Paul René Stuart
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Paul René Stuart has a total of 64 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Virginie Chambost
EnVertis Consulting Montreal Quebec Canada
5 shared publications- Émilie Thibault
Polytechnique Montreal
5 shared publications Jean‐Martin Brault
NSERC Environmental Design Engineering Chair, Department of Chemical Engineering, Ecole Polytechnique de Montreal, Pavilion André Aisenstadt, 2920 Chemin de la Tour, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, H3T 1J7
3 shared publicationsShabnam Sanaei
Polytechnique‐Montréal Montréal Canada
3 shared publicationsBalasubrahmanyan Srinivasan
2 shared publicationsBanafsheh Gilani
Natural Resources Canada, CanmetENERGY, Industrial Systems Optimization
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 29 January 2025
- Published by Wiley in Biofuels, Bioproducts and Biorefining
- Vol. 19 (3) , 634-653
Competitive assessment of biofuel strategies for a case study in eastern Canada: techno‐economic and multi‐criteria decision‐making analysis
Decarbonizing the energy sector through biomass use entails risks and uncertainties linked to implementing early stage technologies. To address this issue, this work presents a panel‐based multicriteria decision‐making (MCDM) framework for a corn‐ethanol plant seeking to reduce its carbon footprint while investing in new bioenergy products. Six technology pathways were considered including gasification technologies, pyrolysis, hydrothermal liquefaction, and alcohol to jet, with products such as renewable natural gas (RNG), biochar, green diesel, green marine, and biojet. The alternatives were assessed based on a set of six criteria classified into three categories: economic performance, technology and commercial risks, and competitive advantages. The MCDM framework was based on the multiattribute utility theory (MAUT) for which an in‐person panel of decision‐making stakeholders set the criteria weights. Internal rate of return (IRR) was considered the most important criterion, followed by technology readiness level (TRL) and total installed capital cost (TICC). Surprisingly, the commercial readiness level was allocated a low weight. Finally, the potential for a fossil‐free site (PFFS) criterion was perceived by the panel members more as a desirable attribute rather than a requirement. Among the alternatives considered, the flexible production of synthetic natural gas (FlexSNG) gasification‐methanation process was found to be preferred. The panel‐based MCDM framework proved to be a practical and effective tool for assessing early‐stage biofuel strategies, encouraging alignment with technological innovation, sustainable development, and the company's values and future ambitions.
- 29 January 2025
- Published by Wiley in Biofuels, Bioproducts and Biorefining
- Vol. 19 (3) , 634-653
Competitive assessment of biofuel strategies for a case study in eastern Canada: techno‐economic and multi‐criteria decision‐making analysis
Decarbonizing the energy sector through biomass use entails risks and uncertainties linked to implementing early stage technologies. To address this issue, this work presents a panel‐based multicriteria decision‐making (MCDM) framework for a corn‐ethanol plant seeking to reduce its carbon footprint while investing in new bioenergy products. Six technology pathways were considered including gasification technologies, pyrolysis, hydrothermal liquefaction, and alcohol to jet, with products such as renewable natural gas (RNG), biochar, green diesel, green marine, and biojet. The alternatives were assessed based on a set of six criteria classified into three categories: economic performance, technology and commercial risks, and competitive advantages. The MCDM framework was based on the multiattribute utility theory (MAUT) for which an in‐person panel of decision‐making stakeholders set the criteria weights. Internal rate of return (IRR) was considered the most important criterion, followed by technology readiness level (TRL) and total installed capital cost (TICC). Surprisingly, the commercial readiness level was allocated a low weight. Finally, the potential for a fossil‐free site (PFFS) criterion was perceived by the panel members more as a desirable attribute rather than a requirement. Among the alternatives considered, the flexible production of synthetic natural gas (FlexSNG) gasification‐methanation process was found to be preferred. The panel‐based MCDM framework proved to be a practical and effective tool for assessing early‐stage biofuel strategies, encouraging alignment with technological innovation, sustainable development, and the company's values and future ambitions.
- Open Access
Industrial Data-Driven Processing Framework Combining Process Knowledge for Improved Decision-Making—Part 2: Framework Application Considering Activity-Based Costing Concepts
Operating time series data collected and stored in historian must be managed to extract their full potential. Part 1 of this paper proposed a structured way (a sophisticated approach) to process industrial data; this first part explains in detail the data processing framework used as the basis for the costing analysis present in the second part of this series. The framework considers the analysis scope definition, data management steps, and operating regimes detection and identification. The added value of this proposed framework is demonstrated in Part 2 via the use of cost accounting for operational problem-solving (debottlenecking), i.e., its practicality is validated via its application alongside a cost analysis on the brownstock washing department of a kraft pulp mill. The traditional debottlenecking approach assumes a single operating condition considering that operating regimes allow for a much more sophisticated debottlenecking study of the washing department. With the use of operations-driven cost modeling (contingent on activity-based costing concepts) and processed time series data corresponding to steady-state operation, incremental profit can be assigned to each operating regime in order to identify the most cost-efficient one. The overall objective of this two-part series is to convert processed industrial steady-state data and cost information into knowledge that can be used to optimize the washing department of a chemical pulp mill. More specifically, different operating regimes are assessed, and the most suitable operating strategy is defined. The application of activity-based costing on a large amount of historically processed industrial data led to the improvement in the operation. The identified optimal way to operate (pulp throughput, pulp conductivity, defoamer and bleaching chemical quantity, etc.) led to a profit of CAD 49 M per year. Lastly, a contribution analysis of the regimes based on PCA highlighted how the process was operated when the preferred performances happened.
Open AccessIndustrial Data-Driven Processing Framework Combining Process Knowledge for Improved Decision-Making—Part 2: Framework Application Considering Activity-Based Costing Concepts
Operating time series data collected and stored in historian must be managed to extract their full potential. Part 1 of this paper proposed a structured way (a sophisticated approach) to process industrial data; this first part explains in detail the data processing framework used as the basis for the costing analysis present in the second part of this series. The framework considers the analysis scope definition, data management steps, and operating regimes detection and identification. The added value of this proposed framework is demonstrated in Part 2 via the use of cost accounting for operational problem-solving (debottlenecking), i.e., its practicality is validated via its application alongside a cost analysis on the brownstock washing department of a kraft pulp mill. The traditional debottlenecking approach assumes a single operating condition considering that operating regimes allow for a much more sophisticated debottlenecking study of the washing department. With the use of operations-driven cost modeling (contingent on activity-based costing concepts) and processed time series data corresponding to steady-state operation, incremental profit can be assigned to each operating regime in order to identify the most cost-efficient one. The overall objective of this two-part series is to convert processed industrial steady-state data and cost information into knowledge that can be used to optimize the washing department of a chemical pulp mill. More specifically, different operating regimes are assessed, and the most suitable operating strategy is defined. The application of activity-based costing on a large amount of historically processed industrial data led to the improvement in the operation. The identified optimal way to operate (pulp throughput, pulp conductivity, defoamer and bleaching chemical quantity, etc.) led to a profit of CAD 49 M per year. Lastly, a contribution analysis of the regimes based on PCA highlighted how the process was operated when the preferred performances happened.
- Open Access
Industrial Data-Driven Processing Framework Combining Process Knowledge for Improved Decision Making—Part 1: Framework Development
Data management systems are increasingly used in industrial processes. However, data collected as part of industrial process operations, such as sensor or measurement instruments data, contain various sources of errors that can hamper process analysis and decision making. The authors propose an operating-regime-based data processing framework for industrial process decision making. The framework was designed to increase the quality and take advantage of available process data use to make informed offline strategic business operation decisions, i.e., environmental, cost and energy analysis, optimization, fault detection, debottlenecking, etc. The approach was synthesized from best practices derived from the available framework and improved upon its predecessor by putting forward the combination of process expertise and data-driven approaches. This systematic and structured approach includes the following stages: (1) scope of the analysis, (2) signal processing, (3) steady-state operating periods detection, (4) data reconciliation and (5) operating regime detection and identification. The proposed framework is applied to the brownstock washing department of a dissolving pulp mill. Over a 5-month period, the process was found to be in steady-state 32% of the time. Twenty (20) distinct operating regimes were identified. Further processing with the help of data reconciliation techniques, principal component analysis and k-means clustering showed that the main drivers explaining the operating regimes are the pulp level in tanks, its density, and the shower wash water flow rate. Additionally, it was concluded that the top four persistently problematic sensors across the steady-state spans that would need to be verified are three flow meters (06FIC137, 06FIC152, and 06FIC433), and one consistency sensor (06NIC423). This information was relayed to process experts contacts at the plant for further investigation.
Open AccessIndustrial Data-Driven Processing Framework Combining Process Knowledge for Improved Decision Making—Part 1: Framework Development
Data management systems are increasingly used in industrial processes. However, data collected as part of industrial process operations, such as sensor or measurement instruments data, contain various sources of errors that can hamper process analysis and decision making. The authors propose an operating-regime-based data processing framework for industrial process decision making. The framework was designed to increase the quality and take advantage of available process data use to make informed offline strategic business operation decisions, i.e., environmental, cost and energy analysis, optimization, fault detection, debottlenecking, etc. The approach was synthesized from best practices derived from the available framework and improved upon its predecessor by putting forward the combination of process expertise and data-driven approaches. This systematic and structured approach includes the following stages: (1) scope of the analysis, (2) signal processing, (3) steady-state operating periods detection, (4) data reconciliation and (5) operating regime detection and identification. The proposed framework is applied to the brownstock washing department of a dissolving pulp mill. Over a 5-month period, the process was found to be in steady-state 32% of the time. Twenty (20) distinct operating regimes were identified. Further processing with the help of data reconciliation techniques, principal component analysis and k-means clustering showed that the main drivers explaining the operating regimes are the pulp level in tanks, its density, and the shower wash water flow rate. Additionally, it was concluded that the top four persistently problematic sensors across the steady-state spans that would need to be verified are three flow meters (06FIC137, 06FIC152, and 06FIC433), and one consistency sensor (06NIC423). This information was relayed to process experts contacts at the plant for further investigation.
- Open Access
- 14 June 2023
- Published by Wiley in The Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering
- Vol. 101 (11) , 6055-6078
Experimental methods in chemical engineering: Data processing and data usage in decision‐making
Industrial facilities collect large volumes of data, store them according to prescribed protocols, and then interpret them for process decision‐making. Several sources and types of error contaminate these data for various reasons, but especially because they come from unreliable or unpredictable instruments. Data (or signal) processing corrects measurement errors to improve fidelity. Here, we highlight decision‐making applications and signal processing methods. To fully appreciate the state‐of‐the‐art, we interviewed plant data experts and software developers in the pulp and paper industry to examine how they apply signal processing methods in the context of decision‐making, including the value of process data, how these data are used, and the major barriers that prevent plants from using data. Process experts clean data thoroughly with basic approaches compared to the advanced techniques available in the recent literature. The interviews demonstrate that decisions in industry are primarily based on steady‐state process operating data. Challenges and barriers that prevent the use of process data to their full potential relate to resource limitations (people, time, and money), an entrenched culture, and access to recent technology. In practice, experts consider, implicitly or explicitly, data that represent the process operating under steady‐state conditions. A plant model that represents steady‐state operations is easier to interpret, is presented in a form that is usable by plant operators, and in this way, better enables decision‐making.
- 14 June 2023
- Published by Wiley in The Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering
- Vol. 101 (11) , 6055-6078
Open AccessExperimental methods in chemical engineering: Data processing and data usage in decision‐making
Industrial facilities collect large volumes of data, store them according to prescribed protocols, and then interpret them for process decision‐making. Several sources and types of error contaminate these data for various reasons, but especially because they come from unreliable or unpredictable instruments. Data (or signal) processing corrects measurement errors to improve fidelity. Here, we highlight decision‐making applications and signal processing methods. To fully appreciate the state‐of‐the‐art, we interviewed plant data experts and software developers in the pulp and paper industry to examine how they apply signal processing methods in the context of decision‐making, including the value of process data, how these data are used, and the major barriers that prevent plants from using data. Process experts clean data thoroughly with basic approaches compared to the advanced techniques available in the recent literature. The interviews demonstrate that decisions in industry are primarily based on steady‐state process operating data. Challenges and barriers that prevent the use of process data to their full potential relate to resource limitations (people, time, and money), an entrenched culture, and access to recent technology. In practice, experts consider, implicitly or explicitly, data that represent the process operating under steady‐state conditions. A plant model that represents steady‐state operations is easier to interpret, is presented in a form that is usable by plant operators, and in this way, better enables decision‐making.
- Open Access
- 13 May 2023
- Published by Wiley in Biofuels, Bioproducts and Biorefining
- Vol. 17 (4) , 944-960
Multicriteria assessment of technology pathways to produce renewable and sustainable biofuels: case study in eastern Canada
One of the key pathways that can contribute to net‐zero goals is to enhance the use of renewable and sustainable biofuels. However, uncertainties remain owing to critical challenges to selecting the right sustainable biofuels technology most suitable for the longer term. These uncertainties can be partly addressed using a multidisciplinary perspective for scenarios and multicriteria decision‐making analysis. Multicriteria decision support tools (DSTs) are a powerful means to conduct the comparison of technology pathways at different technology readiness levels (TRLs). For this case study, a multidimensional DST was used to compare two technology pathways: (1) gasification combined with Fischer–Tropsch; and (2) hydrothermal liquefaction (HTL) to produce biofuels. The metrics available in the DST were examined, and five metrics related to evaluating profitability, robustness and capital efficiency as well as socio‐economic performance were selected. HTL was found to have a higher yield for renewable gasoline and diesel, largely due to higher economic performance and reduced environmental footprint as compared with the integrated gasification Fischer–Tropsch process. However, the TRL of 8–9 of biomass gasification was higher than that of HTL, which was still at 5–6, reflecting that the gasification process is essentially proven at a pre‐commercial scale. Based on sensitivity and scenario analyses, the importance of government support for capital cost and of biofuel price production incentives was identified as critical. From this comparison, HTL emerges as an attractive process for the future because of its outperformance from technical and environmental perspectives, but further demonstration efforts are still needed at the commercial scale. © 2023 Society of Chemical Industry and John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- 13 May 2023
- Published by Wiley in Biofuels, Bioproducts and Biorefining
- Vol. 17 (4) , 944-960
Open AccessMulticriteria assessment of technology pathways to produce renewable and sustainable biofuels: case study in eastern Canada
One of the key pathways that can contribute to net‐zero goals is to enhance the use of renewable and sustainable biofuels. However, uncertainties remain owing to critical challenges to selecting the right sustainable biofuels technology most suitable for the longer term. These uncertainties can be partly addressed using a multidisciplinary perspective for scenarios and multicriteria decision‐making analysis. Multicriteria decision support tools (DSTs) are a powerful means to conduct the comparison of technology pathways at different technology readiness levels (TRLs). For this case study, a multidimensional DST was used to compare two technology pathways: (1) gasification combined with Fischer–Tropsch; and (2) hydrothermal liquefaction (HTL) to produce biofuels. The metrics available in the DST were examined, and five metrics related to evaluating profitability, robustness and capital efficiency as well as socio‐economic performance were selected. HTL was found to have a higher yield for renewable gasoline and diesel, largely due to higher economic performance and reduced environmental footprint as compared with the integrated gasification Fischer–Tropsch process. However, the TRL of 8–9 of biomass gasification was higher than that of HTL, which was still at 5–6, reflecting that the gasification process is essentially proven at a pre‐commercial scale. Based on sensitivity and scenario analyses, the importance of government support for capital cost and of biofuel price production incentives was identified as critical. From this comparison, HTL emerges as an attractive process for the future because of its outperformance from technical and environmental perspectives, but further demonstration efforts are still needed at the commercial scale. © 2023 Society of Chemical Industry and John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- Open Access
Operating regime-based data-driven industrial framework for improved process decision-making-Part1:Framework development
Data management systems are increasingly used in industrial processes. However, data collected as part of industrial process operations, such as sensor or measurement instruments data, contain various sources of errors that can hamper process analysis and decision-making. Therefore, in order to take full advantage of collected and stored data and to increase data quality, an operating regime-based data-processing framework for industrial process decision-making is proposed in this paper. This systematic and structured approach includes the following stages: (1) scope of the analysis, (2) data management and (3) operating regime detection and identification. All steps are based on the combination of process knowledge and data-driven approaches. The proposed framework is applied to data from a brownstock washing department of a dissolving pulp mill, and employed in a case study presented in Part II of this publication, where, considering an activity-based costing analysis, the optimal way to operate the department is identified.
Open AccessOperating regime-based data-driven industrial framework for improved process decision-making-Part1:Framework development
Data management systems are increasingly used in industrial processes. However, data collected as part of industrial process operations, such as sensor or measurement instruments data, contain various sources of errors that can hamper process analysis and decision-making. Therefore, in order to take full advantage of collected and stored data and to increase data quality, an operating regime-based data-processing framework for industrial process decision-making is proposed in this paper. This systematic and structured approach includes the following stages: (1) scope of the analysis, (2) data management and (3) operating regime detection and identification. All steps are based on the combination of process knowledge and data-driven approaches. The proposed framework is applied to data from a brownstock washing department of a dissolving pulp mill, and employed in a case study presented in Part II of this publication, where, considering an activity-based costing analysis, the optimal way to operate the department is identified.
- Open Access
Operating regime-based data-driven industrial framework for improved process decision-making–Part 2:Frameworkapplication
Operating data collected and stored in historian must be managed to extract their full potential. Part I of this paper proposed a structured way to process industrial data. This framework considers the analysis scope definition, data management steps and operating regimes detection and identification. The value of this proposed framework is demonstrated in Part II through the use of cost accounting for operational problem-solving. With the use of operations-driven cost modeling (contingent on activity-based costing concepts) and processed data corresponding to steady-state operation, incremental cost reduction can be assigned to each operating regime in order to identify the most cost-efficient one. The overall objective of this paper is to convert processed industrial steady-state data and cost information into knowledge that can be used to optimize the washing department of a chemical pulp mill. More specifically, different operating regimes are assessed, and the most suitable operating strategy is defined.
Open AccessOperating regime-based data-driven industrial framework for improved process decision-making–Part 2:Frameworkapplication
Operating data collected and stored in historian must be managed to extract their full potential. Part I of this paper proposed a structured way to process industrial data. This framework considers the analysis scope definition, data management steps and operating regimes detection and identification. The value of this proposed framework is demonstrated in Part II through the use of cost accounting for operational problem-solving. With the use of operations-driven cost modeling (contingent on activity-based costing concepts) and processed data corresponding to steady-state operation, incremental cost reduction can be assigned to each operating regime in order to identify the most cost-efficient one. The overall objective of this paper is to convert processed industrial steady-state data and cost information into knowledge that can be used to optimize the washing department of a chemical pulp mill. More specifically, different operating regimes are assessed, and the most suitable operating strategy is defined.
- Open Access
- 12 September 2022
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Sustainability
- Vol. 2
Comparing Biorefinery Processes at the Early Design Stage Using Large Block Analysis
The transformation of pulp and paper mills through the integration of biorefineries is increasingly considered essential to the future of many existing sites. However, evaluating the risk and return of different biorefinery process alternatives at the early design stage is challenging. There are many strategies and technologies that must be considered, each of which is typically accompanied by its unique risks, including high levels of uncertainty in capital and operating cost estimates often obtained from technology providers. The novel methodology presented in this study, called Large Block Analysis (LBA), comprises a systematic approach for addressing these important challenges at the early design stage. LBA is used to obtain relative cost estimates for six process/product combinations incorporating different Technology Readiness Levels (TRLs), for adding value to a hemicellulose stream extracted from hardwood chips. In this case study, it was found that the fixed capital costs obtained using the LBA method differed from the original costs by between 121 and −19%, and operating cost estimates differed by between 117 and −17% from the original. The results show that the most economically-viable options for the hemicellulose stream having reasonable technology risk included the production of (1) animal feed additives, (2) xylitol using a variant of the classical chemical process, and (3) furfural.
- 12 September 2022
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Sustainability
- Vol. 2
Open AccessComparing Biorefinery Processes at the Early Design Stage Using Large Block Analysis
The transformation of pulp and paper mills through the integration of biorefineries is increasingly considered essential to the future of many existing sites. However, evaluating the risk and return of different biorefinery process alternatives at the early design stage is challenging. There are many strategies and technologies that must be considered, each of which is typically accompanied by its unique risks, including high levels of uncertainty in capital and operating cost estimates often obtained from technology providers. The novel methodology presented in this study, called Large Block Analysis (LBA), comprises a systematic approach for addressing these important challenges at the early design stage. LBA is used to obtain relative cost estimates for six process/product combinations incorporating different Technology Readiness Levels (TRLs), for adding value to a hemicellulose stream extracted from hardwood chips. In this case study, it was found that the fixed capital costs obtained using the LBA method differed from the original costs by between 121 and −19%, and operating cost estimates differed by between 117 and −17% from the original. The results show that the most economically-viable options for the hemicellulose stream having reasonable technology risk included the production of (1) animal feed additives, (2) xylitol using a variant of the classical chemical process, and (3) furfural.
- 17 January 2019
- Published by Wiley in The Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering
- Vol. 97 (3) , 687-696
Improving the network pinch approach for heat exchanger network retrofit with bridge analysis
Economic and environmental benefits result from increasing the energy efficiency of industrial systems. This article presents the application of bridge analysis concepts to improve the methodology of network pinch for heat exchanger network retrofit. In two simple examples, we compare bridge analysis with the network pinch approach, in terms of saving energy by heat exchanger network improvement. The first example is solved with both methods, while the second can only be solved by bridge analysis. In the first example, three different solutions are proposed, and the third solution leads to 3800 kW energy savings, i.e., the full savings capacity. In the second example, no heat can be saved using the network pinch approach, but two solutions are proposed using bridge analysis, which lead to 395 kW energy savings, i.e., the full savings capacity. Then, we discuss the advantages and limits of pinch analysis and the network pinch approach. Bridge analysis provides a broader perspective on pinch analysis, explains the natural presence of a pinch in a network, shows that removing cross pinch transfers is not necessary to save energy, and helps improve heuristics for creating new cooler‐heater paths in the network pinch procedure.
- 17 January 2019
- Published by Wiley in The Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering
- Vol. 97 (3) , 687-696
Improving the network pinch approach for heat exchanger network retrofit with bridge analysis
Economic and environmental benefits result from increasing the energy efficiency of industrial systems. This article presents the application of bridge analysis concepts to improve the methodology of network pinch for heat exchanger network retrofit. In two simple examples, we compare bridge analysis with the network pinch approach, in terms of saving energy by heat exchanger network improvement. The first example is solved with both methods, while the second can only be solved by bridge analysis. In the first example, three different solutions are proposed, and the third solution leads to 3800 kW energy savings, i.e., the full savings capacity. In the second example, no heat can be saved using the network pinch approach, but two solutions are proposed using bridge analysis, which lead to 395 kW energy savings, i.e., the full savings capacity. Then, we discuss the advantages and limits of pinch analysis and the network pinch approach. Bridge analysis provides a broader perspective on pinch analysis, explains the natural presence of a pinch in a network, shows that removing cross pinch transfers is not necessary to save energy, and helps improve heuristics for creating new cooler‐heater paths in the network pinch procedure.
- Open Access
- 31 August 2018
- Published by Wiley in Biofuels, Bioproducts and Biorefining
- Vol. 12 (S1) , S46-S59
Systematic assessment of triticale‐based biorefinery strategies: techno‐economic analysis to identify investment opportunities
In recent years, interest has increased in biorefineries that use a variety of biomass residues and non‐food crops. Triticale (X Triticosecale Wittmack) is a human‐developed crop that has the potential to become a preferred industrial energy crop for the biorefinery because of its capacity to grow on marginal land, its higher yields compared to existing cereal crops such as wheat, and its non‐competition with food‐based crops. However, implementation of the triticale‐based biorefinery will require the identification of sustainable strategies and as its sustainability pillar, the identification of economically promising strategies. In this study, the economic performance of several triticale‐based product‐process scenarios, including the production of ethanol, polylactic acid (PLA), and thermoplastic starch polymer, has been assessed through the evaluation of six economic criteria. These conflicting criteria have been evaluated in a multi‐criteria decision‐making (MCDM) panel, demonstrated for PLA platform, which has made it possible (i) to rank the alternatives by their economic performance, and (ii) to identify a set of the most important criteria to be used in a sustainability study. The MCDM results show that the alternatives with the best performance on profitability‐oriented criteria do not necessarily achieve the highest overall economic score. This suggests the need to consider both business‐strategy‐oriented criteria and profitability‐oriented criteria in strategic decision‐making. The MCDM results show that the internal rate of return, the downside internal rate of return, and the resistance to supply market uncertainty with relative weights of 24.8%, 23.6%, and 18.1% respectively, are the most important of the criteria assessed. © 2018 Society of Chemical Industry and John Wiley & Sons, Ltd
- 31 August 2018
- Published by Wiley in Biofuels, Bioproducts and Biorefining
- Vol. 12 (S1) , S46-S59
Open AccessSystematic assessment of triticale‐based biorefinery strategies: techno‐economic analysis to identify investment opportunities
In recent years, interest has increased in biorefineries that use a variety of biomass residues and non‐food crops. Triticale (X Triticosecale Wittmack) is a human‐developed crop that has the potential to become a preferred industrial energy crop for the biorefinery because of its capacity to grow on marginal land, its higher yields compared to existing cereal crops such as wheat, and its non‐competition with food‐based crops. However, implementation of the triticale‐based biorefinery will require the identification of sustainable strategies and as its sustainability pillar, the identification of economically promising strategies. In this study, the economic performance of several triticale‐based product‐process scenarios, including the production of ethanol, polylactic acid (PLA), and thermoplastic starch polymer, has been assessed through the evaluation of six economic criteria. These conflicting criteria have been evaluated in a multi‐criteria decision‐making (MCDM) panel, demonstrated for PLA platform, which has made it possible (i) to rank the alternatives by their economic performance, and (ii) to identify a set of the most important criteria to be used in a sustainability study. The MCDM results show that the alternatives with the best performance on profitability‐oriented criteria do not necessarily achieve the highest overall economic score. This suggests the need to consider both business‐strategy‐oriented criteria and profitability‐oriented criteria in strategic decision‐making. The MCDM results show that the internal rate of return, the downside internal rate of return, and the resistance to supply market uncertainty with relative weights of 24.8%, 23.6%, and 18.1% respectively, are the most important of the criteria assessed. © 2018 Society of Chemical Industry and John Wiley & Sons, Ltd