Volker C. Weiss

Guggenheim’s corresponding-states approach for simple fluids leads to a remarkably universal representation of their thermophysical properties. For more complex fluids, such as polar or ionic ones, deviations from this type of behavior are to be expected, thereby supplying us with valuable information about the thermodynamic consequences of the interaction details in fluids. Here, the gradual transition of a simple fluid to an ionic one is studied by varying the relative strength of the dispersion interactions compared to the electrostatic interactions among the charged particles. In addition to the effects on the reduced surface tension that were reported earlier [F. Leroy and V. C. Weiss, J. Chem. Phys. 134, 094703 (2011)], we address the shape of the coexistence curve and focus on properties that are related to and derived from the vapor pressure. These quantities include the enthalpy and entropy of vaporization, the boiling point, and the critical compressibility factor Zc. For all of these properties, the crossover from simple to characteristically ionic fluid is seen once the dispersive attraction drops below 20%–40% of the electrostatic attraction (as measured for two particles at contact). Below this threshold, ionic fluids display characteristically low values of Zc as well as large Guggenheim and Guldberg ratios for the reduced enthalpy of vaporization and the reduced boiling point, respectively. The coexistence curves are wider and more skewed than those for simple fluids. The results for the ionic model fluid with variable dispersion interactions improve our understanding of the behavior of real ionic fluids, such as inorganic molten salts and room temperature ionic liquids, by gauging the importance of different types of interactions for thermodynamic properties.

More than two decades ago, the elusiveness of a liquid-vapor equilibrium and a corresponding critical point in simulations of the supposedly simple model of dipolar hard spheres came as a surprise to many liquid matter theorists. van Leeuwen and Smit [Phys. Rev. Lett. 71, 3991 (1993)] showed that a minimum of attractive dispersion interactions among the dipolar particles may be needed to observe regular fluid behavior. Here, we adopt their approach and use an only slightly modified model, in which the original point dipole is replaced by a dipole moment produced by charges that are separated in space, to study the influence of dispersion interactions of variable strength on the coexistence and interfacial properties of a polar fluid. The thermophysical properties are discussed in terms of Guggenheim’s corresponding-states approach. In this way, the coexistence curve, the critical compressibility factor, the surface tension, Guggenheim’s ratio, and modifications of Guldberg’s and Trouton’s rules (related to the vapor pressure and the enthalpy of vaporization) are analyzed. As the importance of dispersion is decreased, a crossover from simple-fluid behavior to that characteristic of strongly dipolar systems takes place; for some properties, this transition is monotonic, but for others it occurs non-monotonically. For strongly dipolar systems, the reduced surface tension is very low, whereas Guggenheim’s ratio and Guldberg’s ratio are found to be high. The critical compressibility factor is smaller, and the coexistence curve is wider and more skewed than for simple fluids. For very weak dispersion, liquid-vapor equilibrium is still observable, but the interfacial tension is extremely low and may, eventually, vanish marking the end of the existence of a liquid phase. We discuss the implications of our findings for real fluids, in particular, for hydrogen fluoride.

In experiments, the growth rate of ice from supercooled water is seen to increase with the degree of supercooling, that is, the lower the temperature, the faster the crystallization takes place. In molecular dynamics simulations of the freezing process, however, the temperature is usually kept constant by means of a thermostat that artificially removes the heat released during the crystallization by scaling the velocities of the particles. This direct removal of energy from the system replaces a more realistic heat-conduction mechanism and is believed to be responsible for the curious observation that the thermostatted ice growth proceeds fastest near the melting point and more slowly at lower temperatures, which is exactly opposite to the experimental findings [M. A. Carignano, P. B. Shepson, and I. Szleifer, Mol. Phys. 103, 2957 (2005)10.1080/00268970500243796]. This trend is explained by the diffusion and the reorientation of molecules in the liquid becoming the rate-determining steps for the crystal growth, both of which are slower at low temperatures. Yet, for a different set of simulations, a kinetic behavior analogous to the experimental finding has been reported [H. Nada and Y. Furukawa, J. Crystal Growth 283, 242 (2005)10.1016/j.jcrysgro.2005.05.057]. To clarify this apparent contradiction, we perform relatively long simulations of the TIP4P/Ice model in an extended range of temperatures. The temperature dependence of the thermostatted ice growth is seen to be more complex than was previously reported: The crystallization process is very slow close to the melting point at 270 K, where the thermodynamic driving force for the phase transition is weak. On lowering the temperature, the growth rate initially increases, but displays a maximum near 260 K. At even lower temperatures, the freezing process slows down again due to the reduced diffusivity in the liquid. The velocity of the thermostatted melting process, in contrast, shows a monotonic increase upon raising the temperature beyond the normal melting point. In this case, the effects of the increasing thermodynamic driving force and the faster diffusion at higher temperatures reinforce each other. In the context of this study, we also report data for the diffusion coefficient as a function of temperature for the water models TIP4P/Ice and TIP4P/2005.

One of Guggenheim’s many corresponding-states rules for simple fluids implies that the molar enthalpy of vaporization (determined at the temperature at which the pressure reaches 1/50th of its critical value, which approximately coincides with the normal boiling point) divided by the critical temperature has a value of roughly 5.2R, where R is the universal gas constant. For more complex fluids, such as strongly polar and ionic fluids, one must expect deviations from Guggenheim’s rule. Such a deviation has far-reaching consequences for other empirical rules related to the vaporization of fluids, namely Guldberg’s rule and Trouton’s rule. We evaluate these characteristic quantities for simple fluids, polar fluids, hydrogen-bonding fluids, simple inorganic molten salts, and room temperature ionic liquids (RTILs). For the ionic fluids, the critical parameters are not accessible to direct experimental observation; therefore, suitable extrapolation schemes have to be applied. For the RTILs [1-n-alkyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imides, where the alkyl chain is ethyl, butyl, hexyl, or octyl], the critical temperature is estimated by extrapolating the surface tension to zero using Guggenheim’s and Eötvös’ rules; the critical density is obtained using the linear-diameter rule. It is shown that the RTILs adhere to Guggenheim’s master curve for the reduced surface tension of simple and moderately polar fluids, but that they deviate significantly from his rule for the reduced enthalpy of vaporization of simple fluids. Consequences for evaluating the Trouton constant of RTILs, the value of which has been discussed controversially in the literature, are indicated.