Jennifer S. Shane
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Jennifer S. Shane has a total of 49 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jin Ouk Choi
Univ. of Nevada, Las Vegas
6 shared publications - Douglas D. Gransberg
President, Gransberg & Associates, Inc., P.O. Box 2395, Norman, OK 73070. ORCID:
5 shared publications - Ghada Moustafa Gad
Associate Professor, Dept. of Civil Engineering, California State Polytechnic Univ., 3801 W. Temple Ave., Pomona, CA 91767. ORCID:
5 shared publications - Cliff Schexnayder
Eminent Scholar Emeritus, Del E. Webb School of Construction, Arizona State Univ., P.O. Box 2428, Branford, CT 06405
4 shared publications - Keith R. Molenaar
Professor, Dept. of Civil, Environmental and Architectural Engineering, Univ. of Colorado, 428 UCB, 1111 Engineering Dr., Boulder, CO 80309-0428. ORCID:
4 shared publications - Binit Kumar Shrestha
Ph.D. Student, Dept. of Civil and Environmental Engineering and Construction, Univ. of Nevada, Las Vegas, 4505 S. Maryland Pkwy., Las Vegas, NV 89154. ORCID:
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 29 September 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
- Vol. 2678 (6) , 542-557
BECO (Business, Engineering, Construction, and Other) Framework for Providing Effective and Comprehensive Supportive Services to Disadvantaged Business Enterprises in the United States
The Disadvantaged Business Enterprise program, established by the United States Department of Transportation, aims to remove barriers to participation of Disadvantaged Business Enterprises (DBEs) in highway projects, to promote the use of DBEs in federally assisted contracts, and to assist the development of DBEs. A DBE is a small, for-profit business owned by socially and economically disadvantaged individuals such as women or minorities. DBEs need various supportive services, depending on many factors, such as business area, size, and strategy. State Departments of Transportation often provide or hire third parties to provide supportive services to DBEs that are relatively expensive and inefficient. These services may also support only some and unintentionally exclude other DBEs. Under many challenges, one ultimate goal is to find a framework that covers all valuable DBE supportive services. This study proposes, tests, and validates a framework for providing effective and comprehensive DBE supportive services in the transportation sector. Based on discussions with DBE liaison officers and service providers, we propose the business, engineering, construction, and other (BECO) framework to provide DBE supportive services. We then use a sequential explanatory design in mixed methods, collecting quantitative and qualitative data to evaluate and validate the BECO framework. We analyze quantitative data using confirmatory factor analysis and qualitative data using pattern coding techniques. The results provide insights and reveal useful DBE supportive services using the BECO framework. The framework is useful for assessing DBE needs, informing DBE liaison officers and service providers, and offering the most useful supportive services to DBEs.
- 29 September 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
- Vol. 2678 (6) , 542-557
BECO (Business, Engineering, Construction, and Other) Framework for Providing Effective and Comprehensive Supportive Services to Disadvantaged Business Enterprises in the United States
The Disadvantaged Business Enterprise program, established by the United States Department of Transportation, aims to remove barriers to participation of Disadvantaged Business Enterprises (DBEs) in highway projects, to promote the use of DBEs in federally assisted contracts, and to assist the development of DBEs. A DBE is a small, for-profit business owned by socially and economically disadvantaged individuals such as women or minorities. DBEs need various supportive services, depending on many factors, such as business area, size, and strategy. State Departments of Transportation often provide or hire third parties to provide supportive services to DBEs that are relatively expensive and inefficient. These services may also support only some and unintentionally exclude other DBEs. Under many challenges, one ultimate goal is to find a framework that covers all valuable DBE supportive services. This study proposes, tests, and validates a framework for providing effective and comprehensive DBE supportive services in the transportation sector. Based on discussions with DBE liaison officers and service providers, we propose the business, engineering, construction, and other (BECO) framework to provide DBE supportive services. We then use a sequential explanatory design in mixed methods, collecting quantitative and qualitative data to evaluate and validate the BECO framework. We analyze quantitative data using confirmatory factor analysis and qualitative data using pattern coding techniques. The results provide insights and reveal useful DBE supportive services using the BECO framework. The framework is useful for assessing DBE needs, informing DBE liaison officers and service providers, and offering the most useful supportive services to DBEs.
- 1 September 2020
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Management in Engineering
- Vol. 36 (5) , 04020042
Innovative Technologies and Management Approaches for Facility Design Standardization and Modularization of Capital Projects
Recently, the emergence of new technologies has renewed interest in modularization and facility design standardization. However, the application of both facility design standardization and modularization is still limited in capital projects, especially in upstream, midstream, and mining (UMM) sector projects such as natural gas processing and compressor station projects or well sites projects. The purpose of this study is to identify innovative technologies and management approaches (ITAs) that support achieving higher levels of facility design standardization and modularization in capital projects. Specifically, the authors analyzed the impact and likelihood of occurrence of these ITAs within the next 5 years. The analysis results show that ITAs such as modularization and standardization, lidar, stakeholder engagement and alignment, and discipline to maintain standardization have high impacts and high likelihoods of occurrence in the next 5 years. Other results explore a cooperative culture to support standardization and industrial robots to be ITAs, with significant statistical differences, which elucidate differences in opinions between owners and contractors. The authors also conducted a case study analysis to benchmark real-life standardized projects and derive lessons learned from such projects pertinent to ITAs. This study will help industry practitioners identify ITAs for better project planning, management, and execution of standardized projects as well as serve as the foundation for future studies on the planning and management of ITAs. Furthermore, this study will help capital projects to achieve higher levels of facility design standardization and modularization with greater predictability, agility, and improved cost-effectiveness.
- 1 September 2020
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Management in Engineering
- Vol. 36 (5) , 04020042
Innovative Technologies and Management Approaches for Facility Design Standardization and Modularization of Capital Projects
Recently, the emergence of new technologies has renewed interest in modularization and facility design standardization. However, the application of both facility design standardization and modularization is still limited in capital projects, especially in upstream, midstream, and mining (UMM) sector projects such as natural gas processing and compressor station projects or well sites projects. The purpose of this study is to identify innovative technologies and management approaches (ITAs) that support achieving higher levels of facility design standardization and modularization in capital projects. Specifically, the authors analyzed the impact and likelihood of occurrence of these ITAs within the next 5 years. The analysis results show that ITAs such as modularization and standardization, lidar, stakeholder engagement and alignment, and discipline to maintain standardization have high impacts and high likelihoods of occurrence in the next 5 years. Other results explore a cooperative culture to support standardization and industrial robots to be ITAs, with significant statistical differences, which elucidate differences in opinions between owners and contractors. The authors also conducted a case study analysis to benchmark real-life standardized projects and derive lessons learned from such projects pertinent to ITAs. This study will help industry practitioners identify ITAs for better project planning, management, and execution of standardized projects as well as serve as the foundation for future studies on the planning and management of ITAs. Furthermore, this study will help capital projects to achieve higher levels of facility design standardization and modularization with greater predictability, agility, and improved cost-effectiveness.
- 1 July 2020
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Management in Engineering
- Vol. 36 (4) , 06020003
How Design Standardization CSFs Can Impact Project Performance of Capital Projects
Standardization is a commonplace idea today; however, capital projects have not been able to achieve high levels of facility design standardization. The Construction Industry Institute (CII) identified 15 standardization critical success factors (CSFs) for capital projects, particularly the upstream, midstream, and mining sector, to help the practitioners achieve higher levels of facility design standardization in capital projects. However, there is a need to better understand the CSFs comprehensively by analyzing data from actual standardized projects. To fill this gap, this study examined CSFs’ degrees of accomplishment, as well as project performance scores for different metrics, and have analyzed a correlation between CSFs’ accomplishment and the project performance of 43 projects. The results show that the more standardization CSFs are accomplished, the better the project performances. This research also identified which CSFs are commonly accomplished and which CSFs are challenging to accomplish by analyzing the degree of accomplishment of each CSF. The results show that Basic Engineering Design Data, Operations and Maintenance, Technology Maturity, and Experience and Capability of Project Team are the CSFs that are more commonly accomplished, whereas Constructability of Standardization and Feasibility Analysis of Standardization are the CSFs that the industry finds difficult to accomplish. The research findings will help the industry to understand better the importance of the CSFs, which will lead them to achieve better project performance for capital projects.
- 1 July 2020
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Management in Engineering
- Vol. 36 (4) , 06020003
How Design Standardization CSFs Can Impact Project Performance of Capital Projects
Standardization is a commonplace idea today; however, capital projects have not been able to achieve high levels of facility design standardization. The Construction Industry Institute (CII) identified 15 standardization critical success factors (CSFs) for capital projects, particularly the upstream, midstream, and mining sector, to help the practitioners achieve higher levels of facility design standardization in capital projects. However, there is a need to better understand the CSFs comprehensively by analyzing data from actual standardized projects. To fill this gap, this study examined CSFs’ degrees of accomplishment, as well as project performance scores for different metrics, and have analyzed a correlation between CSFs’ accomplishment and the project performance of 43 projects. The results show that the more standardization CSFs are accomplished, the better the project performances. This research also identified which CSFs are commonly accomplished and which CSFs are challenging to accomplish by analyzing the degree of accomplishment of each CSF. The results show that Basic Engineering Design Data, Operations and Maintenance, Technology Maturity, and Experience and Capability of Project Team are the CSFs that are more commonly accomplished, whereas Constructability of Standardization and Feasibility Analysis of Standardization are the CSFs that the industry finds difficult to accomplish. The research findings will help the industry to understand better the importance of the CSFs, which will lead them to achieve better project performance for capital projects.
- 21 September 2018
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
- Vol. 2672 (26) , 106-113
Effective Post-Construction Evaluation Practices for Work Zone Management Strategies
State departments of transportation (DOTs) invest a significant amount of effort to develop and implement transportation management plans (TMPs) in order to effectively manage the traffic flow of work zones and secure the safety of workers and the traveling public during construction of highway projects. State DOTs typically spend an average 3% to 5% of the total construction cost for TMP development and implementation, but some urban projects, in highly congested areas, may require up to 30% of the total construction cost for this effort. For continuous improvement of TMP development and implementation, it is critically important to monitor the performance of work zone management strategies during construction and evaluate them at the conclusion of construction. However, most state DOTs lack structured policies and/or work processes to ensure the implementation of these important monitoring and evaluation components as part of the TMP. A working feedback loop must be established in the project delivery process to document lessons learned, successes and failures, potential changes to the TMP, and transfer them back to the early TMP development stage. This research extensively reviews existing literature and evaluates the current practices of monitoring and evaluating work zone management strategies. This study identifies and presents effective practices for continuous improvement of TMP development and implementation through creating a working feedback loop.
- 21 September 2018
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
- Vol. 2672 (26) , 106-113
Effective Post-Construction Evaluation Practices for Work Zone Management Strategies
State departments of transportation (DOTs) invest a significant amount of effort to develop and implement transportation management plans (TMPs) in order to effectively manage the traffic flow of work zones and secure the safety of workers and the traveling public during construction of highway projects. State DOTs typically spend an average 3% to 5% of the total construction cost for TMP development and implementation, but some urban projects, in highly congested areas, may require up to 30% of the total construction cost for this effort. For continuous improvement of TMP development and implementation, it is critically important to monitor the performance of work zone management strategies during construction and evaluate them at the conclusion of construction. However, most state DOTs lack structured policies and/or work processes to ensure the implementation of these important monitoring and evaluation components as part of the TMP. A working feedback loop must be established in the project delivery process to document lessons learned, successes and failures, potential changes to the TMP, and transfer them back to the early TMP development stage. This research extensively reviews existing literature and evaluates the current practices of monitoring and evaluating work zone management strategies. This study identifies and presents effective practices for continuous improvement of TMP development and implementation through creating a working feedback loop.
- 29 March 2018
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE)
- p. 278-287
Achieving Higher Levels of Facility Design Standardization in the Upstream, Midstream, and Mining Commodity Sector: Barriers and Challenges
Previous research by the Construction Industry Institute (CII) has recognized that the shipbuilding industry has accomplished high levels of both design standardization and modularization, reaping substantial benefits. In addition, to maximize modularization benefits on capital projects, the levels of design standardization also must be increased substantially. However, the levels of standardized facility design in the upstream, midstream, and mining commodity (UMMC) market fall short of the desired criteria. As the market understands and recognizes its value more fully, the level of design standardization will increase. The CII UMMC standardization research team was established in 2017 to address this situation. In framing their purpose, the team posed this question: How can higher levels of facility design standardization be achieved in the UMMC sector? To answer this research question, first, there was a need to better understand barriers and challenges of achieving higher levels of facility design standardization in the UMMC market. Thus, this paper focuses on identifying these barriers and challenges by conducting an extensive literature review and subject matter expert interviews. The authors have concluded from this study that the key barriers and challenges rest with owners, standard and specs, engineers, mindset/culture of customization, quality vendor availability and as such. These have been further explained in later sections of this paper. Facility owner/operators, contractors, and fabricators will be the beneficiaries of this research, especially those from the UMMC Market.
- 29 March 2018
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE)
- p. 278-287
Achieving Higher Levels of Facility Design Standardization in the Upstream, Midstream, and Mining Commodity Sector: Barriers and Challenges
Previous research by the Construction Industry Institute (CII) has recognized that the shipbuilding industry has accomplished high levels of both design standardization and modularization, reaping substantial benefits. In addition, to maximize modularization benefits on capital projects, the levels of design standardization also must be increased substantially. However, the levels of standardized facility design in the upstream, midstream, and mining commodity (UMMC) market fall short of the desired criteria. As the market understands and recognizes its value more fully, the level of design standardization will increase. The CII UMMC standardization research team was established in 2017 to address this situation. In framing their purpose, the team posed this question: How can higher levels of facility design standardization be achieved in the UMMC sector? To answer this research question, first, there was a need to better understand barriers and challenges of achieving higher levels of facility design standardization in the UMMC market. Thus, this paper focuses on identifying these barriers and challenges by conducting an extensive literature review and subject matter expert interviews. The authors have concluded from this study that the key barriers and challenges rest with owners, standard and specs, engineers, mindset/culture of customization, quality vendor availability and as such. These have been further explained in later sections of this paper. Facility owner/operators, contractors, and fabricators will be the beneficiaries of this research, especially those from the UMMC Market.
- 29 March 2018
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE)
- p. 118-127
Assessing ABET Outcomes in Construction Engineering Curriculum
There are currently seventeen ABET (Accreditation Board for Engineering and Technology) accredited construction engineering programs in the United States and 245 civil engineering programs. Every 6 years these programs undergo a stringent review to assure that the programs meet the quality standards expected for the engineering profession. As part of this review, programs must demonstrate that upon graduation, students have achieved a set of eleven student outcomes, affectionately known as (a) through (k). These eleven outcomes are the same, regardless of which engineering program they are being applied, civil, construction, mechanical, chemical, or agricultural. Some programs have found it useful to develop a set of rubrics that can be used to evaluate student’s work, to demonstrate student achievement of the outcomes. While some programs have worked through this exercise, few examples were found to directly relate to construction engineering curriculum. In preparation for the next ABET review, one university, with the largest construction engineering undergraduate enrollment, worked with faculty and industry to develop rubrics to evaluate student performance related to the student outcomes that are intended to directly represent the construction engineering profession. The process and rubrics are described in this paper and can be helpful for other programs aspiring to ABET accreditation or expecting an ABET accreditation review.
- 29 March 2018
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE)
- p. 118-127
Assessing ABET Outcomes in Construction Engineering Curriculum
There are currently seventeen ABET (Accreditation Board for Engineering and Technology) accredited construction engineering programs in the United States and 245 civil engineering programs. Every 6 years these programs undergo a stringent review to assure that the programs meet the quality standards expected for the engineering profession. As part of this review, programs must demonstrate that upon graduation, students have achieved a set of eleven student outcomes, affectionately known as (a) through (k). These eleven outcomes are the same, regardless of which engineering program they are being applied, civil, construction, mechanical, chemical, or agricultural. Some programs have found it useful to develop a set of rubrics that can be used to evaluate student’s work, to demonstrate student achievement of the outcomes. While some programs have worked through this exercise, few examples were found to directly relate to construction engineering curriculum. In preparation for the next ABET review, one university, with the largest construction engineering undergraduate enrollment, worked with faculty and industry to develop rubrics to evaluate student performance related to the student outcomes that are intended to directly represent the construction engineering profession. The process and rubrics are described in this paper and can be helpful for other programs aspiring to ABET accreditation or expecting an ABET accreditation review.
- 29 March 2018
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE)
- p. 744-754
Construction Manager General Contractor (CMGC) Characteristics and Effective Practices in Transportation Sector
The United States (U.S.) Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) every day counts (EDC) identified the construction manager general contractor (CMGC) as a unique project delivery method to accelerate the delivery of highway projects and to address the challenges presented by limited budgets. State transportation agencies (STAs) recognize CMGC has more benefits than challenges and many are exploring and using CMGC on highway projects. Many research efforts have found benefits and challenges from owner’s perspectives. However, limited research has focused on characteristics and effective practices of successful CMGC projects from perspectives of design professionals and general contractors. Both designers and contractors with limited CMGC experience need more guidance to optimize the value of CMGC project delivery for the owner. The scope of this study is to identify CMGC characteristics and effective practices by conducting literature reviews of successful CMGC projects and semi-structured interviews with design professionals and general contractors. Qualitative analysis formulates a two-dimensional framework for CMGC characteristics. These two dimensions are static project characteristics and dynamic team characteristics. Static project characteristics include cost-effectiveness, schedule sensitivity, innovation, constructability review, and risk management. Dynamic team characteristics include leadership, teamwork cycle, and culture of trust. The teamwork cycle consists of communication, collaboration, and integration for CMGC effective practices include a new model, general protocols, and specific practices. This paper summarized CMGC characteristics and effective practices for future project and team selections, proper risk allocation, and overall project success using CMGC project delivery method. The CMGC characteristics and effective practices will help both owner and contractors use CMGC to deliver highway projects with reduced cost, accelerated schedule, and improved quality and satisfaction.
- 29 March 2018
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE)
- p. 744-754
Construction Manager General Contractor (CMGC) Characteristics and Effective Practices in Transportation Sector
The United States (U.S.) Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) every day counts (EDC) identified the construction manager general contractor (CMGC) as a unique project delivery method to accelerate the delivery of highway projects and to address the challenges presented by limited budgets. State transportation agencies (STAs) recognize CMGC has more benefits than challenges and many are exploring and using CMGC on highway projects. Many research efforts have found benefits and challenges from owner’s perspectives. However, limited research has focused on characteristics and effective practices of successful CMGC projects from perspectives of design professionals and general contractors. Both designers and contractors with limited CMGC experience need more guidance to optimize the value of CMGC project delivery for the owner. The scope of this study is to identify CMGC characteristics and effective practices by conducting literature reviews of successful CMGC projects and semi-structured interviews with design professionals and general contractors. Qualitative analysis formulates a two-dimensional framework for CMGC characteristics. These two dimensions are static project characteristics and dynamic team characteristics. Static project characteristics include cost-effectiveness, schedule sensitivity, innovation, constructability review, and risk management. Dynamic team characteristics include leadership, teamwork cycle, and culture of trust. The teamwork cycle consists of communication, collaboration, and integration for CMGC effective practices include a new model, general protocols, and specific practices. This paper summarized CMGC characteristics and effective practices for future project and team selections, proper risk allocation, and overall project success using CMGC project delivery method. The CMGC characteristics and effective practices will help both owner and contractors use CMGC to deliver highway projects with reduced cost, accelerated schedule, and improved quality and satisfaction.
- 29 March 2018
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE)
- p. 439-448
Resource-Based Exploratory Analysis of Project Complexity Impact on Phase-Based Cost Performance Behavior
In the field of construction engineering, practitioners frequently encounter uncertainties in the process of decision-making and management of complex projects. These uncertainties associated with project complexity, which vastly affect the project development and execution process, may cause favorable/unfavorable impacts on projects cost performance. Several scholars believe that project complexity may cause unintended consequences on project performance; however, some other researchers stated that complex projects might receive higher attention and more resources and as a result, may face less cost overruns. Therefore, this study initially aims investigate the impact of complexity on phase-based cost performance. For this reason, 44 case studies consisting 30 high complexity projects and 14 low complexity ones were collected. Then, engineering, procurement and construction (EPC) phase cost performance of high and low complexity projects were studied and compared. To analyze the collected data, two-sample t-test was utilized. Analysis indicated that complex projects have better EPC phase cost performance compared to low complexity ones. Finally, to find out the underlying causes of better cost performance of high complexity projects in comparison with low complexity ones, the allocated resources and implemented best practices (BPs) were studied. It was observed that high-level of constructability, alignment, partnering, front-end planning, team building, and change management best practices were implemented in complex projects. The findings of this study can help project/program managers (PM) to better understand the phase-based behavior of cost performance in complex projects, and hence implement strategies and allocate resources effectively and efficiently in complex projects.
- 29 March 2018
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE)
- p. 439-448
Resource-Based Exploratory Analysis of Project Complexity Impact on Phase-Based Cost Performance Behavior
In the field of construction engineering, practitioners frequently encounter uncertainties in the process of decision-making and management of complex projects. These uncertainties associated with project complexity, which vastly affect the project development and execution process, may cause favorable/unfavorable impacts on projects cost performance. Several scholars believe that project complexity may cause unintended consequences on project performance; however, some other researchers stated that complex projects might receive higher attention and more resources and as a result, may face less cost overruns. Therefore, this study initially aims investigate the impact of complexity on phase-based cost performance. For this reason, 44 case studies consisting 30 high complexity projects and 14 low complexity ones were collected. Then, engineering, procurement and construction (EPC) phase cost performance of high and low complexity projects were studied and compared. To analyze the collected data, two-sample t-test was utilized. Analysis indicated that complex projects have better EPC phase cost performance compared to low complexity ones. Finally, to find out the underlying causes of better cost performance of high complexity projects in comparison with low complexity ones, the allocated resources and implemented best practices (BPs) were studied. It was observed that high-level of constructability, alignment, partnering, front-end planning, team building, and change management best practices were implemented in complex projects. The findings of this study can help project/program managers (PM) to better understand the phase-based behavior of cost performance in complex projects, and hence implement strategies and allocate resources effectively and efficiently in complex projects.
- 29 March 2018
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE)
- p. 343-350
Understanding Theory of Project Management for Complex Civil Infrastructure
To date, understanding and balancing the iron triangle (traditional three-dimensional project management theory) has been perceived as fundamental project management. However, previous studies have shown that large complex transportation infrastructure projects continually suffer from poor performance in terms of cost, schedule, and deliverables. Recent studies have shown that the current project management body of knowledge (traditional three-dimensional project management theory) may not be adequate to address interrelated and dependent variables encountered on complex civil infrastructure projects. Recent empirical evidence suggests the presence of five dimensions of complex civil infrastructure projects: cost, schedule, technical, context (externalities), and financing that need to be effectively managed on complex civil infrastructure projects. For successful transportation project management, there is a critical need to understand the complex civil infrastructure projects and identify interrelationships among the five dimensions. The aim of this paper is to present a comprehensive review of the literature on complex projects, complexity theories, and five dimensions. This paper provides useful insights into the importance of the understanding the complex civil infrastructure projects, summaries from published literatures on five dimensions and complexity theories.
- 29 March 2018
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE)
- p. 343-350
Understanding Theory of Project Management for Complex Civil Infrastructure
To date, understanding and balancing the iron triangle (traditional three-dimensional project management theory) has been perceived as fundamental project management. However, previous studies have shown that large complex transportation infrastructure projects continually suffer from poor performance in terms of cost, schedule, and deliverables. Recent studies have shown that the current project management body of knowledge (traditional three-dimensional project management theory) may not be adequate to address interrelated and dependent variables encountered on complex civil infrastructure projects. Recent empirical evidence suggests the presence of five dimensions of complex civil infrastructure projects: cost, schedule, technical, context (externalities), and financing that need to be effectively managed on complex civil infrastructure projects. For successful transportation project management, there is a critical need to understand the complex civil infrastructure projects and identify interrelationships among the five dimensions. The aim of this paper is to present a comprehensive review of the literature on complex projects, complexity theories, and five dimensions. This paper provides useful insights into the importance of the understanding the complex civil infrastructure projects, summaries from published literatures on five dimensions and complexity theories.
- 1 November 2017
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction
- Vol. 9 (4)
Culture-Risk-Trust Model for Dispute-Resolution Method Selection in International Construction Contracts
Despite the attractive opportunities that international construction offers, companies need to account for risks of moving into international markets, including major contractual and cultural risks. This paper focuses on the selection of the dispute-resolution method (DRM) clause in the contract. The objective is to develop a DRM culture-risk-trust (DRM-CRT) model to assist international contractors from English-speaking countries planning to operate in the Middle East or Asia in the choice of the appropriate DRMs, given an identified culture, trust, and risk levels, and their interactions. A Delphi technique is used to obtain experts’ views on the effects of these factors. Results show that both culture and risk do not have a statistically significant effect on DRMs’ choice, whereas trust does. Arbitration is most recommended in all project conditions except in projects with high trust, where negotiation is recommended. Nonamicable DRMs are least recommended. The model developed could aid companies venturing internationally to decide on the most suitable DRM to use given different project aspects, especially social aspects, which that are mostly overlooked in construction contracts.
- 1 November 2017
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction
- Vol. 9 (4)
Culture-Risk-Trust Model for Dispute-Resolution Method Selection in International Construction Contracts
Despite the attractive opportunities that international construction offers, companies need to account for risks of moving into international markets, including major contractual and cultural risks. This paper focuses on the selection of the dispute-resolution method (DRM) clause in the contract. The objective is to develop a DRM culture-risk-trust (DRM-CRT) model to assist international contractors from English-speaking countries planning to operate in the Middle East or Asia in the choice of the appropriate DRMs, given an identified culture, trust, and risk levels, and their interactions. A Delphi technique is used to obtain experts’ views on the effects of these factors. Results show that both culture and risk do not have a statistically significant effect on DRMs’ choice, whereas trust does. Arbitration is most recommended in all project conditions except in projects with high trust, where negotiation is recommended. Nonamicable DRMs are least recommended. The model developed could aid companies venturing internationally to decide on the most suitable DRM to use given different project aspects, especially social aspects, which that are mostly overlooked in construction contracts.