Benjamin A. Cleggb
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Benjamin A. Cleggb has a total of 84 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Christopher D. Wickensb
Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado, USA
9 shared publications - James Eric Folkestad
School of Education, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, USA
7 shared publications - Jennifer Stromer-Galley
Syracuse University
7 shared publications - Kate Kenski
University of Arizona
6 shared publications - Rosa Mikeal Martey
Colorado State University
6 shared publications - Francisco Raul Ortega
Computer Science, Colorado State University, Ft. Collins, Colorado, USA
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 16 November 2026
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 1-10
All or Adaptive: The Effects of Adaptive Target Selection and the Number of Cued Targets on Visual Search
- 16 November 2026
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 1-10
Open AccessAll or Adaptive: The Effects of Adaptive Target Selection and the Number of Cued Targets on Visual Search
- 6 November 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting
Investigating Mechanisms for Ensemble Visualization Interpretation: The Influence of Proximity, Contact, Density, and Spread on Judgments of Risk
Cone of Uncertainty (COU) visualizations are commonly used to convey to the public the uncertain forecast path of an approaching hurricane. However, the cone’s edge causes a precipitous drop in the sense of risk for locations beyond the cone, where no such discontinuity truly exists. An alternative approach using visual ensembles—Animated Risk Trajectories (ARTs)—can overcome this containment effect. However, the mechanism underlying resulting judgments of risk have not been explored. The current study used four different features within ARTs to examine which dimensions contribute to a sense of risk at a target location. Replicating prior findings, ARTs showed a gradual change in judgments of risk with increasing eccentricity from the single most likely storm path, whereas COUs showed a steep decline outside the cone. For ARTs, instances of potential storm paths passing just inside (proximity) or outside (spread) a location did not influence judgments of risk. An instance intersecting a location increased perception of risk (contact), but a larger impact was seen from the presence of a number of instances (density) around the location. Implication of these findings for designing visualizations to elicit a commensurate sense of risk are discussed.
- 6 November 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting
Investigating Mechanisms for Ensemble Visualization Interpretation: The Influence of Proximity, Contact, Density, and Spread on Judgments of Risk
Cone of Uncertainty (COU) visualizations are commonly used to convey to the public the uncertain forecast path of an approaching hurricane. However, the cone’s edge causes a precipitous drop in the sense of risk for locations beyond the cone, where no such discontinuity truly exists. An alternative approach using visual ensembles—Animated Risk Trajectories (ARTs)—can overcome this containment effect. However, the mechanism underlying resulting judgments of risk have not been explored. The current study used four different features within ARTs to examine which dimensions contribute to a sense of risk at a target location. Replicating prior findings, ARTs showed a gradual change in judgments of risk with increasing eccentricity from the single most likely storm path, whereas COUs showed a steep decline outside the cone. For ARTs, instances of potential storm paths passing just inside (proximity) or outside (spread) a location did not influence judgments of risk. An instance intersecting a location increased perception of risk (contact), but a larger impact was seen from the presence of a number of instances (density) around the location. Implication of these findings for designing visualizations to elicit a commensurate sense of risk are discussed.
- 21 October 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting
Do You Feel Like Using GenAI? Scenario Emotional Valence Impact on Potential Generative Artificial Intelligence Use
Generative artificial intelligence (genAI) is becoming increasingly ubiquitous, creating questions about what factors are influencing its use. This study explored whether emotions in decision-making scenarios impact the use of genAI writing tools. We presented 35 writing-based scenarios, some associated with the six basic human emotions (sadness, anger, enjoyment, fear, surprise, disgust) and others created as neutral emotional conditions. College student participants were asked whether they would use a genAI tool to complete the task, and then to identify the emotion present. Most participants varied their decision to use AI tools. There were significant effects of emotion on the potential use of genAI assistance, with a higher intended adoption for fear and surprise contexts. Emotion strength also influenced potential AI use, with reported AI trust and task complexity increasing in stronger-rated scenarios. However, the overall rate of AI use was generally low. Implications for automation use and trust theories are discussed.
- 21 October 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting
Do You Feel Like Using GenAI? Scenario Emotional Valence Impact on Potential Generative Artificial Intelligence Use
Generative artificial intelligence (genAI) is becoming increasingly ubiquitous, creating questions about what factors are influencing its use. This study explored whether emotions in decision-making scenarios impact the use of genAI writing tools. We presented 35 writing-based scenarios, some associated with the six basic human emotions (sadness, anger, enjoyment, fear, surprise, disgust) and others created as neutral emotional conditions. College student participants were asked whether they would use a genAI tool to complete the task, and then to identify the emotion present. Most participants varied their decision to use AI tools. There were significant effects of emotion on the potential use of genAI assistance, with a higher intended adoption for fear and surprise contexts. Emotion strength also influenced potential AI use, with reported AI trust and task complexity increasing in stronger-rated scenarios. However, the overall rate of AI use was generally low. Implications for automation use and trust theories are discussed.
- 2 October 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting
Enhanced Visualization of Low Probability Trajectories
Forecast paths for hurricanes are commonly communicated through Cone of Uncertainty (COU) visualizations. An alternative visualization, animated risk trajectories (ARTs), uses dynamic ensembles of instances to convey an array of possible future tracks. Four experiments with simplified scenarios explored how surprising or misleading each form of visualization was for outcomes beyond the most likely forecast path, using participants with little direct experience (Colorado-based participants) versus more familiarity with hurricane risk and forecasts (Florida-based participants). For subsequent landfalls at locations farther from the central projected path, all participant types felt less misled when viewing ARTs rather than COUs. While Colorado-based participants reported less surprise when viewing discrepant outcomes following ARTs, Florida-based participants found deviant outcomes surprising regardless of the visualization used. Results suggest ARTs may help people better understand uncertainty when singular “most likely path” forecasts are wrong, although those expected to have greater experience may benefit less.
- 2 October 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting
Enhanced Visualization of Low Probability Trajectories
Forecast paths for hurricanes are commonly communicated through Cone of Uncertainty (COU) visualizations. An alternative visualization, animated risk trajectories (ARTs), uses dynamic ensembles of instances to convey an array of possible future tracks. Four experiments with simplified scenarios explored how surprising or misleading each form of visualization was for outcomes beyond the most likely forecast path, using participants with little direct experience (Colorado-based participants) versus more familiarity with hurricane risk and forecasts (Florida-based participants). For subsequent landfalls at locations farther from the central projected path, all participant types felt less misled when viewing ARTs rather than COUs. While Colorado-based participants reported less surprise when viewing discrepant outcomes following ARTs, Florida-based participants found deviant outcomes surprising regardless of the visualization used. Results suggest ARTs may help people better understand uncertainty when singular “most likely path” forecasts are wrong, although those expected to have greater experience may benefit less.
- Open Access
- 12 November 2025
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 1-11
The Importance of Cueing While Visually Searching a 360 Degree Environment for Multiple Targets in the Presence of Distractors
- 12 November 2025
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 1-11
Open AccessThe Importance of Cueing While Visually Searching a 360 Degree Environment for Multiple Targets in the Presence of Distractors
- 1 December 2024
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied
- Vol. 30 (4) , 607-630
Quantitative effects of overlay clutter and information access effort: Examining the scan-clutter trade-off in displays with geospatial maps.
Overlaying images from multiple geospatial databases increases clutter and imposes attentional costs by disrupting focusing attention on each database and dividing attention when comparing databases. Costs of overlay clutter may offset the benefits of reduced scanning between two images displayed separately. In two experiments, we examine these attention issues using computational metrics to quantify clutter. We also examine how the scan-clutter trade-off is modified by different levels of clutter, display separation, and task attentional requirements. Participants viewed information from a geographical terrain database and a schematic map database and made judgments that required focusing attention on either database or integrating information across both. In Experiment 1, databases were presented as either overlaid or adjacent displays, and in Experiment 2, as either overlay, adjacent, or more separated displays. Results showed that response time was modulated by the magnitude of clutter, spatial separation, and task type. Results also revealed that clutter costs dominated those of spatial separation, particularly in tasks requiring focused attention. A computational feature congestion metric of clutter effectively predicted performance but could be improved by incorporating an overlay component, which amplified the costs of clutter. The results provide design guidelines for overlay displays (e.g., head-mounted displays) that will minimize the scan-clutter trade-off. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).
- 1 December 2024
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied
- Vol. 30 (4) , 607-630
Quantitative effects of overlay clutter and information access effort: Examining the scan-clutter trade-off in displays with geospatial maps.
Overlaying images from multiple geospatial databases increases clutter and imposes attentional costs by disrupting focusing attention on each database and dividing attention when comparing databases. Costs of overlay clutter may offset the benefits of reduced scanning between two images displayed separately. In two experiments, we examine these attention issues using computational metrics to quantify clutter. We also examine how the scan-clutter trade-off is modified by different levels of clutter, display separation, and task attentional requirements. Participants viewed information from a geographical terrain database and a schematic map database and made judgments that required focusing attention on either database or integrating information across both. In Experiment 1, databases were presented as either overlaid or adjacent displays, and in Experiment 2, as either overlay, adjacent, or more separated displays. Results showed that response time was modulated by the magnitude of clutter, spatial separation, and task type. Results also revealed that clutter costs dominated those of spatial separation, particularly in tasks requiring focused attention. A computational feature congestion metric of clutter effectively predicted performance but could be improved by incorporating an overlay component, which amplified the costs of clutter. The results provide design guidelines for overlay displays (e.g., head-mounted displays) that will minimize the scan-clutter trade-off. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).
- Open Access
Multimedia and Immersive Training Materials Influence Impressions of Learning But Not Learning Outcomes
Although the use of technologies like multimedia and virtual reality (VR) in training offer the promise of improved learning, these richer and potentially more engaging materials do not consistently produce superior learning outcomes. Default approaches to such training may inadvertently mimic concepts like naive realism in display design, and desirable difficulties in the science of learning - fostering an impression of greater learning dissociated from actual gains in memory. This research examined the influence of format of instructions in learning to assemble items from components. Participants in two experiments were trained on the steps to assemble a series of bars, that resembled Meccano pieces, into eight different shapes. After training on pairs of shapes, participants rated the likelihood they would remember the shapes and then were administered a recognition test. Relative to viewing a static diagram, viewing videos of shapes being constructed in a VR environment (Experiment 1) or viewing within an immersive VR system (Experiment 2) elevated participants' assessments of their learning but without enhancing learning outcomes. Overall, these findings illustrate how future workers might mistakenly come to believe that technologically advanced support improves learning and prefer instructional designs that integrate similarly complex cues into training.
Open AccessMultimedia and Immersive Training Materials Influence Impressions of Learning But Not Learning Outcomes
Although the use of technologies like multimedia and virtual reality (VR) in training offer the promise of improved learning, these richer and potentially more engaging materials do not consistently produce superior learning outcomes. Default approaches to such training may inadvertently mimic concepts like naive realism in display design, and desirable difficulties in the science of learning - fostering an impression of greater learning dissociated from actual gains in memory. This research examined the influence of format of instructions in learning to assemble items from components. Participants in two experiments were trained on the steps to assemble a series of bars, that resembled Meccano pieces, into eight different shapes. After training on pairs of shapes, participants rated the likelihood they would remember the shapes and then were administered a recognition test. Relative to viewing a static diagram, viewing videos of shapes being constructed in a VR environment (Experiment 1) or viewing within an immersive VR system (Experiment 2) elevated participants' assessments of their learning but without enhancing learning outcomes. Overall, these findings illustrate how future workers might mistakenly come to believe that technologically advanced support improves learning and prefer instructional designs that integrate similarly complex cues into training.
- 4 March 2024
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics
- Vol. 30 (5) , 2662-2670
Beyond the Wizard of Oz: Negative Effects of Imperfect Machine Learning to Examine the Impact of Reliability of Augmented Reality Cues on Visual Search Performance
Despite knowing exactly what an object looks like, searching for it in a person's visual field is a time-consuming and error-prone experience. In Augmented Reality systems, new algorithms are proposed to speed up search time and reduce human errors. However, these algorithms might not always provide 100% accurate visual cues, which might affect users' perceived reliability of the algorithm and, thus, search performance. Here, we examined the detrimental effects of automation bias caused by imperfect cues presented in the Augmented Reality head-mounted display using the YOLOv5 machine learning model. 53 participants in the two groups received either 100% accurate visual cues or 88.9% accurate visual cues. Their performance was compared with the control condition, which did not include any additional cues. The results show how cueing may increase performance and shorten search times. The results also showed that performance with imperfect automation was much worse than perfect automation and that, consistent with automation bias, participants were frequently enticed by incorrect cues.
- 4 March 2024
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics
- Vol. 30 (5) , 2662-2670
Beyond the Wizard of Oz: Negative Effects of Imperfect Machine Learning to Examine the Impact of Reliability of Augmented Reality Cues on Visual Search Performance
Despite knowing exactly what an object looks like, searching for it in a person's visual field is a time-consuming and error-prone experience. In Augmented Reality systems, new algorithms are proposed to speed up search time and reduce human errors. However, these algorithms might not always provide 100% accurate visual cues, which might affect users' perceived reliability of the algorithm and, thus, search performance. Here, we examined the detrimental effects of automation bias caused by imperfect cues presented in the Augmented Reality head-mounted display using the YOLOv5 machine learning model. 53 participants in the two groups received either 100% accurate visual cues or 88.9% accurate visual cues. Their performance was compared with the control condition, which did not include any additional cues. The results show how cueing may increase performance and shorten search times. The results also showed that performance with imperfect automation was much worse than perfect automation and that, consistent with automation bias, participants were frequently enticed by incorrect cues.
- 9 November 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Human Factors: The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society
- Vol. 66 (8) , 2057-2081
Information Access Effort: The Role of Head Movements for Information Presented at Increasing Eccentricity on Flat Panel and Head-Mounted Displays
Objective: This experiment examined performance costs when processing two sources of information positioned at increasing distances using a flat panel display and an augmented reality head-mounted display (AR-HMD). Background: The AR-HMD enables positioning virtual information at various distances in space. However, the proximity compatibility principle suggests that closer separation when two sources of information require mental integration assists performance, whereas increased separation between two sources hurts integration performance more than when a single source requires focused attention. Previous studies have provided inconsistent findings regarding costs associated with increased separation. Few of these experiments have examined separation for both focused and integration tasks, compared vertical and lateral separation, or measured head movements. Method: Three experiments collectively examined these issues using a flat panel display and a virtual display presented with an HMD, where the separation of information varied laterally or vertically during a focused attention (digit reading) task and an information integration (mental subtraction) task. Results: There was no performance cost for either display when information was increasingly separated. However, head movements mitigated performance costs by preserving accuracy at larger separations without increasing response time. Conclusion: Head movements appear to mitigate performance costs associated with presenting information increasingly far apart on flat panel displays and HMDs. Both eye scanning and head movements appear to be less effortful than expected. Application: These findings have important implications for design guidelines regarding the placement of information presented on flat panel displays and, more specifically, HMDs, which can present information 360° around the user.
- 9 November 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Human Factors: The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society
- Vol. 66 (8) , 2057-2081
Information Access Effort: The Role of Head Movements for Information Presented at Increasing Eccentricity on Flat Panel and Head-Mounted Displays
Objective: This experiment examined performance costs when processing two sources of information positioned at increasing distances using a flat panel display and an augmented reality head-mounted display (AR-HMD). Background: The AR-HMD enables positioning virtual information at various distances in space. However, the proximity compatibility principle suggests that closer separation when two sources of information require mental integration assists performance, whereas increased separation between two sources hurts integration performance more than when a single source requires focused attention. Previous studies have provided inconsistent findings regarding costs associated with increased separation. Few of these experiments have examined separation for both focused and integration tasks, compared vertical and lateral separation, or measured head movements. Method: Three experiments collectively examined these issues using a flat panel display and a virtual display presented with an HMD, where the separation of information varied laterally or vertically during a focused attention (digit reading) task and an information integration (mental subtraction) task. Results: There was no performance cost for either display when information was increasingly separated. However, head movements mitigated performance costs by preserving accuracy at larger separations without increasing response time. Conclusion: Head movements appear to mitigate performance costs associated with presenting information increasingly far apart on flat panel displays and HMDs. Both eye scanning and head movements appear to be less effortful than expected. Application: These findings have important implications for design guidelines regarding the placement of information presented on flat panel displays and, more specifically, HMDs, which can present information 360° around the user.
- 20 September 2023
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Human-Machine Systems
- Vol. 53 (6) , 1061-1072
Fast, Accurate, But Sometimes Too-Compelling Support: The Impact of Imperfectly Automated Cues in an Augmented-Reality Head-Mounted Display on Visual Search Performance
While the visual search for targets in a complex scene might benefit from using augmented-reality (AR) head-mounted display (HMD) technologies by helping to efficiently direct human attention, imperfectly reliable automation support could manifest in occasional errors. The current study examined the effectiveness of different HMD cues that might support visual search performance and their respective consequences following automation errors. A total of 56 participants searched a three-dimensional environment containing 48 objects in a room, in order to locate a target object that was viewed prior to each trial. They searched either unaided or assisted by one of the three HMD types of cues: an arrow pointing to the target, a plan-view minimap highlighting the target, and a constantly visible icon depicting the appearance of the target object. The cue was incorrect in 17% of the trials for one group of participants and 100% correct for the second group. Through both analysis and modeling of both search speed and accuracy, the results indicated that the arrow and minimap cues depicting location information were more effective than the icon cue depicting visual appearance, both overall, and when the cue was correct. However, there was a tradeoff on the infrequent occasions when the cue erred. The most effective AR-based cue led to a greater automation bias in which the cue was more often blindly followed without careful examination of the raw images. The results speak to the benefits of AR and the need to examine potential costs when AR-conveyed information may be incorrect because of imperfectly reliable systems.
- 20 September 2023
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Human-Machine Systems
- Vol. 53 (6) , 1061-1072
Fast, Accurate, But Sometimes Too-Compelling Support: The Impact of Imperfectly Automated Cues in an Augmented-Reality Head-Mounted Display on Visual Search Performance
While the visual search for targets in a complex scene might benefit from using augmented-reality (AR) head-mounted display (HMD) technologies by helping to efficiently direct human attention, imperfectly reliable automation support could manifest in occasional errors. The current study examined the effectiveness of different HMD cues that might support visual search performance and their respective consequences following automation errors. A total of 56 participants searched a three-dimensional environment containing 48 objects in a room, in order to locate a target object that was viewed prior to each trial. They searched either unaided or assisted by one of the three HMD types of cues: an arrow pointing to the target, a plan-view minimap highlighting the target, and a constantly visible icon depicting the appearance of the target object. The cue was incorrect in 17% of the trials for one group of participants and 100% correct for the second group. Through both analysis and modeling of both search speed and accuracy, the results indicated that the arrow and minimap cues depicting location information were more effective than the icon cue depicting visual appearance, both overall, and when the cue was correct. However, there was a tradeoff on the infrequent occasions when the cue erred. The most effective AR-based cue led to a greater automation bias in which the cue was more often blindly followed without careful examination of the raw images. The results speak to the benefits of AR and the need to examine potential costs when AR-conveyed information may be incorrect because of imperfectly reliable systems.