GMGordon R. Mitchell

Gordon R. Mitchell

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Gordon R. Mitchell has a total of 29 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Review of Williams, Young & Launer (2021): The Rhetorical Rise and Demise of “Democracy”

    by Gordon R. Mitchell

    This article reviews The Rhetorical Rise and Demise of “Democracy”

  • Covid-19 and public debate over gain-of-function research on potentially pandemic pathogens

    by Gordon R. Mitchell

    Controversial “gain-of-function” research (GoFR) aims to improve understanding of human health by studying behavior of genetically altered viruses in laboratory experiments. GoFR proponents tout its potential to support public health disease surveillance, drug development and vaccine innovation, while skeptics warn that unplanned laboratory release of genetically altered pathogens could harm millions in pandemics caused by science. Public interest in GoFR grew during the Covid-19 pandemic, as theories circulated that SARS-CoV-2 was the result of GoFR conducted at China’s Wuhan Institute of Virology. Analysis of a 2015 public debate on GoFR research, reconstructed according to pragma-dialectical argumentation theory, sheds light on the increasingly salient scientific controversy and contributes to the growing literature on argumentation and health.

  • Deliberative Stakeholder Engagement in Person-centered Health Research

    by Gordon R. Mitchell, E. Johanna Hartelius, David McCoy, Kathleen M. McTigue

    Robust stakeholder engagement in health research requires broad communicative integration, not only of patients but also other stakeholders such as health system leaders, clinicians, and researchers. As patients’ personal narratives tend to focus on their own health care experiences, it can be challenging to incorporate these perspectives at the health system level, where discussions often address technical issues such as strategies for aggregating and interpreting population-level data. The PaTH Health System Leaders Demonstration Project provides a case study to explore the potential usefulness of deliberative techniques for facilitating heterogeneous stakeholder engagement in what some sociologists of science call ‘hybid forums.’ Close textual analysis of the event transcript yields insight on how social learning motivates group opinion shifts in deliberative processes. Reconstruction of the event’s narrative arc marks a path of ‘dynamic updating’ that manifests in group opinion change. Analysis of episodes where participants perform ‘deliberative openness’ lends qualitative nuance to previously reported process measure outcomes reflecting high participant satisfaction. Such inquiry helps address a gap in literature on stakeholder engagement in comparative effectiveness health research, sheds light on the understudied genre of ‘empowered deliberation’, and illustrates design principles and practices useful for upstream integration of stakeholder engagement in the research process.


  • Using a deliberative forum for engaging health system and health plan leaders to prioritize research topics

    by Kathleen M McTigue, E Johanna Hartelius, Timothey S Anderson, Andrew P Allsup, Treva Alston, Cynthia H Chuang, Stacey Dillon, Daniel E Ford, Nivedita Gunturi, Rachel Hess, et al.

    Background: Including stakeholders in the process and outcomes of comparative effectiveness research (CER) can help ensure that research questions are relevant and findings are communicated to individuals who need them for decision-making. Yet limited strategies are available to assist researchers with stakeholder engagement.While health system leaders’ perspectives are increasingly recognized as valuable for CER planning, their inclusion in the stakeholder pool raises challenges due to differences in culture, training, incentives, priorities and language norms.Objective: To convene and evaluate a deliberative forum for engaging health system leaders and other stakeholders in order to shape health system research priorities for the PaTH Clinical Data Research Network, a member of the National Patient-Centered Clinical Research Network (PCORnet).Methods: Breakout sessions and large group deliberation solicited diverse perspectives and explored benefits and challenges of different research questions. Topic reframing, narrative integration and dynamic updating techniques facilitated communication across diverse backgrounds. Participants included 29 health system and health plan leaders, clinicians, clinical researchers and patients from the network’s 6 participating health systems. Main measures were audience response system (ARS) polling on general topic preferences and survey data on measures of engagement and deliberation success.Results: A slate of 10 specific research topics was vetted; after deliberation, the group converged to favor the characterization of high utilizers of healthcare. Audience response polling revealed opinion shifts. Participants reported high levels of satisfaction with the experience and rated it highly for markers of deliberative quality (e.g., opportunity for active participation and adequate discussion, respect for others’ opinions and awareness of different perspectives). Fifty-four percent noted their views on the issues changed. Most participants learned from the experience (93%) and agreed that the process helped them to empathize with the challenges of others (85%).Conclusions: A deliberation forum can incorporate diverse stakeholders into CER, enabling participants to inform and learn from each other’s perspectives while shaping a person-centered research trajectory.


  • Policy debate topic change controversies in the U.S. and Japan

    by Gordon R. Mitchell, Taylor Hahn, Satoru Aonuma

    In academic policy debate, annual resolutions focus research, facilitate argument development, and enable extensive preparation by participants. Little wonder, then, that calls to change resolutions mid-season tend to spark controversy and reflection. For example, citing strategic Cold War considerations, several branches of the U.S. military pressed the Speech Association of America to change the National Debate Tournament (NDT) NDT topic on recognition of communist China in 1954. Many called for the 2001–2002 NDT resolution dealing with U.S. policy toward Native Americans to be changed in the wake of the September 11, 2001 airline attacks. In Japan, debate officials withdrew the previously announced high school policy debate topic on nuclear power in arguing that it would be “educationally inappropriate” to debate such issues in the midst of the Fukushima nuclear crisis in 2011. Where do calls for mid-season topic change originate? What motivates them? What explains whether they result in mid-season adjustments? Original archival research exploring such questions promises to contribute relevant content to the historical record, as well as shed light on perennial questions regarding policy debate's status and role as a community of practice in the wider world.

  • Big Data and New Metrics of Scholarly Expertise

    by E. Johanna Hartelius, Gordon R. Mitchell

    The 2013 National Communication Association convention included a deliberative double-session on big data, featuring Professor Lawrence Martin, co-founder of one of the leading business intelligence firms serving institutions of higher education, Academic Analytics. Analyzing the program transcript and deliberative polling results of audience feedback, this article explores how the development and use of new scholarly metrics implicate professional knowledge production in communication, and conversely, how conceptual tools from the rhetorical tradition elucidate the surge of digital scholarship that promises to reshape the intellectual landscape. The essay's middle sections isolate in discourse by and about Academic Analytics three “congruities of expertise”—techne, rhetorical exigence, and audience deference—and three topoi of assessment expertise, identified in the analysis as deference, humanizing metric, and negative synecdoche. The article then reviews an ongoing effort to curate a Wikipedia catalog of “measurement fallacies,” designed to supply inventive resources for scholars engaged in practical dialogues in which big data and new metrics are deployed to assess scholarly expertise.


  • Translation Through Argumentation in Medical Research and Physician-Citizenship

    by Gordon R. Mitchell, Kathleen M. McTigue

    While many "benchtop-to-bedside" research pathways have been developed in "Type I" translational medicine, vehicles to facilitate "Type II" and "Type III" translation that convert scientific data into clinical and community interventions designed to improve the health of human populations remain elusive. Further, while a high percentage of physicians endorse the principle of citizen leadership, many have difficulty practicing it. This discrepancy has been attributed, in part, to lack of training and preparation for public advocacy, time limitation, and institutional resistance. As translational medicine and physician-citizenship implicate social, political, economic and cultural factors, both enterprises require "integrative" research strategies that blend insights from multiple fields of study, as well as rhetorical acumen in adapting messages to reach multiple audiences. This article considers how argumentation theory's epistemological flexibility, audience attentiveness, and heuristic qualities, combined with concepts from classical rhetoric, such as rhetorical invention, the synecdoche, and ethos, yield tools to facilitate translational medicine and enable physician-citizenship.


  • The Debate Authors Working Group Model for Collaborative Knowledge Production in Forensics Scholarship

    by Gordon R. Mitchell, Carly S. Woods, Matthew Brigham, Eric English, Catherine E. Morrison, John Rief

    The disconnect between modes of knowledge production in forensics (mostly collaborative) and academic study in the humanities (mostly solo work) is a chasm that can complicate the transition from tournament competitor to professional scholar. Might arrangements that promote joint authorship help harmonize the two modes of knowledge production and convert creative energy from the forensics setting to the academic publishing enterprise? This essay considers the possibility, reflecting on how efforts to coordinate collaborative knowledge production in debate authors working groups relate to professional development challenges isolated in the 1974 Sedalia Conference, the 1984 National Developmental Conference on Forensics, the 1993 Quail Roost Caucus, and the 2009 National Developmental Conference on Debate. The analysis sheds light on issues of perennial importance for the forensics community and also contributes understanding of how recent technological and sociological trends portend changes in the process of knowledge production for the academy writ large.


  • Forensics as Scholarship: Testing Zarefsky's Bold Hypothesis in a Digital Age

    by G. Thomas Goodnight, Gordon R. Mitchell

    The tables of contents from the 1915–1917 volumes of the Quarterly Journal of Public Speaking reveal how the field of communication's academic lineage can be traced back to the forensic debating tradition. In the U.S., that tradition's practical roots were established by hundreds of contracts between universities to hold intercollegiate debates for public audiences. Later in the 20th century, the advent of organized debate tournaments turned forensics into a specialized laboratory for argumentation, where contest round practice yielded first a stock-issues model of argument, followed by multiple debate paradigms, and then a series of critical rhetorics. We envision a next evolutionary step where forensics moves to seize novel opportunities offered by the digital age to refresh its practice as a “participatory culture. “Key to this evolution is recognition of David Zarefsky's insights into the relationship between argument, criticism, and judgment. We illustrate the potential of debate to model strategies of new media literacy through adaptation of his hypothesis-testing model of argument to digital contexts.