Adam J. Berinsky
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Adam J. Berinsky has a total of 147 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- David Gertler Rand
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
31 shared publications - Gordon Pennycook
Department of Psychology, Cornell University
14 shared publications Rocky Cole
Jigsaw (Google), Mountain View, USA
6 shared publications- Andrew Markus Guess
Princeton University
5 shared publications - Antonio Alonso Arechar
Center for Research and Teaching in Economics (CIDE), Aguascalientes, Mexico
5 shared publications Andrew Gully
Google, New York, USA
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 28 September 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Can Accurate Information Change Identity-Linked Political Beliefs? Evidence From Republicans’ Attitudes Towards Election Integrity
Psychological research suggests that identity shapes beliefs and impedes updating in response to contrary evidence. A prominent example is many Republicans’ persistence in believing that the 2020 election was stolen. We test whether credible factual information can shift Republicans' beliefs about election integrity. Immediately before the 2024 presidential election, we randomly assigned 861 conservative Republicans to an intensive informational intervention or a control matched with civic content. The intervention presented extensive, accurate, politically balanced evidence and encouraged sustained engagement. Treated participants reported stronger beliefs in US election integrity overall, greater confidence in the 2020 election, and more positive expectations for the 2024 election (.5 < ds < .8), including those who started lower in electoral confidence (.5 < ds < .97). Effects were still detectable two weeks later, after Trump’s victory. Though learning was incentivized, belief reporting was not – showing that when attended to, credible balanced evidence can change minds.
- 28 September 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessCan Accurate Information Change Identity-Linked Political Beliefs? Evidence From Republicans’ Attitudes Towards Election Integrity
Psychological research suggests that identity shapes beliefs and impedes updating in response to contrary evidence. A prominent example is many Republicans’ persistence in believing that the 2020 election was stolen. We test whether credible factual information can shift Republicans' beliefs about election integrity. Immediately before the 2024 presidential election, we randomly assigned 861 conservative Republicans to an intensive informational intervention or a control matched with civic content. The intervention presented extensive, accurate, politically balanced evidence and encouraged sustained engagement. Treated participants reported stronger beliefs in US election integrity overall, greater confidence in the 2020 election, and more positive expectations for the 2024 election (.5 < ds < .8), including those who started lower in electoral confidence (.5 < ds < .97). Effects were still detectable two weeks later, after Trump’s victory. Though learning was incentivized, belief reporting was not – showing that when attended to, credible balanced evidence can change minds.
- Open Access
- 16 September 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Popular nonfiction can durably shift politically relevant attitudes—and so can a much shorter AI summary
Can reading a chapter of popular nonfiction shift politically relevant attitudes among resistant partisans, and, if so, can an AI-generated summary do so just as effectively? In a preregistered experiment, N = 555 Republicans were randomized to read “The Cyber Sleuth” by Geraldine Brooks—a profile of IRS cybercrime investigators from Michael Lewis’s Who Is Government?—or a control text, and further randomized to either the full text (∼5300 words) or a much shorter AI-generated summary (∼1400 words). Reading “The Cyber Sleuth” produced wide-ranging attitude change relative to control: IRS favorability increased substantially (d = 0.62), with spillover to civil-service favorability (d = 0.37) and opposition to DOGE-led workforce reductions (d = 0.40). These effects remained significant two months later (ds 0.14–0.19). Strikingly, the AI-generated summary produced effects statistically indistinguishable from the full text. Popular nonfiction, and an AI summary thereof, can be an effective tool for politically relevant attitude change, even on a polarized, partisan issue.
- 16 September 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessPopular nonfiction can durably shift politically relevant attitudes—and so can a much shorter AI summary
Can reading a chapter of popular nonfiction shift politically relevant attitudes among resistant partisans, and, if so, can an AI-generated summary do so just as effectively? In a preregistered experiment, N = 555 Republicans were randomized to read “The Cyber Sleuth” by Geraldine Brooks—a profile of IRS cybercrime investigators from Michael Lewis’s Who Is Government?—or a control text, and further randomized to either the full text (∼5300 words) or a much shorter AI-generated summary (∼1400 words). Reading “The Cyber Sleuth” produced wide-ranging attitude change relative to control: IRS favorability increased substantially (d = 0.62), with spillover to civil-service favorability (d = 0.37) and opposition to DOGE-led workforce reductions (d = 0.40). These effects remained significant two months later (ds 0.14–0.19). Strikingly, the AI-generated summary produced effects statistically indistinguishable from the full text. Popular nonfiction, and an AI summary thereof, can be an effective tool for politically relevant attitude change, even on a polarized, partisan issue.
- Open Access
- 11 August 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in APSA Preprints
Survey item placement has little effect on data quality or treatment-effect estimates
Low data quality threatens the scientific merit of survey-based research. Researchers routinely screen out inattentive respondents at the start of a survey, but this does not guarantee that respondents remain attentive throughout. Researchers contributing items to omnibus surveys or deciding where to place key components, such as experiments, need to know whether an item’s position within a survey affects data quality. Existing evidence, however, is limited and inconsistent. Here we report five high-powered surveys (N = 15,159) that randomly assigned a range of data-quality measures, and a diverse set of survey experiments, to early, middle, or late positions. Position effects on data-quality measures were generally modest, mixed in direction and inconsistent across item types. Treatment-effect estimates remained stable across positions. Taken together, these findings indicate that where researchers place items and experiments within a survey is unlikely to matter substantially for data quality or for the treatment effects they estimate.
- 11 August 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in APSA Preprints
Open AccessSurvey item placement has little effect on data quality or treatment-effect estimates
Low data quality threatens the scientific merit of survey-based research. Researchers routinely screen out inattentive respondents at the start of a survey, but this does not guarantee that respondents remain attentive throughout. Researchers contributing items to omnibus surveys or deciding where to place key components, such as experiments, need to know whether an item’s position within a survey affects data quality. Existing evidence, however, is limited and inconsistent. Here we report five high-powered surveys (N = 15,159) that randomly assigned a range of data-quality measures, and a diverse set of survey experiments, to early, middle, or late positions. Position effects on data-quality measures were generally modest, mixed in direction and inconsistent across item types. Treatment-effect estimates remained stable across positions. Taken together, these findings indicate that where researchers place items and experiments within a survey is unlikely to matter substantially for data quality or for the treatment effects they estimate.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 22 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Human Behaviour
- Vol. 10 (8) , 1441-1454
Representativeness and response validity across nine opt-in online samples
The study of human behaviour has shifted in the past 15 years. It increasingly relies on opt-in non-probability online data sources. Here we offer an analysis of nine such sources (N = 13,053), aiming to inform researchers conducting experiments or correlational studies. We assess response validity (attentiveness, effort, honesty, speeding and attrition), the extent to which samples represent the underlying population (demographics, attitude representativeness and experimental treatment effects) and professionalism (number and frequency of studies taken and modality of device on which studies are taken). We document substantial variation across samples on each dimension. Samples using demographic quotas display relatively higher amounts of representativeness across multiple indicators (beyond demographics) but often exhibit less response validity. However, inclusion of two attention checks early in a survey can enhance response validity without negatively impacting representativeness. We offer guidance for choosing opt-in samples, depending on the purpose of the research and resource constraints.
- 22 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Human Behaviour
- Vol. 10 (8) , 1441-1454
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessRepresentativeness and response validity across nine opt-in online samples
The study of human behaviour has shifted in the past 15 years. It increasingly relies on opt-in non-probability online data sources. Here we offer an analysis of nine such sources (N = 13,053), aiming to inform researchers conducting experiments or correlational studies. We assess response validity (attentiveness, effort, honesty, speeding and attrition), the extent to which samples represent the underlying population (demographics, attitude representativeness and experimental treatment effects) and professionalism (number and frequency of studies taken and modality of device on which studies are taken). We document substantial variation across samples on each dimension. Samples using demographic quotas display relatively higher amounts of representativeness across multiple indicators (beyond demographics) but often exhibit less response validity. However, inclusion of two attention checks early in a survey can enhance response validity without negatively impacting representativeness. We offer guidance for choosing opt-in samples, depending on the purpose of the research and resource constraints.
- Open Access
- 18 May 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Short dialogues with AI reduce belief in antisemitic conspiracy theories
Antisemitic conspiracy theories have been central to anti-Jewish prejudice for centuries. Given their longevity and deep ties to religious, ethnic, and ideological identities, debunking them presents a particularly difficult challenge. Here, we test whether having believers discuss their chosen antisemitic conspiracy with a large language model (LLM) prompted to debunk such conspiracies can reduce belief and improve attitudes toward Jews. In a preregistered experiment (N = 1,224 U.S. adults endorsing an antisemitic conspiracy theory), participants were randomized to a dialogue with an LLM (Claude 3.5 Sonnet) prompted to debunk their belief, or one of two control conditions. The debunking dialogue substantially reduced belief in antisemitic conspiracies relative to controls overall, and increased favorability toward Jews among those participants who were initially unfavorable. These findings show that even deeply rooted, identity-linked conspiracies can be effectively debunked through factual correction, offering new insight into prejudice reduction and suggesting that LLM chatbots may offer a route to reducing antisemitism at scale.
- 18 May 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessShort dialogues with AI reduce belief in antisemitic conspiracy theories
Antisemitic conspiracy theories have been central to anti-Jewish prejudice for centuries. Given their longevity and deep ties to religious, ethnic, and ideological identities, debunking them presents a particularly difficult challenge. Here, we test whether having believers discuss their chosen antisemitic conspiracy with a large language model (LLM) prompted to debunk such conspiracies can reduce belief and improve attitudes toward Jews. In a preregistered experiment (N = 1,224 U.S. adults endorsing an antisemitic conspiracy theory), participants were randomized to a dialogue with an LLM (Claude 3.5 Sonnet) prompted to debunk their belief, or one of two control conditions. The debunking dialogue substantially reduced belief in antisemitic conspiracies relative to controls overall, and increased favorability toward Jews among those participants who were initially unfavorable. These findings show that even deeply rooted, identity-linked conspiracies can be effectively debunked through factual correction, offering new insight into prejudice reduction and suggesting that LLM chatbots may offer a route to reducing antisemitism at scale.
- Open Access
- 27 March 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Rethinking Misinformation Interventions: Beyond the Search for a Magic Bullet
The search for effective interventions to counter misinformation has yielded disappointing results despite considerable effort among researchers. This disappointment stems from two interconnected problems: unrealistic expectations about behavioral science’s capacity to change beliefs, and an overly narrow focus on finding single “magic bullet” solutions. The replication crisis revealed that many celebrated behavioral interventions produce smaller effects than initially reported, yet these inflated expectations continue to shape both public discourse and assessments of intervention efficacy. Meanwhile, researchers in the field have pursued individual interventions in a competitive rather than collaborative framework, overlooking potential synergies between approaches. I argue that advancing the field requires both recalibrating our understanding of what constitutes success and reconceptualizing intervention design around bundled, complementary strategies. In addition, proper evaluation must focus on truth discernment – people’s ability to distinguish true from false content – rather than simply measuring reductions in false belief. By combining multiple modest interventions strategically, we can build layered systems of protection that are more robust than any single approach.
- 27 March 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessRethinking Misinformation Interventions: Beyond the Search for a Magic Bullet
The search for effective interventions to counter misinformation has yielded disappointing results despite considerable effort among researchers. This disappointment stems from two interconnected problems: unrealistic expectations about behavioral science’s capacity to change beliefs, and an overly narrow focus on finding single “magic bullet” solutions. The replication crisis revealed that many celebrated behavioral interventions produce smaller effects than initially reported, yet these inflated expectations continue to shape both public discourse and assessments of intervention efficacy. Meanwhile, researchers in the field have pursued individual interventions in a competitive rather than collaborative framework, overlooking potential synergies between approaches. I argue that advancing the field requires both recalibrating our understanding of what constitutes success and reconceptualizing intervention design around bundled, complementary strategies. In addition, proper evaluation must focus on truth discernment – people’s ability to distinguish true from false content – rather than simply measuring reductions in false belief. By combining multiple modest interventions strategically, we can build layered systems of protection that are more robust than any single approach.
- 11 March 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Political Behavior
- p. 1-23
After the Takeover: Rebuilding Trust in Public Media Through Institutional Reform
- 11 March 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Political Behavior
- p. 1-23
After the Takeover: Rebuilding Trust in Public Media Through Institutional Reform
- Open Access
- 27 January 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Peer Review 2027: Scenarios for Academic Publishing in the Age of AI
The practices of peer review and the broader landscape of academic publishing are under strain. Submission rates are rising, placing greater demands on editorial and reviewer capacity. The use of LLMs in the production of academic papers threatens to accelerate these trends beyond the breaking point. This article is the product of a meeting of editors of academic journals across political science, sociology, and communication science to discuss the issue of LLMs in academic publishing. We argue that peer review is an essential and irreplaceably human component of social science: if elements of the research process traditionally done by humans are substituted by AI, humans should increase their involvement with the evaluation of research. We present a scenario-casting exercise illustrating four possible equilibria for the incorporation of LLMs into the publication ecosystem, and we discuss the various levers that academic journals have at their disposal to navigate the changing landscape. We emphasize that adaptive policies with built-in evaluation mechanisms, feedback loops, and a capacity for revision are required, along with new streams of metascientific data to remain up to date as AI and its adoption continue to evolve.
- 27 January 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessPeer Review 2027: Scenarios for Academic Publishing in the Age of AI
The practices of peer review and the broader landscape of academic publishing are under strain. Submission rates are rising, placing greater demands on editorial and reviewer capacity. The use of LLMs in the production of academic papers threatens to accelerate these trends beyond the breaking point. This article is the product of a meeting of editors of academic journals across political science, sociology, and communication science to discuss the issue of LLMs in academic publishing. We argue that peer review is an essential and irreplaceably human component of social science: if elements of the research process traditionally done by humans are substituted by AI, humans should increase their involvement with the evaluation of research. We present a scenario-casting exercise illustrating four possible equilibria for the incorporation of LLMs into the publication ecosystem, and we discuss the various levers that academic journals have at their disposal to navigate the changing landscape. We emphasize that adaptive policies with built-in evaluation mechanisms, feedback loops, and a capacity for revision are required, along with new streams of metascientific data to remain up to date as AI and its adoption continue to evolve.
- Open Access
- 23 December 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Misinformation Distorts Perceived Social Consensus, and Interventions Help Correct It
Misinformation exposure is widely known to affect individuals’ own judgements. Here, we demonstrate that exposure to misinformation also has social consequences which have been largely overlooked. Across multiple experiments (total N=6,273 Americans), we extend the study of misinformation from studying what people believe themselves (first-order beliefs) to also examining what people believe about what others believe (second-order beliefs). Given the substantial evidence that second-order beliefs play a central role in social coordination, collective action, and trust in institutions, understanding the relationship between misinformation and second-order beliefs—while largely overlooked—is of great importance. First, we demonstrate that the illusory truth effect extends to second-order beliefs: exposure to false content increases participants' belief that others believe the claim just as much as it increases their own belief in the claim. Second, we find that individuals tend to overestimate how widely false statements—but not true claims—are believed by others, indicating miscalibrated meta-perceptions. Third, we show that common interventions designed to reduce first-order belief to misinformation— media literacy tips and descriptive norms—also reduce second-order beliefs to a similar extent. By demonstrating that misinformation alters not only private belief but also perceived social consensus, we uncover second-order belief distortion as a critical mechanism through which falsehoods influence societies; and by demonstrating that anti-misinformation interventions also reduce second-order belief in false claims, we reveal a previously underappreciated channel through which such intervention strategies exert social benefits.
- 23 December 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessMisinformation Distorts Perceived Social Consensus, and Interventions Help Correct It
Misinformation exposure is widely known to affect individuals’ own judgements. Here, we demonstrate that exposure to misinformation also has social consequences which have been largely overlooked. Across multiple experiments (total N=6,273 Americans), we extend the study of misinformation from studying what people believe themselves (first-order beliefs) to also examining what people believe about what others believe (second-order beliefs). Given the substantial evidence that second-order beliefs play a central role in social coordination, collective action, and trust in institutions, understanding the relationship between misinformation and second-order beliefs—while largely overlooked—is of great importance. First, we demonstrate that the illusory truth effect extends to second-order beliefs: exposure to false content increases participants' belief that others believe the claim just as much as it increases their own belief in the claim. Second, we find that individuals tend to overestimate how widely false statements—but not true claims—are believed by others, indicating miscalibrated meta-perceptions. Third, we show that common interventions designed to reduce first-order belief to misinformation— media literacy tips and descriptive norms—also reduce second-order beliefs to a similar extent. By demonstrating that misinformation alters not only private belief but also perceived social consensus, we uncover second-order belief distortion as a critical mechanism through which falsehoods influence societies; and by demonstrating that anti-misinformation interventions also reduce second-order belief in false claims, we reveal a previously underappreciated channel through which such intervention strategies exert social benefits.
- Open Access
- 18 December 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
The Unintended Consequences of Labeling AI-Generated Media Online
Media platforms have recently introduced initiatives to label AI-generated media, aiming to increase transparency about content creation. Yet such efforts may carry unintended consequences. AI-generated media often accompany informational content that can vary in veracity. However, labeling may confound perceptions of the media's authenticity and the content's veracity, reducing belief in true information. Moreover, since it isn’t feasible to label all AI-generated media, partial labeling may lead people to assume that the absence of a label implies authenticity and/or veracity. We test for these labeling and implied effects in two survey experiments (N = 11,044), where respondents evaluated political news posts. Labeling decreased perceptions of the authenticity of AI-generated images but also lowered belief in and willingness to share posts—even when the associated claims were true. Furthermore, exposure to partial labeling increased the perceived authenticity of unlabeled content. These results highlight the need for carefully designed labeling practices online.
- 18 December 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessThe Unintended Consequences of Labeling AI-Generated Media Online
Media platforms have recently introduced initiatives to label AI-generated media, aiming to increase transparency about content creation. Yet such efforts may carry unintended consequences. AI-generated media often accompany informational content that can vary in veracity. However, labeling may confound perceptions of the media's authenticity and the content's veracity, reducing belief in true information. Moreover, since it isn’t feasible to label all AI-generated media, partial labeling may lead people to assume that the absence of a label implies authenticity and/or veracity. We test for these labeling and implied effects in two survey experiments (N = 11,044), where respondents evaluated political news posts. Labeling decreased perceptions of the authenticity of AI-generated images but also lowered belief in and willingness to share posts—even when the associated claims were true. Furthermore, exposure to partial labeling increased the perceived authenticity of unlabeled content. These results highlight the need for carefully designed labeling practices online.