COCathy Owen

Cathy Owen

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Cathy Owen has a total of 6 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Intern culture, internal resistance: uptake of peer review in two Australian hospital internship programs

    by Cathy Owen, Paul W. Mathews, Christine Phillips, Wayne Ramsey, Gerry Corrigan, Mark Bassett, Johannes Wenzel

    Objective.: To compare the uptake of peer review among interns in mandatory and voluntary peer-review programs. Population.: All first and second year graduates (n = 105) in two Australian hospitals. Main outcome measures.: Completion of peer review, and reported responses by doctors to peer review. Results.: Eight of sixty interns undertaking the mandated program completed all steps. In the voluntary program, none of 45 interns did so. Resistance to peer review occurred at all stages of the trial, from the initial briefing sessions to the provision of peer-review reports. Discussion.: Hospital internship is a critical period for the development of professional identity among doctors. We hypothesise that resistance to peer review among novice doctors reflects a complex tension between the processes underpinning the development of a group professional identity in hospital, and a managerial drive for personal reflection and accountability. Peer review may be found threatening by interns because it appears to run counter to collegiality or ‘team culture’. In this study, resistance to peer review represented a low-cost strategy in which the interns’ will could be asserted against management. Conclusion.: To enhance uptake, peer review should be structured as key to clinical development, and modelled as a professional behaviour by higher-status colleagues. What is known about this topic?: In non-clinical settings, peer review can lead to improvements in performance. Studies in the US and Canada have demonstrated that junior doctors in hospital have low rates of uptake of peer review. What does this paper add?: In Australia, junior doctors had low rates of engagement with both mandatory and voluntary peer review. Peer review may be resisted because it threatens to undermine the collegiate atmosphere among hospital peers. What are the implications for practice?: Peer review should be modelled as professional behaviour by higher-status colleagues, especially registrars and consultants, and presented as central to improvement in clinical skills.


  • Assessment of a peer review process among interns at an Australian hospital

    by Paul W. Mathews, Cathy Owen, Wayne Ramsey, Gerry Corrigan, Mark Bassett, Johannes Wenzel

    Purpose.: This study considered how a peer review process could work in an Australian public hospital setting. Method.: Up to 229 medical personnel completed an online performance assessment of 52 Junior Medical Officers (JMOs) during the last quarter of 2008. Results.: Results indicated that the registrar was the most suitable person to assess interns, although other professionals, including interns themselves, were identified as capable of playing a role in a more holistic appraisal system. Significant sex differences were also found, which may be worthy of further study. Also, the affirmative rather than the formative aspect of the assessment results suggested that the criteria and questions posed in peer review be re-examined. Conclusion.: A peer review process was able to be readily implemented in a large institution, and respondents were positive towards peer review generally as a valuable tool in the development of junior medical staff. What is known about the topic?: The literature generally concurs that peer review is a useful tool in professional development and can provide a rounded view from diverse sources about a peer’s professional performance. It has been implemented in at least one Canadian medical facility as a mandatory process. What does this paper add?: Our study identifies who is considered the most suitable peer(s) to assess interns, various substantive issues about peer review and about the process itself, and raises questions about the voluntary v. mandatory nature of peer review. It is the first study to trial peer review amongst interns in an Australian hospital. What are the implications for practitioners?: That peer review is a suitable tool in professional development and generally supported in our study, suggesting that it could be implemented into Australian healthcare practice. However, education about the nature and value of peer review would be required amongst healthcare professionals, and the use of peer review could imply greater managerial engagement in medical practice. Peer review is a more effective assessment tool than that currently employed in many Australian hospitals.