Alan Gilbert
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Latest Publications
- 21 October 2009
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Twenty-First Century Society
- Vol. 4 (3) , 257-268
Towards sustainable academic research: should social scientists write less?
The number of social science articles and books appearing each year is growing rapidly. In addition to academic writing, authors from other backgrounds are producing much more in the way of quasi-academic social science. The paper explains the causes of this expansion in writing and recognises that there have been some benefits from the growing volume of literature. Overall, however, it seems that the negative consequences outweigh the positive. So much writing makes it impossible to keep up with the academic literature, encourages readers to take all kinds of short-cuts and often encourages repetition of the same arguments, often by the same authors. Citation indices suggest that rather few articles or books are read by many people. While much of what is written is extremely good, arguably better than ever before, there is too much that is of dubious quality. In my opinion, the proliferation of literature risks damaging the social sciences, academia and indeed society at large. The key problem is that the best fruits of our research are too often ignored. The paper invites the Academy to debate the issue.
- 21 October 2009
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Twenty-First Century Society
- Vol. 4 (3) , 257-268
Towards sustainable academic research: should social scientists write less?
The number of social science articles and books appearing each year is growing rapidly. In addition to academic writing, authors from other backgrounds are producing much more in the way of quasi-academic social science. The paper explains the causes of this expansion in writing and recognises that there have been some benefits from the growing volume of literature. Overall, however, it seems that the negative consequences outweigh the positive. So much writing makes it impossible to keep up with the academic literature, encourages readers to take all kinds of short-cuts and often encourages repetition of the same arguments, often by the same authors. Citation indices suggest that rather few articles or books are read by many people. While much of what is written is extremely good, arguably better than ever before, there is too much that is of dubious quality. In my opinion, the proliferation of literature risks damaging the social sciences, academia and indeed society at large. The key problem is that the best fruits of our research are too often ignored. The paper invites the Academy to debate the issue.
- 14 June 2008
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Transport Reviews
- Vol. 28 (4) , 439-467
Bus Rapid Transit: IsTransmilenioa Miracle Cure?
Successful mass transit solutions are rare in poor cities. When they appear they are lauded across the globe and too often copied uncritically. The latest exemplar of such best practice is the ‘Transmilenio’ rapid bus system in Bogotá. The article describes its main characteristics and applauds the improvements that it has already brought to urban transport in Bogotá. Naturally, the system is not without its flaws and these need to be drawn to the attention of those who might copy the Bogotá example. This is particularly important at the present time when the jewel of Bogotá has come under surprisingly strong local criticism over its cost, its ownership structure, its decreasing effectiveness and, fundamentally, because it has failed to solve the transport chaos of Bogotá. There is a real danger that ‘Transmilenio’ will stagnate as its popularity declines and as demands for a metro increase. Given the strengths of the system that would be something of a disaster and, most certainly, not in the interests of the poor.
- 14 June 2008
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Transport Reviews
- Vol. 28 (4) , 439-467
Bus Rapid Transit: IsTransmilenioa Miracle Cure?
Successful mass transit solutions are rare in poor cities. When they appear they are lauded across the globe and too often copied uncritically. The latest exemplar of such best practice is the ‘Transmilenio’ rapid bus system in Bogotá. The article describes its main characteristics and applauds the improvements that it has already brought to urban transport in Bogotá. Naturally, the system is not without its flaws and these need to be drawn to the attention of those who might copy the Bogotá example. This is particularly important at the present time when the jewel of Bogotá has come under surprisingly strong local criticism over its cost, its ownership structure, its decreasing effectiveness and, fundamentally, because it has failed to solve the transport chaos of Bogotá. There is a real danger that ‘Transmilenio’ will stagnate as its popularity declines and as demands for a metro increase. Given the strengths of the system that would be something of a disaster and, most certainly, not in the interests of the poor.
- Top Cited Papers
- 7 December 2007
- Published by Wiley in International Journal of Urban and Regional Research
- Vol. 31 (4) , 697-713
The Return of the Slum: Does Language Matter?
The ‘cities without slums’ initiative has resuscitated an old and dangerous term from the habitat vocabulary. Use of the word ‘slum’ will recreate many of the myths about poor people that years of careful research have discredited. The UN has employed the word in order to publicize the seriousness of urban problems and to improve its ability to attract funding with which to tackle the issue. But in using such an emotive word the UN risks opening a Pandora's box. The campaign implies that cities can actually rid themselves of slums, an idea that is wholly unachievable. The word is also dangerous because it confuses the physical problem of poor quality housing with the characteristics of the people living there. The UN knows that earlier research has rehabilitated most ‘slum dwellers’ but ignores the danger of conjuring up all of the old images. In the process, the campaign also offers an oblique invitation to governments to look for instant solutions to insoluble problems. Demagogic governments have always shown a willingness to demolish slums despite the fact that experience has shown that policy to be ineffective. I fear that the new campaign will encourage more to employ this foolish policy. Words need to be employed carefully.Résumé: L'initiative ‘Villes sans taudis’ a ressuscité un terme ancien et dangereux du vocabulaire de l'habitat. Utiliser le mot ‘taudis’ va recréer toute une mythologie sur les pauvres que des années de recherches consciencieuses avaient réfutée. L'ONU a fait ce choix pour souligner la gravité des problèmes urbains et renforcer sa capacitéà attirer des fonds avec lesquels résoudre la question. Cependant, ce mot étant connotéémotionnellement, l'ONU risque d'ouvrir une boîte de Pandore. La campagne implique que les villes peuvent réellement se débarrasser des taudis, ce qui est totalement irréalisable. Le mot est dangereux aussi parce qu'il mélange le problème matériel de la piètre qualité des logements et les caractéristiques des populations qui y vivent. L'ONU sait que des études antérieures ont réhabilité la plupart des ‘habitants de taudis’, mais elle ignore le risque liéà l'évocation des vieilles images. Parallèlement, la compagne invite indirectement les gouvernements à trouver des solutions immédiates à des problèmes insolubles. Les gouvernements démagogues se sont toujours montrés disposés à démolir les taudis même si l'expérience a prouvé l'inefficacité de cette politique. Je crains que cette nouvelle campagne n'en encourage d'autres à appliquer cette stratégie insensée. Il faut employer les mots avec circonspection.
- 7 December 2007
- Published by Wiley in International Journal of Urban and Regional Research
- Vol. 31 (4) , 697-713
Top Cited PapersThe Return of the Slum: Does Language Matter?
The ‘cities without slums’ initiative has resuscitated an old and dangerous term from the habitat vocabulary. Use of the word ‘slum’ will recreate many of the myths about poor people that years of careful research have discredited. The UN has employed the word in order to publicize the seriousness of urban problems and to improve its ability to attract funding with which to tackle the issue. But in using such an emotive word the UN risks opening a Pandora's box. The campaign implies that cities can actually rid themselves of slums, an idea that is wholly unachievable. The word is also dangerous because it confuses the physical problem of poor quality housing with the characteristics of the people living there. The UN knows that earlier research has rehabilitated most ‘slum dwellers’ but ignores the danger of conjuring up all of the old images. In the process, the campaign also offers an oblique invitation to governments to look for instant solutions to insoluble problems. Demagogic governments have always shown a willingness to demolish slums despite the fact that experience has shown that policy to be ineffective. I fear that the new campaign will encourage more to employ this foolish policy. Words need to be employed carefully.Résumé: L'initiative ‘Villes sans taudis’ a ressuscité un terme ancien et dangereux du vocabulaire de l'habitat. Utiliser le mot ‘taudis’ va recréer toute une mythologie sur les pauvres que des années de recherches consciencieuses avaient réfutée. L'ONU a fait ce choix pour souligner la gravité des problèmes urbains et renforcer sa capacitéà attirer des fonds avec lesquels résoudre la question. Cependant, ce mot étant connotéémotionnellement, l'ONU risque d'ouvrir une boîte de Pandore. La campagne implique que les villes peuvent réellement se débarrasser des taudis, ce qui est totalement irréalisable. Le mot est dangereux aussi parce qu'il mélange le problème matériel de la piètre qualité des logements et les caractéristiques des populations qui y vivent. L'ONU sait que des études antérieures ont réhabilité la plupart des ‘habitants de taudis’, mais elle ignore le risque liéà l'évocation des vieilles images. Parallèlement, la compagne invite indirectement les gouvernements à trouver des solutions immédiates à des problèmes insolubles. Les gouvernements démagogues se sont toujours montrés disposés à démolir les taudis même si l'expérience a prouvé l'inefficacité de cette politique. Je crains que cette nouvelle campagne n'en encourage d'autres à appliquer cette stratégie insensée. Il faut employer les mots avec circonspection.
- 1 September 2002
- Published by SAGE Publications in Urban Studies
- Vol. 39 (10) , 1911-1933
'Scan Globally; Reinvent Locally': Reflecting on the Origins of South Africa's Capital Housing Subsidy Policy
Perhaps in an ideal world, governments would learn from the experiences of others. What has worked well or badly in one place can be repeated or avoided in another. Of course, one place is different from another so that modifications to any policy are usually necessary. When South Africa adopted its new housing policy in 1994, there was a lot of experience around. However, despite the efforts of powerful institutions like the World Bank, it chose to ignore much of that experience. Arguably, six years later, it is about to adopt some of the advice it previously rejected. The paper considers why South Africa ignored experience elsewhere and how it managed to avoid pressure from the World Bank to accept housing policies that it felt were inappropriate to its needs. The lesson of this experience is ambiguous. It shows that governments often have their own agenda and that medium-sized, middle-income countries have considerable influence in their negotiations with 'developmental' Washington. On the other hand, by adopting a set of macroeconomic policies which were in accord with current orthodoxy, and the reduced housing budget that this policy implied, perhaps South Africa merely showed that there are much more powerful hegemonic forces operating than the World Bank.
- 1 September 2002
- Published by SAGE Publications in Urban Studies
- Vol. 39 (10) , 1911-1933
'Scan Globally; Reinvent Locally': Reflecting on the Origins of South Africa's Capital Housing Subsidy Policy
Perhaps in an ideal world, governments would learn from the experiences of others. What has worked well or badly in one place can be repeated or avoided in another. Of course, one place is different from another so that modifications to any policy are usually necessary. When South Africa adopted its new housing policy in 1994, there was a lot of experience around. However, despite the efforts of powerful institutions like the World Bank, it chose to ignore much of that experience. Arguably, six years later, it is about to adopt some of the advice it previously rejected. The paper considers why South Africa ignored experience elsewhere and how it managed to avoid pressure from the World Bank to accept housing policies that it felt were inappropriate to its needs. The lesson of this experience is ambiguous. It shows that governments often have their own agenda and that medium-sized, middle-income countries have considerable influence in their negotiations with 'developmental' Washington. On the other hand, by adopting a set of macroeconomic policies which were in accord with current orthodoxy, and the reduced housing budget that this policy implied, perhaps South Africa merely showed that there are much more powerful hegemonic forces operating than the World Bank.
- 1 June 1999
- Published by SAGE Publications in Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space
- Vol. 31 (6) , 1073-1091
A Home is for Ever? Residential Mobility and Homeownership in Self-Help Settlements
Self-help housing is clearly an ‘architecture that works’. Owner-occupation is also a highly desired tenure among the Third World urban poor. Governments in most poor countries are encouraging self-help ownership. But what do poor households actually gain through ownership? Unlike the housing of the better off, consolidated self-help housing is seldom sold. If there is a limited market for this kind of property, capital appreciation must be limited and, therefore, the poor are likely to lose out relative to the rich. If the poor do not sell their consolidated self-help homes what do they do with them? Are homes merely to live in or do they have economic functions too? The author attempts to answer some of these questions with the aid of research on consolidated self-help suburbs in Bogotá, Colombia. He broadly concludes that self-help ownership does not offer the same advantages in terms of capital appreciations as does ownership in higher income areas.
- 1 June 1999
- Published by SAGE Publications in Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space
- Vol. 31 (6) , 1073-1091
A Home is for Ever? Residential Mobility and Homeownership in Self-Help Settlements
Self-help housing is clearly an ‘architecture that works’. Owner-occupation is also a highly desired tenure among the Third World urban poor. Governments in most poor countries are encouraging self-help ownership. But what do poor households actually gain through ownership? Unlike the housing of the better off, consolidated self-help housing is seldom sold. If there is a limited market for this kind of property, capital appreciation must be limited and, therefore, the poor are likely to lose out relative to the rich. If the poor do not sell their consolidated self-help homes what do they do with them? Are homes merely to live in or do they have economic functions too? The author attempts to answer some of these questions with the aid of research on consolidated self-help suburbs in Bogotá, Colombia. He broadly concludes that self-help ownership does not offer the same advantages in terms of capital appreciations as does ownership in higher income areas.