Jörg Stolz
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Interests
Jörg Stolz has a total of 27 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jeremy Senn
University of Lausanne (UNIL)
5 shared publications - Anaïd Lindemann
Institut de Sciences Sociales des Religions, University of Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland
4 shared publications Christophe Monnot
University of Strasbourg
4 shared publications- Antonius Liedhegener
Universität Luzern/University of Lucerne
2 shared publications - Arnd Bünker
Schweizerisches Pastoralsoziologisches Institut (SPI)
2 shared publications - Christophe Monnot
University of Strasbourg
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 19 August 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 16 (1) , 1-17
The three stages of religious decline around the world
Religiosity tends to decline across generations. However, religious decline is more pronounced in some countries and the diminishing aspects of religion vary by context. To explain such variation, we extend the general secular transition model, which proposes that countries undergo a similar process of secularization beginning at different points in time. We explain that secular transition happens in three steps: first, public ritual participation declines; second, the importance of religion to individuals declines; and third, people shed religious affiliation. We test this model using datasets from surveys in 111 countries (Pew Research Center), 58 countries (World Values Survey and European Values Study (WVS/EVS)), and a subset of 17 countries measured in at least five WVS/EVS waves. We show the model fits countries with Christian, Muslim, Hindu, and Buddhist pluralities. While Eastern post-Soviet countries deviate from this pattern, traditionally Muslim countries appear to follow its early stages. However, we recommend caution in interpreting longitudinal claims, due to limited data.
- 19 August 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 16 (1) , 1-17
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessThe three stages of religious decline around the world
Religiosity tends to decline across generations. However, religious decline is more pronounced in some countries and the diminishing aspects of religion vary by context. To explain such variation, we extend the general secular transition model, which proposes that countries undergo a similar process of secularization beginning at different points in time. We explain that secular transition happens in three steps: first, public ritual participation declines; second, the importance of religion to individuals declines; and third, people shed religious affiliation. We test this model using datasets from surveys in 111 countries (Pew Research Center), 58 countries (World Values Survey and European Values Study (WVS/EVS)), and a subset of 17 countries measured in at least five WVS/EVS waves. We show the model fits countries with Christian, Muslim, Hindu, and Buddhist pluralities. While Eastern post-Soviet countries deviate from this pattern, traditionally Muslim countries appear to follow its early stages. However, we recommend caution in interpreting longitudinal claims, due to limited data.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Society for Sociological Science in Sociological Science
- Vol. 12, 180-201
The Sequential Rise of Female Religious Leadership
In his seminal work 'Ordaining Women,' Mark Chaves (1997b) highlighted the phenomenon of 'loose coupling' regarding female religious leadership: congregations often display inconsistencies between their stated policies and actual practices. Some congregations declare openness to female leadership but do not practice it, whereas others officially forbid female leadership yet have women in leadership roles. Our article identifies a theoretical mechanism producing this inconsistency. We propose that congregations typically first loosen their formal rules governing female access to leadership and only later allow women to occupy leadership positions in practice. This two-stage process results in a temporal lag between rule change and practice change, creating the observed 'loose coupling,' where rules are often more gender egalitarian than practice. Using two waves of the National Congregation Survey Switzerland covering all religious traditions, we test our theory both on the aggregate and the unit level and find strong support for it. Simulations further indicate that certain characteristics of the organizational population of congregations, such as their low attrition rate, may explain a large part of the lag between rule change and practice change.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Society for Sociological Science in Sociological Science
- Vol. 12, 180-201
Open AccessThe Sequential Rise of Female Religious Leadership
In his seminal work 'Ordaining Women,' Mark Chaves (1997b) highlighted the phenomenon of 'loose coupling' regarding female religious leadership: congregations often display inconsistencies between their stated policies and actual practices. Some congregations declare openness to female leadership but do not practice it, whereas others officially forbid female leadership yet have women in leadership roles. Our article identifies a theoretical mechanism producing this inconsistency. We propose that congregations typically first loosen their formal rules governing female access to leadership and only later allow women to occupy leadership positions in practice. This two-stage process results in a temporal lag between rule change and practice change, creating the observed 'loose coupling,' where rules are often more gender egalitarian than practice. Using two waves of the National Congregation Survey Switzerland covering all religious traditions, we test our theory both on the aggregate and the unit level and find strong support for it. Simulations further indicate that certain characteristics of the organizational population of congregations, such as their low attrition rate, may explain a large part of the lag between rule change and practice change.
- 26 August 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Church and State
- Vol. 66 (4) , 274-275
Beyond Doubt: The Secularization of Society. By Isabella Kasselstrand, Phil Zuckerman, and Ryan T. Cragun
Can we still doubt secularization theory? According to Isabella Kasselstrand, Phil Zuckerman, and Ryan T. Cragun, the answer to this question is a resounding “No.” In their book, Beyond Doubt: The Secularization of Society, they argue that research in the last decades has accumulated empirical evidence unequivocally proving that modernization indeed leads to secularization—and does so all over the world. The goal of the book is to provide a “book-length, in-depth defense of secularization—especially one that goes beyond the confines of Europe and the United States” (p. 15). A second goal is to “refute” the “decades-old claims of Rodney Stark and his colleagues” (p. 15). In this, the book largely succeeds. It is a very well-written and engaging defense of secularization theory as applied to the world in general. The authors are able to show with EVS/WVS (the European Value Study and the World Value Survey) data that religious behavior, belief, and belonging have declined in many countries worldwide and that some often-cited alleged exceptions can, in fact, be explained in the framework of secularization theory. The book is fun to read and uses clear language and useful examples to support its points. The authors clearly take pleasure in introducing their theoretical opponents and their position. The main villain of the story is, of course, Rodney Stark (and he appears right at the beginning of the book in the guise of God). The overall thesis is sound, at least in the eyes of the present writer.
- 26 August 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Church and State
- Vol. 66 (4) , 274-275
Beyond Doubt: The Secularization of Society. By Isabella Kasselstrand, Phil Zuckerman, and Ryan T. Cragun
Can we still doubt secularization theory? According to Isabella Kasselstrand, Phil Zuckerman, and Ryan T. Cragun, the answer to this question is a resounding “No.” In their book, Beyond Doubt: The Secularization of Society, they argue that research in the last decades has accumulated empirical evidence unequivocally proving that modernization indeed leads to secularization—and does so all over the world. The goal of the book is to provide a “book-length, in-depth defense of secularization—especially one that goes beyond the confines of Europe and the United States” (p. 15). A second goal is to “refute” the “decades-old claims of Rodney Stark and his colleagues” (p. 15). In this, the book largely succeeds. It is a very well-written and engaging defense of secularization theory as applied to the world in general. The authors are able to show with EVS/WVS (the European Value Study and the World Value Survey) data that religious behavior, belief, and belonging have declined in many countries worldwide and that some often-cited alleged exceptions can, in fact, be explained in the framework of secularization theory. The book is fun to read and uses clear language and useful examples to support its points. The authors clearly take pleasure in introducing their theoretical opponents and their position. The main villain of the story is, of course, Rodney Stark (and he appears right at the beginning of the book in the guise of God). The overall thesis is sound, at least in the eyes of the present writer.
- Open Access
- 6 May 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion
- Vol. 63 (4) , 809-829
Can We Explain the Generation Gap in Churchgoing?
In western societies, secularization in the sense of declining individual religiosity is mainly caused by cohort replacement. Every cohort is somewhat less religious than its predecessor, indicating that religious transmission is incomplete. The puzzle is just what causes this incomplete transmission and whether there is one or a restricted number of factors that mainly explain the process. Our aim in this article is to establish, describe, and explain this lack of religious transmission in West Germany, comparing parents’ and children's level of church attendance and their determinants over time. We use a data set of more than 8,000 parent‐child pairs across four cohorts from the German Socio‐Economic Panel (SOEP) and test whether indicators measuring parent attributes, family relations, or parental context influence the attendance gap. As expected, we find a substantial parent‐child attendance gap. However, we do not find factors that mainly explain the process. Only family disruption and the percentage of nones in the state slightly increase the attendance gap, but effect sizes are small. Our surprising result is that secularization happens largely independently of attributes of the parents and their immediate surroundings. We discuss how this finding may give credibility to new theories of secular transition and present an agenda for future research on religious transmission.
- 6 May 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion
- Vol. 63 (4) , 809-829
Open AccessCan We Explain the Generation Gap in Churchgoing?
In western societies, secularization in the sense of declining individual religiosity is mainly caused by cohort replacement. Every cohort is somewhat less religious than its predecessor, indicating that religious transmission is incomplete. The puzzle is just what causes this incomplete transmission and whether there is one or a restricted number of factors that mainly explain the process. Our aim in this article is to establish, describe, and explain this lack of religious transmission in West Germany, comparing parents’ and children's level of church attendance and their determinants over time. We use a data set of more than 8,000 parent‐child pairs across four cohorts from the German Socio‐Economic Panel (SOEP) and test whether indicators measuring parent attributes, family relations, or parental context influence the attendance gap. As expected, we find a substantial parent‐child attendance gap. However, we do not find factors that mainly explain the process. Only family disruption and the percentage of nones in the state slightly increase the attendance gap, but effect sizes are small. Our surprising result is that secularization happens largely independently of attributes of the parents and their immediate surroundings. We discuss how this finding may give credibility to new theories of secular transition and present an agenda for future research on religious transmission.
- Open Access
- 14 February 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion
- Vol. 63 (3) , 519-542
Diversity Dynamics: How Local Religious Groups Appear, Persist, or Disappear over Time
Religious diversity is often described and measured statically. This article goes a step further by describing how congregational religious diversity changes over time, and by exposing the mechanisms underlying these changes. We combine data from two censuses (from 2008 and 2020) of congregations in Switzerland with a sample‐based national congregation study conducted in 2008. Our main findings are the following: (1) overall, the number of congregations is in decline. (2) Religious diversity remains stable, but underlying features of religious diversity change radically. For example, established Christian congregations almost only disappear while Orthodox Christians see almost only new congregations. (3) Rural areas lose congregations mainly because established Christian groups merge their parishes, while urban areas have a high turnover. (4) Some congregational characteristics such as religious tradition, number of participants or presence of a meeting space significantly predict a congregation's likelihood of disappearing, in contrast to other variables, including income.
- 14 February 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion
- Vol. 63 (3) , 519-542
Open AccessDiversity Dynamics: How Local Religious Groups Appear, Persist, or Disappear over Time
Religious diversity is often described and measured statically. This article goes a step further by describing how congregational religious diversity changes over time, and by exposing the mechanisms underlying these changes. We combine data from two censuses (from 2008 and 2020) of congregations in Switzerland with a sample‐based national congregation study conducted in 2008. Our main findings are the following: (1) overall, the number of congregations is in decline. (2) Religious diversity remains stable, but underlying features of religious diversity change radically. For example, established Christian congregations almost only disappear while Orthodox Christians see almost only new congregations. (3) Rural areas lose congregations mainly because established Christian groups merge their parishes, while urban areas have a high turnover. (4) Some congregational characteristics such as religious tradition, number of participants or presence of a meeting space significantly predict a congregation's likelihood of disappearing, in contrast to other variables, including income.
- 21 December 2023
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Journal of Religion and Demography
- Vol. 10 (1-2) , 138-161
The Three Religious Revivals. Pentecostal, Islamic, and Orthodox Upswings in the Context of Long-Term Secularization
Secularization theory is often criticized by pointing to counterexamples where— apparently or really—revivals of religion have coincided with modernization. But secularization theorists have responded to such criticisms by arguing that secularization is compatible with temporary religious upswings. Recently, Stolz and Voas (2023) have proposed a typology, distinguishing 5 mechanisms: “crisis”, “reaction”, “transition”, “state intervention”, and “composition”. This paper puts this typology to the test by examining the three most important religious revivals in the 20th and 21st century: the Pentecostal, the Islamic, and the Orthodox religious revival. We argue that all three revivals have led to strong increases in various indicators of religiosity, each of them built on a different combination of central mechanisms. While the Orthodox revival seems to have come to a standstill, the Pentecostal/Charismatic and Islamic revivals are ongoing.
- 21 December 2023
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Journal of Religion and Demography
- Vol. 10 (1-2) , 138-161
The Three Religious Revivals. Pentecostal, Islamic, and Orthodox Upswings in the Context of Long-Term Secularization
Secularization theory is often criticized by pointing to counterexamples where— apparently or really—revivals of religion have coincided with modernization. But secularization theorists have responded to such criticisms by arguing that secularization is compatible with temporary religious upswings. Recently, Stolz and Voas (2023) have proposed a typology, distinguishing 5 mechanisms: “crisis”, “reaction”, “transition”, “state intervention”, and “composition”. This paper puts this typology to the test by examining the three most important religious revivals in the 20th and 21st century: the Pentecostal, the Islamic, and the Orthodox religious revival. We argue that all three revivals have led to strong increases in various indicators of religiosity, each of them built on a different combination of central mechanisms. While the Orthodox revival seems to have come to a standstill, the Pentecostal/Charismatic and Islamic revivals are ongoing.
- Open Access
- 19 November 2023
- Published by Pontifical Catholic University of Sao Paulo (PUC-SP) in REVER: Revista de Estudos da Religião
- Vol. 23 (2) , 279-306
Bens de salvação e mercados religiosos
Apesar do enorme sucesso do conceito de "mercados religiosos", ainda não está claro o que são "bens religiosos", e sob quais condições um "mercado religioso" de fato existe em uma determinada sociedade. O autor integra diferentes conceitos dos teóricos da escolha racional e de Max Weber em uma nova tipologia de bens religiosos individuais e sociais. A tipologia mostra que os mercados são apenas uma possibilidade entre tantas outras de produção, troca e alocação de bens religiosos. Além disso, ela ajuda a entender as condições em que os mercados podem ou não ser ferramentas teóricas importantes.
- 19 November 2023
- Published by Pontifical Catholic University of Sao Paulo (PUC-SP) in REVER: Revista de Estudos da Religião
- Vol. 23 (2) , 279-306
Open AccessBens de salvação e mercados religiosos
Apesar do enorme sucesso do conceito de "mercados religiosos", ainda não está claro o que são "bens religiosos", e sob quais condições um "mercado religioso" de fato existe em uma determinada sociedade. O autor integra diferentes conceitos dos teóricos da escolha racional e de Max Weber em uma nova tipologia de bens religiosos individuais e sociais. A tipologia mostra que os mercados são apenas uma possibilidade entre tantas outras de produção, troca e alocação de bens religiosos. Além disso, ela ajuda a entender as condições em que os mercados podem ou não ser ferramentas teóricas importantes.
- Open Access
- 30 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Humanities and Social Sciences Communications
- Vol. 10 (1) , 1-12
The theory of social games: outline of a general theory for the social sciences
Sociological general theories (or “grand theories”) have been criticized for being too abstract to be of any practical use for empirical sociological work. This paper presents the outline of a general theory that claims to be better linked to empirical social research than previous theoretical attempts. The theory analyzes social life as a multitude of interacting social games. A social game is an entity created by players with resources who engage in action that is shaped by goals, rules, and representations, that involves objects, and that leads to game outcomes. The general theory is as encompassing as previous theoretical attempts, while allowing us to integrate both instrumental and normative action at different levels of the social. Its main advantage is that it is linked to middle-range theory and empirical research by a descriptive-interpretive heuristic, an explanatory heuristic, and formal and agent-based modeling. The article provides many examples to illustrate the claims.
- 30 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Humanities and Social Sciences Communications
- Vol. 10 (1) , 1-12
Open AccessThe theory of social games: outline of a general theory for the social sciences
Sociological general theories (or “grand theories”) have been criticized for being too abstract to be of any practical use for empirical sociological work. This paper presents the outline of a general theory that claims to be better linked to empirical social research than previous theoretical attempts. The theory analyzes social life as a multitude of interacting social games. A social game is an entity created by players with resources who engage in action that is shaped by goals, rules, and representations, that involves objects, and that leads to game outcomes. The general theory is as encompassing as previous theoretical attempts, while allowing us to integrate both instrumental and normative action at different levels of the social. Its main advantage is that it is linked to middle-range theory and empirical research by a descriptive-interpretive heuristic, an explanatory heuristic, and formal and agent-based modeling. The article provides many examples to illustrate the claims.
- Open Access
Explaining Religious Revival in the Context of Long-Term Secularization
Secularization theory has often been criticized for not being able to explain counterexamples. However, secularization theorists argue that transitory religious resurgences are expected to occur even in modernizing conditions. The aim of this article is to identify mechanisms that can explain the temporary upswing of religion against the backdrop of long-term modernization. We classify the mechanisms under five broad headings: crisis, reaction, transition, state intervention, and composition. Historical examples are provided to illustrate these mechanisms. The mechanisms are not mutually exclusive and can be understood within the framework of rational action.
Open AccessExplaining Religious Revival in the Context of Long-Term Secularization
Secularization theory has often been criticized for not being able to explain counterexamples. However, secularization theorists argue that transitory religious resurgences are expected to occur even in modernizing conditions. The aim of this article is to identify mechanisms that can explain the temporary upswing of religion against the backdrop of long-term modernization. We classify the mechanisms under five broad headings: crisis, reaction, transition, state intervention, and composition. Historical examples are provided to illustrate these mechanisms. The mechanisms are not mutually exclusive and can be understood within the framework of rational action.
- 1 October 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies
- Vol. 50 (8) , 1977-1997
To speak out or not to speak out? Exploring the reporting of discrimination among Muslims and Jews in Switzerland
Muslims and Jews are among the minorities in Switzerland who are most disliked and discriminated against, but the frequency with which the two groups report racist incidents to official bodies and initiate court proceedings differs greatly. The goal of this paper is to establish the extent of these differences and to explore the reasons for them. We use data from a representative survey, official datasets of reported cases of discrimination and legal proceedings, as well as 27 semi-structured interviews with representatives from Muslim and Jewish organisations, and from government centres that record incidents. We show that Muslims and Jews perceive discrimination at similar levels, but that the latter report discrimination and initiate court proceedings much more frequently than Muslims. We find that these differences can be explained by a divergence between the two groups in terms of perceived costs, in-group norms, structural factors, and organisational opportunities. In comparison to Jews, Muslims typically (1) are less confident that reporting discrimination will have a positive outcome; (2) are more concerned about being seen as ‘victims’; (3) are less well-informed about the possibilities available to them to report discrimination; and (4) come from communities that have lower organisational capacities in this regard.
- 1 October 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies
- Vol. 50 (8) , 1977-1997
To speak out or not to speak out? Exploring the reporting of discrimination among Muslims and Jews in Switzerland
Muslims and Jews are among the minorities in Switzerland who are most disliked and discriminated against, but the frequency with which the two groups report racist incidents to official bodies and initiate court proceedings differs greatly. The goal of this paper is to establish the extent of these differences and to explore the reasons for them. We use data from a representative survey, official datasets of reported cases of discrimination and legal proceedings, as well as 27 semi-structured interviews with representatives from Muslim and Jewish organisations, and from government centres that record incidents. We show that Muslims and Jews perceive discrimination at similar levels, but that the latter report discrimination and initiate court proceedings much more frequently than Muslims. We find that these differences can be explained by a divergence between the two groups in terms of perceived costs, in-group norms, structural factors, and organisational opportunities. In comparison to Jews, Muslims typically (1) are less confident that reporting discrimination will have a positive outcome; (2) are more concerned about being seen as ‘victims’; (3) are less well-informed about the possibilities available to them to report discrimination; and (4) come from communities that have lower organisational capacities in this regard.