Nicole Stremlau
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Nicole Stremlau has a total of 14 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Emanuele Fantini
Department of Cultures, Politics and Society, University of Turin, Turin, Italy
2 shared publications- Ashnah Kalemera
Collaboration on International ICT Policy for East and Southern Africa (CIPESA)
1 shared publication Gerawork Aynekulu
1 shared publication- Gianluca Iazzolino
University of Manchester
1 shared publication - Giovanni De Gregorio
PLMJ Chair in Law and Technology, Católica Global School of Law Giovanni De Gregorio Lisbon, Portugal
1 shared publication Iginio Gagliardone
Programme in Comparative Media Law and Policy, Oxford University, UK
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 22 December 2024
- Published by Wiley in Global Policy
- Vol. 16 (2) , 372-379
Internet Shutdowns, Sovereignty, and the Postcolonial State in Africa
Despite strong international condemnation, there is growing acceptance of internet shutdowns as a legitimate response to online content that governments—particularly in Africa—find concerning. This article explores government decision‐making around internet shutdowns during contentious periods such as elections and in situations of violent conflict. In arguing for a reading of shutdowns that goes beyond simply seeing them as a blunt tool of censorship, it discusses the underlying issues, including the vast inequalities between Big Tech companies based in the United States or China and resource‐poor countries in the Global South. Building on this, the article probes the intensifying disputes around who writes the rules governing how social media companies address harmful content, how such rules are implemented, and, finally, what this means for the postcolonial state in Africa. In some contexts, a government's use of shutdowns represents an effort to reassert sovereignty amid a longstanding context of contestation around borders, power, and national identity.
- 22 December 2024
- Published by Wiley in Global Policy
- Vol. 16 (2) , 372-379
Open AccessInternet Shutdowns, Sovereignty, and the Postcolonial State in Africa
Despite strong international condemnation, there is growing acceptance of internet shutdowns as a legitimate response to online content that governments—particularly in Africa—find concerning. This article explores government decision‐making around internet shutdowns during contentious periods such as elections and in situations of violent conflict. In arguing for a reading of shutdowns that goes beyond simply seeing them as a blunt tool of censorship, it discusses the underlying issues, including the vast inequalities between Big Tech companies based in the United States or China and resource‐poor countries in the Global South. Building on this, the article probes the intensifying disputes around who writes the rules governing how social media companies address harmful content, how such rules are implemented, and, finally, what this means for the postcolonial state in Africa. In some contexts, a government's use of shutdowns represents an effort to reassert sovereignty amid a longstanding context of contestation around borders, power, and national identity.
- 23 July 2024
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 514-525
Accessible censorship
Internet shutdowns as a tool for censorship have been growing in popularity, particularly for governments in the Global South. While it is a relatively blunt approach to addressing content online that governments deem problematic, compared with other tools for content moderation, it is relatively accessible. This chapter outlines the spectrum of approaches that fall under the umbrella of internet shutdowns and explores two of the most popular justifications in depth - shutdowns around elections in response to disinformation and to protect the integrity of the electoral process, and shutdowns in response to concerns that online speech is inciting or inflaming offline violence. We conclude by exploring the limitations of laws and policies in addressing shutdowns, as well as how and why shutdowns have become increasingly popular as a response to the challenges of implementing such laws and policies, particularly on the part of resource-poor governments, which makes shutdowns so accessible and appealing.
- 23 July 2024
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 514-525
Accessible censorship
Internet shutdowns as a tool for censorship have been growing in popularity, particularly for governments in the Global South. While it is a relatively blunt approach to addressing content online that governments deem problematic, compared with other tools for content moderation, it is relatively accessible. This chapter outlines the spectrum of approaches that fall under the umbrella of internet shutdowns and explores two of the most popular justifications in depth - shutdowns around elections in response to disinformation and to protect the integrity of the electoral process, and shutdowns in response to concerns that online speech is inciting or inflaming offline violence. We conclude by exploring the limitations of laws and policies in addressing shutdowns, as well as how and why shutdowns have become increasingly popular as a response to the challenges of implementing such laws and policies, particularly on the part of resource-poor governments, which makes shutdowns so accessible and appealing.
- 21 November 2023
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 259-286
Online content moderation during conflict
War increasingly has a digital dimension. Recent conflicts around the world have underlined the role of social media spaces in providing channels to fight propaganda and denounce atrocities but also facilitating governments to share disinformation or hate speech that contribute to inflaming conflicts. In this chapter, we underline how social media spaces are critical channels influencing conflicts focusing particularly on online hate and disinformation. Issues of censorship, online hate speech, and disinformation during conflict are a huge concern given their potential to exacerbate violence and erode election integrity. Yet how and when social media companies respond has long been an overlooked and under-addressed problem, particularly in countries beyond their priority markets. This chapter underlines the role of social media in moderating conflicts through artificial intelligence systems and the inequalities in this process. The first part of this chapter underlines the role of content moderation in times of war. The second part explores the inequalities in the field of social media and conflicts. We conclude by underlining potential paths to address this situation, particularly though systems of oversight, information intervention and crisis protocols.
- 21 November 2023
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 259-286
Online content moderation during conflict
War increasingly has a digital dimension. Recent conflicts around the world have underlined the role of social media spaces in providing channels to fight propaganda and denounce atrocities but also facilitating governments to share disinformation or hate speech that contribute to inflaming conflicts. In this chapter, we underline how social media spaces are critical channels influencing conflicts focusing particularly on online hate and disinformation. Issues of censorship, online hate speech, and disinformation during conflict are a huge concern given their potential to exacerbate violence and erode election integrity. Yet how and when social media companies respond has long been an overlooked and under-addressed problem, particularly in countries beyond their priority markets. This chapter underlines the role of social media in moderating conflicts through artificial intelligence systems and the inequalities in this process. The first part of this chapter underlines the role of content moderation in times of war. The second part explores the inequalities in the field of social media and conflicts. We conclude by underlining potential paths to address this situation, particularly though systems of oversight, information intervention and crisis protocols.
- 23 June 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 190-211
A tale of two publics? Online politics in Ethiopia's elections
- 23 June 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 190-211
A tale of two publics? Online politics in Ethiopia's elections
- Open Access
- 22 March 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The International Journal of Human Rights
- Vol. 23 (8) , 1378-1394
Developing bottom-up indicators for human rights
There is a growing effort to quantify and track trends in human rights. The reliance on large, international indicators, including global indexes and national human rights report cards, is increasing as part of international development assistance and human rights monitoring. This article explores the limitations of mainstream human rights indicators, particularly in the developing world, arguing that many of these approaches overlook local realities. An alternative strategy for designing bottom-up human rights indicators is offered drawing on the experience of constructing the Uhakiki Human Rights Index in Tanzania. The challenges of developing an appropriate and feasible methodology in complex environments is discussed, particularly given that with bottom-up indicators, what works in one situation might not necessarily be transferrable to another context.
- 22 March 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The International Journal of Human Rights
- Vol. 23 (8) , 1378-1394
Open AccessDeveloping bottom-up indicators for human rights
There is a growing effort to quantify and track trends in human rights. The reliance on large, international indicators, including global indexes and national human rights report cards, is increasing as part of international development assistance and human rights monitoring. This article explores the limitations of mainstream human rights indicators, particularly in the developing world, arguing that many of these approaches overlook local realities. An alternative strategy for designing bottom-up human rights indicators is offered drawing on the experience of constructing the Uhakiki Human Rights Index in Tanzania. The challenges of developing an appropriate and feasible methodology in complex environments is discussed, particularly given that with bottom-up indicators, what works in one situation might not necessarily be transferrable to another context.
- 26 July 2017
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Third World Quarterly
- Vol. 38 (10) , 2242-2257
New media and governance in conflict
The role of new media in shaping the interactions of formal and informal leaders with their audiences is frequently misunderstood and often narrowly focussed on electoral processes and political competition. By weaving together strands of scholarship on political communication and political settlement while engaging with concepts of hybrid governance and leadership more prevalent in the African studies literature, this article takes a different, wider focus. We attempt to knit a framework that challenges normative assumptions on institutional communicative practices and considers the role of power, leadership and communications in both exacerbating and mitigating violent conflict in emerging and consolidating democracies. By bringing together disparate strands of scholarship that are rarely in dialogue, we question a characterisation that contrasts vertical mainstream media with more horizontal and inclusive social media, arguing that a more nuanced view of the political significance of these spaces is required, one that highlights their interplay and blurs the boundaries between online and offline. In doing so, the article places power at the centre of analysis to examine how entrenched relations of patronage can be left unscathed, transformed or even reinforced by networked forms of communication.
- 26 July 2017
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Third World Quarterly
- Vol. 38 (10) , 2242-2257
New media and governance in conflict
The role of new media in shaping the interactions of formal and informal leaders with their audiences is frequently misunderstood and often narrowly focussed on electoral processes and political competition. By weaving together strands of scholarship on political communication and political settlement while engaging with concepts of hybrid governance and leadership more prevalent in the African studies literature, this article takes a different, wider focus. We attempt to knit a framework that challenges normative assumptions on institutional communicative practices and considers the role of power, leadership and communications in both exacerbating and mitigating violent conflict in emerging and consolidating democracies. By bringing together disparate strands of scholarship that are rarely in dialogue, we question a characterisation that contrasts vertical mainstream media with more horizontal and inclusive social media, arguing that a more nuanced view of the political significance of these spaces is required, one that highlights their interplay and blurs the boundaries between online and offline. In doing so, the article places power at the centre of analysis to examine how entrenched relations of patronage can be left unscathed, transformed or even reinforced by networked forms of communication.
- 19 April 2016
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in African Affairs
- Vol. 115 (459) , 225-245
Constitution-making, media, and the politics of participation in Somalia
The United Nations-led constitution-making process, while highly controversial, has sought to create an opening to help Somalia transition to a new phase in its political development. This article considers the structural features, problems, and opportunities of the process, particularly in the context of debates over external interventions and state sovereignty. It also addresses an area that is often overlooked during constitution-making: the role of media and communications in advancing narratives that not only shape perceptions, but also define the scope of the debate. International actors have worked to promote legitimating narratives, emphasizing certain aspects and values with a focus on the constitution being ‘Somali-owned’. This article shows how local and private media treated and reshaped these emphases and priorities. At this stage it is not possible to conclude whether efforts to “sell” the constitution have generated greater legitimacy, but what is clear is that the narratives that have dominated public discourse have been focused on participation and politicking, reflecting underlying concerns about which groups will have access to state resources, as well as responding to the interventions by international actors. This emphasis has obscured the role of local legal cultures and previous experiences with grassroots constitution-making processes and reconciliation in the Somali territories that might allow for the reimagining of the nation.
- 19 April 2016
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in African Affairs
- Vol. 115 (459) , 225-245
Constitution-making, media, and the politics of participation in Somalia
The United Nations-led constitution-making process, while highly controversial, has sought to create an opening to help Somalia transition to a new phase in its political development. This article considers the structural features, problems, and opportunities of the process, particularly in the context of debates over external interventions and state sovereignty. It also addresses an area that is often overlooked during constitution-making: the role of media and communications in advancing narratives that not only shape perceptions, but also define the scope of the debate. International actors have worked to promote legitimating narratives, emphasizing certain aspects and values with a focus on the constitution being ‘Somali-owned’. This article shows how local and private media treated and reshaped these emphases and priorities. At this stage it is not possible to conclude whether efforts to “sell” the constitution have generated greater legitimacy, but what is clear is that the narratives that have dominated public discourse have been focused on participation and politicking, reflecting underlying concerns about which groups will have access to state resources, as well as responding to the interventions by international actors. This emphasis has obscured the role of local legal cultures and previous experiences with grassroots constitution-making processes and reconciliation in the Somali territories that might allow for the reimagining of the nation.
- 2 January 2016
- Published by Review of African Political Economy in Review of African Political Economy
- Vol. 43 (147)
The political economy of the media in the Somali conflict
This article explores the political economy of the media in the context of weak formal state institutions in Somalia. Drawing on literature examining the political economy of war, the authors argue that, rather than being either a system of anarchy or a system in which journalists strive to serve normative functions of a fourth estate, the media in Somalia have their own internal logic that operates according to local norms and rules. This accounts for the media's ability to continue to grow despite the serious security concerns and the absence of strong state institutions and regulations, as well as predictable and regular revenue.
- 2 January 2016
- Published by Review of African Political Economy in Review of African Political Economy
- Vol. 43 (147)
The political economy of the media in the Somali conflict
This article explores the political economy of the media in the context of weak formal state institutions in Somalia. Drawing on literature examining the political economy of war, the authors argue that, rather than being either a system of anarchy or a system in which journalists strive to serve normative functions of a fourth estate, the media in Somalia have their own internal logic that operates according to local norms and rules. This accounts for the media's ability to continue to grow despite the serious security concerns and the absence of strong state institutions and regulations, as well as predictable and regular revenue.
- Open Access
- 19 August 2015
- Published by Centre for Security Governance in Stability: International Journal of Security and Development
- Vol. 4 (1)
Courts, Clans and Companies: Mobile Money and Dispute Resolution in Somaliland
One of the world’s most ambitious experiments in mobile money is underway in the Somali territories. In the absence of a strong central government and internationally recognized banking institutions, remittance companies and the telecoms industry have been innovating to provide services unique to the Somali context, which is making the economy increasingly ‘cashless’. Mobile money has posed new regulatory and legal challenges, particularly when disputes involving consumers are involved. This article focuses on a case study from Somaliland (the northern, self-declared independent region of Somalia) and examines Zaad, the dominant mobile money platform. Given the weak state institutions, there are a variety of actors, including private companies, government police and courts, sharia courts and traditional elders that play an active role in resolving conflicts that result from mobile money transactions, forging a hybrid judicial approach. We examine how these different actors intervene and create an enabling environment to allow innovation and foster trust in a region of the world that is frequently characterized as violent and lawless
- 19 August 2015
- Published by Centre for Security Governance in Stability: International Journal of Security and Development
- Vol. 4 (1)
Open AccessCourts, Clans and Companies: Mobile Money and Dispute Resolution in Somaliland
One of the world’s most ambitious experiments in mobile money is underway in the Somali territories. In the absence of a strong central government and internationally recognized banking institutions, remittance companies and the telecoms industry have been innovating to provide services unique to the Somali context, which is making the economy increasingly ‘cashless’. Mobile money has posed new regulatory and legal challenges, particularly when disputes involving consumers are involved. This article focuses on a case study from Somaliland (the northern, self-declared independent region of Somalia) and examines Zaad, the dominant mobile money platform. Given the weak state institutions, there are a variety of actors, including private companies, government police and courts, sharia courts and traditional elders that play an active role in resolving conflicts that result from mobile money transactions, forging a hybrid judicial approach. We examine how these different actors intervene and create an enabling environment to allow innovation and foster trust in a region of the world that is frequently characterized as violent and lawless
- 3 August 2015
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Third World Quarterly
- Vol. 36 (8) , 1510-1526
Patronage, politics and performance: radio call-in programmes and the myth of accountability
The role of media in promoting political accountability and citizen participation is a central issue in governance debates. Drawing on research into the interactions between radio station owners, journalists, audiences and public authorities during Somali radio call-in programmes we argue that these programmes do not simply offer a new platform for citizens to challenge those who are governing but that they are also spaces where existing power structures reproduce themselves in new forms. We identify the ways the programmes are structured and the different motivations the audience has for participation. Three types of programmes are identified and their relationships with patronage, politics, and performance are examined. Rather than focusing on normative assumptions about the media as a tool of accountability, the article emphasises the importance of understanding radio programmes in their social and political environment, including the overlapping relationships between on-air and off-air networks.
- 3 August 2015
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Third World Quarterly
- Vol. 36 (8) , 1510-1526
Patronage, politics and performance: radio call-in programmes and the myth of accountability
The role of media in promoting political accountability and citizen participation is a central issue in governance debates. Drawing on research into the interactions between radio station owners, journalists, audiences and public authorities during Somali radio call-in programmes we argue that these programmes do not simply offer a new platform for citizens to challenge those who are governing but that they are also spaces where existing power structures reproduce themselves in new forms. We identify the ways the programmes are structured and the different motivations the audience has for participation. Three types of programmes are identified and their relationships with patronage, politics, and performance are examined. Rather than focusing on normative assumptions about the media as a tool of accountability, the article emphasises the importance of understanding radio programmes in their social and political environment, including the overlapping relationships between on-air and off-air networks.