Lindsay Blank
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Lindsay Blank has a total of 80 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Elizabeth Goyder
School of Health and Related Research, The University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
12 shared publications - Anna Cantrell
Sheffield Centre for Health and Related Research (SCHARR), School of Medicine and Population Health, The University of Sheffield Faculty of Medicine Dentistry and Health, Sheffield, South Yorkshire, S1 4DA
8 shared publications Elizabeth Goyder
Sheffield Centre for Health and Related Research (SCHARR), School of Medicine and Health, The University of Sheffield, Sheffield, S1 4DA, UK
8 shared publications- Susan Baxter
School for Health and Related Research, University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
7 shared publications - Emma Stefania Hock
School of Medicine and Population Health, University of Sheffield, Sheffield, South Yorkshire, S1 4DA
5 shared publications - Andrew Booth
ScHARR, The University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 24 August 2026
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in NIHR Open Research
- Vol. 6, 127
The effectiveness and acceptability of neighbourhood-level interventions to reduce outdoor air pollution: A systematic review
Background Outdoor air pollution is a major public health concern, exacerbating health inequalities, and causing serious illness and death. A comprehensive evidence synthesis of neighbourhood-level outdoor air pollution reduction interventions was commissioned to inform local decision-making in the UK. Methods We searched 10 databases, reference lists, citations, and UK grey literature. We included quantitative, qualitative and observational studies examining the effectiveness and/or acceptability of neighbourhood-level interventions aimed at reducing human exposure to and health impacts of outdoor air pollution, compared with a separate site or pre-intervention control, on health and wellbeing outcomes and air quality. We applied narrative synthesis and best fit framework synthesis, informed by an a priori conceptual framework, to examine the impacts of interventions designed to prevent, mitigate and avoid air pollution. Results We examined 8912 records and 108 full texts from databases, 103 full texts from grey literature sources, 30 full texts from citation searches, and included 24 studies reported in 26 papers/reports. We identified a range of interventions, almost all traffic-related, implemented by different stakeholders. Low traffic neighbourhood and school streets interventions reduced air pollution levels and traffic counts, with little evidence of traffic spilling over to surrounding streets. Anti-idling messages reduced idling traffic. Walking school bus initiatives encouraged modal shift. Green wall interventions reduced air pollution, possibly depending on wind direction. Street adaptations had mixed effects on air pollution but reduced polluting traffic. A light-touch traffic calming intervention reduced traffic levels. An early warning system had a mixed impact on air pollution. Some studies lacked comparison sites and some may have been confounded by the COVID-19 pandemic. Conclusions A range of neighbourhood-level interventions have the potential to reduce outdoor air pollution locally. The most impactful appear to be low traffic neighbourhoods, school streets, anti-idling messages and green walls.
- 24 August 2026
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in NIHR Open Research
- Vol. 6, 127
Open AccessThe effectiveness and acceptability of neighbourhood-level interventions to reduce outdoor air pollution: A systematic review
Background Outdoor air pollution is a major public health concern, exacerbating health inequalities, and causing serious illness and death. A comprehensive evidence synthesis of neighbourhood-level outdoor air pollution reduction interventions was commissioned to inform local decision-making in the UK. Methods We searched 10 databases, reference lists, citations, and UK grey literature. We included quantitative, qualitative and observational studies examining the effectiveness and/or acceptability of neighbourhood-level interventions aimed at reducing human exposure to and health impacts of outdoor air pollution, compared with a separate site or pre-intervention control, on health and wellbeing outcomes and air quality. We applied narrative synthesis and best fit framework synthesis, informed by an a priori conceptual framework, to examine the impacts of interventions designed to prevent, mitigate and avoid air pollution. Results We examined 8912 records and 108 full texts from databases, 103 full texts from grey literature sources, 30 full texts from citation searches, and included 24 studies reported in 26 papers/reports. We identified a range of interventions, almost all traffic-related, implemented by different stakeholders. Low traffic neighbourhood and school streets interventions reduced air pollution levels and traffic counts, with little evidence of traffic spilling over to surrounding streets. Anti-idling messages reduced idling traffic. Walking school bus initiatives encouraged modal shift. Green wall interventions reduced air pollution, possibly depending on wind direction. Street adaptations had mixed effects on air pollution but reduced polluting traffic. A light-touch traffic calming intervention reduced traffic levels. An early warning system had a mixed impact on air pollution. Some studies lacked comparison sites and some may have been confounded by the COVID-19 pandemic. Conclusions A range of neighbourhood-level interventions have the potential to reduce outdoor air pollution locally. The most impactful appear to be low traffic neighbourhoods, school streets, anti-idling messages and green walls.
- Open Access
- 22 August 2026
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in NIHR Open Research
- Vol. 6, 124
Stakeholder perspectives on the benefits and challenges of engagement in public health evidence synthesis: a systematic review
Background Stakeholder engagement enhances the relevance of public health evidence synthesis for policy and practice. However, the prevailing narrative foregrounds the review team perspective, meaning that the perspectives of stakeholders by role (professional stakeholders) remain poorly understood. The aim of this paper was to identify and synthesise evidence on the benefits and challenges of involvement in the review process that accrue to the stakeholders themselves. Methods We searched nine bibliographic databases (MEDLINE, Embase, PsycINFO, Social Sciences Citation Index, Science Citation Index, International Bibliography of Social Sciences, Applied Social Sciences Index and Abstracts, Scopus, and the King’s Fund Library Catalogue), performed citation searching, and conducted a targeted CLUSTER search. Two reviewers screened titles/abstracts and full texts, resolving disagreements through discussion. Results From 1,085 records identified, only one study met inclusion criteria. Key challenges from the perspectives of stakeholders by role include: addressing power dynamics, providing training for all parties, maintaining flexible engagement methods, and allocating sufficient time within the review process. No papers were identified that specifically explored benefits to stakeholders. Conclusions The lack of published evidence highlights a very important gap in our understanding of the benefits and challenges for stakeholders by role. Insights from fields such as environmental science, where the ‘stakes’ of those involved are made explicit, highlight the potential for further exploration. The benefits and challenges for stakeholders by function or by role need to be recognised alongside those for stakeholders by experience. A genuinely collaborative approach to public health evidence syntheses is recommended.
- 22 August 2026
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in NIHR Open Research
- Vol. 6, 124
Open AccessStakeholder perspectives on the benefits and challenges of engagement in public health evidence synthesis: a systematic review
Background Stakeholder engagement enhances the relevance of public health evidence synthesis for policy and practice. However, the prevailing narrative foregrounds the review team perspective, meaning that the perspectives of stakeholders by role (professional stakeholders) remain poorly understood. The aim of this paper was to identify and synthesise evidence on the benefits and challenges of involvement in the review process that accrue to the stakeholders themselves. Methods We searched nine bibliographic databases (MEDLINE, Embase, PsycINFO, Social Sciences Citation Index, Science Citation Index, International Bibliography of Social Sciences, Applied Social Sciences Index and Abstracts, Scopus, and the King’s Fund Library Catalogue), performed citation searching, and conducted a targeted CLUSTER search. Two reviewers screened titles/abstracts and full texts, resolving disagreements through discussion. Results From 1,085 records identified, only one study met inclusion criteria. Key challenges from the perspectives of stakeholders by role include: addressing power dynamics, providing training for all parties, maintaining flexible engagement methods, and allocating sufficient time within the review process. No papers were identified that specifically explored benefits to stakeholders. Conclusions The lack of published evidence highlights a very important gap in our understanding of the benefits and challenges for stakeholders by role. Insights from fields such as environmental science, where the ‘stakes’ of those involved are made explicit, highlight the potential for further exploration. The benefits and challenges for stakeholders by function or by role need to be recognised alongside those for stakeholders by experience. A genuinely collaborative approach to public health evidence syntheses is recommended.
- Open Access
- 1 March 2026
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Public Health Research
- p. 1-30
The NIHR Public Health Research Review Programme (2019–2025)
Background: The Public Health Review Team, University of Sheffield, was commissioned to deliver a programme of public health evidence synthesis projects. The review programme (2019–25) provided a unique opportunity to develop effective and efficient processes to maximise the value and impact of evidence synthesis for public health practitioners, policy-makers, commissioners and research funders. Objectives: The overall purpose of the programme was to deliver evidence reviews that could inform the commissioning of further primary research and directly inform public health policy and practice. This synopsis summarises the programme content and reflects on lessons learnt. Methods: Diverse appropriate methods were used for individual reviews to ensure the timely and efficient production of evidence synthesis products that were as useful as possible to the relevant stakeholders and decision-makers. These included an umbrella review (review of reviews), mapping reviews, systematic reviews, rapid reviews and evidence briefings. The majority of reviews were informed by both public and practitioner involvement, from defining the review questions and identification of relevant evidence to interpreting and disseminating the findings. Both established public panels and topic-specific groups with relevant lived experience recruited for individual projects were involved in the review process. This synopsis was produced by collating and synthesising information from across all 11 commissioned review topics. The review team informally reflected on the learning and generated a number of recommendations for future review programmes. Data sources: All review projects across the programme used online database searches to identify relevant peer-reviewed journal articles. For many topics, relevant data were identified from grey literature identified by topic experts and other stakeholders and from website searches. Results: Evidence synthesis outputs were generated across 11 different topics prioritised by the Public Health Research Programme Prioritisation Committee: gambling-related harm, working in later life, working from home, access to services for ethnic minority populations, parenting programmes, warmer homes, student mental health, housing insecurity, alcohol licensing, local interventions to reduce air pollution, health impact assessment to inform spatial planning. Individual project outputs were used to inform both primary research commissioning calls and public health policy development. Research reports, research summaries and other outputs, such as animations, webinars, posters and presentations, were widely shared with both public and professional audiences. The programme benefited from high levels of engagement from public panels and professional involvement as well as close engagement with topic experts and policy-makers. Future work: Experience from this programme is informing commissioning of further national evidence synthesis teams, and we continue to build on the learning to develop efficient approaches to the delivery of timely, high-quality reviews which are of maximum value to decision-makers. Limitations: This synopsis can only summarise some key aspects of the programme. Further work is underway to disseminate learning on the value of stakeholder engagement and other methodological aspects of public health evidence synthesis. Conclusion: Commissioning flexible evidence synthesis teams and ensuring effective engagement with stakeholders are efficient approaches to the delivery of timely, high-quality reviews that can optimise impact on population health and health inequalities. Funding: This synopsis presents independent research funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Public Health Research programme as award number NIHR127659.
- 1 March 2026
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Public Health Research
- p. 1-30
Open AccessThe NIHR Public Health Research Review Programme (2019–2025)
Background: The Public Health Review Team, University of Sheffield, was commissioned to deliver a programme of public health evidence synthesis projects. The review programme (2019–25) provided a unique opportunity to develop effective and efficient processes to maximise the value and impact of evidence synthesis for public health practitioners, policy-makers, commissioners and research funders. Objectives: The overall purpose of the programme was to deliver evidence reviews that could inform the commissioning of further primary research and directly inform public health policy and practice. This synopsis summarises the programme content and reflects on lessons learnt. Methods: Diverse appropriate methods were used for individual reviews to ensure the timely and efficient production of evidence synthesis products that were as useful as possible to the relevant stakeholders and decision-makers. These included an umbrella review (review of reviews), mapping reviews, systematic reviews, rapid reviews and evidence briefings. The majority of reviews were informed by both public and practitioner involvement, from defining the review questions and identification of relevant evidence to interpreting and disseminating the findings. Both established public panels and topic-specific groups with relevant lived experience recruited for individual projects were involved in the review process. This synopsis was produced by collating and synthesising information from across all 11 commissioned review topics. The review team informally reflected on the learning and generated a number of recommendations for future review programmes. Data sources: All review projects across the programme used online database searches to identify relevant peer-reviewed journal articles. For many topics, relevant data were identified from grey literature identified by topic experts and other stakeholders and from website searches. Results: Evidence synthesis outputs were generated across 11 different topics prioritised by the Public Health Research Programme Prioritisation Committee: gambling-related harm, working in later life, working from home, access to services for ethnic minority populations, parenting programmes, warmer homes, student mental health, housing insecurity, alcohol licensing, local interventions to reduce air pollution, health impact assessment to inform spatial planning. Individual project outputs were used to inform both primary research commissioning calls and public health policy development. Research reports, research summaries and other outputs, such as animations, webinars, posters and presentations, were widely shared with both public and professional audiences. The programme benefited from high levels of engagement from public panels and professional involvement as well as close engagement with topic experts and policy-makers. Future work: Experience from this programme is informing commissioning of further national evidence synthesis teams, and we continue to build on the learning to develop efficient approaches to the delivery of timely, high-quality reviews which are of maximum value to decision-makers. Limitations: This synopsis can only summarise some key aspects of the programme. Further work is underway to disseminate learning on the value of stakeholder engagement and other methodological aspects of public health evidence synthesis. Conclusion: Commissioning flexible evidence synthesis teams and ensuring effective engagement with stakeholders are efficient approaches to the delivery of timely, high-quality reviews that can optimise impact on population health and health inequalities. Funding: This synopsis presents independent research funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Public Health Research programme as award number NIHR127659.
- Open Access
- 22 October 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Public Health
- Vol. 249, 105993
Evidence for the effectiveness of health impact assessment in spatial planning on health outcomes: A systematic review and stakeholder involvement from a UK perspective
- 22 October 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Public Health
- Vol. 249, 105993
Open AccessEvidence for the effectiveness of health impact assessment in spatial planning on health outcomes: A systematic review and stakeholder involvement from a UK perspective
- Open Access
- 24 July 2025
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Formative Research
- Vol. 9, e67608
Acceptability and Utility of a Web-Based Patient-Completed Clinical Decision Aid for the Differential Diagnosis of Transient Loss of Consciousness: Qualitative Interview Study
Background: Web-based patient-completed clinical decision aids (CDAs) have the potential to reduce inefficient resource use and patient risk in acute and emergency settings while minimizing additional clinician time burdens. However, such interventions must be acceptable for use by their target audience—patients. Objective: The objective of this study is to assess acceptability and utility to patients of a novel online patient-completed CDA for the differential diagnosis of transient loss of consciousness (TLoC). Methods: Within a larger validation study of a patient-completed CDA, we conducted nested qualitative semistructured interviews with a purposive sample of 20 patients who used the CDA in the study and performed thematic analysis of interview transcripts. Results: We identified 11 themes within the data: 3 addressing the content of the CDA, 3 addressing the online implementation, and 4 addressing usability and acceptability of the CDA. Respondents generally felt an online CDA was easy to complete and acceptable, though they felt that increased options to personalize descriptions of their experience would be helpful and offered guidance on how to make it a more useful resource for patients as well as clinicians. We present good practice points for the design of patient-completed online CDAs on the basis of our thematic analysis. Conclusions: Findings suggest that patient-completed CDAs may be accessible and feasible in acute and emergency settings, though further research is needed to explore their real-world usability. In designing such tools, clinicians should endeavor to maintain their accessibility for all relevant patient groups and to use them to provide direct patient benefit, as well as to support clinical decision-making, for example, through simultaneous patient-directed outputs.
- 24 July 2025
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Formative Research
- Vol. 9, e67608
Open AccessAcceptability and Utility of a Web-Based Patient-Completed Clinical Decision Aid for the Differential Diagnosis of Transient Loss of Consciousness: Qualitative Interview Study
Background: Web-based patient-completed clinical decision aids (CDAs) have the potential to reduce inefficient resource use and patient risk in acute and emergency settings while minimizing additional clinician time burdens. However, such interventions must be acceptable for use by their target audience—patients. Objective: The objective of this study is to assess acceptability and utility to patients of a novel online patient-completed CDA for the differential diagnosis of transient loss of consciousness (TLoC). Methods: Within a larger validation study of a patient-completed CDA, we conducted nested qualitative semistructured interviews with a purposive sample of 20 patients who used the CDA in the study and performed thematic analysis of interview transcripts. Results: We identified 11 themes within the data: 3 addressing the content of the CDA, 3 addressing the online implementation, and 4 addressing usability and acceptability of the CDA. Respondents generally felt an online CDA was easy to complete and acceptable, though they felt that increased options to personalize descriptions of their experience would be helpful and offered guidance on how to make it a more useful resource for patients as well as clinicians. We present good practice points for the design of patient-completed online CDAs on the basis of our thematic analysis. Conclusions: Findings suggest that patient-completed CDAs may be accessible and feasible in acute and emergency settings, though further research is needed to explore their real-world usability. In designing such tools, clinicians should endeavor to maintain their accessibility for all relevant patient groups and to use them to provide direct patient benefit, as well as to support clinical decision-making, for example, through simultaneous patient-directed outputs.
- Open Access
- 13 October 2024
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Public Health
- Vol. 2 (2) , e000953
Public health involvement in alcohol licensing decisions in the UK: a systematic review of qualitative studies
Introduction: One approach to reducing alcohol consumption and related harm is to limit physical availability. However, a recent review found alcohol licensing decisions are not consistently associated with improved local health outcomes in the UK, despite public health teams (PHTs) having a statutory role in licensing. This may be explained by limitations in regulatory powers, or because PHTs have been unable to sufficiently influence the use of regulation. This review aims to synthesise qualitative evidence to understand the nature, barriers and enablers, and value of PHT involvement in alcohol licensing decisions in the UK. Methods: A systematic review of qualitative evidence was conducted. Five electronic databases were searched, supplemented by web searches for grey literature and author, reference and citation searches for included studies. Data was extracted and quality assessed using the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) checklist. Data was synthesised using thematic synthesis, and confidence in the findings was judged using the Confidence in Evidence from Reviews of Qualitative research (CERQual) approach. Results: 10 reports, relating to four separate studies, met the eligibility criteria. Thematic synthesis generated seven analytical themes. We found variation in how PHTs’ role in licensing is understood and enacted, with shared barriers and enablers. PHTs are often not regarded as a key consultee, though some teams found success in pursuing a more strategic approach. While the public health licensing objective in Scotland is considered an asset, it does not guarantee influence. Regardless of its presence, there is variation in the perceived value of PHTs’ involvement in licensing. Conclusions: A more strategic focus may be of value to PHTs and help strengthen their impact on licensing. However, given the limited potential for public health benefits through influencing regulatory decision-making, PHTs may want to consider if it is the most effective use of limited resource in tackling alcohol-related harms. PROSPERO registration number: CRD42023452508.
- 13 October 2024
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Public Health
- Vol. 2 (2) , e000953
Open AccessPublic health involvement in alcohol licensing decisions in the UK: a systematic review of qualitative studies
Introduction: One approach to reducing alcohol consumption and related harm is to limit physical availability. However, a recent review found alcohol licensing decisions are not consistently associated with improved local health outcomes in the UK, despite public health teams (PHTs) having a statutory role in licensing. This may be explained by limitations in regulatory powers, or because PHTs have been unable to sufficiently influence the use of regulation. This review aims to synthesise qualitative evidence to understand the nature, barriers and enablers, and value of PHT involvement in alcohol licensing decisions in the UK. Methods: A systematic review of qualitative evidence was conducted. Five electronic databases were searched, supplemented by web searches for grey literature and author, reference and citation searches for included studies. Data was extracted and quality assessed using the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) checklist. Data was synthesised using thematic synthesis, and confidence in the findings was judged using the Confidence in Evidence from Reviews of Qualitative research (CERQual) approach. Results: 10 reports, relating to four separate studies, met the eligibility criteria. Thematic synthesis generated seven analytical themes. We found variation in how PHTs’ role in licensing is understood and enacted, with shared barriers and enablers. PHTs are often not regarded as a key consultee, though some teams found success in pursuing a more strategic approach. While the public health licensing objective in Scotland is considered an asset, it does not guarantee influence. Regardless of its presence, there is variation in the perceived value of PHTs’ involvement in licensing. Conclusions: A more strategic focus may be of value to PHTs and help strengthen their impact on licensing. However, given the limited potential for public health benefits through influencing regulatory decision-making, PHTs may want to consider if it is the most effective use of limited resource in tackling alcohol-related harms. PROSPERO registration number: CRD42023452508.
- Open Access
- 17 January 2024
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Public Health
- Vol. 2 (1) , e000533
Evaluating the impact of local alcohol licensing decisions on outcomes for the community: a systematic review
Background International evidence reviews suggest that reducing the availability of alcohol positively impacts both levels of alcohol consumption and associated harms. To understand the impact of recent changes to alcohol licensing and public health in the UK, this review aimed to identify and synthesise quantitative research evidence on the impact of local alcohol licensing decisions on the health and well-being of the community. Methods We searched peer-reviewed articles and grey literature for UK studies. We extracted and tabulated key data from the included papers and appraised study quality. We included topic expert and public consultation to confirm the scope of the evidence synthesis and suggest evidence for inclusion. We synthesised narratively and made recommendations based on our findings. Results We identified a small volume (seven papers) of evidence regarding the health (and related) impacts of local alcohol licensing decision undertaken in the UK local authorities. The evidence we identified did not demonstrate a consistent or sustained association between local interventions and health or crime outcomes downstream. This was despite relatively sophisticated study designs using a range of available data sources and some longer-term analysis. Conclusion Given that the impacts of local licensing decisions are currently limited, greater regulatory powers are needed if local licensing interventions are to be an effective public health interventions to reduce alcohol-related harms.
- 17 January 2024
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Public Health
- Vol. 2 (1) , e000533
Open AccessEvaluating the impact of local alcohol licensing decisions on outcomes for the community: a systematic review
Background International evidence reviews suggest that reducing the availability of alcohol positively impacts both levels of alcohol consumption and associated harms. To understand the impact of recent changes to alcohol licensing and public health in the UK, this review aimed to identify and synthesise quantitative research evidence on the impact of local alcohol licensing decisions on the health and well-being of the community. Methods We searched peer-reviewed articles and grey literature for UK studies. We extracted and tabulated key data from the included papers and appraised study quality. We included topic expert and public consultation to confirm the scope of the evidence synthesis and suggest evidence for inclusion. We synthesised narratively and made recommendations based on our findings. Results We identified a small volume (seven papers) of evidence regarding the health (and related) impacts of local alcohol licensing decision undertaken in the UK local authorities. The evidence we identified did not demonstrate a consistent or sustained association between local interventions and health or crime outcomes downstream. This was despite relatively sophisticated study designs using a range of available data sources and some longer-term analysis. Conclusion Given that the impacts of local licensing decisions are currently limited, greater regulatory powers are needed if local licensing interventions are to be an effective public health interventions to reduce alcohol-related harms.
- Open Access
- 1 December 2023
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Public Health Research
- Vol. 11 (13) , 1-71
Exploring the impact of housing insecurity on the health and well-being of children and young people: a systematic review
Background: Housing insecurity can be understood as experiencing or being at risk of multiple house moves that are (1) not through choice and (2) related to poverty. For example, due to short-term private rental tenancies, temporary or emergency housing, and homelessness. Housing insecurity has grown due to recent trends in the cost and availability of housing. The quality, affordability and stability of housing have all been shown to impact children’s health and well-being. However, the pathways linking housing and child health and well-being are complex and poorly understood. Objectives: To identify, appraise and synthesise research evidence that explores the relationship between housing insecurity and the health and well-being of children and young people. Data sources: MEDLINE via Ovid (searched 8 April 2022), EMBASE via Ovid (searched 8 April 2022), PsycINFO via Ovid (searched 8 April 2022). Review methods: We undertook a systematic review synthesising qualitative data. We searched databases, reference lists and United Kingdom grey literature. We extracted and tabulated key data from the included papers, and appraised study quality. We synthesised the data qualitatively into an a priori conceptual framework using best-fit framework synthesis combined with thematic synthesis, and generated logic models to highlight links between specific exposures, impacts and outcomes. Results: We included 59 studies and identified four populations: those experiencing housing insecurity in general (40 papers); associated with domestic violence (nine papers); associated with migration status (13 papers) and those forced to relocate due to demolition (two papers). Most published studies had an overall assessment of moderate-high quality, and most grey literature originated from known and valued sources. Housing insecurity took many forms and resulted from several, often inter-related, situations, including being evicted or having a forced move, living in temporary accommodation, exposure to problematic behaviour, overcrowded/poor-condition/unsuitable property, and making multiple moves. The resultant housing insecurity had multiple impacts, including school-related, psychological, financial and family well-being impacts, long-distance travel to attend school and see friends, living in a poor-condition or unsuitable property, all of which could further exacerbate housing insecurity. These experiences impacted health and well-being, in terms of mental health problems (often manifesting physically/behaviourally) and physical health problems related to poor housing conditions. Some factors lessened the impact of housing insecurity, including friendship and support, staying at the same school, having hope for the future and protective parenting. The negative impacts of housing insecurity on health and well-being may be compounded by specific situations and life circumstances, such as escaping domestic violence, migration status, or a forced relocation due to housing demolition. Limitations: Many accounts were from parents or other informants, and more data directly from children and young people may give a more nuanced picture. Likewise, there was little information relating to outcomes, and it is difficult to know whether the current evidence has captured all relevant outcomes, and the links from impacts to health and well-being outcomes are less well understood. The complexity and diversity of the data added additional challenges to the synthesis process. Conclusions: Our findings suggest that policies should focus on reducing housing insecurity among families, particularly in relation to reducing eviction, improving and reducing the need for temporary accommodation, minimum requirements for property condition, and support to reduce multiple moves and moves far from families’ desired location. Those working with children and families experiencing housing insecurity should give them optimal choice and control over situations that affect them. Future work: Future qualitative research should focus explicitly on the health and well-being of children and young people experiencing housing insecurity, and how it links with the impacts identified in the current review, foregrounding the accounts of children and young people themselves, including specific groups of young people who are likely to be marginalised. Qualitative research focusing on the impact of interventions to address housing insecurity among families in the United Kingdom is also needed. Study registration: This study is registered as PROSPERO CRD42022327506. Funding: This award was funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Public Health Research programme (Award ref: NIHR135455) and is published in full in Public Health Research; Vol. 11, No. 13. See the NIHR Funding and Awards website for further award information. The views expressed are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of the NIHR or the Department of Health and Social Care.
- 1 December 2023
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Public Health Research
- Vol. 11 (13) , 1-71
Open AccessExploring the impact of housing insecurity on the health and well-being of children and young people: a systematic review
Background: Housing insecurity can be understood as experiencing or being at risk of multiple house moves that are (1) not through choice and (2) related to poverty. For example, due to short-term private rental tenancies, temporary or emergency housing, and homelessness. Housing insecurity has grown due to recent trends in the cost and availability of housing. The quality, affordability and stability of housing have all been shown to impact children’s health and well-being. However, the pathways linking housing and child health and well-being are complex and poorly understood. Objectives: To identify, appraise and synthesise research evidence that explores the relationship between housing insecurity and the health and well-being of children and young people. Data sources: MEDLINE via Ovid (searched 8 April 2022), EMBASE via Ovid (searched 8 April 2022), PsycINFO via Ovid (searched 8 April 2022). Review methods: We undertook a systematic review synthesising qualitative data. We searched databases, reference lists and United Kingdom grey literature. We extracted and tabulated key data from the included papers, and appraised study quality. We synthesised the data qualitatively into an a priori conceptual framework using best-fit framework synthesis combined with thematic synthesis, and generated logic models to highlight links between specific exposures, impacts and outcomes. Results: We included 59 studies and identified four populations: those experiencing housing insecurity in general (40 papers); associated with domestic violence (nine papers); associated with migration status (13 papers) and those forced to relocate due to demolition (two papers). Most published studies had an overall assessment of moderate-high quality, and most grey literature originated from known and valued sources. Housing insecurity took many forms and resulted from several, often inter-related, situations, including being evicted or having a forced move, living in temporary accommodation, exposure to problematic behaviour, overcrowded/poor-condition/unsuitable property, and making multiple moves. The resultant housing insecurity had multiple impacts, including school-related, psychological, financial and family well-being impacts, long-distance travel to attend school and see friends, living in a poor-condition or unsuitable property, all of which could further exacerbate housing insecurity. These experiences impacted health and well-being, in terms of mental health problems (often manifesting physically/behaviourally) and physical health problems related to poor housing conditions. Some factors lessened the impact of housing insecurity, including friendship and support, staying at the same school, having hope for the future and protective parenting. The negative impacts of housing insecurity on health and well-being may be compounded by specific situations and life circumstances, such as escaping domestic violence, migration status, or a forced relocation due to housing demolition. Limitations: Many accounts were from parents or other informants, and more data directly from children and young people may give a more nuanced picture. Likewise, there was little information relating to outcomes, and it is difficult to know whether the current evidence has captured all relevant outcomes, and the links from impacts to health and well-being outcomes are less well understood. The complexity and diversity of the data added additional challenges to the synthesis process. Conclusions: Our findings suggest that policies should focus on reducing housing insecurity among families, particularly in relation to reducing eviction, improving and reducing the need for temporary accommodation, minimum requirements for property condition, and support to reduce multiple moves and moves far from families’ desired location. Those working with children and families experiencing housing insecurity should give them optimal choice and control over situations that affect them. Future work: Future qualitative research should focus explicitly on the health and well-being of children and young people experiencing housing insecurity, and how it links with the impacts identified in the current review, foregrounding the accounts of children and young people themselves, including specific groups of young people who are likely to be marginalised. Qualitative research focusing on the impact of interventions to address housing insecurity among families in the United Kingdom is also needed. Study registration: This study is registered as PROSPERO CRD42022327506. Funding: This award was funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Public Health Research programme (Award ref: NIHR135455) and is published in full in Public Health Research; Vol. 11, No. 13. See the NIHR Funding and Awards website for further award information. The views expressed are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of the NIHR or the Department of Health and Social Care.
- Open Access
- 1 May 2023
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health and Social Care Delivery Research
- Vol. 11 (4) , 1-59
Factors which facilitate or impede patient engagement with pulmonary and cardiac rehabilitation: a rapid evaluation mapping review
Background: There is a considerable body of systematic review evidence considering the effectiveness of rehabilitation programmes on clinical outcomes. However, much less is known about effectively engaging and sustaining patients in rehabilitation. There is a need to understand the full range of potential intervention strategies. Methods: We conducted a mapping review of UK review-level evidence published 2017–21. We searched MEDLINE, EMBASE and the Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health (CINAHL) and conducted a narrative synthesis. Included reviews reported factors affecting commencement, continuation or completion of cardiac or pulmonary rehabilitation, or an intervention to facilitate these factors. Study selection was undertaken independently by two reviewers. Results: In total, we identified 20 review papers that met our inclusion criteria. There was a bias towards reviews considering cardiac rehabilitation, with these numbering 16. An additional 11 unpublished interventions were also identified through internet searching of key websites. The reviews included 60 identifiable UK primary studies that considered factors which affected attendance at rehabilitation; 42 considered cardiac rehabilitation and 18 considering pulmonary rehabilitation. They reported on factors from the patients’ point of view, as well as the views of professionals involved in referral or treatment. It was more common for factors to be reported as impeding attendance at rehabilitation rather than facilitating it. We grouped the factors into patient perspective (support, culture, demographics, practical, health, emotions, knowledge/beliefs and service factors) and professional perspective (knowledge: staff and patient, staffing, adequacy of service provision and referral from other services, including support and wait times). We found considerably fewer reviews (n = 3) looking at interventions to facilitate participation in rehabilitation. Although most of the factors affecting participation were reported from a patient perspective, most of the identified interventions were implemented to address barriers to access in terms of the provider perspective. The majority of access challenges identified by patients would not therefore be addressed by the identified interventions. The more recent unevaluated interventions implemented during the COVID-19 pandemic may have the potential to act on some of the patient barriers in access to services, including travel and inconvenient timing of services. Conclusions: The factors affecting commencement, continuation or completion of cardiac or pulmonary rehabilitation consist of a web of complex and interlinked factors taking into consideration the perspectives of the patients and the service providers. The small number of published interventions we identified that aim to improve access are unlikely to address the majority of these factors, especially those identified by patients as limiting their access. Better understanding of these factors will allow future interventions to be more evidence based with clear objectives as to how to address the known barriers to improve access. Limitations: Time limitations constrained the consideration of study quality and precluded the inclusion of additional searching methods such as citation searching and contacting key authors. This may have implications for the completeness of the evidence base identified. Future work: High-quality effectiveness studies of promising interventions to improve attendance at rehabilitation, both overall and for key patient groups, should be the focus moving forward. Funding: This report presents independent research funded by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR). The views and opinions expressed by authors in this publication are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the NHS, the NIHR, NETSCC, the HSDR programme or the Department of Health. Study registration: The study protocol is registered with PROSPERO [CRD42022309214].
- 1 May 2023
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health and Social Care Delivery Research
- Vol. 11 (4) , 1-59
Open AccessFactors which facilitate or impede patient engagement with pulmonary and cardiac rehabilitation: a rapid evaluation mapping review
Background: There is a considerable body of systematic review evidence considering the effectiveness of rehabilitation programmes on clinical outcomes. However, much less is known about effectively engaging and sustaining patients in rehabilitation. There is a need to understand the full range of potential intervention strategies. Methods: We conducted a mapping review of UK review-level evidence published 2017–21. We searched MEDLINE, EMBASE and the Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health (CINAHL) and conducted a narrative synthesis. Included reviews reported factors affecting commencement, continuation or completion of cardiac or pulmonary rehabilitation, or an intervention to facilitate these factors. Study selection was undertaken independently by two reviewers. Results: In total, we identified 20 review papers that met our inclusion criteria. There was a bias towards reviews considering cardiac rehabilitation, with these numbering 16. An additional 11 unpublished interventions were also identified through internet searching of key websites. The reviews included 60 identifiable UK primary studies that considered factors which affected attendance at rehabilitation; 42 considered cardiac rehabilitation and 18 considering pulmonary rehabilitation. They reported on factors from the patients’ point of view, as well as the views of professionals involved in referral or treatment. It was more common for factors to be reported as impeding attendance at rehabilitation rather than facilitating it. We grouped the factors into patient perspective (support, culture, demographics, practical, health, emotions, knowledge/beliefs and service factors) and professional perspective (knowledge: staff and patient, staffing, adequacy of service provision and referral from other services, including support and wait times). We found considerably fewer reviews (n = 3) looking at interventions to facilitate participation in rehabilitation. Although most of the factors affecting participation were reported from a patient perspective, most of the identified interventions were implemented to address barriers to access in terms of the provider perspective. The majority of access challenges identified by patients would not therefore be addressed by the identified interventions. The more recent unevaluated interventions implemented during the COVID-19 pandemic may have the potential to act on some of the patient barriers in access to services, including travel and inconvenient timing of services. Conclusions: The factors affecting commencement, continuation or completion of cardiac or pulmonary rehabilitation consist of a web of complex and interlinked factors taking into consideration the perspectives of the patients and the service providers. The small number of published interventions we identified that aim to improve access are unlikely to address the majority of these factors, especially those identified by patients as limiting their access. Better understanding of these factors will allow future interventions to be more evidence based with clear objectives as to how to address the known barriers to improve access. Limitations: Time limitations constrained the consideration of study quality and precluded the inclusion of additional searching methods such as citation searching and contacting key authors. This may have implications for the completeness of the evidence base identified. Future work: High-quality effectiveness studies of promising interventions to improve attendance at rehabilitation, both overall and for key patient groups, should be the focus moving forward. Funding: This report presents independent research funded by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR). The views and opinions expressed by authors in this publication are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the NHS, the NIHR, NETSCC, the HSDR programme or the Department of Health. Study registration: The study protocol is registered with PROSPERO [CRD42022309214].
- Open Access
- 1 May 2023
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Public Health Research
- Vol. 11 (4) , 1-100
Exploring the relationship between working from home, mental and physical health and wellbeing: a systematic review
Background: Understanding the impact of working from home on health and wellbeing is of great interest to employers and employees alike, with a strong need for up-to-date guidance. The aim of this systematic review was to identify, appraise and synthesise existing research evidence that explores the impact of home working on health and wellbeing outcomes for working people and health inequalities in the population. Methods: We conducted a systematic review of qualitative, quantitative and observational studies. We searched databases, reference lists and UK grey literature and completed citation searching of included papers. We extracted and tabulated key data from the included papers and synthesised narratively. Factors associated with the health and wellbeing of people working at home reported in the literature were displayed by constructing mind maps of each individual factor which had been identified. The findings were combined with an a priori model to develop a final model, which was validated in consultation with stakeholders. Results: Of 96 studies which were found to meet the inclusion criteria for the review, 30 studies were published before the COVID-19 pandemic and a further 66 were published during the pandemic. The quality of evidence was limited by the study designs employed by the authors, with the majority of studies being cross-sectional surveys (n = 59). For the most part, for studies which collected quantitative data, measures were self-reported. The largest volume of evidence identified consisted of studies conducted during the COVID-19 pandemic which looked at factors which influence the relationship between working from home and measures relating to mental health and wellbeing. Fifteen studies which considered the potential for working at home to have different effects for different subgroups suggested that working at home may have more negative consequences during the COVID-19 pandemic for women and in particular, mothers. There was very little evidence on age (two studies), ethnicity (one study), education or income (two studies) in terms of moderating home working effects, and very limited evidence from before the COVID-19 pandemic. The concept of enforced working from home and having ‘no choice’ was reported in only one paper prior to the pandemic and two papers reporting on working from home as a result of COVID-19. However, the concept of lack of choice around working from home was implicit in much of the literature – even though it was not directly measured. There were no clear patterns of wellbeing measures which changed from positive to negative association (or vice versa) during the pandemic. Limitations: The quality of the evidence base was very much limited by study designs, particularly for studies published during the COVID-19 pandemic, with the majority of studies consisting of data collected by cross-sectional surveys (often online). Due to the rapidly expanding nature of the evidence on this topic, it is possible that new studies were published after the final citation searches were conducted. Discussion: The evidence base for the factors which influence the relationship between home working and health-related outcomes has expanded significantly as a result of the need for those whose work could be done from home to work at home during the COVID-19 pandemic. Our findings suggest that there are factors relating to the external context, the role of employers and the circumstances of the employee which contribute to determining whether someone works at home and what the associated impacts on health and wellbeing may be. Learning from the COVID-19 lockdown experience will be important to inform future policy on home and hybrid working. Future work: There is a need for better-quality studies of the health impact of home working, in particularly studies which recruit a range of participants who are representative of the working population and which are designed to minimise sampling/recruitment biases and response biases. Funding: This project was funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Public Health Research programme (project reference 18/93 PHR Public Health Review Team) and will be published in full in Public Health Research; Vol. 11, No. 4. See the NIHR Journals Library website for further project information. The views expressed are those of the authors and not necessarily those of the NIHR or the Department of Health and Social Care. Study registration: This study is registered as PROSPERO 2021 CRD42021253474.
- 1 May 2023
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Public Health Research
- Vol. 11 (4) , 1-100
Open AccessExploring the relationship between working from home, mental and physical health and wellbeing: a systematic review
Background: Understanding the impact of working from home on health and wellbeing is of great interest to employers and employees alike, with a strong need for up-to-date guidance. The aim of this systematic review was to identify, appraise and synthesise existing research evidence that explores the impact of home working on health and wellbeing outcomes for working people and health inequalities in the population. Methods: We conducted a systematic review of qualitative, quantitative and observational studies. We searched databases, reference lists and UK grey literature and completed citation searching of included papers. We extracted and tabulated key data from the included papers and synthesised narratively. Factors associated with the health and wellbeing of people working at home reported in the literature were displayed by constructing mind maps of each individual factor which had been identified. The findings were combined with an a priori model to develop a final model, which was validated in consultation with stakeholders. Results: Of 96 studies which were found to meet the inclusion criteria for the review, 30 studies were published before the COVID-19 pandemic and a further 66 were published during the pandemic. The quality of evidence was limited by the study designs employed by the authors, with the majority of studies being cross-sectional surveys (n = 59). For the most part, for studies which collected quantitative data, measures were self-reported. The largest volume of evidence identified consisted of studies conducted during the COVID-19 pandemic which looked at factors which influence the relationship between working from home and measures relating to mental health and wellbeing. Fifteen studies which considered the potential for working at home to have different effects for different subgroups suggested that working at home may have more negative consequences during the COVID-19 pandemic for women and in particular, mothers. There was very little evidence on age (two studies), ethnicity (one study), education or income (two studies) in terms of moderating home working effects, and very limited evidence from before the COVID-19 pandemic. The concept of enforced working from home and having ‘no choice’ was reported in only one paper prior to the pandemic and two papers reporting on working from home as a result of COVID-19. However, the concept of lack of choice around working from home was implicit in much of the literature – even though it was not directly measured. There were no clear patterns of wellbeing measures which changed from positive to negative association (or vice versa) during the pandemic. Limitations: The quality of the evidence base was very much limited by study designs, particularly for studies published during the COVID-19 pandemic, with the majority of studies consisting of data collected by cross-sectional surveys (often online). Due to the rapidly expanding nature of the evidence on this topic, it is possible that new studies were published after the final citation searches were conducted. Discussion: The evidence base for the factors which influence the relationship between home working and health-related outcomes has expanded significantly as a result of the need for those whose work could be done from home to work at home during the COVID-19 pandemic. Our findings suggest that there are factors relating to the external context, the role of employers and the circumstances of the employee which contribute to determining whether someone works at home and what the associated impacts on health and wellbeing may be. Learning from the COVID-19 lockdown experience will be important to inform future policy on home and hybrid working. Future work: There is a need for better-quality studies of the health impact of home working, in particularly studies which recruit a range of participants who are representative of the working population and which are designed to minimise sampling/recruitment biases and response biases. Funding: This project was funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Public Health Research programme (project reference 18/93 PHR Public Health Review Team) and will be published in full in Public Health Research; Vol. 11, No. 4. See the NIHR Journals Library website for further project information. The views expressed are those of the authors and not necessarily those of the NIHR or the Department of Health and Social Care. Study registration: This study is registered as PROSPERO 2021 CRD42021253474.