Karen A. Haubensak
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Karen A. Haubensak has a total of 22 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Clare E. Aslan
School of Earth and Sustainability Northern Arizona University Flagstaff Arizona USA
2 shared publications - Derek Andrew Uhey
Department of Forestry, Northern Arizona University , Flagstaff, AZ
2 shared publications - Richard William Hofstetter
School of Forestry, Northern Arizona University , Flagstaff, AZ
2 shared publications Sara Souther
2 shared publications- Sneha Vissa
Biology Department, Northern Arizona University , Flagstaff, AZ
2 shared publications Andrew D Ballard
Biology Department, Northern Arizona University , 617 South Beaver Street, Flagstaff, AZ 86011
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 22 September 2025
- Published by Wiley in Restoration Ecology
- Vol. 34 (1)
Evaluating the restoration and commercial seed growing potential of native plants that support pollinators
A key limitation for dryland restoration is the availability of native seed sources adapted to arid conditions; however, many native forbs lack basic ecological data relevant to restoration seed production. To address this gap, we evaluated six native forb species collected across the Colorado Plateau for their potential to be developed into restoration materials. We established a common garden trial designed to replicate agricultural conditions using 100 individuals from four populations per species and measured survival, growth, reproduction, and pollinator visitation. Three species, Spreading fleabane ( Erigeron divergens ), Hoary aster ( Dieteria canescens ), and Hairy false goldenaster ( Heterotheca villosa ), exhibited high survival, prolific flower and seed production, and attracted diverse pollinator groups, including multiple native bee taxa. In contrast, Horsetail milkweed ( Asclepias subverticillata ) and Prairie flax ( Linum lewisii ) had low seed yields but attracted distinct floral visitor guilds. Sphaeralcea parvifolia exhibited poor propagation success. Despite variable performance among species and populations, the trial demonstrated that plantings comprising multiple species and populations supported a wide array of pollinators and extended the timing of floral resource availability. These results underscore the value of integrating functionally complementary species into restoration plantings to promote pollinator diversity and identify candidate species for native seed production.
- 22 September 2025
- Published by Wiley in Restoration Ecology
- Vol. 34 (1)
Evaluating the restoration and commercial seed growing potential of native plants that support pollinators
A key limitation for dryland restoration is the availability of native seed sources adapted to arid conditions; however, many native forbs lack basic ecological data relevant to restoration seed production. To address this gap, we evaluated six native forb species collected across the Colorado Plateau for their potential to be developed into restoration materials. We established a common garden trial designed to replicate agricultural conditions using 100 individuals from four populations per species and measured survival, growth, reproduction, and pollinator visitation. Three species, Spreading fleabane ( Erigeron divergens ), Hoary aster ( Dieteria canescens ), and Hairy false goldenaster ( Heterotheca villosa ), exhibited high survival, prolific flower and seed production, and attracted diverse pollinator groups, including multiple native bee taxa. In contrast, Horsetail milkweed ( Asclepias subverticillata ) and Prairie flax ( Linum lewisii ) had low seed yields but attracted distinct floral visitor guilds. Sphaeralcea parvifolia exhibited poor propagation success. Despite variable performance among species and populations, the trial demonstrated that plantings comprising multiple species and populations supported a wide array of pollinators and extended the timing of floral resource availability. These results underscore the value of integrating functionally complementary species into restoration plantings to promote pollinator diversity and identify candidate species for native seed production.
- 11 March 2025
- Published by Wiley in Restoration Ecology
- Vol. 33 (4)
Pollination networks and plant local adaptation: the importance of serving the pollinator community in restoration
The need to consider present and future species interactions can make it difficult to ensure the long‐term effectiveness of a restoration effort. We designed an experimental restoration garden in an arid system to investigate the relationship between seed source population and plant‐pollinator interactions. Seedlings planted in the garden were sourced from eight populations of each of seven forb species. For 18 months, we tracked flower visitation by insects. We used network analysis to examine the roles of plant species and populations. In the whole‐garden network, taller plants as well as those that differed more in temperature of the source environment from the garden were more generalized, receiving visitation from a higher subset of the local visitor community. We detected no other relevant network patterns consistent across the full garden. However, when within‐species networks were constructed, plants from different populations exhibited significant differences in metrics of centrality and generalization for four out of seven plant species. Plants sourced from populations that exhibit similar climatic conditions to those found in the experimental garden, as well as plants from populations that displayed traits indicative of greater pollinator reward (e.g., greater plant size and greater floral abundance), were linked to increased centrality and generalization in networks. Our results suggest that it may be possible to select restoration plantings by seed source to bolster the diversity and frequency of pollinator interactions in a site, and further, that considering how plant local adaptation serves pollinators is likely to be important in restoration success.
- 11 March 2025
- Published by Wiley in Restoration Ecology
- Vol. 33 (4)
Pollination networks and plant local adaptation: the importance of serving the pollinator community in restoration
The need to consider present and future species interactions can make it difficult to ensure the long‐term effectiveness of a restoration effort. We designed an experimental restoration garden in an arid system to investigate the relationship between seed source population and plant‐pollinator interactions. Seedlings planted in the garden were sourced from eight populations of each of seven forb species. For 18 months, we tracked flower visitation by insects. We used network analysis to examine the roles of plant species and populations. In the whole‐garden network, taller plants as well as those that differed more in temperature of the source environment from the garden were more generalized, receiving visitation from a higher subset of the local visitor community. We detected no other relevant network patterns consistent across the full garden. However, when within‐species networks were constructed, plants from different populations exhibited significant differences in metrics of centrality and generalization for four out of seven plant species. Plants sourced from populations that exhibit similar climatic conditions to those found in the experimental garden, as well as plants from populations that displayed traits indicative of greater pollinator reward (e.g., greater plant size and greater floral abundance), were linked to increased centrality and generalization in networks. Our results suggest that it may be possible to select restoration plantings by seed source to bolster the diversity and frequency of pollinator interactions in a site, and further, that considering how plant local adaptation serves pollinators is likely to be important in restoration success.
- Open Access
- 30 November 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Entomology
- Vol. 53 (1) , 180-187
Increased cover of native and exotic plants on the rims of harvester ant (Hymenoptera: Formicidae) nests under grazing and drought
Harvester ants create habitats along nest rims, which some plants use as refugia. These refugia can enhance ecosystem stability to disturbances like drought and grazing, but their potential role in invasion ecology is not yet tested. Here we examine the effects of drought and grazing on nest-rim refugia of 2 harvester ant species: Pogonomyrmex occidentals and P. rugosus. We selected 4 rangeland sites with high harvester ant nest densities in northern Arizona, USA, with pre-existing grazing exclosures adjacent to heavily grazed habitat. Our objective was to determine whether nest refugia were used by native or exotic plant species for each site and scenario of drought and grazing. We measured vegetation cover on nest surfaces, on nest rims, and at 3 distances (3, 5, and 10 m) from nests. At each site, we sampled 2 treatments (grazed/excluded) during 2 seasons (drought/monsoon). We found that nest rims increased vegetation cover compared with background levels at all sites and in almost all scenarios of treatment and season, indicating that nest rims provide important refugia for plants from drought and cattle grazing. In some cases, plants enhanced on nest rims were native grasses such as blue gramma (Bouteloua gracilis) or forbs such as sunflowers (Helianthus petiolaris). However, nest rims at all sites enhanced exotic species, particularly Russian thistle (Salsola tragus), purslane (Portulaca oleracea), and bull thistle (Cirsium vulgare). These results suggest that harvester ants play important roles in invasion ecology and restoration. We discuss potential mechanisms for why certain plant species use nest-rim refugia and how harvester ant nests contribute to plant community dynamics.
- 30 November 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Environmental Entomology
- Vol. 53 (1) , 180-187
Open AccessIncreased cover of native and exotic plants on the rims of harvester ant (Hymenoptera: Formicidae) nests under grazing and drought
Harvester ants create habitats along nest rims, which some plants use as refugia. These refugia can enhance ecosystem stability to disturbances like drought and grazing, but their potential role in invasion ecology is not yet tested. Here we examine the effects of drought and grazing on nest-rim refugia of 2 harvester ant species: Pogonomyrmex occidentals and P. rugosus. We selected 4 rangeland sites with high harvester ant nest densities in northern Arizona, USA, with pre-existing grazing exclosures adjacent to heavily grazed habitat. Our objective was to determine whether nest refugia were used by native or exotic plant species for each site and scenario of drought and grazing. We measured vegetation cover on nest surfaces, on nest rims, and at 3 distances (3, 5, and 10 m) from nests. At each site, we sampled 2 treatments (grazed/excluded) during 2 seasons (drought/monsoon). We found that nest rims increased vegetation cover compared with background levels at all sites and in almost all scenarios of treatment and season, indicating that nest rims provide important refugia for plants from drought and cattle grazing. In some cases, plants enhanced on nest rims were native grasses such as blue gramma (Bouteloua gracilis) or forbs such as sunflowers (Helianthus petiolaris). However, nest rims at all sites enhanced exotic species, particularly Russian thistle (Salsola tragus), purslane (Portulaca oleracea), and bull thistle (Cirsium vulgare). These results suggest that harvester ants play important roles in invasion ecology and restoration. We discuss potential mechanisms for why certain plant species use nest-rim refugia and how harvester ant nests contribute to plant community dynamics.
- Open Access
- 7 July 2020
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 10 (15) , 8313-8322
Climate and vegetation structure shape ant communities along elevational gradients on the Colorado Plateau
Terrestrial animal communities are largely shaped by vegetation and climate. With climate also shaping vegetation, can we attribute animal patterns solely to climate? Our study observes ant community changes along climatic gradients (i.e., elevational gradients) within different habitat types (i.e., open and forest) on the Colorado Plateau in the southwestern United States. We sampled ants and vegetation along two elevational gradients spanning 1,132 m with average annual temperature and precipitation differences of 5.7°C and 645mm, respectively. We used regression analyses and structural equation modeling to compare the explanatory powers and effect sizes of climate and vegetation variables on ants. Climate variables had the strongest correlations and the largest effect sizes on ant communities, while vegetation composition, richness, and primary productivity had relatively small effects. Precipitation was the strongest predictor for most ant community metrics. Ant richness and abundance had a negative relationship with precipitation in forested habitats, and positive in open habitats. Our results show strong direct climate effects on ants with little or no effects of vegetation composition or primary productivity, but contrasting patterns between vegetation type (i.e., forested vs. open) with precipitation. This indicates vegetation structure can modulate climate responses of ant communities. Our study demonstrates climate‐animal relationships may vary among vegetation types which can impact both findings from elevational studies and how communities will react to changes in climate.
- 7 July 2020
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 10 (15) , 8313-8322
Open AccessClimate and vegetation structure shape ant communities along elevational gradients on the Colorado Plateau
Terrestrial animal communities are largely shaped by vegetation and climate. With climate also shaping vegetation, can we attribute animal patterns solely to climate? Our study observes ant community changes along climatic gradients (i.e., elevational gradients) within different habitat types (i.e., open and forest) on the Colorado Plateau in the southwestern United States. We sampled ants and vegetation along two elevational gradients spanning 1,132 m with average annual temperature and precipitation differences of 5.7°C and 645mm, respectively. We used regression analyses and structural equation modeling to compare the explanatory powers and effect sizes of climate and vegetation variables on ants. Climate variables had the strongest correlations and the largest effect sizes on ant communities, while vegetation composition, richness, and primary productivity had relatively small effects. Precipitation was the strongest predictor for most ant community metrics. Ant richness and abundance had a negative relationship with precipitation in forested habitats, and positive in open habitats. Our results show strong direct climate effects on ants with little or no effects of vegetation composition or primary productivity, but contrasting patterns between vegetation type (i.e., forested vs. open) with precipitation. This indicates vegetation structure can modulate climate responses of ant communities. Our study demonstrates climate‐animal relationships may vary among vegetation types which can impact both findings from elevational studies and how communities will react to changes in climate.
- 17 January 2020
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Invasive Plant Science and Management
- Vol. 13 (1) , 30-36
Chemical and mechanical control of the invasive shrub Cytisus scoparius in forest clearings in western Washington, USA
We conducted a large-scale, multiple-year study in harvested areas of Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii [Mirbel] Franco) forests in western Washington, examining the effectiveness of control methods on the widespread invasive shrub Scotch broom [Cytisus scoparius (L.) Link]. We tested both chemical and physical control methods, using three different approaches that are management relevant: (1) triclopyr, a POST herbicide, at different times of year and on different-sized plants; (2) cutting (or brushcutting) of mature individuals; and (3) scarification of soil surface to remove seedlings once versus multiple times. We measured initial mortality, seed germination, and percent cover of C. scoparius in plots for 3 yr following treatments. Triclopyr treatment resulted in greater mortality and reduced percent cover compared with all other treatments with the effect persisting for 2 yr after spraying. Further, triclopyr had the same effect on C. scoparius cover and mortality irrespective of time of year applied. Similar to soil scarification, triclopyr treatments resulted in a flush of seedlings, suggesting that removal of conspecific competitors and not soil disturbance per se promotes seed germination. Brushcutting was generally effective in reducing C. scoparius cover in the short term, but effects did not persist as long as triclopyr treatments, in part due to large differences in stump resprouting rates across sites. Soil scarification to remove seedlings, even over multiple years, did not result in reduced C. scoparius cover. Triclopyr is an effective approach for controlling both emerging and established stands of C. scoparius.
- 17 January 2020
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Invasive Plant Science and Management
- Vol. 13 (1) , 30-36
Chemical and mechanical control of the invasive shrub Cytisus scoparius in forest clearings in western Washington, USA
We conducted a large-scale, multiple-year study in harvested areas of Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii [Mirbel] Franco) forests in western Washington, examining the effectiveness of control methods on the widespread invasive shrub Scotch broom [Cytisus scoparius (L.) Link]. We tested both chemical and physical control methods, using three different approaches that are management relevant: (1) triclopyr, a POST herbicide, at different times of year and on different-sized plants; (2) cutting (or brushcutting) of mature individuals; and (3) scarification of soil surface to remove seedlings once versus multiple times. We measured initial mortality, seed germination, and percent cover of C. scoparius in plots for 3 yr following treatments. Triclopyr treatment resulted in greater mortality and reduced percent cover compared with all other treatments with the effect persisting for 2 yr after spraying. Further, triclopyr had the same effect on C. scoparius cover and mortality irrespective of time of year applied. Similar to soil scarification, triclopyr treatments resulted in a flush of seedlings, suggesting that removal of conspecific competitors and not soil disturbance per se promotes seed germination. Brushcutting was generally effective in reducing C. scoparius cover in the short term, but effects did not persist as long as triclopyr treatments, in part due to large differences in stump resprouting rates across sites. Soil scarification to remove seedlings, even over multiple years, did not result in reduced C. scoparius cover. Triclopyr is an effective approach for controlling both emerging and established stands of C. scoparius.
- 1 May 2014
- Published by Elsevier in Rangeland Ecology & Management
- Vol. 67 (3) , 275-284
A Comparison of Bromus tectorum Growth and Mycorrhizal Colonization in Salt Desert vs. Sagebrush Habitats
- 1 May 2014
- Published by Elsevier in Rangeland Ecology & Management
- Vol. 67 (3) , 275-284
A Comparison of Bromus tectorum Growth and Mycorrhizal Colonization in Salt Desert vs. Sagebrush Habitats
- 14 December 2010
- Published by Springer Nature in Biological Invasions
- Vol. 13 (6) , 1275-1282
The importance of nitrogen-fixation for an invader of a coastal California grassland
- 14 December 2010
- Published by Springer Nature in Biological Invasions
- Vol. 13 (6) , 1275-1282
The importance of nitrogen-fixation for an invader of a coastal California grassland
- 1 June 2009
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Arid Environments
- Vol. 73 (6-7) , 643-650
Effects of fire and environmental variables on plant structure and composition in grazed salt desert shrublands of the Great Basin (USA)
- 1 June 2009
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Arid Environments
- Vol. 73 (6-7) , 643-650
Effects of fire and environmental variables on plant structure and composition in grazed salt desert shrublands of the Great Basin (USA)
- 26 February 2009
- Published by Wiley in Applied Vegetation Science
- Vol. 12 (1) , 33-44
Soil fertility, heterogeneity, and microbes: towards an integrated understanding of grassland structure and dynamics
Objective: To highlight the need and the potential for an integrated understanding of three key soil‐based drivers of plant community structure and dynamics – soil fertility, soil heterogeneity, and microbes.Location: European and North American grasslands.Methods: Review and discussion of conceptual models and empirical literature, including examples of observational and manipulative studies from both natural and restored grassland communities.Results and Conclusions: In general, the results of empirical studies on soil fertility, soil heterogeneity, and soil microbes in grassland communities do not support expectations of common conceptual models. Ecological theory assumes a unimodal relationship between soil fertility and plant community diversity, yet empirical relationships from grassland communities are variable, the mechanisms underlying these variable patterns are not yet well understood, and there is mixed success at manipulating soil fertility to facilitate restorations. While theory predicts that increased soil heterogeneity will lead to increased plant community diversity, results of experimental manipulations of soil heterogeneity often show the opposite. Of two major conceptual models proposed for how microbes structure plant communities, there is little support for the hypothesis of microbially mediated niche partitioning. Plant‐microbe feedbacks do have significant empirical support to date and there is increasing application of positive feedback dynamics in restoration, yet field tests of feedback dynamics remain limited. We suggest that an understanding of interactions between these soil drivers may help to resolve discrepancies between conceptual models and empirical results, improving our understanding of grasslands and our ability to restore them.
- 26 February 2009
- Published by Wiley in Applied Vegetation Science
- Vol. 12 (1) , 33-44
Soil fertility, heterogeneity, and microbes: towards an integrated understanding of grassland structure and dynamics
Objective: To highlight the need and the potential for an integrated understanding of three key soil‐based drivers of plant community structure and dynamics – soil fertility, soil heterogeneity, and microbes.Location: European and North American grasslands.Methods: Review and discussion of conceptual models and empirical literature, including examples of observational and manipulative studies from both natural and restored grassland communities.Results and Conclusions: In general, the results of empirical studies on soil fertility, soil heterogeneity, and soil microbes in grassland communities do not support expectations of common conceptual models. Ecological theory assumes a unimodal relationship between soil fertility and plant community diversity, yet empirical relationships from grassland communities are variable, the mechanisms underlying these variable patterns are not yet well understood, and there is mixed success at manipulating soil fertility to facilitate restorations. While theory predicts that increased soil heterogeneity will lead to increased plant community diversity, results of experimental manipulations of soil heterogeneity often show the opposite. Of two major conceptual models proposed for how microbes structure plant communities, there is little support for the hypothesis of microbially mediated niche partitioning. Plant‐microbe feedbacks do have significant empirical support to date and there is increasing application of positive feedback dynamics in restoration, yet field tests of feedback dynamics remain limited. We suggest that an understanding of interactions between these soil drivers may help to resolve discrepancies between conceptual models and empirical results, improving our understanding of grasslands and our ability to restore them.