also describe an ecosystemic model of actuated performance activities that blur traditional boundaries between the physical and virtual elements of musical interfaces. Actuated musical instruments are physical instruments that have been endowed with virtual qualities controlled by a computer in real-time but which are neverthelesstangible. These instruments provide intuitive and engaging new forms of interaction. They are different from traditional (acoustic) and fully automated (robotic) instruments in that they produce sound via vibrating element(s) that are co-manipulated by humans and electromechanical systems. We examine the possibilities that arise when such instruments are played in different performative environments and music-making scenarios, and we postulate that such designs may give rise to new methods of musical performance. The Haptic Drum, the Feedback Resonance Guitar, the Electromagnetically Prepared Piano, the Overtone Fiddle and Teleoperation with Robothands are described, along with musical examples and reflections on the emergent properties of the performance ecologies that these instruments enable. We look at some of the conceptual and perceptual issues introduced by actuated musical instruments, and finally we propose some directions in which such research may be headed in the future.
- 1 April 2011
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Organised Sound
- Vol. 16 (2) , 154-165
Advancements in Actuated Musical Instruments
This article presents recent developments in actuated musical instruments created by the authors, who also describe an ecosystemic model of actuated performance activities that blur traditional boundaries between the physical and virtual elements of musical interfaces. Actuated musical instruments are physical instruments that have been endowed with virtual qualities controlled by a computer in real-time but which are neverthelesstangible. These instruments provide intuitive and engaging new forms of interaction. They are different from traditional (acoustic) and fully automated (robotic) instruments in that they produce sound via vibrating element(s) that are co-manipulated by humans and electromechanical systems. We examine the possibilities that arise when such instruments are played in different performative environments and music-making scenarios, and we postulate that such designs may give rise to new methods of musical performance. The Haptic Drum, the Feedback Resonance Guitar, the Electromagnetically Prepared Piano, the Overtone Fiddle and Teleoperation with Robothands are described, along with musical examples and reflections on the emergent properties of the performance ecologies that these instruments enable. We look at some of the conceptual and perceptual issues introduced by actuated musical instruments, and finally we propose some directions in which such research may be headed in the future.
- 1 March 2010
- Published by Acoustical Society of America (ASA) in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Vol. 127 (3_Suppleme) , 1737
A physically motivated room reverberation enhancement system that is stable in any (passive) room.
Prior active room reverberation enhancement systems have typically employed microphones, artificial reverberator filters, and loudspeakers to change the reverberant properties of a room. However, acoustic feedback from the loudspeakers to the microphones has had the potential to drive such systems unstable. In contrast, techniques from feedback control can be used to design a stable room reverberation enhancement system from the ground up. A feedback controller implements a passive connection between virtual acoustic spaces, which are realized using digital waveguidenetworks, and special transducers, which operate concurrently as microphones and loudspeakers. Because the feedback controller models a passive system, it is theoretically stable for arbitrarily large loop gains in any (passive) acoustic environment. As a consequence, the system does not suffer from “ringing tones” at high‐loop gains in the same way as prior systems have suffered. Furthermore, the system does not need to be re‐calibrated if the properties of the room change or even if moved to a whole new room. Finally, this method for designing room reverberation enhancement systems may generally result in more realistic reverberant sound because it implements the acoustical features of a system that could exist naturally in the physical world.
- 1 March 2010
- Published by Acoustical Society of America (ASA) in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Vol. 127 (3_Suppleme) , 1737
A physically motivated room reverberation enhancement system that is stable in any (passive) room.
Prior active room reverberation enhancement systems have typically employed microphones, artificial reverberator filters, and loudspeakers to change the reverberant properties of a room. However, acoustic feedback from the loudspeakers to the microphones has had the potential to drive such systems unstable. In contrast, techniques from feedback control can be used to design a stable room reverberation enhancement system from the ground up. A feedback controller implements a passive connection between virtual acoustic spaces, which are realized using digital waveguidenetworks, and special transducers, which operate concurrently as microphones and loudspeakers. Because the feedback controller models a passive system, it is theoretically stable for arbitrarily large loop gains in any (passive) acoustic environment. As a consequence, the system does not suffer from “ringing tones” at high‐loop gains in the same way as prior systems have suffered. Furthermore, the system does not need to be re‐calibrated if the properties of the room change or even if moved to a whole new room. Finally, this method for designing room reverberation enhancement systems may generally result in more realistic reverberant sound because it implements the acoustical features of a system that could exist naturally in the physical world.
- 1 March 2010
- Published by Acoustical Society of America (ASA) in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Vol. 127 (3_Suppleme) , 1733
Haptic interaction for music with unrestricted freedom of the musician’s motion: Promoting augmented interaction with physical tools.
A haptic musical instrument is an electromechanical musical instrument that provides a musician not only with audio feedback but also with force feedback. Many commercial force feedback devices consist of a tool, such as a thimble or pen, attached to the end of a robotic arm. The musician can grab onto the tool and use it to manipulate a virtual musical instrument. While this configuration provides multiple degrees of freedom, it is suboptimal for many musical interactions. For instance, typically the workspace of the arm is restricted, which can detract from the musician’s enjoyment of the experience. The workspace restriction can be resolved by freeing the tool from the end of the haptic device and having the musician hold the tool, which may be a plectrum, bow, or drumstick, in his or her hand. Further benefits can be reaped if multiple points of haptic interaction are available, enabling the musician to manipulate the points and move freely in between them. A dual voice coil woofer provides a convenient collocated sensor/motor for constructing a single degree-of-freedom point of haptic interaction. We present an example instrument in which a musician employs a conventional plectrum to interact with a virtual digital waveguide string.
- 1 March 2010
- Published by Acoustical Society of America (ASA) in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Vol. 127 (3_Suppleme) , 1733
Haptic interaction for music with unrestricted freedom of the musician’s motion: Promoting augmented interaction with physical tools.
A haptic musical instrument is an electromechanical musical instrument that provides a musician not only with audio feedback but also with force feedback. Many commercial force feedback devices consist of a tool, such as a thimble or pen, attached to the end of a robotic arm. The musician can grab onto the tool and use it to manipulate a virtual musical instrument. While this configuration provides multiple degrees of freedom, it is suboptimal for many musical interactions. For instance, typically the workspace of the arm is restricted, which can detract from the musician’s enjoyment of the experience. The workspace restriction can be resolved by freeing the tool from the end of the haptic device and having the musician hold the tool, which may be a plectrum, bow, or drumstick, in his or her hand. Further benefits can be reaped if multiple points of haptic interaction are available, enabling the musician to manipulate the points and move freely in between them. A dual voice coil woofer provides a convenient collocated sensor/motor for constructing a single degree-of-freedom point of haptic interaction. We present an example instrument in which a musician employs a conventional plectrum to interact with a virtual digital waveguide string.
- 1 May 2008
- Published by Acoustical Society of America (ASA) in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Vol. 123 (5_Suppleme) , 3873
Practical implementation of low-latency DSP for feedback control of sound in research contexts
Feedback control of sound requires low‐latency signal processing. In addition, because the human range of hearing extends roughly from 20 Hz to 20 kHz, controllerhardware must process signals with relatively large bandwidths in comparison with common control applications. Over the past decade, the appropriate embedded hardware has become a niche product, so its cost has actually increased. The open source community has developed an excellent alternative: a general‐purpose computer runs Linux with the real‐ time application interface (RTAI). Open source drivers (see www.comedi.org) enable software to communicate efficiently with data acquisition cards. For the first time, we describe in detail from start to finish how to configure such a system. In particular, we explain how to run control code from user space while still disabling interrupts. We further explain how to reserve a processor for running only feedback control code. This configuration achieves less than one sample of total system delay at sampling rates as high as 50 kHz. Other processors remain free to run standard Linux programs, allowing researchers to control sound with calls to many generic software libraries. We present detailed measurements of system jitter for various configurations and provide an example open‐source toolbox demonstrating all these aspects at http://ccrma.stanford.edu/̃eberdahl/Projects/TFCMI.
- 1 May 2008
- Published by Acoustical Society of America (ASA) in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Vol. 123 (5_Suppleme) , 3873
Practical implementation of low-latency DSP for feedback control of sound in research contexts
Feedback control of sound requires low‐latency signal processing. In addition, because the human range of hearing extends roughly from 20 Hz to 20 kHz, controllerhardware must process signals with relatively large bandwidths in comparison with common control applications. Over the past decade, the appropriate embedded hardware has become a niche product, so its cost has actually increased. The open source community has developed an excellent alternative: a general‐purpose computer runs Linux with the real‐ time application interface (RTAI). Open source drivers (see www.comedi.org) enable software to communicate efficiently with data acquisition cards. For the first time, we describe in detail from start to finish how to configure such a system. In particular, we explain how to run control code from user space while still disabling interrupts. We further explain how to reserve a processor for running only feedback control code. This configuration achieves less than one sample of total system delay at sampling rates as high as 50 kHz. Other processors remain free to run standard Linux programs, allowing researchers to control sound with calls to many generic software libraries. We present detailed measurements of system jitter for various configurations and provide an example open‐source toolbox demonstrating all these aspects at http://ccrma.stanford.edu/̃eberdahl/Projects/TFCMI.
- 1 May 2008
- Published by Acoustical Society of America (ASA) in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Vol. 123 (5_Suppleme) , 3666
Active control of a vibrating string
We discuss the specifics of applying active feedback control to a vibrating string. Using sensors, actuators, and digital controller hardware, we make the acoustics of the string programmable, yet the string retains its tangible qualities. As a consequence, fretting, bowing, and plucking controlled and uncontrolled strings have similar physical consequences. Consider that any controller emulating a network of springs, masses, and dashpots attached to the string is a passive controller. To allow the string's acoustics to be programmable over a wide range, we should be able to implement passive controllers. This means that there must be at least one linear and collocated sensor/actuator pair. We explain how to construct such a pair in the laboratory. Finally, we explain one controller particular to one‐dimensional systems such as vibrating strings. Whenever the sensor detects a pulse arriving, the actuator emits a new pulse. The output spectrum consists of a harmonic series proportional to the sampling of the product of the pulse's Fourier transform and the transfer function from the actuator to the sound recording device. Sound examples are presented. Finally, we discuss an open source environment we have created for adjusting controller parameters in real time from standard computer musicsoftware.
- 1 May 2008
- Published by Acoustical Society of America (ASA) in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Vol. 123 (5_Suppleme) , 3666
Active control of a vibrating string
We discuss the specifics of applying active feedback control to a vibrating string. Using sensors, actuators, and digital controller hardware, we make the acoustics of the string programmable, yet the string retains its tangible qualities. As a consequence, fretting, bowing, and plucking controlled and uncontrolled strings have similar physical consequences. Consider that any controller emulating a network of springs, masses, and dashpots attached to the string is a passive controller. To allow the string's acoustics to be programmable over a wide range, we should be able to implement passive controllers. This means that there must be at least one linear and collocated sensor/actuator pair. We explain how to construct such a pair in the laboratory. Finally, we explain one controller particular to one‐dimensional systems such as vibrating strings. Whenever the sensor detects a pulse arriving, the actuator emits a new pulse. The output spectrum consists of a harmonic series proportional to the sampling of the product of the pulse's Fourier transform and the transfer function from the actuator to the sound recording device. Sound examples are presented. Finally, we discuss an open source environment we have created for adjusting controller parameters in real time from standard computer musicsoftware.